One of Pacino's best performances

Rating: 8/10 (5 February 2005)

Al Pacino's extraordinary talent is beautifully displayed in this movie. A low key, introspective performance with not a single raised voice. His Lefty is exploited and passed over but continues to "soldier" on, observing protocol. The scene on the boat with Mr. Tafficante defines his sad role in the organization. Very effective, and a tribute to the players and director.
Some years back I read the book this movie was based on. Although the story was faithfully told, the depth of Pistone's betrayal of his friends (and wife and kids) and his egotism were not adequately portrayed. The affection in which he was held by Sonny (who in reality was killed for his involvement with Donnie/ Joe) was also not illustrated.
Small gripes. Every actor contributed a fine effort with honorable mention to Anne Hesche as Donnie/Joe's long-suffering wife.