Very Overrated Movie That Can Only Be Enjoyed If You Suspend Common Sense and Logic

Rating: 5/10 (12 December 2014)

I went into this movie with high hopes based on the various stellar reviews - but now I see myself baffled how this movie could get such good ratings.
The plot is illogical and doesn't make any sense. I found myself getting turned off by the movie 10 minutes in since I tried to see sense and explain what was unfolding on screen.
I save yourself from mentioning the numerous plot holes others already listed here in reviews. Just my own here: * No one, no police anywhere would start a missing person investigation if a person would only be missing for 24 hours. I am no cop, but I know that police is usually allowing some reasonable time before such an investigation starts.
* In the movie there is a media spectacle going on about missing Amy after she is missing for a day. I am still puzzled WHY they would make a media spectacle UNLESS Amy was a big-shot celebrity, royality, politician etc. I think the movie somewhere mentions she is a writer, but I was entirely turned off by this since I could simply not understand why there would be media-coverage for "some missing person", plus the fact (see above) that such an investigation would not start that early.
* What awesome planning and foresight: On the alleged "day one of her missing" (repeat: DAY ONE!) they already had a press conference with relatives etc. present. Not only that, on day one they already had a working website dedicated to her appearance and a 1-800 number for people to call in clues. Who should buy that? I can't. Who wrote that script? A 10 year old? * At the end she murders one of her early ex and comes home, soaked in blood. End of story. No one would ask what happens? No one would maybe doubt her story? SHE SLASHED HIS THROAT for god's sake.
This movie and the plot as a whole and in detail is so far from reality that I had problems enjoying the movie. Others called it rightfully a "lifetime movie on a big budget" - and this is exactly what it is. With the difference that some afternoon lifetime movies probably have a better and more well-thought-out plot than this.
Some people mention "plot twists" ..problem only, there were none. There were no surprising elements in that movie, in fact I was hugely disappointed when it was "revealed" that it was her who staged all this in the middle of the movie. From there, everything was clear. NO MYSTERY whatsoever, no exciting plot twists etc.
I am baffled since I know Se7ven, one of my wife's fav. movies which is 1000x more credible and mysterious...THIS is just a bad $0.50 supermarket novel script made into a movie, entirely wasted talent, a trashy movie which could have been MUCH better with a good and plausible script.