Movie is OK but struggles a bit to match the genius of the book...

Rating: 7/10 (18 May 2013)

..That said,it was certainly a commendable effort by the writing/directing/acting team as Cloud Atlas was without a doubt a huge undertaking.(I'm usually late with my reviews as I seldom see them in theaters and wait for the DVD and this time, no exception -sorry). Having read the book, I was able to "fill in the blanks" but I have to wonder if the whole thing was just too confusing to someone who hadn't read it. The constant jumping back and forth between all 6 plot lines would have to be dizzying to someone just walking in and one has to wonder if that is why the movie didn't do particularly well. I found it particularly disappointing that Robert Frobisher's story wasn't delved into more. His was one of the most interesting. The character Eva was completely eliminated - why? - and although I don't remember Robert making "a pass" at Ayrs (although maybe he did and I just don't remember), I seem to remember their discord was over Ayrs discovering Robert's affair with his wife Jocasta. OK, I digress; I realize movies and TV shows deviate all the time from their literary "parents" but I don't know. This was one of the best books I've read in ages and I guess I just expected more. And - really - did the dog need to be shot? I'll give it a 7 anyway for amazing sets, costumes and the sci-fi stuff is sweet! I just don't know whether or not you should read the book before watching or not! Thanks, Jeb...