Very good first attempt. All time top 10 scene.

Rating: 9/10 (29 May 2005)

Very good first attempt, especially for one crossing over from television. Not certain I would rate it a 9 from someone more accomplished. Some very skillful movie-making but it does not hang together completely. As opposed to Garden State, which was totally engaging throughout, I found myself occasionally looking at my watch during Crash. It has some amazing scenes, and as opposed to Garden State has one scene that is well within the all-time top 10. Won't elaborate as it would give away a key plot element. Casting is mixed. Ludicrous was the most entertaining part of movie. Sandra Bullock was the least. Excellent performance by Matt Dillon. Can't wait to see what Mr. Haggis does next on film.