Riveting performances compensate for implausibilities

Rating: 7/10 (2 September 2007)

A compelling story lead by two of the most talented and charismatic actors working in film (Christian Bale and Russell Crowe) is kept from achieving the level of a great film because of plot points that are implausible. If the viewer can let go of the need for logic and enjoy fine acting and entertaining dialogue, it should not be too difficult to appreciate the characters brought to life by Crowe, Bale, and the supporting cast. What the script lacks in consistent believability, it makes up for with humor and chemistry. Crowe, as the hardened, life-long (yet charming) criminal searching for something decent in himself, and Bale as the beleaguered, beaten down rancher desperate to hold onto his land and last shred of self-respect make a memorable screen duo who square off against each other (and themselves) physically and psychologically.