One of the best of 1998

Rating: 8/10 (18 August 1999)

American History X is a startling film that never lacks focus in its portrayal of a white racist; both in his learning and departure of the extremest beliefs. Kaye's debut is something he should be proud of, rather than trying to distance himself from the project. Each and every shot is well taken and the story, although constantly changing from past to present, flows like few other films do. Dealing with such a subject matter with force and staying neutral is an accomplishment in itself.
Edward Norton's performance definitely merited the Oscar nod. Scenes in which he shows rage and anger towards Blacks, Jews or even members of his own family are what make this film what it is. Very few actors could have pulled this role off (think of Ben Affleck in this role instead and you will follow). Norton also shows the other side of his acting ability frequently in the film and is especially potent towards the end. This role moves Norton into the upper echelon of actors that can carry a film on their own. Without Norton, there is no American History X.
The supporting cast all play their role to par. Edward Furlong does well in the role of the younger brother, although he is no Norton. Stacy Keach plays the leader of the skinheads very well and should have had a greater presence in the film. Beverly D'Angelo, John Avery and Elliot Gould round up the cast, all giving their usual smart performances.
The only problem I has with this film was the manner in which Norton's character is such an extreme racist and is changed so quickly. Without giving away the reason, and a good one it may be, I felt that the sudden change took away credibility from the story. Perhaps this was one of the points that Norton and Kaye disagreed on.
Regardless of any squabbles that may have occured between Kaye and Norton, this film is still one of the best of 1998. I would surely like to find out what the disagreement was about and whether it was personal or film-based.

This full gets a full recommendation.
8/10 stars.