Obviously fails, though I am not sure why

Rating: 5/10 (14 March 2008)

For all its professional craftsmanship, which has given this film a superb look, and all its fine acting, "Empire of the Sun" is somehow unable to engross its viewer as perhaps it could have. Spielberg's failure here is obvious, the reason why is not so clear.
This would be epic features cinematography that is both breath taking and awe inspiring. Director of Photography Allen Daviau captures some amazing images of the People's Republic of China, including some superb aerial action. Special effects, sound effects and stunts here are outstanding. Production design from Art Director Norman Reynolds is very handsome, and John Williams provides another strong score. Even the costumes and editing departments have done a commendable job.
Add to all this a thoroughly convincing cast lead by newcomer Christian Bale, who creates a very believable character in the young, very English Jim Graham. Lending him support are John Malkovich, Miranda Richardson and the ever enjoyable Nigel Havers, whose own turn is one of this film's best. So, given this movie's credentials, including some spectacular screen imagery and fantastic camera work, what on earth is wrong with it?
Perhaps it's just that screenwriter Tom Stoppard was unable to involve us in the events of the war and the camps, no matter how he tried, leaving us feeling as if we're viewing it all from a distance. Character development may be another problem, as both Spielberg and the cast struggle to endear us to the pivotal players. Bale's character Jim is particularly hard to embrace, being a pompous, know-it-all, self-important English brat.
In any event Spielberg has failed to do what he set out to do here. Though he has crafted a fine film, full of eye catching scenery and top notch craftsmanship, the entire show cannot truly move, involve or otherwise affect its audience. Therefore any message or point Mr. Spielberg wished to convey is lost in this crucial lack of depth. I am sure this missing element is in J.G. Ballard's book, so all I can suggest is that you read that instead. Surprisingly disappointing.
Thursday, February 29, 1996 - Video