Scorsese Lite

Rating: Null/10 (26 January 2003)

A film that, despite the magnificent sets, never quite seems plausible. Leonardo DiCaprio has the presence and mien for this story, but somehow the direction given this actor with great charisma (and hints at great depth) seems off. Also, the use of Mr. DiCaprio as narrator, though contextually logical, prods the audience to keep comparing him to other Scorsese narrators, such as Ray Liotta, Robert De Niro, and Joe Pesci. The comparisons distract, but are hard to avoid.
Much of the fine work Mr. DiCaprio does is gravely undermined by the scenes with Cameron Diaz. When they are together the movie suddenly gets a Disney feel--and I don't mean a Disney movie feel, but a Disney World Theme Park feel. Ms. Diaz seems like a costumed park employee daintily skipping her way through realistic settings. When Mr. DiCaprio is with her in a scene, he too seems to be merely wearing a costume, rather than professionally acting. It would be interesting to know what led Scorsese to the casting decisions.
There is much worth seeing in this film full of interesting visuals, but fans (like myself) of Scorsese have been spoiled by films that are electrifying, not just entertaining.