marks its one hundredth anniversary this year is one of the few remaining nearly intact stretching continuously from the top of down into key hay and whereas according to family history this was purchased from the cornwell family by by molly sen harold w popped rice in one nine hundred sixteen marking the start of our normal ranch is legacy and whereas harold lossky rice arena for a fourth of july rodeo in one nine hundred fifty six and has turned it into a home by east premier rodeo and an annual upcountry tradition and continuing the family's strong ranching traditions and whereas the ranch is continually planning for its future success and higher it can round up as general manager in ninety two thousand and fourteen who will work closely with family members charlie king wendy rice peterson will be king and henry f price to continue oh no lose ranching legacy whereas the partners recognise the importance of agriculture and ranch life in mali and in despair and they continue to employ many long time funny onal families whereas the greater community has come to recognize the contributions made by  anniversary and to that certified copies of this resolution be transmitted to co not will ranch family members henry f rice harold frederick freddy rice j recognize and honor their one hundred anniversary renting has played a very important role in our modern history and is a part of what makes a country truly special the rolling pastures the horses and of course the cattle that you find sometimes on your street ranting however is not an easy profession it takes a commitment to working long and nights and in part for the right thinking families continuing an important family  the ranch has found a workable formula that has allowed them to outlast many other businesses in ranches while keeping much of their ranch land intact the recognition today is also quite momentous as it kicks  an important weekend for the race family they played a major role in creating and building up the muck rodeo and later the markwell parade and old growth of the rodeo both henry and freddie have been named as grand marshals of the parade to help honor not only their work but also those that came before them including us and harold pop writes it is a fitting honor and i know it's going to be an exciting weekend for all we wish the king and race family along with their entire extended the best in all of their future endeavors and send a big mahalo for their numerous contributions to our community and helping to make would also want to offer my congratulations to the racing king family for the many years of not only operating and being a part of the wrenching scene but also for their contributions to this community they have been a large country contributor and philanthropist rocked this community for many many years and i want to thank them for that it is really enjoyable to see the four generations sitting here today together it's amazing how things move ahead and how things change yet with all the changes this franchise has played an integral part and stayed very much the way it was set up to be yes they're looking at different options in their business and you have to that's the business where we live in but as an entity and as a family they have been a stalwart in our community again i'd like to congratulate them on the hundredth anniversary and w hundred years of success i mean i've been around maybe my grandchildren great grandchildren will celebrate just two hundred anniversary of the ranch itself thank you mr chairman thank you mr grunow members any further discussion mr carrol i gave earlier were prepared for chair and it was my honor to be able to present them to you today but as you know a country is the home of my family has been for all of our lives three generations of it and it felt really good to walk into this chamber today and see people that actually have called way and it makes me feel really comfortable to see faces on my entire life and that they have been a part of our lives and i know my husband won't mind if i tell a little story and he of course what this is part of his life too because his dad for the races they had one point had a very large hall farm which my father my father in law ran and of course sherman as a race i boarded up a very hall and to still drive that road and to come up upon the gates and the whole that area it's still like i recall because there's many places to be that you can't recognize it but in that area  preserved and of course we're honoring the tradition of the you know the ranch the root of the parade that will all i'm sure be a part of tomorrow which will be exciting so i just think that it's it's a great  he rodeo and the parade the ranch does come down into sometimes more often than i like it when it rains but we still have a lot of the ranch lands are down  and look forward to many more years thank you thank you for your share i too would like to congratulate the ranch and in thinking about our history of  maui or a few families in this community that have built this island in the in the county to what it is today and these are the families that have made up the fabric in the foundation of what we have today by starting out traditions and when you think of that you think of the king family and the rice family and many others but today we honor the king family and the rice family for being that pillar in the community  to maintain our traditions and our legacies what's so delightful is to see this next generation sitting here in the chamber knowing that our heavenly father will continue to bless these families and that they will continue to be the protectors of our land and that with all hope our prayers are with the family to overcome any challenges and difficulties because they are