Good, but not the best.

Rating: Null/10 (17 January 1999)

Mob films are a popular genre, and a lot of very gifted filmmakers have turned their talents to them. Scorsese's best attempt so far has indeed been 'Goodfellas'. It is a very well filmed, very well acted and very entertaining crime movie. It's the sort of movie that film students like. However I feel what it lacks is a heart. 'Goodfellas' just isn't moving or emotional enough. I don't believe it's the best, or even _one_ of the best crime movies of recent times.
If you want an elaborate tale of several decades in the life of the mafia then watch the 'Godfather' movies. If you want a realistic look into life for the average 'wiseguy' then watch 'Donnie Brasco'. If you want a hip crime flic with great dialogue, then watch 'Pulp Fiction'. Goodfellas is simply outclassed by these three films.
8/10 - An imperfect but honorable addition to the genre.