A brilliantly authentic, heartfelt, yet comedic work... all thumbs up!

Rating: 10/10 (14 November 2006)

Mr. Braff has crafted a captivating work that not only tickles you with its sharp wit, but grabs your heart and doesn't let go... his combination of careful and purposed frame composition with original, heartfelt, and authentic writing fuse together to create a picture that is visually rich as well as deeply alluring to the heart and mind... Portman easily enchants through her stunning portrayal of Sam, and her truly authentic filling of that character provides a splendid balance of quirkiness and beauty that brilliantly complements Braff's character and the entire attitude of the film. Ian Holm provides a characteristically realistic and professional performance as only he can... Sarsgaard brilliantly supports with sharp wit and attitude... An amazing, mind-blowing experience that has earned its place in my top 5.