anybody to replace him why isn't that a reduction in force or it is an interesting i don't know that you you either add new people or you reduce the force when somebody leaves unless he wasn't doing anything it isn't t and he wasn't replaced by anybody then well what did happen what did happen is he did some work and now some other people are doing it and if those old more than seven years younger than he was why isn't that a prime  man and what i understand that what's the difference on understand the difference i mean if if you're replaced by people who are already there then that's a riff isn't and i mean you know less you don't i mean i guess i'm having trouble with the terminology was voluntary or not which i understand but that to me is a different issue with respect to the problem of facie case of whether he was replaced you can voluntarily leave and then they replace you with other pete with that if you voluntarily leave and then they replace you with a with a with the one younger person that they've newly hired you still have an issue about whether was voluntary or not but that's a different issue from whether you were replaced by a younger person standing trying to get at the prime of facie case one element of the primal facie case is that you're replaced by a younger person and to say well that isn't met because he left voluntarily this seems to be apples and you seem to be talking about two different things whether doesn't have to do with who we risk replaced by those are different issues aren't they both are different issues you're i but i was so if i'm asking you a question about whether he was replaced by somebody younger it's not responsive to say well he did it all he left on purpose that if he is saying i'm asking whether he was replaced by younger people younger person or whether it was a riff i think those are kind of the categories are or he was replaced by by a not younger person but there's no argument that he was replaced by another person who was close to him in age so you see the replaced by a younger person well are there was a route out of this is judge bogs are there cases or doctrine that says that everyone who brings a suit either was replaced or rift i'm just asking that because the usual quote is you decide we need to save money and then you choose who to who to fire and this doesn't smell like that but a judge rogers is right that either someone has replaced or you quit you quit doing his work at all and that's not quite the case here either so does the doctrine permits you to say this just doesn't fit into either a real or replacement in whi it's this is not accurate is that your client wanted to retire from being an employee and basically wanted the caribbean accounts to be my commission today and then when it and  act actively trying to reach that status you know trying to get someone to take his mainland accounts but he still wanted and was and thought he had just one person on board to support his his getting those those to those caribbean accounts and bahamas and then it turned out the people who were in charge of the new company said we're going to do all that but we're not going to give him the bahamas like counts and then he was on hand p and and ultimately filed suit to basically what he was unhappy with was not achieving a situation where he he had kind of a package deal he would no longer be an employee whether you call every tire mentor or some retirement or something else and that he would however get some some accounts maybe some other accounts and then it and then the other side well having that be the package didn't come didn't come through and instead said no we don't want to do it that way we want all of the package except we don't want to give you the most accounts and is that more or less exactly what's going on more or less what's going on seems to me that it sounds like they weren't very good to your client but they brew they if anything they broke the contract but it's hard to see how that was burton you can go ahead and hang up and we'll call you back from the conference room