Fails in traditional elements but succeeds in being a thrill ride

Rating: Null/10 (5 January 2002)

Although the film fails in traditional aspects such as plot, characterization, and feasibility, it succeeds in being what the producers probably wanted: a roller coaster ride, possibly unrivaled. Notwithstanding the cheesy plot and gratuitous patriotism, this film is a feast visually, sonically, and emotionally. Sure it is manipulative, but so artfully done that I enjoyed it most of the time. It's a long movie with some definite slow scenes, and some annoying scenes as well. The whole storyline involving father, daughter, and fiancÃ© was tedious and just used to prop up the tear-jerking sacrifice and salvation at the end. On the bright side, it had a seemingly unlimited visual effects budget. The music by Trevor Rabin and Harry Gregson-Williams is a masterpiece by itself and all the more impressive when supporting the visuals. You are pulled through joy, sorrow, laughter, and sheer adrenalin-rush. There are many memorable visual sequences from the film, and even some memorable quotes and facts about asteroid collisions. One that was especially appropriate mirrors a theme from the novel _Lucifer's Hammer_: Never before has a species had the power to prevent its own extinction.