really interest you if you look at the rules of construction for contracts i think we're all familiar with those all those with favor a ruling in favor cuba  up the contract and the deficiencies in the contract should be construed against can then there's the question of well what is the word it may mean but as another element by the purchase of it says as may be required by the just i are suggesting that gives the purchaser the right to determine how to look at those figures to be terminal why is the rate so high that hugo thinks they can provide it separately well i can does a lot of provided information i frankly think under the law i god of the freedom of information but that isn't the central issue that we want to decide that's another issue i think if you look at the questions i  must use the language will require something similar that language is not in disagreement second of course all agreed to use the terminology  and for once government for lack of a better term is trying to do the right thing by providing a valuable service to people we all need water and they can provide cheaper and the case there can be a thread made that well if the manufacturer had to go out and provide something in order to be able to provide this product then they have they don't want to tell us how they got their rates perhaps if we knew that would be another story so i'm sure what i'm asking this court to do customers and is a government they should not be able to do they're not in the business of trying to make a profit they provide a service but it's not it's customers and citizens in cuba are totally at their mercy they can't go to the i c c they just keep paying more and more so for those reasons and i realize it's a matter of interpretation and it's a difficult thing we can all look at something and interpret it a little differently we probably wouldn't be here but i think contract has the word name and q because to great lengths to argue that that word is permissible it is not mandatory and therefore they do not purchase all their water from  but i do think you have to read that in the context of the entire sentence his sentence says as may be required by the purchaser or used by consumers of the purchaser now counsel referred to in his brief the case wall and how the fireman's contracts generally are provided the product or service is supposed to be used in quotes the words will be or will wire didn't actually look at those cases nowhere to drafters ever say you have to use the word will the have to use mandatory language there's rather assertions that the language has to be sufficient to go to a sufficient to promise to buy all th marty that the buyer may need him she would promise to buy water that all the consumers would use and that is sufficient in this case to pull out one thing he didn't hear closing counsel mention is the course of dealing and the city of cuba purchased all of their water from the city now it's not of which it it's not a goal it's not a baseball card it's not something that is readily available it's water and as we all know that's becoming a commodity that's harder and harder to come workarounds and go through that particular process one thing that i think is important to know here because the council mentioned it i think the references say you can't be greedy that we're attempting to make a profit off of this contract we charge the city of cuba the same price that w can't reasonable fluctuations in the amount of water they use they're going to happen sooner and then they're going to have seen workers move at all but they cannot because they simply have decided the price is too high this point not purchase all of their water cuba the original agreement prohibit the resell of water to other commercial entities so they could have resold it to other small towns and it's had to make profit off of it so we allowed them to modify a few green men their context it was used to determine the validity of whether they have a contract or not not necessarily whether it's a requirements contract or not and if you look at the