Disappointing hollowness

Rating: 6/10 (27 March 2004)

I had high expectations as I prepared to see this film, driven by two factors. First, I was very impressed with the originality of Kaufman's Being John Malkovich. Second, I have thoroughly enjoyed Kate Winslet's excellent performances in several previous films, most notably Heavenly Creatures. Perhaps it was the shattering of these high, but realistic, expectations that made watching this film so disappointing.
This was the first time in a couple of years that I considered walking out of the theatre (twice). After an hour, enough of a plot framework had developed that it was no longer necessary to invest significant effort in following the story. Furthermore, a couple of comparatively interesting subplots developed: although they are variations on the main plot, they involve more appealing characters.
The acting was acceptable but unremarkable; Winslet and Carrey are both capable of better. The cinematography and editing were garish, and seemed to be designed to distract the audience from the hollow characters.

There are a few funny and emotive scenes towards the end. However, their impact quickly faded, and I was left with nothing to think about as I left (except, where did my 13 bucks just go?). If you like original, artistic, and intelligent films, it is possible that this will appeal to you, but be warned: it is not BJM.