Almost perfect

Rating: 9/10 (26 October 2018)

Thumbs up for Bradley Cooper, being somebody totally new and very well done directing. And Lady Gaga is having another amazing performance, keep on altering herself from pop star, jazz singer with Tony Bennet, moved audience for standing ovation on the Sound of Music, now an actor. I say big wow for them.
Anyway, for me the peak scene to end the whole drama is not enough. Lady Gaga should have been singing in bit of trembling and more tears to show her sadness but still posing high in showing how she's done with her misery. I would compare her to Rebecca Ferguson in her lipsync of Never Enough, and Ferguson nailed it, whilst Gaga could have been much better since she really sings.