Why this great movie has been criticized so much.

Rating: 9/10 (15 May 2005)

Being a fourteen year old male, I realize the legendary Alien and Predator movies will never be rivaled by a modern day exercise in action, adventure, special-effects and overall great film making. However, having watched Alien, Aliens, Predator and Predator 2, I believe Alien Vs Predator matches these four movies in grandeur. I also think that AVP has been given an unfair time by the critics. I believe these factors are responsible: THE 'VS' TAG: Any film with a 'versus' in its title indicates it is going to be a rip off of two other successful creations and after numerous Godzilla vs. films from Japan and the fun but highly unintelligent Freddy Vs. Jason, AVP was immediately shunned.
DOESN'T MATCH THE ORIGINALS: And what sequel can? However, AVP does a pretty damn good job of it. The originals were more adult films and this one appeals to teenagers also.
finally CREDIBILITY: Alien and Predator pitted against each other? Sounds stupid? Not really. Two extraterrestrial species against each other in an unlikely area that has not been explored at all is an excellent premise for a science-fiction movie.
In short, AVP is a great action movie that does justice to the originals. Its harsh reviews are by biased critics who cannot fault the originals and are not open minded to new and improved films.