said dr brown a physical demand she which it the number of hours per day she could repetitive tasks based on that dr brown issued a report that he felt that this could be possibly related for evidence that deposition dr browne did not think that the nurse fay blakely and he preaches this disposition to develop qwirkle tunnel she wasn't a diabetic she had no other medical whether the commission's decision is supposedly supported by evidence and not upon speculation yes ok what i'm saying is dr brown's testimony constitutes speculation especially the way that they that you need liberally construed to effectuate its need purposes which is to provide financial protection for injured workers regardless of the showing of negligence or contributory negligence or preclude employees that's right by the working person i mean these are being used now to to put not only put people out of work but that i am medical benefits and t c t there's something really wrong here and the government or the governor is  sent her the medical records and they sent her a physical demand sheet she attended the i am meet with the sheet there the first report was written based upon the physical examination and upon his plate use description upper respiratory represented typical duties of a respiratory therapist and he did not believe that respiratory therapist duties were typically of a repetitive nature she performs three to four and up your lighter treatments and hour and testified that during those nebulizer treatments eight to ten minutes of the time she's standing back doing nothing she's watching while the patient is breathing in the treatment through the mask and there's no hand to the fruit eight to ten minutes of extreme i'm getting back to  activities for five to six hours a day he didn't know what repetitive meant and he felt uncomfortable with his dancers contrary to what counsel said h r didn't tell him to fill out a new form he didn't even know if after brown sat he's never been shared a copy of the report he went back to h r and said ok i don't feel comfortable with how i feel that well if you feel uncomfortable why don't you fill out another one and what did he want to that is that there is no that mr irving filled out he said she performed five to six hours a day of repetitive the math doesn't add up if she's doing a reading for treatments an hour and she's standing there for eight to ten minutes of that treatment doing nothing that's thirty two to forty minutes per hour and you're standing there watching watching the patient over the course of an eight hour shift that's almost five hours of rest it's not consistent with saying that she's probably ripping an activity for five to six hours so dr brown indicated that it was not possibly related to her treating physician dr hafner and initially said that her activities as a respiratory therapist doing thirty to forty freezing treatments a day and turning on and off oxygen tanks could contribute to cost article tunnel on cross exam i asked him to assume that her job duties don't include turning on off oxygen tanks and he said well that's the activity that would have some effort at the wrist if that's not part of her job to these high significant basis that i would have difficulty relating her employment to carpal tunnel it was undisputed trial to chipchura green she doesn't change