A film that ALMOST works

Rating: 5/10 (12 September 2005)

At first I nearly walked out- I love thought provoking movies- but with this I just felt preached at. And not in a subtle manner! But it did improve! The characters evolved to be a (little) more than one-dimensional. But only a little. As all that really happened was each character was shown doing something good as well as something bad!! (wow how deep!) Also, though I have not been to LA, I cannot believe everyone is that racist or shallow. I could not find one redeeming character in the whole film. Now I realise this is probably the point- but sorry I prefer a little more optimism and faith in humanity.
Nevertheless the film DOES have merits. It is wonderfully directed, acted and shot. It also brings a necessary debate to the fore. However this aspect is let down- due to the movie feeling a little smug and self satisfied.
I would rate this as an interesting, if clumsily handled film. Alas it is not NEARLY as good as 'IT' thinks it is.
Magnolia does it better.
6 out of 10- a little too smug