L.A. Story

Rating: 9/10 (24 October 2008)

Roman Polanski's celebrated neo-noir 'Chinatown' was made when the director, and his star Jack Nicholson, were arguably both at the peak of their powers; indeed, there's a strong case that the early 1970s represented a golden age for the Hollywood movie, full stop. One achievement of this film is the actor's, Nicholson creating the character of the fast talking private eye while staying clear of the shadow of Philip Marlowe: perhaps one can think of Jake Gittes as a younger version of Chandler's hero, not yet as disillusioned (at least, this is true at the start of the film). One can also state he avoids his own shadow, playing wholly within the role, something he has not always managed since. Meanwhile, Robert Towne's intelligent script, about the economic growth and control of Los Angeles, seems particularly appropriate for a Hollywood film. In late career, Polanski has made some pretty ropey thrillers: but here his direction is taut throughout, and the film is compelling and atmospheric. It deserves its reputation; and passes muster alongside the other amazing movies that Nicholson made between 1970 and 1975.