In which we are asked, "Is it better to have loved and lost, or to have forgotten we loved at all?"

Rating: 10/10 (21 March 2004)

Upon seeing the billing for this movie headed by Jim Carey and Kate Winslet, I had my reservations. After such performances as "The Majestic", and "Titanic" (respectively), I was anticipating that Kaufman and Gondry would be carrying the weight. However, I was in for a treat, as both Carey and Winslet gave what may well turn out to be Oscar worthy performances. Also giving noteworthy performances are Kirsten Dunst, Elijah Wood, David Cross, and Tom Wilkinson.
As for the movie itself, Kaufman delivers once again, with a stunningly beautiful movie that forces careful examination on what we think of love and life. One of Kaufman's triumphs in this film is the effect it has on your emotions. Very few writers can achieve a film that has the ability to swing your emotions from one extreme to the other, often leaving you bewildered in the process. Kaufman's subtle touch makes this neither a tear-jerker nor a comedy, yet something that falls in the middle. There are many times in the movie where an overall feeling of misery and regret seems to leap out from the screen, while the very next moment the happiness and contentment of the characters surrounds you.
Not to be left out in the cold, Michel Gondry brings his brilliant cinematography to the film. His direction of countless music videos and other works has earned him a cult following, yet after this film I would not be surprised to see him walk away with a major award. His transitions between scenes, and the direction of the camera within the scene is fluid and deft. Had his particular style been attempted by anyone else, the effect would have been jarring and dizzying. His camera work is most appreciated during scenes involving the inner workings of Carey's thoughts.

Not much can be said about the relationship between Carey and Winslet's characters without giving away the plot. Suffice it to say that their relationship highlights the possibilities and actions of many people's relationships, and both are offered an opportunity that many would readily grasp, but one that comes attached with obvious yet unforeseen consequences.
In all honesty I can say this is one of the best movies I have ever seen, and easily the best I've seen in the last eight months. It delivers on all accounts, in acting, directing, and writing.