A Review Of Both The Theatrical and Director's Cut of the Film

Rating: 10/10 (30 September 2005)

THEATRICAL VERSION Oliver Stone's "Alexander" is a great film that chronicles the life of Alexander the Great, the Macedonian King/General that conquered 90% of the "Known World," and was never defeated in battle! From great performances by Colin Farrell (who performance in this film is highly underrated) and an all-star cast, to it's brilliant recreations of Ancient places, as well as some exciting battle sequences, the film never ceases to be both exciting and emotional! It is a thrilling and historically accurate portrayal of the man whose dreams and vision would shape the world in which we live in today!
THE DIRECTOR'S CUT Oliver Stone's new Director's Cut of "Alexander" is slightly better than the theatrical version. Scenes were cut (Including some of Anthony Hopkins' beautiful portrayal of Old Ptolemy), but the new material is just as good. Some scenes were reshaped, and are much better because of it. If you didn't enjoy the theatrical version, then you may enjoy Stone's new Director's Cut.
THE DVD: Both of the DVD releases of the film feature the same three-part behind-the-scenes documentary by Sean Stone (Which could have been better, but is still fascinating), as well as an interesting featurette on Greek composer Vangelis scoring the film. The commentary tracks on both DVD's are worthwhile. The one on the theatrical DVD is by Stone and Historical Consultant Robin Lane Fox, who gives great historical insights and further details on the real Alexander. Most of Stone's comments are the same as on the Director's Cut DVD, in which he is the only participant. Although I don't agree with Stone politically, he has a fine grasp of the English language, and has a powerful presence when he speaks. His insight into Alexander, as well as the making of this "unconventional historical epic," are fascinating to listen to on both versions of the film.
IN CLOSING: All in all, both DVD's are worthwhile. No matter which version of the film you end up seeing, know that Oliver Stone has truly captured the essence and the grandeur of one of histories greatest legends. This film should definitely hold a place in everyone's collection of historical epics.
Theatrical Cut Grade: A Director's Cut Grade: A DVD Grade: A