the city and also because of her that they said you chinese woman you what's interesting about indonesian is that the country does not have any laws that criminalize at least the sexual harassment and so it doesn't appear the government takes seriously that particular crime it also requires two witnesses to prove up sexual harassment and in this case for instance it would ethnicity the gender ratio goes to course membership in a particular social group and that would be ethnic chinese christian women who are a greater risk of persecution than the general population in indonesia please the court brian boyle for the united states the claim to pass pretty cute it's based on two incidents eight years apart  near as we can tell in the gang where she went to school she was the victim of offensive touching connection with that incident and then eight years later when she returned to indonesia in two thousand she was in a restaurant with her family and others entire restaurant was robbed all the patrons in the restaurant were forced to surrender their belongings now i will assume for the moment that these do not a map of the sort of extreme mistreatment that qualifies persecution as the i j a put it these are the and i'm quoting these are the kinds of incidents that happen in probably every country in the world between one ethnic group unwilling to police against robberies in one thousand nine hundred wasn't even reported to police and the two thousand incident was and there was no information on what the result of that investigation absent any evidence of past persecution it well the petitioner to prove a reasonable prospect of persecution will she be returned in the future and in this respect her submission sorry it's been a miracle a miracle i think i mean it's hard to overcome the the long ethnic difficulty in a couple of years with   ethnic chinese tradition are now openly practice without violence there's seven chinese newspapers in circulation there's even a t v station that broadcasts in chinese now whereas those traditions and spent five months of the better part of five months in the country and i think that speaks volumes about the you know whether those country conditions truly can provide the immigration judge put it i think quite reasonably it's clear that the church and herself was in the wrong place at the wrong time in one thousand nine hundred two she was in the wrong place at the wrong time at that restaurant in two thousand well she was in the wrong place at the wrong time and she word you chinese give me your belongings and that's it now i will assume that that indicates some racial inspiration but the motive for the robbery was obviously money that is the motive typically characterized as robber conclude that no reasonable fact finder could find otherwise an example the case from one thousand nine hundred five the evidence there was that the house was repeatedly stoned there were attempted  we said in two thousand and three we said that the greater the risk on members of the group the last evidence of the individual is persecution correct and i would say there is some evidence that embraces six religions including catholicism from the state department report again page three sixty eight there were no reports of religious detainees or prisoners during the period covered by the report three sixty nine quote there were markedly fewer reports of specifically anti chinese violence during the period of about this report from the san francisco chronicle in two thousand that headline hundred ninety eight there is a box in the upper portion of the page it says that fifty laws against the ethnic chinese chinese social organization asked the government to investigate the human rights abuses during the one nine hundred ninety eight riots and i quote no one is from brought to justice the deaths of twelve pattern of practice evidence and that would include country conditions and then country conditions fight cell equals we believe in this case at least the well founded fear a future persecution in addition her very very strong foundation and these cases do have repeated right so we're not even talking about the riots that happened in one nine hundred sixty five during the coup we're not talking about the fact that the rivers ran a red but the ethnic chinese were