living legacies of what we have grown up to mentors whether it be the even my own father and i would touch base with them asking them years ago about certain applications coming before me as a council member and i'm telling the story because there is one thing i appreciated that for that gentleman and myself we still believed in the or ethic that a man's word and a man's handshake is good enough you don't need an attorney if you need a piece of paper to memory remember lie something that is a man of integrity sincerity that your word in your handshake was good enough and we had a great discussion we came to terms and you think that mr price without a piece of paper fulfilled everything that he said he would do regarding this project i find it commendable he should meet again stated as a character trait that is very rare but is very precious in my perspective of what is true character and i mention this because it is something that i hope is in doubt within this family because it's great to put it on us and that they can share this with other members of our general community that integrity is still something cherish and respected in my wee county and i think this family when they're part of keeping take radio business fulfilling their obligations and commitments that they have fallen kelly to is something to be commended and appreciated by everyone in this county so the race family congratulations on your hundredth anniversary it is a testament to the character of your families thank you very much mr chairman thank you for so comma i couldn't add a better word than integrity and i think all of us have a great appreciation to the old families that have been able to provide a level of stewardship that continues and a level of stewardship that we don't often see in other areas and i think it's you know i think we take our hats off to you and i want to thank you from the bottom of our hearts for maintaining the property maintaining the the kinds of assets that you've been able to provide to the community such as the arena and the areas around it because it really helps to cement the fabric of our community if you look at what's happening this weekend with the rodeo and the parade that's just one one of the times that the asking price arena is used it's that area is used for the country fair it's used for many other things so without that i think we would have a much more difficult time keeping the ranching community and as together and as as whole as it has been i think a lot of us also need to be thankful for the level of focus that these families have on maintaining pastures because they're not just raising cows they're raising grass they're raising other animals if they need to they're doing it in such a way that they're they're focus on not losing the ability to call i mean ranchers are basically grass farmers and their their job is to maintain their lands in such a way that they don't run off during a heavy rain so they're always maintaining the environment that we all love to look at in ways that wouldn't be possible without the level of integrity that these many of these families have in this family especially so it's with great honor that we recognize you this morning and take our hats off and i guess put our spurs on and wish you all the best for the next hundred years like to call down the partners of calm old eventually long with the members of the rights thinking family to present them with the official copy of the resolution and yes please come forward said i'd like to proceed with the presentation i'm very honored today again to be able to do this and we have for you the copy of the resolution and you can hold on to that henry and then on top of it i have your buckles for being grand marshals and this is for you freddy and this is for you henry thank you and we definitely want to hear few words from you say if you would please nd council members thank you this is  which you met here truly appreciate this this resolution is truly actually a reflection of cooperation and support between elected officials and the ranchers and farmers  parade i can recommend the cello fun and it's a very good and it's an honor for both freddie and i to be writing as grand marshals in our nerve our father so thank you very much fre probably nobody here is old enough to remember h w rice harold harold rice and he was controversy at times and i might just take advantage of this situation for a project that i've had in mind for a long time the second world war the military took over what is now the call louis airport skein feel and at the end of the war it was going back to the plantation so it still be on his own dollar went to washington and convince the military to give that area the airport as it stood over to the county and  controversy there was no what he wanted to spend the money to renovate it so again he raised the funds to do that and it's been in my mind for a long time and something i'm going to pursue  es thought carluke airport should be named the harold w rice airfield because without his efforts that airport would not exist today would be just another cane field thank you for your guys we'll get you back here thank you very much in our best aloha to all of you and i'd like to again thank your light for doing the resolution today and thank you for letting me do it you know she's my home and i love it thank you thank you so much and thank you for all of you for showing up today and allowing us to recognize the great work you've done district offices should now sign up with the district office staff individuals who wish to offer testimony in the chamber please sign up at the desk located on the eighth floor lobby just outside the chamber door testimony and all  get to the items listed on today's agenda and pursuant