No bombs, no karate, no love story, no major scene changes, no color......GREAT MOVIE!!!!

Rating: 10/10 (30 April 2004)

Can you believe that there is a successful movie that has none of the major Hollywood tried and true methods to create a lasting memory? This film is a major triumph that still creates a stir in me every time I see it. It's power is not in the visual images created, (although much of the cinematography is imaginative, especially the last shot from the coat closet, even with the challenge of one major room), but in the drama created by the tension of men coming together from all walks of lives to judge another human being. They bring their prejudices, their fear, their life experiences, their lack of interest, and their anonymity into a room to make a decision--that's when the real story starts.
We all think about the possibility of having to face that day--some relish the opportunity while others fear making a bad decision. It's one reason this film resonates with so many people. It's a common experience that brings out different emotions in different people. The remake, although not as effective because of the lack of originality, is also good and brings in other points of view, including racial issues. Both lack one thing--a female's point of view! But that creates even more tension. After all, men don't want to deal with their emotions the same way women do. Besides, we would have to change the title! :o)