Decent but overrated

Rating: 7/10 (27 May 2005)

Johnny Depp has always been a good actor. He finally got the recognition he deserved when he was nominated for an Oscar 2 years in a row. He deserved his nomination however the film didn't. Although all of the performances are excellent the film becomes boring after a while. I would have more respect for the film if it wasn't heaped with praise. I would advise people to see it but like a lot of films it wont suit all tastes. The film does have some strong points however. The imagery is beautiful and the final moments are suitably sad. Fans of Depp and Winslet should see the film on the strength of their performances alone.