inappropriate like the united states supreme court in riverside versus rivera awarded two hundred forty five thousand dollars two hundred forty five thousand four hundred fifty six dollars on a thirty three thousand two hundred fifty dollars judgment so it was grade on party and there were a large number of people involved and people were arrested people were injured and i believe that the only award was on the state law claims and that's all i can be you can get arrested i don't think you need to you know i don't i don't think you need really need to reach that question certainly don't need to reach it under federal law because under state law to clear people versus money decided by the california supreme court for pain agreed to put up mr smith for a few days because he didn't have any place to go after they released him for jail and so there for a few days and he was gone she long of a car for a few days he return the car and it was gone ninety eight was when she first complained to for mr wilson the new branch manager with scarlet is you imagine ninety three months prior she followed that up in january of one nine hundred ninety eight was another complaint with regard to is continuing to perform successfully despite the fact that she her billing condition has been aggravated and she is now under medical care in the market for example that's not a question are you saying the manager cannot sell or to come in are you telling me in the first the motivation or he tell me the manager cannot tell him that he wants her in the office more to do that and she can say mother i'm not going to do it right and she can say well she can say them or she can also say i h know that's not the case we know that her doctor even scars she can take her tank into the office and nobody's ever told me she can probably tells me i can wear my glasses in the office but nobody's ever told me i can't you have all recounted concentrated seventy five eighty percent of them into three elderly clients so you've got a problem there with only over concentration if you count those clients leave for asking her to come in and i don't see how that can be rejected me tonight he ninety eight in one hundred ninety i asked him or didn't complain if everyone was happy with those jobs and make sure they don't complain that the company does it doesn't get to needed to get a handle on her being office and the office records but it's clear from wilson's declaration that he went through he computed a percentage of her business that was concentrated in these accounts and he needed to address him in june that she was regularly after he first tried to deal with it by just asking her what's up interview more often and then when she didn't respond he ultimately  as well as the an office manager place while this case was getting there on a tuesday between united states and the city you could have had all other applicants who had ever applied to be a firefighter in the year two thousand you for example could have all come in with their attorneys and filed a motion passed by the can't california legislature the word party does not mean something different then it means in one nine hundred eighty eight action in federal court you're either party or you're not a party and i don't think that archy gets things moving right all right then when