both movies great

Rating: 8/10 (28 September 2005)

Hello, I have seen Charlie and the chocolate factory, I have seen the Willy wonka and the chocolate factory, I have even read the book. Tim Burton's Charlie and the chocolate factory is closer to the book, everything is the same, the only difference is that Wonka has flash backs. Other then that its very close to the original book, and Roald Dahl would be proud. Wilder is great, Depp is great, that's all there is to it get over it. You cant tell me you want to watch a movie with the same characterisation, BORING. THIS MOVIE IS NOT A REMAKE. It is an adaption of the book by Roald Dahl. To different eras two different movies. You guys can fight over which movie is better, all u want, I just had to clear a few thins up. And Oompa Loompa's are not orange, that was Mel Stuart's art direction, not Roald Dahl. So stop talking about how they got the color wrong. Its like when a director does a play, they have their own direction of how it should look how it should sound, that's the same with movies, leave Tim Burton alone hes doing a good job. Depp is awesome wonka, and u can never stop quoting him this film is fantastic. So I hope I helped someone understand a little about a persons imagination and vision.