Disappointing

Rating: 7/10 (18 August 2003)

I was really looking forward to this movie and finally got round to catching it on DVD. Firstly, I admit that I watched the dubbed version which, although approved by Ang Lee, was stunted and did the film a disservice. The voice acting was wooden - simple as that. Hey - it was late and I didn't fancy keeping an eye on subtitles!
The plotline was interesting but nothing special - the story of a stolen sword intertwining with that of a young woman who must decide which path she wants to take in her life. It's quite long winded but worth sticking with despite it ham-fistedness because the loose ends are tied up quite beautifully.
The only great thing about this film is the visuals that are simply stunning. The fight scenes are over rated and what really stands out is the gentle cinematography that frames the story in a mythical almost childlike fashion. It's basically a fairytale - just imagine you were to write down the story on paper and read it to your children (once upon a time there was a mighty sword....)
I was left fairly cold by this film, despite the beautifully poetic ending. I disagree with what some others have written in that I don't think this is a better film than Gladiator. Visually it could be argued that it is superior, but in all other ways it is inferior.
It is a good film in it's own right and is well worth your time, although whether you'll return for repeated viewings is another matter.