Aw common people......

Rating: Null/10 (11 July 2004)

The movie stank. It was not in line with the first two. The sets changed, the location looks totally different. All those little details in 1 and 2 that made for a common look and feel element to the movie (the book always attempted for the same feel when you read it) are lost. The director can't have read the book or had his kids there to make the movie honest otherwise they would have burned dad at the stake for blatant mistakes. I won't say that the director could not have done a great job but they obviously let em have 2 many liberties. What's the frakin deal anyway. I mean just study the fricking first two movies, work the same magic, keep things as similar as possible for the feel and it would have been a hit. Who the heck approved this piece, it wrecked the whole series. So much left out, so much out of order, no details with even a remote similarity. You would think the author would have had a shi% storm once she saw it. Do us all a favor and re-do this one with the original formula in tact. We don't care what it costs just do it right! Yes, we would pay to see it done right and I think that all the viewers of the first two would agree to that. Let's keep the movies on par with the book. It's damn stu&1d to put out such great book work and then two brilliant movies only to allow a #3 to be so bad. Heck I was looking forward someday to buying the entire movie collection but with #3 out there I feel it would be a waste of good money. I could rip this third movies up on details after detail either gotten wrong or left out or out of sequence but whats the point. Overall they did it wrong and they need to get back and do it over again. Oh BTW, the new Dumbeldore needs talk slower and more to the point, he never rattled off his dialog like the new guys doing. If I were Harry I'd hide under a rock an pray that they fire the new director or set him straight, whatever it takes to remake it. It wasn't bad it just wasn't in line with the book.