What were they thinking?

Rating: 4/10 (25 November 2005)

The plot is as good as in the other movies, since it is based on the book. However, I wonder what was the director thinking? Several important facts of the book are missing, while other scened that are only briefly or not mentioned at all in the book are played. The movies seems to be made of several short scenes, that for someone that never read the book do not make any sense at all. It is understandable that lots of cuts had to be made to fit such a large book in only one movie... but they could at least have tried to create a movie in which there was a clear connection between the scenes and accessible for everyone(not only to those that read the book). In conclusion: very disappointing and illogical!