Gaga as Gaga, Copper as Mint.

Rating: 1/10 (25 February 2019)

Although it deserve a 7. I qualify with 1 to downgrade the unexpecting high fans reviews.
I agreed to see the movie after the Oscar. I really do not understand how the Oscar works to have nominated Lady Gaga as best actress. She played a role where she could easily perform. Practically Gaga acting as Gaga, it is not fair to give merit to her when many other actresses deserved to be finalists making a hard perfom.
Gaga did well, but only that, it is not a role to be praised as it has been until now.
Cooper on the contrary, he did a role that does not correspond to his life. Excellent performance, however incredible that the film has been nominated for Oscar since the film is lost in concerts and the rapid fame of a new singer, leaving aside the true development it should have: dive into the drug and alcoholic problem of Cooper and a real relationship with problems.
Cooper as director lost the oportunity to make a better remake telling a better and different story behind the great music.