to the rules of the counsel each testify is allowed to testify for up to three minutes with one minute to conclude if requested and when testifying please take the name and the name of any organization before you the minutes of the special meeting of april first twenty sixteen minutes of the regular meeting of april fifteenth twenty sixteen and minutes of the public hearing of april twenty first tw satisfied responses as regards to the investments at the start of the fiscal year the interest earned on those short term investments as well as the balances at the end of set theory is a comedian is a review says fay with those responses and hear by recommends planning commissions a proposed bill amending conference of zoning ordinance related to enforcement procedures for a bed and breakfast homes and short term rental homes be adopted and to their general communication fifteen dash one five fifteen dash five proposed bill entitled a bill for an ordinance amending the comprehensive zoning ordinance relating to the enforcement procedures for bed and breakfast homes and short term mental homes the proposed bill would amend the enforcement provisions for better breakfast homes and short term mental homes to add requirements and timelines for enforcement of violations relating to advertising of unpermitted operations in addition to strengthening the enforcement process the proposed bill would amend chapter one thousand point six four of our county code relating to bed and breakfast homes for consistency with the recent revisions made by ordinance forty three debt forty three one five two thousand and sixteen to chapter one thousand point six five maui county code relating to short term mental homes but also like to mention that there are some there's some confusion out there about what the proposed bill would do the mowing news published a viewpoint article on june twenty eighth two thousand and sixteen that included a number of false statements i made copies of the article for the members if they want one paragraph in particular stands out which reads despite these benefits home sharing on maui county is currently under threat from our county council planning committee is considering a move that would fundamentally undermine the way residents and visitors use home sharing platforms if approved this proposed change would require home sharing companies to police their users and be responsible for user generated content on their platforms nothing could be further from the truth in fact the proposed bill would place the burden squarely upon the owner to establish that b in b that the b and b or s t r age that is being advertised is being operated legally and in compliance with all it took up a lot for years a proposed resolution referring the proposed bill to the planning commissions for the review and comment your committee recommended the adoption of this similar type of businesses that he's considering to veto and i believe that some of the comments mr couch keep the earlier was in regards as it relates to the state legislation in not necessary county or this council's your questions first let me remind everybody that this is sending the bill to planning commission for review so we still have another crack at it when it comes back to this bill only should that bill  vetoed that was just to allow for taxation for the air b n b and home away and all those folks to actually collect the taxes on behalf of the state and then pay the taxes to the states so that really has nothing to do with the least the one i'm familiar with that's up there has nothing to do with the actual enforcement they just would collect the taxes and i think the governors concern was that it would make it would put the impression out there that if you've got a d eighty number in a g d p number then that means you're legal and that would actually do harm to the county's ordinances or at least to the impression that people need to  follow the county rules as well so i think that's his concern but it has nothing to do with enforcement as far as i know so it shouldn't this bill shouldn't be affected and if there is something in there that is affects the bill we get a chance to take a and he doesn't have the appropriate permit from the county i'm just going to see whether this is going to be more confusing for those that are actually trying to comply versus those they really want to try and hide so  understood and i do believe that the states still could cause that confusion so if the governor vetoes it then then that will take some of that confusion away but yes it could cause  confusion this bill before us today not at all in fact in enhanced is our ability to enforce and the resources as well and one lesson that may jeopardize the county's the county's ability to right to oversee zoning and other issues that are our purview not not the states but the grace period thing more pertains to the next bill coming i think you know any further discussion on this measure so you know those in favor of placing the five i saved i was oh say no if you're passing with more planning commissions a proposed bill amending section nineteen point six five point zero three zero molly county coley to establish ownership duration of require months for short term rental home permit applications be adopted and to that county communication sixteen dash nine five be filed they can be sure moved up the recommendations in planning committee report sixteen dash one zero five a bill for an ordinance amending section in one thousand point six five point zero three zero in our county code to establish ownership durational requirements for short term mental home permit applications the proposed bill would require that an applicant applying for a short term in a home  must have on