garcia's case the judge limited his findings to its time line in fact the judge made specific findings that mr garcia had said that he would be glad to pay the brother in law about the brother in law she would ask to borrow money from her brother and i said well ok i'll pay him back when i get the money and then there are you takes a break and says you know i will be asking questions about that and says you know oh there's problems here then the only the only portion that the judge perhaps relied on was that single response to that very broad question and in that response that mr garcia gave he did the law does it make a difference was there he intended to pay the brother back before she came across with my car he decided to do that after my does that make a you say that doesn't make clear what really happened i think that that is not clearly state when he agreed to pay the brother in law back and it is not a clear statement of what happened for purposes of impeaching him later well the that the evidence compels a contrary meeting and if it's simply unclear how can it compel a reading contrary to what the i j a said it was because joining contact with the rest of  identified evidence compelling the conclusion that mr garcia did not at any time no knowingly encourages aid or abet his then girlfriend illegal entry into the united states and the answer there is more evidence than this particular paragraph that the court and counsel were discussing on page one hundred twenty of the administrative record mr garcia testified that his then girlfriend called and said call him and said that she was ready to come home from mexico after she had spent two months there and then  obviously smother i believe he had admitted earlier that she was smuggled over by smuggling and then in response to that he says well i can't pay at the moment and she says  i actually read the passage and i told her that i didn't have the means the money to pay for that there and then and she laughed and her brother she would ask to borrow money from her brother and i said well ok i'll pay him back when i get the money  honor if it's unclear and i'm not saying that it is absolutely clear i think in context it is fairly clear but even if it's unclear the question is whether or not there's evidence compelling the judge's compelling an inference the influence of the immigration judge drew that and that inference was that during that conversation or perhaps even two conversations before she left that he was on board with the agreements that agreement a smuggler was involved there was an agreement there was this agreement because she called me on the telephone told me she was ready to come home and she needed the money to pay the smuggler and that he didn't have the money so only knowledge was that he had to pay the brother back the smuggling money afterwards that is assisting in the smuggling he paid the money it's assisting in the smuggling in congresses and there's no told her i didn't have the means the money to pay for that they're in and she asked her brother to borrow money she said you can ask your brother to borrow money and i said he telephoned well ok i'll pay him back when i get the money and she left he was just kind of a random three words in the middle that doesn't disturb the context of the fact this was during a telephone conversation when after she told h she was really come back the united states and she needed money to pay a smuggler the immigration judge then was not simply relying obviously on his notes he went back with the counsel and he listened to the tape and after listening to the tape after hearing mr darcy is a voice in question his voice he maintain his original opinion of that testimony that in fact before him and before she came over he knew about the agreement and agreed to repa pretty sure we don't know where the money will come from cancer is nothing in here that says for sure it's coming from the brother but she's going to jail she can to get back here turns out she gets money from the brother and three months later he pays the credit