Finally, a film worth Rowling's Vision

Rating: 10/10 (4 June 2004)

The title says it all. This episode, when seen through the eyes of Alfonso Cuarón, is finally what the previous two films should have been. Chris Columbus can make a pretty Hollywood film, but he's best in the producer's chair. He doesn't have the vision of Alfonso. While Chris was busy showing pretty scenes, Alfonso draws a tight story.
The new director has made all the difference in the world. Especially interesting is that Hogwarts is FINALLY a multi-racial school. In other films, all the students were caucasian. And Harry interacts with different races, which is interesting.
You will notice some casting changes -- at least I did, especially of Cornelius Fudge and the Fat Lady. Additionally, the geographic location of some places, especially The Whomping Willow and Hargrid's house have moved.
You will quickly notice that the cast is growing up. Neville Longbottom is certainly growing. He lost all of his baby fat. I had to take a double look to ensure I was looking at the same person! The acting ability is growing with age, like a fine wine. Dan Radcliffe is finally given a chance to show his true talent, especially in the Dursley's house.
The character of Snape finally develops to show his hatred of Harry. I was a bit concerned about the casting of Lupin, but it comes out fine.
Be prepared for some cuts and unusual additions. The second Sirius Black attack is missing. The relationship between Crookshanks and animagus Sirius is gone as well. Watch the film and you will see that the spirit of the film is there (albeit with "flying dementors"), even though Alfonso altered it a bit. But his vision is dead on.