Overall I was happy about how this one turned out.

Rating: Null/10 (7 June 2004)

The first two tried so hard to follow the books and at first I thought that was how I would like them. But seeing the completely anticlimactic way they told Harry he was a wizard in SS was my first let down. I think this film was adapted pretty well for being such a large book. There were some things I was very disappointed with though such as the total lack of explanation about Moony Wormtail Padfoot and Prongs. I think it was an important part about understanding the relationship between Harry's Dad and his friends. And the lack of explanation about the shreaking shack. And I am not a fan of the actor who played Prof. Lupin. Didn't like him in Dragonheart and don't like him here. The other things I wasn't thrilled about was lack of screentime for Alan Rickman (Snape) and the new actor playing Dumbledore could have been good- had he been given any lines to work with. And lastly I didn't get the feeling that Harry really came to like Prof Lupin or Sirius-it just ended too quickly. On the upside I think the direction was good and the cinematography was great. I think it is the perfect film to introduce younger (age 7 maybe) kids to scary movies. Nothing bloody or gory but good enough effects to provide a jump or 2. Also I think this film had depth since it was filled with a little action with some comic relief. Loved the Knight's bus scene.
All in all I agree with one comment I read- don't read the book right before you see this movie-it will only disappoint if it's expected to be the same. But if you see it just for entertainment and to see your old friends Harry, Ron and Hermoine you should enjoy it.