A fine romantic drama that doubles as an exploration of perception & storytelling

Rating: 8/10 (1 September 2008)

Joe Wright's "Atonement" concerns a fledgling writer who accuses her older sister's lover of a crime that he didn't commit, thus changing their lives irrevocably. Eventually she seeks to atone for her actions and what on the surface seems to be merely romantic melodrama evolves subtly over the course of the film into something wholly unique.
The cast is well-assembled with fine performances all around, though perhaps none that are particularly outstanding. Saorise Ronan, as the young Briony Tallis, received an Oscar nomination in the Best Supporting Actress category. She showed herself fully able, at a young age (13), to match the high standard put forth by the rest of the cast.
The story is an interesting one, though the chain of events leading up to the accusation somewhat stretches the limits of plausibility. These events are easier to accept in the end, though, as certain facts come to light which cast doubts on the entire story. I should note that the script garnered a not undeserved Oscar nomination.
The direction by Joe Wright is excellent, so I am baffled by the fact that he didn't even receive a Best Director Oscar nomination. His debut, "Pride and Prejudice", showed promise and here he delivers on that promise. The art direction, costumes & cinematography all received Oscar nominations so it should be apparent that the film is easy on the eyes. The only Oscar win for the film was for the score, which is quite unique and memorable.
I definitely recommend the film though some may find the romantic aspect off-putting. Nevertheless, let it be known that this film is not merely throwaway romantic fluff; there is indeed plenty of substance here for the discerning viewer.