problem with the trial of course opinion was he threw out the fat in the in his opinion there was a fair question of whether the definition of international student which by the way no party ever are presented a fair international student further is additionally if you look at the use of the term international student within the context of the bible if it comes up in the residency section and is a very specific residency section so we look at all lack of analysis on the issue of whether there's a likelihood of success on the merits it will be that i think percy that his question about how many students endure or particularly schools are impacted by this a see as a lot of scrutiny that he was looking at if there are only three students impacted by this were seven students and the off happened to be at a certain school that could be too difficult to overcome don't think and i don't i don't look at it that way because whether it's one student or a thousand students it's all of the competition which you're asking about is we're going to take it case by case review and i'm missing the bylaws don't fall for that the public school for one year you can attend a private school for the entire duration of your of your high school of your education i'm going to die school career and you don't have to pay your own tuition so all this by law doesn't try to say hey we've  organization set up to recruit students from africa to place them in the united states to play basketball and get an education if you go to their website they boast about how many students are there was nothing in the record that he's a shill that this means that an international student would necessarily negatively affect competition by his or her participation so i mean the trucker didn't students to play basketball i mean why couldn't you pass it over or what about your because you have something about students themselves or someone on their behalf marketing students for the simple aspect of playing basketball what we're getting at is your view of every  existing rules which are reasonable and fair debate they would argue they could put they could look ahead and they can be proactive if they see a problem of the horizon before manifests itself and if they have an example of it which is you know the charter which i don't know if it ever and then he added they added be this is kind of the door if they don't have parents if they are orphaned if they are homeless but their particular tenant is in the district and their parents are in jail they can't cla except journal you know that's not the case in the end unless you have some circumstance where they're so he can see with the new yorker randomly placed these kids without you know to make sure that there is no influence in where these kids get placed then you recruitment you know certainly seems reasonable male circumcision i still disagree around but you know there were there were circumstances there and some sympathy for the kids in that situation but again do we want to do that on their not basis to want to say how to  i suppose if we had more time to talk about what happens in chicago public schools maybe that's where we would find out some of these things but the fact remains he contacted somebody from not in chicago he contacted somebody in plano