I like Will, but I was disappointed with this. - 5 of 10

Rating: 6/10 (16 November 2003)

More Will, less cruddy writing and plot. It has it's moments, but ultimately turns into a middle of the road X-mas film, which is fine for most. Will could have raised the marks on this film by displaying more of his talents and fleshing out more of his scenes, but sadly the writing and direction missed the target. I really like Jon Favreau, too! Perhaps his next effort will lead to more success as this film will fade into memory in a few months. Admirable try, but only 5 of 10 from me.