neither horror nor action film here...

Rating: 2/10 (15 August 2004)

tries to be a twitch film like alien, tries to be an action film like A2.. falls hopelessly in between, managing to do neither well. Also breaks the mythology of *both* the aliens and predator universes, which is a major bummer for viewers that care about such inconsistencies. truly sad, it could have been outstanding if they had put some real thought into it.
scores low for plot, for consistency with prior films, for action, and for horror. not as bad as highlander 2, but really a betrayal of the series
the original darkhorse AvP comic was far better... go find the graphic novel and read that instead of wasting ten bucks and two hours.