Instant Classic

Rating: 10/10 (17 December 2005)

One of the great movie romances of all time, and I've seen them all. Brilliantly adapted from a brilliant short story by Annie Proulx, Ang Lee and his cast and crew have created a landmark cinematic event like no other. This is the first movie that presents a gay love affair that seems entirely real, with no phoniness and no glossing over the physical part of the relationship. But it's not about the sex, it's about the deep love between two strong masculine men who are thwarted by things outside their control. All the cast is superb, but Heath Ledger is astonishing, giving a legendary performance - who would have thought? He's the new Brando. His minimalist performance is overwhelming and heartbreaking. Jake Gyllenahall is also amazing. Although he's overshadowed by Ledger's power, he too breaks your heart. The women are great too. You will never forget this movie.