their property for at least five years before submitting their application the cold artery prevents an owner from building a new home immediately and immediately applying to convert to short term now use the proposed bill would simply p an older home and immediately applying for a permit your committee noted that the proposal would help discourage speculation and keep older properties as long as as long term housing the proposed bill will take effect six months after its approval to allow owners with less than five year ownership to apply for permits the proposed bill also includes exceptions for properties that had a short term and a home permit within three years of the date of purchase and for more proper for properties with an s s value of one million dollars or more and that's for the building alone before you as a proposed resolution referring the proposed bill to the planning commissions for their review and comment your committee recommendation recommended adoption of the resolution of filing the communication  proceeding lake county communications you have before you county communication number sixteen dash one one six hundred director of finance transmitting to house all fifty contracts grants for the month of april twenty sixt cook county communications sixteen dash one one seven from the director of finance transmitting to council sixty seven contracts in grants for the month of may twenty sixth mr hogan chairman i here by requests members of the council if you have a specific contract you would like to have reviewed by the budget in france committee under its finance responsibilities to me those contracts known members are there any other requests for granting aids award period of july one twenty sixteen june thirtieth twenty seventeen in the amount of three hundred seventy three thousand two hundred seventy six dollars mr okama chairman i move to first sixteen this one one planning for this grant this helps with funding a position in the department of planning that is very critical to our coastal zone management and yes i'm a rule rules and procedures  especially preservation of beaches and we're working really hard with her and she's done a great job and in the time that we've been here so thank you thank you mr couch any further discussion members seen none of those in favor pl further discussion mr holder chairman i also think a resident for monday is a field giving time and service to the county in our community when you look  her reasons for this decision that she has made is quite disturbing for me canceled meetings and meetings with our cor and i wish i had some point in time maybe under mr victory knows leadership we can ask are they outstanding issues that we need to be made aware of those that volunteer whereby for those of of those to surf aro on our part to improve the situation to have this meetings then i think people will tend to be more open to volunteering and volunteer in framing of that they're being frustrated and choose to resign so something very brief on the fourth especially for the outlying districts and their quality problems and maybe some changes need to be made and then be something to this council and the administration needs to speak to so thank you to thank you any further entitled approving the appointment of tracy for as a legislative analyst in the office of council services degree from golden gate university as well as a broad range of relevant professional experiences for the past five years she has served for the serve the county as a deputy director of liquor control in this position she has been the first counsel for fourteen years i have known tracy for several years i think more than eighteen years or so i think she's a very good worker efficient her integrity is beyond doubt one of the best that i've known she's going to be a great asset to this team and so i recommend the appointment of tracy villa rosales as the legislative analysts in the office of council service members to please approve it i think they were very fortunate to have this quality coming to help us in council services which is a stellar resume and all i can say is lickers losses  yes mr richard oh and i also like to act with the same sentiments i've worked not only in a professional manner but with a family for many many years and i know i'm going to be all standing citizens in this community and i know tracy is a welcome addition for us and  sixteen dash nine five you have before you cannae communication number sixteen dash one twenty two from council member or comma transmitting to counsel an amendment to bill sixty seven twenty sixteen mr ho following county communications are recommended to the following committees as noted to your budget and finance committee county communication sixteen dash one twenty three from the director of finance translating to counsel a proposal and titled a bill for an ordinance authoriz twenty four from the director of finance transmitting to counsel a proposed resolution entitled the bill for an ordinance authorizing the mayor of the county of mali to enter into an at and governmental agreement with the employers retirement system of the state of relating to the acquisition of a governmental accounting standards board statement number sixty eight report county communication number sixteen dash one twenty five from the budget director transmitting to council the following proposed bills in title one a bill for an ordinance amending appendix housing fun habitat for humanity home a project county communication sixteen one twenty six from the budget director transmitted to council the following proposed bills and titled a bill for an ordinance amending appendix is able to fiscal year twenty seventeen budget for the county of mali as it pertains to estimated