Confusing.

Rating: 10/10 (6 November 2012)

Now how does the time travel in this film work?!!!! It doesn't make sense what so ever when the time travel is introduced and even before it is. when harry is in Hagrids hut before Buckbeak is executed he clearly gets hit on the head with a pumpkin stone and another stone smashes a jar in the hut and when harry turns around no-body is there. But when Harry and Hermione go back into the past it is Hermione that throws the stone at harry to warn him the executioner is coming this leads to a very confusing story line of how originally hit harry with the stone because this would mean they had already went back in the past which would have meant again they had went back in the past before that and also when Ron is in the hospital wing and harry and Hermione come back after saving Serius black and Buckbeak we see an other Hermione and harry leaving to go back in time which would mean it would happen all over again which is very confusing.