I am giving the score of 9 points based on these 10 reasons (9 in favor).

Rating: 9/10 (28 March 2016)

1. Characters: The criteria to judge, how good the actors take on the role basically comes from comic world. They all did it really well.
2. Set Design: I didn't had any issues with set design of MOS, the movies does a great job in setting up the scenes.
3. VFX: Well it is a movie by Zack Snyder, the VFX are amazing. The criteria to judge will be obviously how well they are in sync with the story, momentum and thrill it provides. So it definitely delivers the result.
4. Sound Track: Junkie and Hans Zimmer, They have been world class before and doesn't disappoint in this one either.
5. Story: Story is decent, it will keep you engaging and you will be interested in watching this movie again for few times because a lot of things happen which will only become noticeable if you see it again. I loved the take on the story where Batman is actually inspired from "The Dark Knight Returns", the movie keeps the basic idea of that Animated Movie but still comes with a great story.
6. Wardrobe & Costumes: Costume Designer did an amazing work with everything, all the characters fitness into the dark world.
7. Action: Very good action sequence, both Batman and Superman have different style and different level strength and you will feel the different in their strength from music, vfx and cinematography. The movie have plenty of action.
8. Momentum: The pace of the movie is fast enough to keep you engaged for the whole time. Everything is synced really good. But this is the part where I agree with the negative critics, there are some areas which could have been improved by reducing the pace. I am not going to give away any spoilers but you will notice that something is a bit off when it comes to momentum of the movie.
9. Plot Holes: I personally think the plot holes could have been avoided by stretching the movie for more 15-20 mins because they seem to be due to the reason that the movie runtime was already decided.
10. Villain: Really good villain.