Great For The Readers, Somewhat Harsh For The Watchers

Rating: 10/10 (11 July 2007)

Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, though definitely the best adaptation of the Harry Potter Novels to date, assumes the fans know the book too many times. From the simple act of going to the Hog's Head (which was in Hogsmeade, as I had to tell a friend), to the cut ending dialog between Dumbledore and Harry, there was too many things that were cut that should have been kept. Especially since the longest book became the shortest movie.
However, there are many points that are better seen than read, especially near the climax of the book. The special effects were spectacular, and seem to get better with each release.
The cast, of course, shines in OotP. The trio are growing up, and are able to convey a much greater emotional range as the books expand the emotions conveyed. Alan Rickman shined as the greasy and mysterious Severus Snape, though it would have been nice to see more of him on screen. Gary Oldman finally gets much needed screen time with Harry, and excels in the role of Sirius Black. Michael Gambon does an excellent job portraying Dumbledore, though, I must admit, I still miss Richard Harris's portrayal. Newcomer Evanna Lynch's portrayal of Luna Lovegood was spot on and excellent. Imelda Staunton's portrayal of Dolores Umbridge was excellent, easing my worries after seeing the trailers. And finally, Ralph Ralph Fiennes was perfect and portrayed the evilness of the character far better than even in Goblet.
In summary, Order of the Phoenix is an excellent adaptation, though if you're a book loyalist, you may leave the theater with a bad taste in your mouth. The essence and plot of the book are portrayed excellently by David Yates, and the music is touching and fits the scenes well (Kudos to Nicholas Hooper in filling in the rather large shoes of John Williams). The movie was shorter than it should have been, but portrayed excellently in the time that was allotted. Definitely a must see.