If you have read the book you will be dis-appointed

Rating: 6/10 (13 August 2007)

In general I think the following were not covered correctly
1. More details about the order of the phoenix, I mean it was mentioned as if BTW 2. About Dumbeld being the secret keeper of the headquarters of the OOTP, and about the fidules charm (not sure how to write it), because this will re-appear in the last book 3. The battle between Dumbeld and Voldy was not as impressive as the book described it. 4. And in general, Michael Gambon sucks he appears broken and defeated and helpless, even in the battle against voldy it looks like ge barely makes it alive. 5. Nothing about percy change of heart, this will fire back in the last book/movie because whoever did not read the book will not understand it. 6. Removing all the discussions between Umbreige and McGonagall (Minerva) who barely appeared this time which is really disappointing
However I liked the following
1. The way it should how the members of the OOTP had appeared inside the ministry (the white light covering them was cool) 2. Cuttiong on the Weasly twin inventions. 3. Removing all the Quidetch SHT 4. very good umbrige