Lots to like, a little to dislike.

Rating: 9/10 (30 June 2016)

It's not perfect, but I found lots to like in this movie.
I liked the plot. Convoluted and a bit all over the place but that's preferable to pedestrian. No immersion breaking moments for me.
Good character introductions. Good back-story hints given the time available and numbers. Good balance between dark/gritty and cartoon-y for me.
Actors all do a solid job. Nothing stand-out like a Heath Ledger Joker but something new and nuanced brought to the table for all.
Twin Cities of Gotham and Metropolis are a nice touch. It wasn't just downtown generic skyscraper cities which are overdone recently.
Batplane and Batmobile were good. Sound effects distinctive and somewhat memorable which is difficult these days.
Comparison to other recent franchises:

I liked Batman Begins and I rate it on par with this. Dark Knight and Rises were terrible movies and only Health Ledger saved the former.

Better than Avengers 2, equal to Civil War for me.

Far FAR better than Star Wars VII, that movie had nothing to like, lots to dislike and immersion breaking stupidity throughout. This is a solid EU franchise starter, STVII killed its franchise for me.