I guess trailer #1 set the hype too high, but overall I liked it.

Rating: 7/10 (28 March 2016)

Finally my 3-years-wait is over...Suffice to say I liked it, I really liked as a fan but I didn't love it and that's a bittersweet feeling to be honest. It's a strong start for the DCEU and I can't wait for what's coming. Despite its flaws, if you're a comic book fan you'll geek out over it.
First I'll list what I believe are the Negative points of this movie:

Transition between scenes, it annoyed me a little because it didn't feel natural and maybe one of the reasons is that some scenes were really quick and jump from a point to another with a different tone and plot, so it takes the immersion away and doesn't let a plot progress fluidly.

Cutting 30min from it, did more harm than good, it felt like a Comic with missing pages. For example, we have a scene where Bruce tracks the kryptonite o LexCorp, next scene...They show LexCorp destroyed and the kryptonite stolen, so what happened there? That may be shown in those 30min.

Due to the amount of information they wanted to give us during the movie, a lot of scenes (not all of them) felt underdeveloped. 2h and 20min of movie is not enough to develop every plot correctly. Like for example, when Superman leaves Metropolis, it would've been nice to develop the outcome of it and maybe get the answer to: Does the world needs a Superman? But no, he left, next scene he talks to Jonathan, next scene he's back to save Lois, it all happened so fast.

Now the Points I have mixed feelings with:

Like I said, this movie is aimed at fans and I appreciate that, I could enjoy ever little reference and easter eggs. I think bringing 2 stories together was nice, they did a good job mixing them, BUT it felt underdeveloped too, I mean I understood the reasons behind everything, but it lacked a lot of development, the conflict between the main characters, there should've been more scenes between them to rise the tension and be more dynamic, this movie could've been split into 2 parts.

The way they ended the fight, it's not like I hated it, far from it, actually it was a good way. Bruce having memories of his mother's death, he didn't want the same thing to happen to another person, especially to someone who reminded him of his mother, it's like a way for him to save his mother, to redeem himself since he couldn't do anything when he was a kid. But the WAY it ended, could've been a bit better and more emotional, it felt so dry.

Doomsday, thing is I've never cared about Doomsday in all honesty, so I don't get the excitement over his character and people claiming that he was underdeveloped, actually the movie got him right, he's just a (Kryptonian) beast that wants to destroy everything, its only feeling is rage, and its origin is similar to the comics. But Doomsday has always been a Plot Device, I think people fail to see it, it was only created for one reason and that's to kill Superman (that's the only reason it's famous, because if he didn't do it, he would've been just another monster), that's it and he doesn't need a lot of screen time.

Now, everything else was awesome and these are some points I consider to be good to great:

The casting, it's perfect, Affleck is Bruce AND Batman, I wanted to see more of Gal Gadot, she was awesome. Cavill is still a great Superman, I don't think there's a better choice. I loved Jeremy's Alfred, he's the Alfred I wanted to see portrayed.

Jesse as Luthor, in front of the crowd he's quirky, but macabre when he's face to face with someone. The scene when he shows Superman the pics of Martha was really sinister.

The opening sequence is a masterpiece, it was filmed flawless. From Bruce's origin to the destruction of Metropolis from Bruce's POV, it was excellent, that was the level of storytelling I expected from the whole movie, it was exceptional.

I loved the montage they made when Superman is rescuing people around the world while you can listen some interviews in the background, it's really interesting what they say and the questions they bring to the table. Neil was a surprise and I liked it.

Every cameo, easter eggs and references made in the movie. It opens a door for great stories like Flashpoint Paradox, Under the Red Hood and (why not) Injustice. That nightmare sequence was great, but some scenes were cut, however watching the Parademons and the Omega symbol was a dream come true, HE'S HUNGRY AND HE'S COMING.

Bruce and Clark spent almost the same time on screen, it was really balanced.

Kryptonite spear!

Every nod to The Dark Knight Returns, from quotes to scenes, especially the one when Batman rescues Martha, it's almost the same as the scene in The Dark Knight Returns when he rescues the little kid.

Overall I enjoyed the film, but it's a bittersweet feeling since I didn't love it, maybe I was expecting a lot, trailer #1 set the bar too high I guess. I like the way Snyder takes inspiration from the source material, bringing scenes to life and it's like he took the characters from the comics and pasted them into the movie. But that's not enough, because the movie, especially what we, as fans, are expecting from WB/DC, is a flawless storytelling, on the same as the opening sequence. In my opinion, WB should hire a co-director for their next major events, it's too much to be handled by one guy, especially by one who excels at some stuff but is not so good at others.