Mesmerizingly good

Rating: Null/10 (9 October 2018)

Gaga is terrific and I wasn't surprised. The big surprise for me was Cooper's performance, not to mention his directing. Here's hoping he directs again. I did not expec a remake (let alone a remake of A Star Is Born) to keep me guessing.
It has been updated intelligently and with respect to its predessors. For me, no one can top Judy Garland as the "Star" but Gaga comes very close indeed. Cooper as the doomed husband is simply unforgettable. The last half hour is gut-wrenching and I admit I wept.
The music is excdllent and Cooper has cast the supporting roles to perfection. Particulary great are Sam Elliott as his brother and Andrrew Dice Clay as Gaga's father. Dave Chappelle is terrific as Cooper's best friend. The movie is very well acted down to the smallest roles. The meet cute in the drag bar is wonderfully charming.
This film excels technically on all fronts. It will get many Oscar nominations. It is a lock for Best Song.
Go see it. Even if you think you've seen it before, you haven't.