revenues the department of water supply it ministration program waterfront total operating up appropriations and total appropriations operating in capital improvement projects and to construction plan review fees county communication number sixteen one twenty nine from the director of finance transmitting to council a report on transfers from the general fund and department of water supply revenue fund to the twenty seventeen propose general obligations bond fund as of may thirty first two thousand and sixteen to your housing human services and transportation committee county communication number sixteen dash one thirty from council member crew velo relating to the  short range transit plan county communication number sixteen nash one thirty one from councilman chris council member crew velo relating to homelessness in maui county county communications sixteen one thirty two from council member crew velo relating to amendments to the residential workforce housing policy county communication number sixteen dash one thirty three hundred director of housing and human concerns transmitting to council a document in title low income housing tax credit project for sale under qualified contract requests in accordance with section forty two age six of the internal revenue scold front street apartments to your infrastructure and environmental management committee county communication number sixteen dash one thirty four from the director of environmental management transmitting to counsel a proposed resolution in title authorizing site police related to electricity generating carli waste water reclamation facility to your policy and intergovernmental affairs committee county communication number sixteen nash one thirty five from de mer transmitting to counsel a proposed resolution entitled so ordered mr clerk mr chair proceeding with resolution for a second and final reading you have before you resolution number sixteen dash ninety proposing proposing an amendment to the revised charter of the housekeeping thing that we wanted to change the name from civil defense agency to our county emergency management agency because civil defense agency when it was first founded if you will was to basically  the defense of the civilians in war time now the civil defense agency does a lot more than just that it does emergency management and basically does the same things that fema does on the federal level and the state and national guard in the state emergency management agency does on the state level so i felt it was more appropriate to call them what clerk mystic chair proceeding with ordinances for a second final reading you have before you bill number seven your one twenty sixteen a bill for an ordinance to change zoning from income discreet to our story residential district conditional carroll a second from us by so to defer this until our next count any further discussion of those in favor please signify by saying i was opposed say met mr chair proceeding with unfinished business you had before you cannae communication number sixteen dash one of five from deputy cooperation council relating to a bill for annoyance amending section two to brought up i never heard him say i moved his motion and the two numbers of the what he was saying was his motion is still on the floor from our last meeting ok ok objection so ordered to mr chair county communication number sixteen dash one twenty killed from council member hold a comma transmitting to counsel an amendment to a bill sixty seven twenty sixteen just so you're very clear is will a man exhibit one to bill sixty seven to just matters discussed at the previous council meeting of june seventeenth two thousand and six dean so for further discussion mr chairman i intend to now place emotion before the members in the motion is the man chapters three seven nine ten and thirteen and appendix lane point three of exhibit one to bill sixty seven are you placing language s on the test markup you have presented to you this morning from from i so another amendment added recommended by cooperation council and in that that's meant you will see that this  the discussion that the community advisory committee or the complaining little and i planning commission had to discuss this is to make clear that besides the water use development plant any other laws that have been passed either by the state or the county also will have an implementation and enforcement such as budgets district ordinances so i ask the members to take this recommendation as put forth by cooperation council i am in support of this and i believe this in will help clarify the community's position on this subject thank you q members a further discussion on this item our community was happy to share their thoughts with me on this one they would like to see a final resolution one way or the other the island once a now better understanding of what the plan is trying to state where we are trying to go and definitely what we are trying to preserve that is unique to our night and one of the tools that our community has chosen to protect in class fights uniqueness is its language of the community and that is why there are adamant about words such as for hiphop they are very concerned about other generic words that takes away the unique character of what makes us special on monday so therefore members the proposal that i have here this morning before your is something the community in general is very supportive of like any plan it is not one hundred percent department mr wong and his deputies in cooperation council but i have been guided more by what i believe is my now what i believe is right what i'm i believe is the true history of our island retrain of protect and enhance as well as the ability to give our people hope for that a future