SPOILER - likes and dislikes of the film

Rating: 9/10 (2 December 2004)

These comments focus on the effects etc. of Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban and make brief comparisons to the past Harry Potter Films
I was particularly impressed with Lupin's transformation from human to werewolf - the look of pain in his eyes, the way they changed colour (contacts) and how it looks as though the werewolf was trapped inside him and was breaking out - as if his exterior ripped away to reveal the core. The idea of having the water bottle turn to ice on the train was great - showing that it made them feel cold and icy. John Williams has as usual provided great music that completes the movie. I think it is great that they've changed the look of hogwarts castle in this film to its predecessors. For example the giant pendulum and the covered bridge. It gives a feeling that hogwarts is always changing - just as you think you know your way around it. Michael Gambon has taken on the role of Dumbledore well, i like the way he appeared to make the candle go out and come back on again as he was speaking - it kept interest.
I was not happy in the change to malfoys hair - it started long and slicked back which suited him perfectly - now its short and doesn't look quite so evil anymore. There is a lot more emotion and even occasional physical contact in this film as opposed to the previous ones. Hermione reaching for Ron's hand for example. The choir at the start of term suited hogwarts very well - especially as lots of them were holding toads etc. Finally, this is a much darker film and we learn a lot more bad things - particularly about Harry's family. Although this is necessary to the future plot i think there should have been a few more contrasting scenes of happiness and joy - it feels the same sort of darkness all the way through!