have to change with reference shows change and make a new something that's not an intuition patient and couple of steps well if i understand your theory correctly that these claims are not describing functions to describing structure and that claim doesn't isn't anticipated if the structure has to be rearranged in the used the wrong words but what i meant was i think it's your position that the language arranged to should be interpreted to have a structure requirement yes yes that is your position  or ranged a range to engage as meaning capable of engaging yes you can it is that's what they claim says in it and it has to description now we have some cases where we've talked about what does different language that sounds like the greatest feeling which is that meaning things like adapted to design to and in those cases we've said that it depends on what specifications sometimes it can mean something like capable of and sometimes it can mean it's actually tough to meet the limitation it's not enough that it's just capable of perhaps doing that do you have a view i mean whether it just assuming that we're going to go out and consider i understand you have an alternative argument that even if the claim is capable of the p t o hasn't met its burden here but you also argue that the language do it that only deals with a kennedy that doesn't begin with the provide translations of this french pattern so i can't read french well there is a translation of grandparents abstract at peaches to sixteen and i mean to eighteen to nineteen and if you look at page two nineteen know one two three four seven to facilitate the implementation of the human component and allow it to be fixed without resort to the mat they've got to screw and they've added this lost track that you're showing no i did not your honor but i i believe i was responding to your asking the question of how could you attach it without twenty seven and i think what i said was it seems from the figure they are relying on they would have to remove twenty seven b because it says appropriating surface in a flat surface the are engaging with the bed twenty seven be engaging the glen always surface using shell twenty seven day that the claims don't discount that and there's nothing in the claims that says you need protruding surface or raise to engage the surface of a cavity at doesn't require direct contact me it does refer to the surface it doesn't just say arrange to engage a gleaner cavity anything and i think you're reading a range too as being capable of right correct and that is the basis for the courts decision and one of the rationale to put forth by the examiner and i believe that is the correct rationale just directly can be directly inserted into the clinic by one of the problems i'm having is you say it can be but i see no justification for that their record nothing that suggested it would be used in that way if they can be  unsupported but also the arranged to construction seems overly broad not reasonable i would say in light of the specification given the precedent that we have what a range to should be interpreted to mean that it should i guess like a raise to adapt it to that it means there's an actual structural limitation in many cases in light of the specification how do you respond with claims destruction point my response to  that much i would agree with your honor in what it what happens here procedurally from procedural posture the boards that we have reason to believe that th you're relying on those passages in the specification to explain because the specification says you can have many shapes that means the word arranged to should be limited to capable of and not have a structural element resected to match the profile of any the that can be respected to match the profile of any shell and in that case the shell having this shape or pure mental shape or modify remember that doesn't seem like a proper way to for the p t o to analyze claims respectfully your honor again where it is not our opinion that referent needs to be rambert acknowledges that these sorts of implants ten be a first of all our place and remove surfaces that match whatever the implants going to be and then they can be screwed in a place where they can be cemented into