Subtext is the name of the game...

Rating: Null/10 (27 July 2002)

I couldn't disagree more with the "Frankenstein" analysis of this movie. (Aside - even the story of Frankenstein is not a "monster" story. It is a story about man's drive to create due to his inability to give birth.) Edward is a freak. Edward is exotic. Edward is to be stared at. In short - Edward is an artist. But, Edward is not a monster. You don't invite "monsters" to sleep in your daughters bed!
I agree that this movie is full of subplot and symbolism. The central theme - as I see it - is "artists are misunderstood". But more than this, "artists are created in a vacuum - away from meddling 'ordinary folk'." I believe there are two kinds of artists - artists who identify themselves with the ordinary people of this world and artists who live completely inside their imaginary world. It is obvious Tim Burton would count himself as the latter type. All his movies have a definite feel of "manufactured sets". You never know if they take place in the past or the future. (I saw the movie tonight on the science fiction channel.)
I agree Tim Burton is a master of his craft - even honour him with the title of "Artist". But after watching Edward Scissorhands - one walks away thinking that artists belong in a gothic mansion secluded from the "mob". I couldn't disagree more. The best-loved art - is art that makes a connection with the 'ordinary folk' of the world.
Tim Burton does make one small acknowledgement to the 'ordinary folk'. In the movie, Edward has a hard time feeding himself. When he goes to the BBQ in his honour, he is fed by the guests of the party. But at one point, Edward is even in danger of becoming the main course. Have no fear Tim - if anyone is going to eat you up and spit you out, it is Hollywood. But I am sure you know this.
I should mention - I am not an artist. Just an ordinary working-class person.
One final comment - this is not a love or hate type of movie. It is a movie to be watched and analysed. It is food for your eyes and your mind. Open your eyes and keep a critical mind.