PoA critique...

Rating: 8/10 (7 June 2004)

I felt that the acting was better in this film and Harry's character was a little more developed. Hermione's character was also great, but the movie did not fully capture her growth from the book. For instance, in the book Hermione is overextended with classes, is in a fight with Ron because of her cat Crookshanks, and alienates Harry because of the broom situation and his illegal visit to Hogsmeade (and getting caught by Malfoy and having to rush back only to be caught by Snape). My friend who watched the movie, but didn't read the book, asked what was wrong with Hermione when she
stormed out of Divination class. It was confusing because she didn't understand what was going on internally with Hermione's character. Also Ron is hardly developed at all in the film. He's confined to a few one liners, but he it doesn't affect the overall story.
I've read some other comments on the apparent holes in the plot line of Azkaban. One important plot twist is the revelation of why Snape can't stand Harry. It's very much related to Sirias Black, James Potter, and Lupin. This is not mentioned in the film, although it should come out in the last act. I think in the book, Lupin tells Harry about these details, or they are revealed in some other way. They may be more developed in the next film.
The definite high point of this film was the ending. It was great! I loved the scenes when they went back in time. Harry and Hermione have a real connection and I truly felt the anguish of Harry's character knowing he couldn't change everything that happened although it might mean he could be with his Godfather. I wish the rest of the film could have been as poignant. Overall, great movie and I can't wait for the next one.