well i think he was being fairly clear that he did not want the police in his apartment in his home and the police pretty much ignored what he want shut the door when he walked down shut the door immediately when he heard somebody else inside and they called for that gentleman to come out he came out he left the door open and mr washington said could someone please close the door and the officer answered him no i like it open go inside and talk and three times mr washington attempted not to go inside his room with the officers and finally he was and the police words led and he was led into his room sat down on the ba right it all started out at a window shopping center somebody had shoplifted one hundred bottles are sort of a factor and then one in the officers that there was a shane laughing while living on the third floor of the that's not live there he's been evicted so right there the cia is wrong but then they go on to say well how about the fifteenth or anything going on the fifteenth floor and the clerk says well fifteen twenty floor has a lot of phone excuse me use of drugs condition for mr washington now his wife came out with an old trafficking conviction so that's what they had when they went there and the underlying offense is only a misdemeanor law enforcement must yield to the fourth amendment in all but the rarest of cases and i submit this is not a really rare case you have a gentleman surrounded by six officers three of which are kept out of sight of the he went through the suppression hearing which when you read the fashion might think this would have been a couple hours of hearing that actually went on for two days and judge reads findings that went on for twenty pages and nationalizing what had information from this person they had apprehended that there was sales of meth taking place on the fifteenth floor and they didn't have a particular name so the officers followed up on the chip when they arrived at the hotel and that person tell them that they was either it was either production or sales taking place on the fifteenth floor ok when they responded there they found out that this person named shane had in the room that he'd been in victim by the hotel records unclear as to why he was  d i think there's some one of the officers not just something about the trash the room which could have been for the for the method actually who knows but they do talk to the hotel clerk and ask about the fifteenth floor of you know is there anything happening up there in the clerk's that is large amount of foot traffic substantial number of calls those facts by themselves might seem right and somewhat innocuous to myself or to anyone on the street or in the officers who investigate drug trafficking cases know that paragraph which would reading i'm giving this written permission to these officers trillian voluntarily without any threats or promises having been made and actually ever having been informed by said officer that i have the right to refuse the search and seizure that's your right they were talking about a span of fifteen minutes from the time they first make contact with him to the time that it's  question in this case would be did the court making its findings that is there i think judge read good examine all the facts and did find the you know now a clear cut case a very difficult close call case where he found that the government had  he didn't get one reason except that he signed a consent form and i believe and judge paez just in december on the collin case you had said that that was insufficient to get rid of the fourth amendment taint so we have a fourth amendment taint maybe you will find we had if the men would consent i don't think it was there but we certainly have a fourth amendment tape that is not vitiated by anything by any intervening time space or event which is what is required to make this and ok search also they were searching before i'm sorry they were searching the room visually which is wrong underwent and then i'm going to finish my statement and they also were searching the room and picking up things and looking at things before they even asked him to sign the consent and i'll just leave it at that thank your honest was  motion you don't know but i couldn't tell you for sure i believe that's where i got it from all right thank you thank you