An modern epic that isn't glossed over. Hooray!

Rating: 9/10 (21 June 2001)

It has been quite noticeable how heated the Gladiator versus Crouching Tiger debate has been after one triumphed over another. These two films show the difference between a real Hollywood Studio Epic, and storytelling which is firmly in the control of the director.
This film, on the surface, tells the events of a Chinese mythical tale. It has leanings towards martial arts, and, due to its 'fairy tale'-like style, it also contains unbelievable scenery. However, this film also succeeds in that it doesn't try to force its issues ( loyalty being the most recognisable), and neither does it have cartoon-like villains or heroes, unlike the all too unbelievable story of 'Maximus' or Mel Gibson's portrayal of William Wallace. The final thing that really made this a 'special' movie, was how interesting the quieter bits of this film are. Not many films can keep tension so effectively, and it seems to be something that Ang Lee is particularly good at ( look at the Ice Storm). The ending to this is also so serene and understated. It's truly wonderful when a film can give so much respect to its audience, and not be overbearing with a big orchestral score, or pretensious and unrealistic speeches by its lead character.

This movie doesn't directly answer any of the moral questions it puts foward, and although this could be considered laziness, I think that it also allows you to consider what you have scene totally open mindedly, rather than having conclusions shoved down your throat (like that awful speech in Pearl Harbour. A movie which is totally enjoyable. Essential.