Disappointing

Rating: Null/10 (23 December 2000)

I was looking forward to an inspiring plot and a unique role for Hanks, but this movie was disappointing. Though the film was over two hours in length, I couldn't help but feel that a lot of content had fallen gracelessly to the cutting-room floor. Time as a concept seemed to flip-flop senselessly, particularly when Hanks' first few compelling and frightening weeks on the island abruptly end and we are informed (with an awkward subtext) that four years has transpired, leaving Hanks lean, mean, and slightly demented.
Some scenes with his "co-star" Wilson were touching. Others were contrived. And Hanks' pathetic, throaty cries as Wilson metaphorically drifts away reminded me more of his character in 'The Money Pit' than anything else. It was hard to take him seriously. And I won't even mention the silliness of Hanks' cetacean buddy, who seemed to magically appear when he was needed most.
Finally, there is Helen Hunt, who seems to be the flavor-of-the-moment in Hollywood, but in this film she is poorly cast. Her performance lacked the true grief, desperation and elation her character should have demonstrated.
Overall, this movie was disappointing. I expected a more riveting performance from Hanks, but the film's editors and writers should accept a greater share of blame for the oft-contrived shallowness of what should have been the best film of the year.
See it, but wait for the video.