Such a far cry from the depression of Million Dollar Baby

Rating: 10/10 (17 July 2005)

The storyline is very good. From the onset the sequence of introduction of characters to unfolding is at an engaging pace. The conflict and build up of tension is superbly done. The foci of the plot are masterfully followed, described and pushed along by succinct but substantial dialogue. After all characters are in place, the genius and delightfulness of the main character (James Barrie) is presented in both personal character and his artistic child the play Peter Pan. The use of medium and tight close-ups to register the emotional charge of the plot is just so well crafted.
The casting is close to perfect. Johnny Depp's restrained James Barrie is a good anchor portrayal. Kate Winslett is so totally believable as the disabled artist. Freddie as Peter almost steals the show from everybody. Julie Christie and Dustin Hoffman as doyens of the medium strengthen the movie by not overpowering their roles.
I should have voted this the Best Picture.