Action-packed, visually stunning and incredibly atmospheric, but somehow more than a little disappointing

Rating: 6/10 (4 April 2016)

NO SPOILERS HERE
SUMMARY This movie is not as terrible as the critics try it to be. The style of the movie is very different from his direct competition, Marvel, and it's good. The atmosphere it creates is very gritty and mature, and the mythos combine magic and cold science-fiction, in contrast with the more light-hearted and colorful sci-fi in the Marvel franchise. The real problem is the mess of a plot and destruction porn that suffers in the second and third act.
SPOILERS BEGIN
PROS
+ The first half of this movie has a thought-provoking plot: How should a weapon such as Superman be dealt with? Who does he answer to? The characters deal with this theme with enough maturity, and it's a very common and good Superman plot.
+ Batman is dealt with conviction by Ben Affleck. His artifacts are visually stunning, he has a strong personality and feels like the protagonist throughout this film.
+ Many supporting characters are magnetic. Senator June Finch, Alfred, Perry White and Wonder Woman are some of them.
+ As I said, the film has a strong atmosphere. You can easily figure out the world you are watching, a world filled with human- trafficking, terrorism, serious moral dilemmas and death.
+ Many of the action scenes are superb. I highlight the final scene of Batman vs. Luthor thugs.
+ The bombing of the Capitol is probably the best scene in the movie. Very well-acted, tense and has serious consequences. I loved every second of it.
CONS

The film doesn't follow the direction of questioning the place of Superman in the world. Instead, it begins to crumble in a mess that culminates in a fight that conveniently kills Superman to avoid a satisfying conclusion of the movie's most important theme.

The second act is filled with secondary plots that don't collide very well. The third act, while having some good action bits, it's filled with destruction porn.

The movie pulls out Doomsday out of nowhere, just to add some more action to the film. Put Doomsday out, and this film would have been better.

The supposed main theme of "Superman VS Batman" is not explored enough, and has a disappointing conclusion. One second they are fighting to death, then suddenly they are best friends? What the hell?

Lex Luthor appears to be a completely different character from his comic-book counterpart, and this new character is not appealing, but only annoying and confusing.

The Justice League scenes feel unnecessary and out of place.

END SPOILERS
CONCLUSION
I liked this movie for the atmosphere, most of the characters and the big world it begins to shape. But the plot, which starts promisingly, finally crumbles and finishes on a mediocre note.
6/10