My thoughts as a fan of the book.

Rating: 6/10 (11 July 2007)

I thought they rushed it. I know they can't put everything in but I think they tried to hard to include everything and it ended up being all to quick. They could have cut out a few of the things they did include. I thought they followed the story well even though they did change /alot/. I /hated/ the casting of Mrs. Figg was terrible. All in all quite good.
The acting has really improved but I was disappointed that Ron and Hermione weren't in it all that much. I don't think Luna was as dreamy and "weird" as she was in the book but still very similar.
-SPOILER WARNING-
I also didn't like how they used the AK curse to kill Sirius. I guess we can now rule out him coming back to life in book 7.