persecution for the same reason and he also would be tortured if he did return truck urea how was it persecuted he was persecuted in the past for it was based on about four events that happened to him first his brother who is known to be i  leave the government but what what did he do that was through persecution directly as well first of all because he was related to his brother that's it and if i may back up for just a second there was no other reason for his brother university then the terrorist would assume he was supporting the government and that the third furthermore when he did withdraw from the university and he left out geria the government went after him they question his mother as to his whereabouts of the i j a is question he says is there the question and says is there anything else that he brings up the army and he said my mother didn't want me to go into the army because if i went into the army there would be killing and then the  who was trying in this very difficult political situation to stay below the radar and he's caught between a rock and a hard places that this is maybe what how does th members other members political opinions and then finally they did go searching for him so he does differ from anyone else in algeria he's trying to put stay below the radar and moreover consciously made the decision he did not want to be involved in either action and the judge did sort of distill the down at the very end with all due respect that judge i know that the ninth circuit has had some problems with him in the past for sort of leading the people through the series in a bit of a  pages one eighty two which is his desperation in which he says that armed militants came to my house and told my mother that my brother had been killed and his testimony he says a policeman who was a friend of the family home when the army came and said to his mother your brother your son was killed he was at home at the time the army came and said to his mother we've killed your son in testimony he there's no finding and i'm just looking at the testimony and ninety four yes do you know who killed your brother my brother that your said to my mother that he was going to work in libya that year they informed us though not officially but the police came the police been there to serve it if they went to his house they may have just been looking for him to take your time it's your time to serve your country and there's no evidence to the contrary indeed his burden to do that to establish evidence which c incidents do not occur so what he's saying is i left the universe because people were pining university that's not persecution directed toward him it was a political statement and he happens to be a university student so he feels he will  be harmed by random terrorist acts which may be directed against the university but then that would entitle every university student to asylum and that's not what the law allows and same thing with not wanting to join the military i being a university student he says he doesn't know what happened to his brother there is no political opinion which may have been imputed to his brother his brother indeed was killed that would have been imputed to him there's no nexus to a statutorily protected ground so it's country to asylum there has to be a specific reason why this individual would be targeted and there is to mean is different than the other anyone else in algeria who was a student he was sought after by the military unless media or the government and once they determined that he he had left the country they told his mother he safer there that is  that's an extra detail that other people don't have it and i would argue that it can be treated that he's in some kind of trouble the government he'd better not come back for them or in his brief you could sort out that people who have deserted the army