surely a wonderful movie for readers of Harry but for others???

Rating: 8/10 (19 November 2005)

I saw the movie last night and it deserves being watched. I really enjoy the film as a H.P. fan. However, this film is really hard to understand for people who haven't read the fourth book, so if you haven't read the book you most probably won't like this movie.. for readers it's just another fun and a new question: "How will be the next film?" On the other hand, Mike Newell couldn't improve the quality of the film as much as Alfonso Cuaron did. I think that the directors' understanding of the characters were quite different from the book; especially Dumbuldore was seemed to be were angry and excited unlike the book in which he was usually calm. My other disappointment about the film is the final of the film. The scenes in which Voldemort appears lacks being scary and exciting especially when compared with the scenes full of Dementors in the third film. In short surely a wonderful movie for readers but for others???