EstÃ¡ bastante bien. It's pretty good

Rating: 6/10 (10 February 2019)

Tiene una de las mejores presentaciones de personajes que he visto en mucho tiempo. Como presenta a Bradley en un solo momento es genial. Con Gaga no le pasa lo mismo, necesita varios planos pero no estÃ¡ mal.
La verdad es que no la querÃ­a ver, otra pelÃ­cula de amor, pero como estÃ¡ nominada pues toca verla. Y me ha sorprendido para bien. No es la pelÃ­cula del aÃ±o, pero estÃ¡ bastante bien. La quÃ­mica entre ellos es increÃ­ble. Si bien la mÃºsica, para ser una pelÃ­cula de mÃºsicos, no me hace que baile en la silla.
Es curiosa, o al menos yo lo he entendido asÃ­, la critica que hace la pelÃ­cula a los tipos de mÃºsica actuales en los que importa mÃ¡s la imagen que la mÃºsica.
Los actores estÃ¡n tremendos, todos ellos, no sÃ© si para nominar a Sam, eso ya me parece excesivo, pero solo por cÃ³mo estÃ¡n los dos si lo merecen. El parece que realmente esta borracho toda la pelÃ­cula.
La iluminaciÃ³n estÃ¡ bastante bien. Salvo algunos exteriores que tienen demasiada luz, pero el resto estÃ¡ de maravilla. Te mete en la pelÃ­cula y ni los conciertos, que sabes que es ordenador, ni se notan.
Como director, no le habrÃ­a nominado. Si bien tiene cosas muy buenas, sobre todo para ser su primera pelÃ­cula, pero no creo que sea para Oscar. La cÃ¡mara es un mero acompaÃ±amiento, solo observa, no cuenta. Pero sÃ­ que es capaz de contarte la historia sin aburrirte y eso que estÃ¡ demasiado tiempo con los temas musicales.
No me gusta nada el final. Se le ha ido. Lo ha hecho sentimentalista. Los dos Ãºltimos planos no quedan bien. Imagino que no sabrÃ­a como terminarla.
It has one of the best character presentations I've seen in a long time. How he presents Bradley in a single moment is great. With Gaga the same thing does not happen, he needs several plans but it's not bad.
The truth is that I did not want to see her, another love movie, but since she is nominated, it's time to see her. And it has surprised me for good. It's not the movie of the year, but it's pretty good. The chemistry between them is incredible. While music, to be a movie of musicians, does not make me dance in the chair.
It is curious, or at least I have understood it that way, the criticism that the film makes of the current types of music in which the image matters more than music.
The actors are tremendous, all of them, I do not know if to nominate Sam, that already seems excessive, but only for how are the two if they deserve it. He looks like the whole movie is really drunk.
The lighting is quite good. Except some exteriors that have too much light, but the rest is great. It puts you in the movie and not even the concerts, which you know is a computer, or noticed.
As a director, I would not have nominated him. While it has very good things, especially to be his first film, but I do not think it's for Oscar. The camera is a mere accompaniment, just watch, it does not count. But he is able to tell you the story without getting bored and that is too long with the musical themes.
I do not like the ending at all. It has gone. It has made him sentimentalist. The last two planes do not look good. I guess I would not know how to finish it.