not as good as the first movie

Rating: 6/10 (16 July 2005)

I believe overall that this new version is not as good as the old movie. Some parts that weren't in the new movie but in the old were very important to the story line. Also, Johnny Depp doesn't fit the part perfectly, in my mind he is a little too young for it. Also they tried to make the movie more comical then it should be. I did enjoy the old movie very much and I was looking forward to a new remake. But when i saw the new movie, i was disappointed with its unsimilarity to the old movie. Overall this movie was not as great as the old one but is good for a family with young children to see. Little kids seemed to be enjoying the movie.