I'll definitely receive a lot of "thumbs down" for it, but let's do this...

Rating: 4/10 (21 February 2019)

Yeah, you saw my grading, and it's probably thinking "wtf, dude?". I don't know how so many people like this movie (it's apparently almost a consensus, I think, but we'll, I didn't, and I'll try explain why).
The main problem, for me, it's that the movie is confusing, not in the sense that it is too complicated for you to understand, but actually in the sense of there are some many things happening at the same time, that you get lost. For example, the beginning of the it. I was impressed with how many things happen in the first 20/25 minutes of movie. She is in a pilot suit (?). Then she apparently works in a kitchen...? (They never explain that). Then she is singing in a drag bar. They come out. She punches a cop. They go to the market to buy freeze food (why don't you buy ice...? Since you are in the supermarket...). They SING in the parking lot. All of that in 20 minutes.
But this is just an example. Don't get me wrong, I love most of the songs (c'mon, Gaga is amazingly talented, she is awesome), the acting is good. The cinematography is... ok?. But the story its self, I mean, she didn't have nothing to overcome thought the movie, they talk about her nose (?) but this is never an issue. She also says at some point that she doesn't want to be change by fame, but its ok with painting her hair orange...? And again, they never come back to this point again, she just changes and that's it. Even the dancers scene, after that show, she starts to use the dancers, and... that's it. Zero conflict.
Also at the end. The producers it's kinda of responsible for her husband's death, but... Yeah, apparently nobody will ever now that, and confronts him about it.
I love Sam Elliot, he is amazing, a legend, but I don't get all the buss here. Really, he does those type of things in The Ranch. Literally, his character in The Ranch, has some emotional scenes, that are as emotional as his scenes here are. What again, don't get me wrong, they ARE good, but it's not something he hasn't done before.
Another scene, that to me sums up a lot of what is wrong with the movie: Their "fight" in the bathroom. I mean. Wtf was going on there...? WHY do they fight?! There is literally no reason, and leads to nowhere. Cause in the next scene they are fine again.
Anyways, to wrap up, A Star is Born, for me, it's a movie with a great cast and soundtrack, but that brings a story without depth, that at the end, just seems like a bunch of scenes cut together with much of a narrative objective. Definitely not worthy of the best picture nomination.