again the offer and offer some reasoning to why this should be appealed to be a judge to be judged in a federal court donald ball william  his memorandum and judgment order on april th two thousand and eighteen stated that the court couldn't consider this case because of the previous filing and in new york state court this case was b by counsel who after some time did not make themselves available to me or appear before the judge on the request the dates to represent me effectively the myself the  appellant had no knowledge of how many times the counsel had not made an appearance before the judge the appellant tried myself try to contact counsel by phone by mail and i visited their or that the state case had been thrown out no i found out after the attorney that let is so for for the case inform me remember i was represented by understand i'm trying to i'm trying to find out when you learned that the state case was thrown out i learned approximately two weeks after  attorney refused to give me any information refused to give me any legal counsel in his office and didn't inform me that they decided to let me let me try to explain why we're asking these questions as i understand what the district court said was that you filed suit in the federal court to late it has to be filed within three years of the incident that you're complaining about where you were injured and this lawsuit here was not filed until more than three years after the incident with the police officers you understand that's what the didn't you at some earlier point within what we call the statute of limitations within three years after what happened to you file this lawsuit that you're here on now why is that so late in being filed your stand is there are rules the one rule is that the case has to be filed within three years and our law is that that applies whether you have a lawyer or whether you're on your own and there are only certain very limited circumstances that would excuse not filing for three years and that's that's the issue that's really before us is whether there is one of these excusing circumstances and what will be one of the reasons i filed this in federal court was because the attorneys who were supposed to be representing me gave me the in the false information that these things were being carried out properly i found out later on that they were not and one of the things that you pointing out is very very effective and it would have been very informative if had i been told the truth in the beginning and then of course i found out later on that no none of that was taken into a fit of course the problem is not yours and not got to do with the police officers who were injured you in the st place who are the people you're trying to sue now many years after what i heard but that's that's the issue for us and i understand what you're saying you're saying that you were the victim of bad lawyers in effect and that's why the case didn't get filed in federal court within that three year period will last just the beginning the if if the judges were allowed to look at the case from the very beginning you see that i've been harassed by this same precinct for close to thirty years and i've lived all over the world not one mic not one citation from various police agencies and new york and other states and other countries this is definitely i mean just from what i've learned in order for there to be a crime has to be criminal intent what was their in all i was bike riding not only was a travesty given to me from these attorneys but a travesty from this precinct and the various individuals and there were many and the thirty year the thirty year period would verify what i'm saying this is an ongoing thing this isn't start with just these two attorneys this is coming from a precinct that decided to make me a criminal in other words they knew they couldn't have any any jurisprudence and they didn't have any any evidence so they said we're going to make you a criminal anyway and if you look at the case and you look at the information that's given you see that this is a fact and harassment continue in some prominent person in my community they've had to let that go for a minute but i'm always harassed i'm always being i'm being monitored i'm the head of my black association i'm a homeowner i'm a father and a grandfather and a very loved person in my community the last time before this case they knew they were losing the case and they decided to sell my property in this case how do you arrest someone and you take their property and you you you don't give the property back and you what you're saying i understand i understand your argument and thank you