Mostly GREAT!

Rating: 8/10 (20 November 2005)

Okay, I'm a HUGE Harry Potter fan. I loved this movie, BUT there were some key points that I felt missed the mark. First and foremost, I truly think that Michael Gambon is not capturing the true essence of Dumbledore. Gambon's emotional performance (too much so at times) lacks the strength and compassion that Richard Harris so effortlessly exhibited. Also, the way they chose to create Sirius's image in the fire is definitely not how it is described in the book. That along with the lack of his presence in this movie, was a big disappointment. I also would have liked to have had someone comment in more detail about Neville's parents, and the pain he's gone through. It seems as if those who have not read the book will not have the same connection with Neville's character and vulnerabilities. The last subplot that I feel was sorely missed was that of the triwizard tournament winnings (the money) and Harry's choice of where to spend it (or give it). This is a subplot that leads to so many other important connections, that if they are all eliminated for the next movie, we fans will be greatly disappointed. They SHOULD present the next movie in two parts. It's just too much good fun to cut out!!!