A bittersweet must-see

Rating: 9/10 (2 January 2003)

The synopsis of City of God was compelling enough to begin with, but when the subject matter is coupled with the dazzling, lush visuals that Meirelles and Lund have achieved, the result is a true cinematic treat.
The often shocking and always compelling storyline - following the coming-of-age of a group of teenagers living in a forgotten, desperate place - is crushingly constrasted by the sun-drenched visuals and upbeat soundtrack. This bittersweet contrast is part of the reason why this film is so compelling; its 130 minute running time having no meaning for me as I was lost in the narrative. The camerawork and cinematography were exemplary - rarely has a film looked so good. The style does have much in common with some American directors, but for me the comparisons drawn with Scorsese and Tarantino are unsatisfying. I don't believe this film could have been made by any other director, given the expert handling of the subject matter. There is a distinctive feel to the style, but it is never an entirely familiar one. In addition, the cast are all entirely convincing, unsurprising since they were picked from the Brazilian favelas where the movie is set.
This is truly a movie which takes full advantage of its medium. I saw it on its UK opening on 1st January, but had I seen it in 2002 it would certainly have been in the top three of the year. All-round, a technically masterful treatment of excellent subject matter which deserves all the critical praise it has received. Highly recommended.