the five fifty one patent is still asserted in that litigation upon the entry of the board's decision instead as it stands now which is on appeal now finding the claims invalid the claim is not abhor the case for his transfer back to texas and then read the tennessee it's a well i don't think so the the documentary thing from is obviously the part of the record here i don't have that in front of me that's a representation made by fed ex is incorrect to the extent that it would suggest that that pattern has event in any way withdrawn or that the claim is it will never be asserted currently there's a board decision and the  construed the corresponding structure examiner did a means full functionality has looked at the specification concluded the social structure is quote readily apparent and quote from the specification this is that j a two two seven seven one eight hundred nine nine nine nine nine nine nine nine is the number you dial the winning an american airlines reservation what this means is that when i dial you know with the dean of signals that your honor just described it's not merely to identify a format based on the drina signal it's not merely to select the format based on the drina signal it's  more encompassing term to control the processing formats of the analysis structure and set forth in the papers there's analysis structure there processing structures that provide that implement formats for true essentially certainly the identification of the format based on being as may be encompassed within the recited function but it's something broader it's controlling the form and controlling the operation in accordance with the next it's not just saying i know what the number the interface twenty device including the call data analyzer so that the call data analyzer there's no description whatsoever in the specification of what it does other than its name indicating call data analyzer just that the name indicates it only analyzes so there's an incoming data stream of call data which includes various information which needs to be analyzed interpreted the call data analyzer analyzes that information makes available the  the dial the number digits to the interface twenty which is it it's a part of that and then the specification repeatedly describes and they in the passages we could we could look at a site in our group as well it's the interface twenty that's that's the description voice recognition doesn't work in twenty yet so there's no description whatsoever in the specification of the call the analyzer by itself controlling processing formats of the analysis structure that's the recited function here that's the yardstick  sixty five which is commentary that the processors are what implement the foremast and as described elsewhere and as we've presented in the papers and i think there's no dispute on that those processors implement formats different ones are reached by dean as and then returning to quote th visitation select processors would be reached through the interface units e g interface twenty figure one that's a clear link between interface twenty and the identification of format and the control of the format in accordance with dina's there's no description whatsoever linking the called analyzer by itself with controlling the processing formats of the analysis structure w control of processing formats of the analysis structure this is just a generic structural description that says beingness is available and i which is calling number capability is available both capabilities are available for use with equipment as the interface twenty so those are associated with interface twenty itself and to provide control through the call data analyzer our function here is to control the processing formats of the analysis structure company he said rather another one and this is the one that the examiner correctly recognized as being readily apparent and teaching precisely those undisputed below until the final court decision column six lines associates the called number rendered available using standard hotel is going to use techniques through the interface twenty and then the switch to keeping connection with a specific processor in g the processor peer one formatting the health related program accordingly the processor pier one cooperates with the interface twenty six to the interface twenty to operate as a voice generator and this is tell those multiple things that are critical here there's no mention whatsoever of this  data analyzer twenty eight it's the interface twenty and they're describing how this actually works in practice it's the interface twenty is the only link to the structure there as a unitary structure that provides a connection to particular processors implementing different formats and i'm no roll over time here i'm going to cut you off now will we st connection to another component in this case the interface and the switch and if you look at page figure one at page twenty five  and we're looking at figure one here can you'll see that the interface twenty and the call data analyzer twenty eight are connected to switch twenty one ok and the switch twenty one is connected to the processors which is the analysis structure language is just and going to the median column search is that talking about well the function the claim eighteen is i think what column six and what this disclosure is talking about is it says you do have to go through the interface to connect to the processors you also have to connect river from interface to the switch so the interface doesn't actually perform the clean function by itself and it sounds council said that was what that was the main reason why the call they had allies there could not be the corresponding structure because it does not perform the client function by itself but the case was clear just because a connection is required to enable the corresponding structure to perform the claim function doesn't make th can usually with well i would argue that under under his argument that the corresponding structure must perform the claimed function by itself if that were true you'd actually need to include structure associated with voice recognition when you live within this particular means less not only for correct is part of the corresponding structure it could arguably be part of the corresponding structure then it goes to the switch and then it goes to connect to the processors it's just describing how all this route is not described and what's contemplate what's the corresponding structure of the means of a function limitation be american airlines processors who could be a health survey the call data analyzer just needs to know where to route three three three three to american airlines and if you change that number you just need to somehow reprogram the call they have wiser to understand that process or paulding what they did say to look at page six of the joint appendix the first page of the board's analysis the second paragraph and the second full sentence they talk about what the examiner did examiner interpreted the language really have to send it back i think there's enough support in the record here in what we just discussed in the board's decision what did examiner did that if you feel confident that the board's rejection that the board will affirm the rejection even under as captains proposed several points first critically critically important to correctly identifying construe in understanding the sighted function it's a means to control processing formats and this was emphasized by the examiner j a two to seven seven underline what is controlled are the processing formats it's not controlling venus it's controlling the processing formats as a matter of grammar logic and the description and the specification secondly the call didn't mean to be controlling the process processing format so the processor implements processors implement different formats which are essentially interactive applications the interface twenty is a structure that control those as in the past as we looked at zero data the interface is the device that uses and controls using that information as expressly described throughout the specification is zero description of reference by councils this call data and whether it could be programmed or it makes routing decisions the claim function the claim function is what's performed by the interface twenty it's the connection in which has the processing capability that it does that the called a letter is or does not have very quickly if i could just have a few more rely on the us as our reference as having any structural input into this means to us function claim element zero there's nothing in the record whatsoever it's conceded by the board in the briefing although it may be stuck back from that