Overrated

Rating: 3/10 (16 January 2011)

Whilst the central premise of exploring some of the ethics outside of the traditional WWII "goodies and baddies" is one that ought to be interesting, there isn't a single moment in this film that really feels like a moral dilemma for any of the characters, due to the lack of any emotion or character development. Despite the 2 1/2 hour length, the plot is too fast-paced and feels more like a Hollywood action film.
Events that should be upsetting - such as the murder of the main protagonist's family - are dealt with in a matter-of-fact manner, quickly moving onto the next scene without thought.
Others end up looking ridiculous, with over-the-top efforts to throw in some sort of "twist". This is particularly true for the climax of the film which sees a sad and compelling situation of misunderstanding descend into farce.
"Black Book" is a very shallow and disappointing film which fails to make the emotional impact that the likes of "The Pianist" or "Schindler's List" do.