transportation providing expert guidance and handling every detail this is a very broadly defined duty assume you told the intruders and we believe you get over on the issue of legal cause by looking at the foreseeability of the event the one think this case in their regards closer to the case of coles versus jenkins which we strike and in that case it was a bicycle to work part of the design of the tour was that one day they were going to have a very busy highway and with a narrow shoulder  finds that this tour with negligently designed by choosing the road then it is for see that this was this design was a legal cause that it would be it's situation what is foreseeable that when you have a group of senior citizens that arrive at a hotel late that it's night time by the time the check given to their whether it was reasonably foreseeable that a member of this tour group would decide to jaywalk across the highway without a signal and she never asked any questions of the tour director did she well when outside the state of illinois i'm not quite sure why that is maybe because we don't have a big tourist industry within norway but i think that and i think this is true of the police grie it's an assumed duty it had to do with providing all transportation and then the judge says according to that there was no duty because you the defendants had no control over the control finlay wrote now if you can reconcile or explain how one fits into the other is a or is a a lesser included duty of what you claim i'd appreciate because i'm in a little this is the first night of the tour de driven five hundred miles they get there late by the time the people whom there's no restaurant in the witches hotel this was correct so they check dinner was not included in that night they should have provided transportation given those facts and the kind of the intersection they had to traverse and my point is that if they feel the proof by transportation then it is the was she and her friend florence were walking towards the intersection to see if there was a cross walk they saw none but before they got there other members of the tour group are walking back towards that and say hey there's no cross walk on they have you know at that time that there was not a restaurant in that comforting they should hear no there wasn't a restaurant that doesn't mean that it means there's a dangerous situation the effect is the restaurants  unusual about this configuration there's a cross walk it's marked it's controlled by a specific air traffic signals with walking don't walk the plane of voluntarily shows not to use that cross for there throw off or throw into the mix different duties that the plaintiffs are arguing about the motives talking about a duty to provide transportation and you come up with a different one then when you say that this is judy doesn't there is no evidence that the action would have been known and she has for this or did she said she knew there was a transfer titian available but she didn't want to i don't know what more you could getting back to my comment you said it wasn't foreseeable that these things with take place and you just indicated that there were these two people that did the same thing at the same place and one of them got to get the other one did i don't see how that makes it anyone here who reasonably anticipated their decision that is the decision to gene walk and cross in the middle of the street in whiting of the previous conduct of the different which is th tour where dinner was not included word specifically stated in there to hurry that we would bring places on the bus why that wasn't done here i don't know but considering the the proximately the same place in the road of they didn't cross it in mass together i think a few people had crossed ahead of my client and then my client and her friend florence  crossed in about the same place that was when the accident happened carlos who mentioned that my client thought she could beat a car and my client the car and hit her because it was too far away she doesn't know she doesn't call that oversee the particular car that that hit or consulate made reference that cash available what it is there's nothing in the