Semi sweet and rather nutty....NOT A REMAKE

Rating: 10/10 (17 July 2005)

First I will say that I have been awaiting this film eagerly for a long long time. I have always thought that Willy Wonka was one of literature's best characters. He's a genius, he's crazy, and he's oh so intriguing. I love the book as well as the 1971 classic film. However it should be known that the book and '71 film were written by the same Roald Dahl and are obviously intended to be different from one another. This film IS NOT a remake but in fact an adaption of the novel as imagined by Tim Burton. Those who know Burton's works can probably guess that this film is just as awe inspiring as a triple shot of LSD. Burton achieves a gorgeous and stylized treat that will keep your eyes glued to the screen even if you hate the movie. As for staying true to the story they stick to the book with surprising accuracy except for several key parts. Willy Wonka as portrayed by Johnny Depp is an eccentric and slightly frightening candy maker who is haunted by an unhappy childhood as shown in a series of flash-backs. These scenes add significant elements to the film that fleshes out Wonka more than ever and alters the ending slightly. The children are all portrayed by talented actors and actresses who do all but add horns and wings to the children to make them as detestable as possible, making their demises satisfying rather than disturbing. A fresh new twist on the oompa looma chants deviates from the well known chants of the '71 film but uses lyrics found in the book. I found Charlie Bucket portrayed by Freddie Highmore to be far less irritating than Peter Ostrum's portrayal of the boy in 71. As for Mr. Willy Wonka. He is far more upbeat with a much wilder disposition and wit with a much more fleshed out character who seems to have been affected by the 20 years of isolation through his lack of social graces and crazy nature. It's wild, fun, and pretty. Depp is incomparable and Burton's vision is brilliant. All of this topped off with much more humor and a superb score make this the family movie of the year. As for which film is better, they cannot be compared they are two uniquely different but equally superb films. Those who enjoy a light musical and a more laid back film should stick to the 1971 version. Those with a love for the odd or who want a more faithful adaption should see this one. Everyone should see this one if for no other reason than it's beauty. I LOVE WILLY WONKA!!