Underrated film

Rating: 7/10 (24 March 2013)

While it's not an Oscar-level movie, I think this film is underrated. I agree with those who felt that Nicholas Cage's accent left something to be desired. And I agree that Penelope Cruz's performance was hardly stellar. But there are lots worse films out there.
And this film does have some very good qualities. It's a war movie that's less about war than it is about the every day tragedies that befall the locals who are caught up in war. The cinematography and scenery is excellent, and on location. And it reminds us that even in war, soldiers are still people, and not necessarily very different than ourselves. Although the film has a happy ending, there is a great deal of tragedy in between, so there is a sense of realism here.
Nicholas Cage's performance here is actually quite good, even if the accent isn't...and I say that as no fan of Cage. John Hurt is good as the doctor, Christian Bale very good as the young fiancé, and Gunther Weber is fine as the Nazi soldier with the most contact with the people. It's also good to see Irene Papas as an authentic Greek.
I think this is a pretty decent film. A balance between the horror of war and the joy that can be found in many adverse situations. Recommended, though it may not end up on your DVD shelf.