A Little Too One-Dimensional

Rating: 5/10 (13 December 2002)

I haven't seen this movie in some time but now feel compelled to offer my opinion, First off this is just that, an opinion. I realize that this movie provided a lot in the way of, not only entertainment, but patriotism and a unified belief in what America stands for. So, I'm not trying to belittle any of that. Having said that I have to admit I was quite disappointed with Ridley Scott's effort here. I love a good action flick as much as anyone, but I also watch other genres and with:
1) a fantastic & untapped story like this- for any interested in what actually occurred I would suggest reading the novel by Mark Bowden; it's much more clear.
2) a director of Ridley Scott's caliber- which I personally disagree with. Alien was great and Thelma & Louise was good too, but Gladiator & Blade Runner are highly overrated movies and Hannibal, GI Jane, White Squall, Black Rain and Legend are all pathetic.
3) the budget, the cast, etc., etc., etc. I expected something (epic, enthralling, moving) and ended up with a film with at least 18 main characters. The story is all over the place, never once gaining any discernible focus other than "we leave no one behind" or some such nonsense... Ewan McGregor has no part in this movie, Orlando Bloom is better as Legolas (much), Hartnett should stick more dramatic/less action because he's a good actor though has received less praise due to 13 yr old female's obsession with him....and as for Tom Sizemore, he's become one of the biggest jokes in the film industry since Jean Claude Van Damme. There are good parts to this movie but I felt like the masses were blindly praising this movie and needed to get this off my chest. 5* out of 10*