I have a Question

Rating: 10/10 (23 April 2005)

OK so i haven't used this b4 and i don't know if my question will be spoiling anything so i put spoiler just in case. i just watched the movie and I have a question about it. First of all I must say that I LOVED this movie! Today is grey, rainy but beautiful.. and those are the words i would use to describe the feeling of the movie for me i know that sounds dumb but ya. Its originality was beautiful, its realness was beautiful and its love story was beautiful. OK now for my question... One thing i'm confused on is well i know that all the stuff at the beginning up until Elija's character comes to the door of the movie was what happened after their memories were erased and that stuff that happened on the ice with them two.. that was after their memories had been erased right? SO then how could ELija's character copy what Joel on the ice if that was really what happened after their memories were erased