of importing anti government articles which is exactly true in this case and that the record demonstrated that the prosecution for falun gong was politically motivated because the president had made some some comments and i believe that the record in this case also demonstrates the same thing on page two forty eight in two seven three there's evidence showing that the crackdown on fallen gong is politically motivated and therefore because it's a pretext for persecution prosecution under these laws must be considered to be persecution and junk the court didn't even examine that the issue of whether persecution came from this prosecution it was it was a given because the government told them when they were searching the house when they were searching songs houses that john had imported articles from the united states that were critical of the chinese government's treatment and he also wrote some letters espousing that idea that the chinese government was sort of hiding something but the same can be case because the articles the newspaper articles that petitioner brought in were critical of the chinese government so and when they were searching petitioners house they told petitioners brother we're searching your house because she brought in anti government articles so between the government pretext of of pursing someone persecuting someone because of their political opinions and the government stating that they were searching them and harassed them and because of these anti government articles the song should also control on you know  that he would be persecuted if he were right and here petitioner is only arguing that the record compels the finding that it's reasonable for her to fear persecution she doesn't even have to get to that burden of more likely than not that close friends originally with with the person that she brought the articles in for after a party in two thousand she began to have more discussions with her and she being began to become more sympathetic and i think if anything the fact that she has gotten word from her family in china that china is now cracking down on her that they've come to her house if anything that is going to have the effect of her being more sympathetic to those political opinion yes yes and that's and i think it logically follows that if she's going to be prosecuted for something and that prosecution is in fact there's no indication of what the charges a and then there's no testimony about you know whatever happened to her job or should terminated there's nothing in there about whether inger being terminated based on all of the information on the record she determined that it to her whole story the fact that she came here for a month the fact that her claim appear to be implausible on light of the evidence on the case is that she would take this risk knowing that it was illegal but clearly explains on page one twenty seven that she had a different address than the one in her family registration because she couldn't get authorization to live and the place of her new job the x for testifies on page two twenty one and she twenty two that it's not a given that anybody can you can just up and move and get a new family registration and and then i j and government cancel misstate the expert testimony because he only mentions this floating pack relation for three sentences and his entire testimony basically on speculation nothing that the judge points to in the record supports the finding the judge states that she wasn't very good friends and that she had a very good job however there is nothing in the record to support that petition as habit of helping friends which she testified to the chinese custom of helping others which she also testified to there's nothing in the record that shows that those customs and habits wouldn't apply to her relationship and his practicing and his family being arrested the court in the strong mention that the family being arrested goes to the likelihood it didn't go to the imputation and of political pain when the judge when the when the court and jo