NOT a classic

Rating: 6/10 (1 January 2003)

This is a reasonable movie, worth watching once, but by no means the masterpiece that some here have described it as. Visually, the recreation of Stalingrad is impressive. The battle scenes are well executed, but lack the impact and realism of Private Ryan. It is the overly romantic script and wooden acting by Jude Law and the smaller supporting roles that really let this movie down. Vassili's cheerful attitude after a good days shooting really negates any gritty realism that may have been achieved on the battle field. Ed Harris's Major König is a far more believable character.

As a WWII epic this pales in comparison to Private Ryan, Thin Red Line and Band of Brothers. The sniper scenes are poorly done when compared with `Sniper' starring Tom Berenger.