Question for those who think CTHD was not realistic

Rating: 10/10 (4 August 2001)

Let me stick out my neck and said that I get frustrated with user comments regarding CTHD as being "faked", "unrealistic", etc.
A question just dawn on me as I watched the trailer for Lord of the Ring (LOTR) last night at the Rush Hour 2 screening. My question is how will the same bunch of people who bashed CTHD because it's a Chinese fantasy respond to LOTR? Will they post that LOTR is so cool and fantastic because it's a Western's fantasy? Will you be able to suspend your believe and more tolerance for LOTR because you are more familiar with that type of fantasy?