nicaraguan converting to become a jehovah's witness and in those cases stand for the proposition that we're in i j has reason to question the credibility of an applicant and the african fails to provide corroborating evidence and provide no explanation for  on notice that there was a problem with the with what he had with the statements of the assessment to refer his it was his it was his attorney who asked him on direct examination to try to provide you know why why can she say this i can just say that  he he could have easily provided if not the his friend who interpreted herself or she couldn't be there personally he could provide an affidavit a statement of family perjury even just you know just a letter just anything from her to say it turns out that i could not understand i wasn't able to translate some of the some of the questions that were asked of me it's dead what we have is his sort of after the fact explanation that well she said later on that  there's no this isn't a situation where it's it's a government provided translator that you know it's hard to obtain you don't know who it is this is someone who knows personally sisters able to be there attend the hearing with them that i think best easily available  importantly the as far as you know having a fair notice or an opportunity to present its case it was mr gold cars attorney who brought who raised these issues in the first place he knew that there was there was a problem he knew that hears thousands of these cases per year and you know regularly season like this this court you know where these removal proceedings it's that it's a rare case that you don't find some letter from some church or some religious organization saying you know this is a good person he goes here we know him anything like that he's to say that this church of our many members i think is a relatively large you know fifty sixty members many chapters are in the bible or does the chapter and verse ryall i don't i think i just find that difficult i and if this were a case where the adverse credibility terminations are simply that he couldn't asylum interview where he provides no detail no explanation you know sometimes no answer and then in this testimony he provides a very detailed explanation of how he you know he sunni he was in fact a christian coming from a country where it's forced persecution you have to keep secret it's not simply a matter of what is he supposed to know it's a matter when you're asked to provide some some some some details to provide you know where it is your burden t eligible for asylum he can provide no detail and later on he's able to provide a great of a lot of detail and he's not able to say and his explanation for why he couldn't provide the detail is not i didn't know any of these things is that there was a problem with the translation but he doesn't act it's simply his statement there was a problem with the translation not here's my friend who will tell things that this is a problem with translation or here's a letter from my friend or an affidavit from my friend so i think if it's not just  brief page nineteen you know a lack of knowledge of certain basic concepts of one's religion is essential to claim so you need to be able to provide some detail some aspect of it he was able to write nine