Entertaining yet boring, not Oscar material at all.

Rating: 6/10 (9 January 2019)

I've been a fan of Gaga, so I know that what I'm gonna say might probably give me a lot of thumbs down, but I'll be honest...
People were thrilled when it was announced. Then it premiered and I have to say, wow... I can't believe the hype, it makes no sense.
Bradley's performance is solid... Yes, but I didn't buy his role, he looked like an imitation of whatever he thought a country musician is in real life and didn't nail it.
His addiction is poorly developed during the whole movie, he just portraits the character like a spoiled brat who barely struggles with his addictions.
Gaga's, on the other hand... I understand it's her first movie and she's not an actress, but we can't pretend she's great at it.
Her expressions are stiff, her face is so rigid in many scenes...
We have to separate our feelings for Gaga and her music from her career as an actress. She has a great voice, but don't ask her to show emotions in her expressions, this movie shows she can't do it.
It's entertaining, but definitely not Oscar material.