Very enjoyable, and quite moving

Rating: 9/10 (28 January 2006)

Let me start by saying that I really liked it. The acting was great overall, and the dialog/plot seemed believable. Also, if you're the type that is still a little uncomfortable watching homosexual situations, you shouldn't be afraid to see this movie...It was tastefully done.
As far as the acting, my favorite performance would have to be that of Michelle Williams. She brought such emotion and pure feeling to that part. Her performance was sincere and moving. Anne Hathaway was equally great, but with a more subdued character. She was the type that acted as if nothing could touch her, that she had everything in control, and in the end, you witness the pain that was always there...she really made it work. Randy Quaid was just as impressive. He showed yet another facet of his acting talent. His character was dead on. I know men like him, and he hit the nail on the head. Jake Gyllenhaal was brilliant as always. He is one of my favorites since Donnie Darko, and he just has an extreme and inspiring talent for acting. The only complaint here for me is Heath Ledger. He was not horrible, but I found the accent, and mannerisms a little rehearsed. I just didn't buy it. He was a non-cowboy trying to act like a cowboy...it's just the general feeling I got.
Some people on the site are complaining of a slow moving story, and that nothing really happens. I even heard some comments to that same effect on my way out of the theater. The fact is, this is really an all out drama. The basic story of a group of people and the hardships they endure through a number of years. I'm not sure what everyone is expecting to happen. If you like tons of action, murder and mayhem, graphic sexuality, or other in your face types of themes, then you won't enjoy this. But...if you're like me, and you enjoy seeing everyday people facing the challenges of life, and struggling to find happiness, then you'll be in awe.
As for the sexuality, I don't judge people on it, but I have to admit, I was a little uncomfortable during a few of the love scenes. I will say though, that I thought they were tastefully done, leaving a lot to the imagination...which, for my taste, is more enjoyable...whether it is gay or straight.
That sums it up! I was very impressed with this movie!