Most realistic film I've seen

Rating: 10/10 (3 November 2000)

This amazing film somehow manages to capture the dense texture of real life. Improvisational acting, no artificial lighting, no costumes or makeup other than what was essential to the character, and no musical score help make it that way. So do intense performances from Al Pacino, John Cazale, and Charles Durning. Frank Pierson's screenplay was well-constructed, although 60% of the dialogue was improvised. It allowed room for moving drama, so-surreal-it-could-only-happen-in-real-life comedy, and quite a bit of suspense. The characters are sketched out incredibly well, with even minor ones having their own "moments." Director Sidney Lumet deserves kudos for orchestrating the whole thing, and proving himself a master of the open form. The film also carries an excellent message of tolerance.