A Subtle, but Crowded Comedy

Rating: 8/10 (6 February 2016)

Hail, Caesar! as a film feels very much like an attempt by the Coen Brothers to make an old-fashioned Hollywood film, in a day and age where it is not accepted. For those who love the films of 1950's Hollywood, and the general history of Hollywood this film is a great way to spend time. Hail, Caesar! is funny, well shot, but lacks the memorable stature of the previous Coen Brothers films. For those who love Coen Brother's films this is not there best, but is still enjoyable.
Not that it is all that surprising but this film has quite a few moments that are truly laugh-out-loud funny, but the humor is more subtle. It should be noted that the film is not as funny as The Big Lebowski, so those hoping for another Coen Brothers comedy classic it may not be that funny. Another small problem with the humor is that while the film is funny, many of the funnier jokes are in the trailer, and naturally the film lacks surprises.
Another trademark of the Coen Brothers is there beautiful cinematography, thanks to cinematographer Roger Deakins. It seems ironic watching it because the film is set in 50's Hollywood and the film reels they watch look like some of the cleanest film of today. The overall look of the film is mesmerizing, and may be honored a year from now for it's cinematography. However, in many aspects the film falls short of the expectations that the Coen Brothers deserve today.
While the film is a good and solid entry it has a few too many weaknesses. The villains of the film are a little weak, and because of the crowded story are never really fleshed out in a realistic way. On top of that the story is a little weak, often taking detours that aren't necessary, and often feeling as though what we're seeing isn't all that important. The film also seems to gloss over the consequences of characters actions, and tries to just be funny, but not over the top just subtly funny, which doesn't quite jive.
In the end Hail, Caesar is a comedy for the thinking man who doesn't like the modern comedies that are often dumb and overbearing. Hail, Caesar is a film that looks back at 50's Hollywood lovingly, and for that reason is a great film for film buffs, especially those that love classic Hollywood. However, if you're expecting a great comedy that is both subtle, and brilliant like The Big Lebowski, this isn't quite that.