Nicholson steals the show

Rating: Null/10 (6 August 1998)

Yes, the story is contrived, not even slightly realistic, nor is it beleivable that Carol the waitress would be in the least bit attracted to Melvin. However Nicholson turns in one of his most unforgettable performances in years. His neurotic, self-serving, obsessive compulsive behavior is amazing to watch. His crass comments and facial expressions are brilliantly acted. I suppose Helen Hunt did the best she could with what she had to work with for her character, but nobody flip-flops that much in one movie. One minute she hates him, the next she loves him... Yeah, sure the guy is sick and he needs help. But he's a total jerk! It must have been a really weak year for female leads for her to have won. Greg Kinnear deserved to win best supporting actor more than Helen Hunt deserved her best actress award. I also enjoyed the too few scenes with Cuba Gooding, one of the most charismatic young actors going. Nicholson however carries this thing on his back. Another well deserved Oscar for Jack!