One of the most gripping movies I have seen

Rating: 10/10 (29 May 2005)

Oscar calibre performances for Russell Crowe, Renee Zelweiger, and Paul Giamatti. There were no bad performances from any of the actors. All of the minor characters were authentic.
Cinematography was superb. Historical research seemed to be complete and well implemented. I especially appreciated the tone of the film in its portrayal of the 1930. Costuming and set design were not only authentic but evocative.
I suspect that Ron Howard may be nominated for best director.
This film is to be commended not only for portraying a great moment in sports history but also for its authentic sense of family life and Irish American Catholicism. I think the clerical characters actions were believable considering the year and historical circumstances. Very little of the film can be discounted on grounds of anachronism or inauthenticity.
I can see how the film could be disliked by anyone with an interest in boxing, history, or family relations.
I really appreciated the portrayal of the simple religious and ethical values of the undereducated and poor.