As good as some movies get

Rating: 6/10 (8 April 2005)

A stand-out film in many ways, but ultimately unnecessary ; I recommend watching this once, but repeat performances may seem paltry. All elements of film are here in good form; good acting, good structure, good angles, whatnot. But, in the end, a romantic comedy is just that, and there's nothing here you haven't seen, save perhaps a wider age difference between leads, which is by no means that rare in Hollywood these days anyhow. Good performances, especially by minor players like Cuba Gooding, Jr., light up this film. Helen Hunt, however, is a sorry excuse for Oscar winner in her role. Not so much that she made a lot of mistakes, but the role is a simple one that anyone can play. There are no stretches, no real grit, and certainly no punch. She's as interesting as her apron.
All things considered, a good film, but not exceptional. It effects the soul like an after-dinner mint: refreshing, but brief.