not responsive and he looked over any saw some things yes i can saw that why he gave her well the shower off yes he went off to the scene there were multiple call from individuals yes isn't that what the stitches refer you to a person who takes action to appease to see guru to be a person is to take action just like the good samaritan who takes action and you know the messages he her personally jenny didn't she was dying in the car she was incapable of call nine one one foot of unity all argument one of the state's arguments is that if you look at the plain language and the language is pretty plain to see who's seeking a teeny thing all require some around twelve fifteen more just with this statue is a metaphor to keep people alive but now let's then look at what happened when they got there because this is this is kind of important here in the ne at least it accomplished that probably on a heart to could have been a seizure we don't inject that drug just because someone is turning blue and having difficulty breathing you have to have a reason  determined based on what they found in the car did the believe this was the reason and think goodness they were right absolutely and so there was an investigation before there was sitting together doing it all goes in some and one of the individuals dies of a heart attack does it mean they're the nine one one call was fruitless i don't think so because as i prepared for this i thought about this if we need this decision the state's asking for and this would be probably a case of first impression so there would be a complication in this case are we in some ways defeating the purpose of the statute in that people will be a free to call because they don't the idea is we're trying to save them we're trying to save their life it's a small amount and they don't want to get in trouble they were stupid but they don't want to get in trouble are we now preventing people from calling because we say that the statute says that you can still be arrested if there are other circumstances e clearly they want to prevent drug deaths for small time drug users as it was discussed before they could have simply said in the case where  other thing they could have done simply say under certain nobody's approval that was also asked to encourage people to seek treatment but they did not do that what they said was they took a first past more encouraging you to save lives in this case for small amounts so no i don't think that your decision is is going to do that if anything it sort of courage is a drawing to use because they'll say if i'm lucky enough to overdose then i get a free than a free pass which may have been part of the legislature's thinking i don't know if you look at the argument that the fundi question that the evidence in this case was recovered as a result of the defendant up pain or mercy medical treatment even though she didn't initiate the action something else  write you also argue that it serves no purpose to provide immediately someone who receives treatment while unconscious because she or he could be neither encouraged or discouraged from acting in her own self interest well in this particular case and we hope in others the person's life is saved you know go whoa the media shouldn't do this anymore and go into treatment h and i think that there is i said before i think there is a policy issue to say you don't want to do it that way because the everything well the what if you prefer but it lacks over into well i almost died so therefore you also argue about here taking community care taking do you really think that applies here mayor even though it's really kind of a fourth amendment type concept because it usually goes in search and seizure i'm sorry it because it's to intrude in their private space is not is an investigation of crime function but for the purpose of rendering community care taking in emergency aid which is a bit is a separate figure out this traffic problem didn't created a different situation being were there to investigate traffic because if people are unhappy if you're stuck that seems to be pretty thank you very much hate you still requires strict compliance with the court's orders are saving lives too and the so you policy on either senior policy or makes sense but probation county jail sentences drug ordered treatment also makes sense and it is saving lives like your clients your clients probably a lot because she's on top of the court no