Task: Table-QA (source dataset: FinQA)

Task: 
You are given a table containing structured data and a natural language question referring to the table. Your goal is to analyze the table and provide an accurate and concise answer based on the given data.

Instructions:
1. Understand the Table: Examine the structure, headers, and data in the table. Identify relevant columns and rows related to the question.
2. Interpret the Question: Determine whether the question requires direct retrieval, aggregation, comparison, sorting, filtering, or inference.
3. Extract the Answer: Use logical reasoning and numerical operations (if necessary) to derive the correct response from the table.
4. Format the Answer: No explanation, return the answer in a structured JSON format: {"answer": <answer>}. If the question cannot be answered due to missing or ambiguous data, return a JSON response with {"answer": null}.

Table:
| Unnamed: 0                                                 | 2017              | 2016             | 2015             |
|:-----------------------------------------------------------|:------------------|:-----------------|:-----------------|
| statutory u.s . federal tax rate                           | 35.0% ( 35.0 % )  | 35.0% ( 35.0 % ) | 35.0% ( 35.0 % ) |
| state taxes net of federal benefit                         | 2.1               | 3.7              | 3.0              |
| domestic production activities deduction                   | -1.0 ( 1.0 )      | -1.3 ( 1.3 )     | -1.3 ( 1.3 )     |
| increase ( decrease ) in domestic valuation allowance      | -0.1 ( 0.1 )      | -4.7 ( 4.7 )     | 0.1              |
| impact of revised state and local apportionment estimates  | 3.1               | 0.5              | -0.7 ( 0.7 )     |
| reclassification of accumulated other comprehensive income | 3.5               | 2014             | 2014             |
| impact of 2017 tax act                                     | -101.6 ( 101.6 )  | 2014             | 2014             |
| other net                                                  | -1.8 ( 1.8 )      | -0.3 ( 0.3 )     | 0.2              |
| effective tax expense ( benefit ) rate                     | ( 60.8 ) % (  % ) | 32.9% ( 32.9 % ) | 36.3% ( 36.3 % ) |

Question:
what was the fluctuation between the effective tax expense rate and the statutory u.s . federal tax rate in 2016?


pre_text: after , including a reduction in the u.s .
federal corporate income tax rate from 35% ( 35 % ) to 21% ( 21 % ) .
the 2017 tax act makes broad and complex changes to the u.s .
tax code including , but not limited to , the repeal of the irc section 199 domestic production activities deduction in 2018 and accelerated depreciation that allows for full expensing of qualified property beginning in the fourth quarter of 2017 .
on december 22 , 2017 , the sec staff issued a staff accounting bulletin that provides guidance on accounting for the tax effects of the 2017 tax act .
the guidance provides a measurement period that should not extend beyond one year from the 2017 tax act enactment date for companies to complete the accounting for income taxes related to changes associated with the 2017 tax act .
according to the staff accounting bulletin , entities must recognize the impact in the financial statements for the activities that they have completed the work to understand the impact as a result of the tax reform law .
for those activities which have not completed , the company would include provisional amounts if a reasonable estimate is available .
as a result of the reduction of the federal corporate income tax rate , the company has revalued its net deferred tax liability , excluding after tax credits , as of december 31 , 2017 .
based on this revaluation and other impacts of the 2017 tax act , the company has recognized a net tax benefit of $ 2.6 billion , which was recorded as a reduction to income tax expense for the year ended december 31 , 2017 .
the company has recognized provisional adjustments but management has not completed its accounting for income tax effects for certain elements of the 2017 tax act , principally due to the accelerated depreciation that will allow for full expensing of qualified property .
reconciliation of the statutory u.s .
federal income tax rate to the effective tax rate is as follows: .
post_text: in 2017 , the effective rate was lower than the statutory tax rate due to the remeasurement of the deferred tax liabilities as a result of the 2017 tax act .
this decrease was partially offset by an increase in the state apportionment impact of the illinois income tax rate change on deferred tax liabilities as well as the reclassification of income tax expense from accumulated other comprehensive income related to the disposal of bm&fbovespa shares .
in 2016 , the effective rate was lower than the statutory tax rate largely due to the release of the valuation allowances related to the sale of bm&fbovespa shares .
the decrease was partially offset by an increase in state tax expense and the state apportionment impact on deferred tax liabilities .
in 2015 , the effective rate was higher than the statutory tax rate primarily due to the impact of state and local income taxes .
the effective rate was primarily reduced by the section 199 domestic productions activities deduction ( section 199 deduction ) and the impact of state and local apportionment factors in deferred tax expense .
the section 199 deduction is related to certain activities performed by the company 2019s electronic platform. .
label: 0.021
qa: answer: 2.1%
explanation: its the difference between those tax rates
ann_table_rows: 1
9
ann_text_rows: 15
steps: op: minus1-1
arg1: 35%
arg2: 32.9%
res: 2.1%
program: subtract(35%, 32.9%)
gold_inds: table_1: the statutory u.s . federal tax rate of 2017 is 35.0% ( 35.0 % ) ; the statutory u.s . federal tax rate of 2016 is 35.0% ( 35.0 % ) ; the statutory u.s . federal tax rate of 2015 is 35.0% ( 35.0 % ) ;
table_9: the effective tax expense ( benefit ) rate of 2017 is ( 60.8 ) % ( % ) ; the effective tax expense ( benefit ) rate of 2016 is 32.9% ( 32.9 % ) ; the effective tax expense ( benefit ) rate of 2015 is 36.3% ( 36.3 % ) ;
text_15: in 2016 , the effective rate was lower than the statutory tax rate largely due to the release of the valuation allowances related to the sale of bm&fbovespa shares .
text_1: federal corporate income tax rate from 35% ( 35 % ) to 21% ( 21 % ) .
exe_ans: 0.021
program_re: subtract(35%, 32.9%)
model_input: text_12
federal income tax rate to the effective tax rate is as follows: .
table_1
the statutory u.s . federal tax rate of 2017 is 35.0% ( 35.0 % ) ; the statutory u.s . federal tax rate of 2016 is 35.0% ( 35.0 % ) ; the statutory u.s . federal tax rate of 2015 is 35.0% ( 35.0 % ) ;
table_9
the effective tax expense ( benefit ) rate of 2017 is ( 60.8 ) % ( % ) ; the effective tax expense ( benefit ) rate of 2016 is 32.9% ( 32.9 % ) ; the effective tax expense ( benefit ) rate of 2015 is 36.3% ( 36.3 % ) ;