whether the government agencies have basically the ability or the legal authority to ignore the one year deadline i would submit to the court and that is not what the government submitted a plethora of evidence that being female in honduras automatically you know better just by virtue of your birth which you have a much more significant risk of  can you hear me we can ok greet me please the court sharif prep for the respondent the acting united states attorney general first i will address the court's three questions and then i'll explain why exhausted her claim therefore it is not properly before the court and i don't believe that the failure to give miss the last was individualized notice of the one year statutory piling deadline violated her due process rights she has a remedy and it looks like she has it availed herself of it and the remedy is to write in the settlement agreement on pages eight and nine paragraph  t even if she filed a motion to reopen and even if her at the file application is ultimately barge cannot show that she is prejudiced because she still has to show that the particular social group class then she has to use the mechanism provided in that simple it agreement which is to file a motion to reopen before the board and let them determine if she a member of the class but even if  the settlement agreement was fully finalized until after that and so now there is a settlement agreement in place that's been adopted by the district court and she has a mechanism in place follow if she believes she's a member of the class it's inappropriate for her to bring the claims here when she hasn't followed the procedure to th in the settlement  alternatively assuming d it was cognizable now hurt the group she set forth was female victims of gender based violence or female victims of violence and the board cites to the id decision because it did not exist independently of the harm asserted now the agency credited her testimony that she was kidnapped beaten and raped and then they said to me that her particular social group was cut there was no next they found that it was violence by criminals because the kidnappers didn't just kidnap two women they kidnapped four men and then beat the men were beaten and the women  well so well if you're looking at her claims she claims that they never actually threatened to traffic her that she just assumed that that's the car right but the reason that her sexual assault is not the reason that she's claiming that she wants to that she came to the night the chief claiming because they threatened to kill her if she reported the crime and the person would threaten to kill her is not her then she says in her testimony he was not the man who raped her and father her child pages ninety two to ninety three so from her testimony she's saying that the reason and her and the letter from the person the other woman who was kidnapped also says that she had to come to the united states because they threatened to kill her if she reported the crime that's at karr thirty three by the threat caused her to leave the united states it was never a threat to put her into appropriately found it was no nexus and in looking at government acquiescence to torture that was she never reported the crime so the the the government couldn't help her couldn't find those those there's no case law in this circuit or in any other circuit that says the whole entire population of the milton hunter is it's a particular social group and then if you're looking at the you know her threat which was the threat that they were going to kill her if she told they also twenty years various committees and commissions have been formed and laws have been passed and special prosecutors set up with the noble goal of reduc of reducing if not ending gender based violence and yet still it continues with mere utter impunity and i point the court to herman store for affidavit  protection and yet still unable to provide with that said your honors i would like to note for the record that my office has been pro bono on this appeal to those who