Yardstick

Rating: 8/10 (16 January 2006)

I am surprised at some of the savagely critical reviews of this film. I wonder what films rank high with reviewers who slate this one. Most films based on much loved comic books are disappointing for a variety of reasons. I think this film delivers on all fronts. I'd rate it as high as Blade and far better than Daredevil, the Fantastic Four or the Hulk.
Keanu Reevs is sometimes regarded as a wooden actor, but I think he is fine in the central role. All the other characters are distinctive and impressive. I especially rate the performances of Peter Stormare as SatanGavin Rossdale as Balthazar, and Tilda Swinton as Gabriel.
The script is fine and resonant if you're willing to accept the premise of a film where Hell is a reality. As far as I could tell the theological logic is sound enough leading to a satisfying resolution where Constantine wins and loses. I'd say there's far more sense in this film than in the Prophecy trilogy.
I am more than satisfied with the film's creatures and the vision of the Inferno. The production values are high and the art direction is superb. I'd very much enjoy a sequel to this film.