Apples and Oranges, and this is a very fine orange

Rating: 8/10 (6 August 2005)

There will be inevitable comparisons to this and the Gene Wilder version. I would say, Gene Wilder's version has two virtues, the two songs and Gene Wilder.
This version has Tim Burton's quirky, unmistakable stamp on it. Fantastic sets, beautiful imagery, and a central character that has trouble relating to the world.
Gene Wilder's Wonka was warmer, but Johnny Depp's characterization had reasons he's more standoffish. I understand the direction he took the character (also it's consistent with Tim Burton's worldview). I like both takes of the same character but unfortunately if forced to pick, I'd pick Wilder. Only IF I'm forced to pick. I'd rather have both and fortunately, I do now.
Freddie Highmore, he's a competent actor, like Dakota Fanning is a competent actress. Yet I didn't warm up to him. I do love the original Charlie, who had expressive eyes. He wasn't that competent but he didn't have to be, in that role.
I think it's interesting this version is entitled "CHARLIE and the Chocolate Factory" when we have more about Willie Wonka here, while in "WILLIE WONKA and the Chocolate Factory" the focus seems clearly on Charlie.