Read the book . . . disappointed

Rating: 5/10 (4 November 2014)

The theme of the book is how we often hide our true selves and role play in the beginning of a relationship in order to attract and hold onto a partner. Then, when we can no longer maintain the facade, our real selves emerge and things can go bad. In this case, things don't just go bad, they go totally off the rails. This theme, which explains both main characters in the book, isn't emphasized as forcefully in the film.
Fincher made the mistake of believing his audiences are comprised entirely of those who read the book. Those who haven't can get left behind, especially in the Amazing Amy subplot, which is not fleshed out.
Rosamund Pike is the cast standout as Amy, the wife gone missing. Missi Pyle is a close second as a Nancy Grace-like cable news commentator who's seen only on TV screens in many scenes. Nevertheless, she steals every scene she's in. Ben Affleck is capable as the husband under suspicion in his wife's disappearance. But, it's awfully tough to buy Neil Patrick Harris in his role as a slightly creepy, obsessed former suitor.
Being honest about how well I felt the book was brought to the screen, I can't give Gone Girl a high rating. Fincher did a creditable job, but this is not his best work.