well here versus ashcroft wife is now converted to islam why can't they just look somewhere else in a country well the buddhists are the vast majority of the country and  if the family or the clan would pretty quickly find out where these people are and they would continue to be in danger is there any evidence of that never heard i don't know if i can point to where i believe that they testified to that but you know i can't point to and i don't recall when i was looking for it but if you can maybe give us a page number in your rebuttal that might be helpful  that government action is an important element where the issue of relocation arises because i believe it was being because the government was persecuting the sikh in india the ninth circuit said that if the government act or we assume that no collective central government there's no place in the country where the person you say but not having an official government told him this doesn't keep it from being so i think you would qualify even one of the first invention where the acquiescence of the government is required element the government were able to control again or some group then there would be no threat but this is a situation where the government is unwilling to put a new strain on  a dominant senior in the in the local clan i don't think there was ever any evidence that anyone went to the government and asked them to and that although there's some explanation of that for this village well the uncle was a big man in smallest minority and who are discriminated against can still live safely without persecution in many countries and often have had the question is whether they f persecution that the government is unable or unwilling to protect them from or is itself the actor the persecutor and no matter where they go in sri lanka well the muslims do live without constant persecution but the wife here converted to islam and this apple stacy was one of the nice things about islam is once you convert to it your real muslim yes but the the buddhist don't appreciate that and her plan are very upset about it might be a good idea to live in a muslim community if that's the way that the buddhists feel but there was no evidence that there are no such communities what was their big party no evidence that there were no communities where they could live safely in sri lanka as muslims i'm sorry i can't answer that accurate mixture of different racial or ethnic groups i can think of ethnic groups in the united states that constitute approximately two percent of the population and used to be discriminated against but are not and have not been persecuted in the united states when i'm trying to find out as and who would have faced a great deal of hostility from family son if there were in sororities and what i'm trying to find out is is this analogous to that or is this a situation where these people just can't go back well i believe that there they definitely feel they can't go back i'm sorry i'm can't they come back five times for vacations the first time the young man went back for a funeral  did not go out to sea he kept himself even though they were living in oddly gobby together they were very guarded in their trips back the longest trip was they spent two weeks in colombo they did not spend time in the village they went they went there with bodyguards because of the fear they had and they fear that if they stayed long enough that i know that in the testimony if they stayed longer they would be their presence would be known to the family an indian danger acceptance that's like a convert not being fully accepted in a church or synagogue that doesn't rise to the level of persecution people don't invite you over for cocktails or whatever  nobody except some nobody will invite their little girl over for birthday parties and have people will laugh insult them but that can still not rise to the level of persecution and what i'm trying to find out is is there evidence in the record that they could not avoid persecution by relocating