through this document so i asked the members to support this amendment at this time thank you and you further discussion mr couch mr chair and i want to thank mr hall comma and corporation counsel and mr garneau for really working hard with the community on finally coming to language that everybody can agree with in so i wholeheartedly any further discussion on the amendment see none of those in favor please signify by saying i right those opposed say no sure passes with the nine eyes zero nose and i believe we're back to mr couch corporation counsel if those words that are in the document currently is appropriate to be there i guess or how is it this county can enforce or you know follow up implement to prohibit this when i believe it is not under the purview of the county to do so is the one i'm not could you provide him so i shall i repeat i guess what the question is strong or well if you wish ok yeah so just to bring everybody back to what i  am leading to it's in reference to under infrastructure section chapter seven then is a policy that states prohibit the extension of the ear ports or runway runway in the direction of l period prohibit aircraft flight patterns over land that use city as a means of noise mitigation period identifying implement other aircraft noise mitigation measures such as the prohibit of late night aircraft operations that's a current language it isn't in existing community plan planning department houser recommendation and this is where i spoke to procreation council just now they would like to see the word prohibit replace would discourage which still in essence gives the intent of no this is not wanted and i wholeheartedly agree and replace on the last sentence there the input identify and implement with encourage so it would still be encouraging the prohibition of late night flights and things of that meter so mr wong just if you can transportation can or cannot do but of course we can share our our you know intent and want to discourage and say hey this is not really welcome on the island or what have you so just checking in to see if that is still properly explained in even if the words are changed i guess sort of a later version innocent so if mr wong could i have some comments at this time  chair thank you member cochran for the question and i have reviewed the comments from the planning department and just so the body is aware of these comments were reviewed by my department prior to the presentation today and also during the interim we did a thorough review of all of the those changes and the  proposed agenda is to changes by mr okama take into consideration the language that you reflect upon to the extent that the softer language would the language in the document prohibits or discourages it's a matter of policy consideration versus whether the document is legal or not so for your consideration if you choose to soften the language throughout the remaining areas of the plan please reflect upon the planning department other  proposed changes for example they also in the same matrix discuss the prohibition on the use of part of the water for the golf course or a geisha that too is a prohibition so with that said you know i believe that the bodies policy decisions to prohibit those areas or those types of changes is purely that the policy consideration if and when the enforcement of  it is confronted is confronting the department will have to cross that bridge when we get to it so is it legal as written and as proposed yes would it remain legal with the softer language that through would be accurate so or whether you choose to keep the language as a prohibition or to amend the language as discouraging action is yours to decide and the chair and fair thank you very much for that explanation mr wong and i think you for highlighting the of their probation is that are in this matrix as i saw it too and the additional language that was added in as the very ending of both those pretty bishan and as stated by law i think as provided by law are in there to cover i guess this county in reference to we were nazi worm they have jurisdiction over water and things of that nature so i really really want to appreciate your input here this morning on this subject and share this opportunity and members for your indulgence and also planning his recommendation so what i heard is that even with the word in there it's not like something that is illegal of thank you mr share just to note the rule suspension will require a vote of at least six members this is needed because mr okama second amendment was not posted on the agenda and dance of the meeting all the other ones were now was the one with the word and and mr wong felt that it was strong enough of a change that we need to waive any further discussion on the waiver members see none of those in favor  thank the department for sticking with us i want to thank the community for sticking with us and mr hall comma for you know working hard with the community and the committee and mr  just doing a good job of listening to the community and also getting and listening to the department and it's a really good piece of compromise so support of this motion is amended scuse me this morning let me first say it's been a longer and more difficult task for everyone than was previously anticipated and we thought after ninety eight we made improvements to the ordinance that guides this process to make it clear easier and faster considering has always looked at it from an island standpoint we've never been so narrow in our perspective to only focus on the city proceed or what the world community is we have always been from the macro point of view that everything on the and it impacts everybody on board and so we have always had a sense of a more bigger perspective