a religious association organization that exists in india mr singh was found to be credible in his a felt that since he fled to another state star and lived in hiding for a year that he could relocate safely in india within india we do not agree neighbor that he knew where he was living in his in another former home state called him to let him know that conservative six were coming after him therefore he fled that you would be safe in any part of india did not look into whether in every country there are twenty nine states in india iran and twenty nine states with different languages different religions and he can't he could not possibly live in but the it's not about living your honor but when he moves to another if he decides to move to any of those states would he be allowed to work in india even though the government does not pose any restriction some of the states do not allow outsiders to come and work in their state to on property to be in the language is also different in some of the states with whether he's going to be believe that i mean he may have taken a risk when he was doing that but he was not working he was not moving around but if you had been working or if you because if you if all he was doing was a standing his religion or his religion organization all of those people are associated with them so it's not that he's exposing himself to the conservative six that he's afraid of if he had been working in if he had been moving around then we would know whether he would have been   or not but the fact is that he was not the only thing he was doing was just living in hiding in that state out position is that the record does not show that there is going he would be safe in any the board did not abuse its discretion in denying humanitarian with regard to internal relocation finding the standard here is high it is the substantial evidence standard and under the record that we have before us it is clear that mr singh was able to internally relocate within india he lived in a different state from the state in which he was persecuted for over one year or for approximately one year he said he was never bothered during that year he left his house once a week to go to volunteer with the s which was the activity that was the source of the harm that he suffered and the fact that he spent one full year continuing to engage in this activity demonstrates that he was able to safely relocate this is exactly like several of this court case law if you look at the the same case at four thirty five f third to sixty and there is no evidence in that case that the harm was countrywide just is here the evidence in the record demonstrate that the d s s is headquartered in the northern part of india that's at page one twenty six of the record and his testimony at seventy nine and it shows that the problems apologize for not having the docket in front of me on that but yes if the if the court found that there is no likelihood of success that should sway this court's ruling is what are your concerns the creedal language in this case should simply be petition for review is correct something else has to be acted on correct the petition for a view just needs to be denied with respect to the internal relocation and the humanitarian asylum where the two substantive issues raised  with respect to the cat claim the petitioner briefs the merits of the cat claim however the board found that that claim was on exhausted as we have before the board so any merits claim with our starting that relief is an exhausted before this court as we have enough to know in our brief if the court has no questions about humanitarian asylum or any further questions about internal relocation i spent my time thank you ver used by the judge to deny the asylum claim the petitioner was that was that was virtually a prisoner he was not moving around he was inside the house the only activity he had was once a week when he went to attend his religious honor he cannot i think he testified he testified that he could not provide corroboration from the neighbor because he has no contact with him the wife is not living in anymore she's moving around so she has no contact with