It's a weird and different movie, but it's not that good!

Rating: 5/10 (13 February 2008)

I was expecting something more from it With such high rate here on IMDb, some promising plot keywords (as "amnesia", "erased memory" or "surreal") and great cast as it has, I was certainly expecting something much better! The main idea, in spite of not being bad, is not completely original and the way the plot was developed was not the best. I think it turned too much melancholic, repetitive, and too centred in this night of the "erasing memory" process The "surrealism" of this movie can only be connected to the mentioned process itself or to some weird settings that appear in some scenes of the film, since I don't think it's a "traditional surreal" story. And the plot is not so non-linear either. It's pretty understandable indeed.
As positive features I will refer the cinematography (there are really good settings in this film, and the idea of the things start to disappearing around him while his memory was being erased was also pretty nice) and the acting, which is not bad either. Kate Winslet and Kirsten Dunst were very hot in this film!
The soundtrack I didn't appreciate too. I think it's too poor and sometimes it's just too weird, on a bad way
Generally I think it could have been better, so I will score it 5/10.