and island perspective and again it is just how most of us grew up in our history with an island i appreciate your support i think words such as protection prohibit gives you a clear sense of what the unique community position is of that community at that time he bishan night flights and they were very forceful in their position regarding that and it is now the policy and operational restrictions of the state as agreed to before couple of the people spoke up and said this is what is our primary concern so yes we you know i appreciate for the jurisdiction but being able to express your sense of what makes that unique community special these are words that express that sentiment m know for all of us the changing times and the quickness of the changing times if anything makes us more concerned i bought the things we need to preserve and protect my mother you know   only read it one thing there's t v now we're going to the moon now we look at mars we but times have changed so fast i hate for us to question who we are as a people and what is our culture that would be more disturbing for me and so for me making clear understanding of who we are what we are and why we are multiple and so i ask the members to again continue to support our district support one night this morning by allowing our uniqueness to be preserved allow our character to move forward and th and i look forward to mr coaches recommendations because i for one definitely will agree we need to make this a better process thank you mr chairman thank you mr dulles in further discussion members  mr and thank you mr o'connor for those comments i totally agree with you about the the process and we had a discussion about that night and i think the planning department as well agrees with that you know i was remiss in thanking the hard allowing that communication to be shared mr chairman and that is why i think today we have a better document that we were originally started with when council received it so stating that to our staff must agree no thank you the community is just kind of express how happy that was to what they would in one judgment on the defensive person above the work product and so thank you for that and i hope that this  continue to be very open to and supportive of and as all the future communities in their involvement to speak up and express what you feel is important even if you're told this may not be your jurisdiction here it is an important open to receiving and support thank you mr victoria no and she is with thanking everyone let's think not only the staff who had countless meetings not only up because we heard it directly from the community and the community at large all of those played an intricate part of what in this plan together i hope and pray that the next plans are a little bit easier a little well a little better planned out i'm not going to be here to see the end on know that but i really believe the process can be streamlined if first and foremost we have tools me tricks that we can see the various different just who did what and what who recommended what changes so that it's easier for all of us to have a better understanding when you're trying to complete the plan but i want to take all of those because many of us spent many hours not only in this chamber but on my reviewing listening grasping and then finally saying ok i think this is workable and today we've come i believe what the community mr victory no any further comments members just like to share this is this is a very long and arduous tough process and i think at least mr couch probably gained a few extra gray hairs that are a lot i want to thank the advisory committee and i want to thank them and i plan a commission i specially want to thank the department because they are the ones who are left hurting three different sets of cats and it's not an easy process we can see the challenges but the department is the one that's dealing with them on a daily basis and  know you know i watch how hard is it is to get things done and just one group of nine but we're dealing with multiple groups in each of these community plan areas island planners community plan areas we have some real challenges i believe to to streamline the process make it easier on the three groups make it easier on the department to come up with a plan that is meaningful and reflective of beach communities desires and wishes and dreams i especially want to take my hat off to the department because they've stuck through it and put up with all the challenges that each of three groups as presented them s to you all any further discussion members see none of us in favor of placing a five by saying i was opposed say no measure passes with nine eyes zero  mr cherry still have some motions to make but prior to that mr chairman i would take a point of personal privilege thank you you know you didn't hear me say too much about the planning department in my thinks i wanted to save it for this time if everybody looks on page one of this plan and on the inside cover the planning department not only worked really hard they had to overcome a significant tragic tragedy and i just don't want to forget the names of kathleen kern and tremaine bertie and doug miller and james we know doug and duro and mark king are still here with us thankfully and then the course the pilot dick rooney those folks were working on this plan and so the department  only had to deal with the three cats three herds of cats they had to deal with their pain and it's the county's pain and this plan is dedicated to those folks and i just want county communication on the floor it is appropriate to file both of these at this at this time any further discussion on these items none of those in favor signify by saying i think i those opposed say no