Good enough for a 7.4?

Rating: Null/10 (18 February 2003)

I thought this movie did a fantastic job of portraying what life on either side was like, their information was right on, and the depiction of the battes was great. But what about the acting? This was hands down the worst acting job I have ever seen out of Berenger and Sheen. Nevertheless, this was still a great movie, but was it good enough for a 7.4? So far Gods and Generals only has a 6.3, yet it has actors like Robert Duvall and Jeff Daniels. Why is this?