one whether the bankruptcy erred as a matter of well about finding that is twenty two thousand and fourteen order granting interesting as we expressed in our brief we believe that this is one matter and this race you've got it would so maybe i mean you can do whatever you want it's your time but maybe you should start with the m case is concerned especially as a regular practitioner of bankruptcy court we're very familiar with lehman and its implications five twenties who have and how those calculations are made and we've we've been familiar for twenty years because wanted to do with my list fill out the concerns are brought up in the brief as to the th circuit having the layman opinion and the tars opinion even though it is  published and that is this with how the court interpreted the statute in lebanon we use this common sense the court used a common sense approach to avoid the absurd they looked at five hundred and twenty two f two a specifically three f two a three and said that we use the debtor's value then we have a sore outcome and that we should instead replace the total value and that's what has been the law what's interesting to me a with with this case language of twenty two dollars of so even though both courts were really into it at looking at the congressional into it but of course did it differently so narrow and that's how you know how but i mean hasn't the supreme court said that although we follow the text of the statute and that's the end of the matter if it's clear there is an exception which is if the result would the potential confusion that we have where in one situation in the th circuit we we interpret this statute broadly so as not to and not and not strictly it is not it is not it the wall that particular case because nobody held a mandate to try to take it on but that doesn't mean that it is the law of the circuit or doesn't like the law of the circuit all the circuit is published decisions and i know that it's difficult there i don't want to take up your other four minutes and i have explained to you well that's true but everybody agrees that's the ground rule an unpublished opinion disposes th way to follow him in or easy you follow layman yes i understand now you may have a good shot and getting the district court to follow terrorists because sometimes they blur the distinction but i promise you if it comes up to a panel this court we're going to follow the published pen yes thank you thank you oh  we look at layman the result in my mind is consistent i don't think you have to reach to necessarily the observer stall in order to find that the go through then and look at the calculation standard you have to breathe the section as a whole so we're only looking at no matter what you do with this language we're looking at the exemption and the preserving of an exemption to a debtor and i would suggest that the fair reading of one to half without having to go to the absurd result or drafting is that the debtors are interested in property as expressed in the last sentence of a debtors interest in the property for the purposes of this is exemption and when you read it that way you actually get to the appropriate calculation that was reached by the bankruptcy court and the district court in this matter which would leave the debtor five thousand dollars that's exemption amount if you follow the other purported allegation i mean a result you would leave a negative to our client of five hundred and thirty nine thousand dollars which would be zero recovery and you would leave the debtor with sixty one thousand dollars after the sale of this property that cannot be the intent of five hundred and twenty two dollars because it's to preserve exemptions i would suggest that that who is discharged and just debt of six hundred thousand dollars is to then keep sixty one thousand dollars with his applicable state law exemption is five thousand dollars rather redemption given the circumstances and the figures the man well i would suggest that there is not probably not enough information in the record as it stands right now