Just not really that good, plain and simple

Rating: 2/10 (30 November 2006)

It's obvious that a lot of the over the top praise for this movie comes from lefties and gays because it addresses a topic that hasn't been addressed previously. And it's also obvious that some of the hate is from right wing guys who are just disgusted by homosexuals.
Look, there's some very basic very real problems with this movie that I don't know how you can overlook. First of all, the guys and their wives don't age. Secondly, the two men have zero chemistry on screen. Thirdly there are so many small things which make you just say "WTF was lee thinking?" Cutting cold turkey on thanksgiving is just one of many of these.
The views and some of the cinematography are great. The women are FAR FAR more believable than the men in this movie, and considering the movie was about the men, that's not really a good thing.