Amazing...

Rating: 9/10 (25 January 2009)

I've just gotten back from seeing this movie. I knew it was loosely based on a true story, but I see from the other comments on this discussion that it isn't a faithful telling of that story. The number of movies with just that flaw, from Lord of the Rings to The Longest Day, is pretty extensive. The point is, it isn't attempting to be a documentary.
Be that as it may, it is an amazing movie. If you take the movie on it's own terms, and in it's own context, it is exceptional. Craig and Schreiber are outstanding, showing the push-pull dynamics of two strong personalities that just happen to be brothers. While most of the other actors are not familiar to me, I thought they brought an wonderful reality to the story. The women had strong roles, not just the helpless appendages they are in some movies of this type. They might start out that way, but in the effort to survive, they take on stronger and stronger roles.
The oldest brother, played by Craig, has a past...that is hinted at by his old teacher who ends up in the camp. He's a bit of an enigma at the first, showing both an almost heartless ruthlessness, and squeamishness too. He doesn't want to become an animal, but realizes that there is a balance between strength and morality. The different relationships are very interesting, and psychologically, at least, are very valid.
So I guess I could summarize it by saying, if you are looking for absolute truthfulness, read a book or see a documentary. If you are looking for a realistic take on what makes intolerance and war hell, but not without it's redeeming side, see this movie.