A largely faithful sweet treat

Rating: 7/10 (5 November 2006)

Having read the book, and seen the film starring Gene Wilder, I was pleased with the new film, and the fact that they stayed pretty close to the Roald Dahl book. The pluses were the chocolate garden, the pre-story Oompa Loompa scene in their natural habitat, and the squirrel scene (far better than the golden goose in the old film). Not so good was the flash-back to Wonka's father, or the reuniting scene, which didn't appear in the book. Also I feel Tim Burton missed a trick leaving no way for the sequel film following the book.
Unlike "Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory", which as I type is being televised and looks very dated (pinned at all corners to the 1970's), I feel this 2005 version will remain timeless and a classic suitable for the audience the book was intended - children of all ages. The casting was excellent, with good use of the big name stars, particularly Johnny Depp as the most excellent Willy Wonka. The dirty city scene was so fitting for Charlie and his family, and the iconic chocolate factory in the midst of it.
However, one word of caution. Before you let your younger children see the movie, I suggest they read the book first. The morals of the story will not shock when seen in all their graphic glory in the film. But even if your children don't read the book, I would commend it as a good stand-alone view just so long as you explain the somewhat real-looking nasties are not real at all.
I do admire Tim Burton's work. When your little urchin is older, do see Corpse Bride!