sony computer actions well let's talk about flexible pads sort of now i suppose you could say that i just cause that bench to flex by touching it there but don't we understand this term in a more customary carefully i didn't find a independent claim that used the word embedded that's correct or that so the word attach really does have to sort of soon both the a narrower word that's just clearer so when they're describing the environment you know they said attached maybe that's not quite as clear whether it's inside or outside but when they say that it they know you're going to understand exactly what they mean by respon defining something that's you using old words and when you use those old words they sometimes don't quite fit and so is our rules to be vol we say we're going to read those patch if it happens to be underneath the plastic instead of on top of the plastic if you're holding your hand with it i would say to you that not only are we not using old words made stands and my submit to you that there is no difference in this case there's nothing about this technology which is either particularly unique or particularly exotic we're not talking about building a sonic databases or member devices we're talking about agave control that worked but kids pressing buttons and getting a vibration controllers k man controllers none of them have the tactile feedback that make these games so exciting after year five boys are my four daughters and that's all no it's a new and exciting technology a couple of points picking up on the disavowal point the judge is a reader and more made when mr foreigner intended to use words of limitation and consequence that's exactly what he did an so specifically with respect to the location of attachment to the gamepad now look at thirty eight c and thirty eight b that he showed you do seem to see an attachment of a pat my colleague repeatedly no where is it use no or is it used and what mr johnson was talking about of course is nowhere does the specification use the term attached when we see in a body to disclose them body meant that ha the actuators on the inside of the of the input control the bias to speak more broadly but if we are in terms of the embodiment we're talking about inside the handheld game that for example the gamepad of thirty eight c or thirty eight  column thirty eight and if you would join me at line forty seven that's a new paragraph starting with the words that are generally i think putting aside the fact that we embedded with then is subsume within the broader definition of attached to it must be but we do have something in the specification and i read quote generally all of the peripheral attachment means for attaching attaching the vibratory motors to a given control input device a given control and put device we're not limited in this case to the seat or the hand the handheld dual shock type input control device but let me go on this is illustrated in figures thirty seven to forty and what is within that range of figures your honour's figure thirty eight c and figure thirty eight d which is the one of the two figures you just asked me about your honor so here we have an example that i think is consistent with common sense in the fundamental principles of philips we look at the plain language of the claim the world attaches is self evident i would submit that we look at the other principles under philips what's going on with mr thorne or in terms of him being a lexicographer there is no express this of all but let's take it a step further philips tells us the starting point is very frequently the specification the specification tells us th