crimes it's hard to get a bright line necessarily from the cases and your argument is that ultimate point error is probably the fastest support for what you're what you want to say look at the language that we're talking about here if you do it does refer to user selection and in that language it says that it says the machine receives from the user a selection of one or more of the user selectable database fields and up elsewhere in your claim for you in your patent you use language that says that the system is adapted to now you are essentially asking us to put the adapted to language into this claim as well is that right i don't think we are verb talking about the user that does this how can you say whether that covering the system or the actions what you're talking about the actions performed by the user interface you're talking about the capabilities her we propose that that plane order a meeting is a computer software object or structure defining interactive table they can show the same data from a lister database in more than one to range it's right so in other words that as i understand it the district court conceded that the plain meaning could be a blank table or a populated table but in the context of this specification in this patent the district co in the facts of this case aside if there was an ordinary meeting of the word but then when that same word is understood in light of the specification the prosecution history it might have a different meaning wri generate a pivot table within the electronic worksheet according to the database query where in the pivot table contains the c r m data from the c r m database so i mean if we are talking about table that is present and i think that even if we don't think the prosecution history is a disclaimer it is informative that when in your history you talk about constructing pivot table or creating a pivot table as as by populating it right and you used the word creating in conjunction with populating it with court construed it in as if you just threw me a beverage can you explain how you stipulated to not infringement under this construction so how does the allegedly infringing product work with it like table  interact with dynamics c r m they choose basically the data source that they want to use for their pivot table excel then is that launched and what happens is this bla m program appear in the field well but then when user wants to create their give a table they have to either they interact with the excel spreadsheet program one way they drag sam and then but you so you would agree i take it with the district court that the common meeting up to pivot table could be one that's empty or one that's populated i don't know your honor i wouldn't say that we would really at issue here but you have nothing in that empty shell until you pick the field that's going to go into iraq right but i understand the district court's analysis it was a pivot table could have either meaning seven developer's guide it also says the pivot table is constructed by dragging and dropping fields into an empty stale iton so that you know fifteen seventy five fourteen having you know taking these fields interacting with a spreadsheet program taking these fields dragging the fields and dropping him into an empty shelf and that's what the examiner pointed to  that a pivot table is generated mastermind in order to overcome that rejection mastery amended its claims and added the word automatically in front of generate a pivot table require that each one of its claims audio the cli generate a pivot table with an electronic worksheet and then after doing so they said this they they then traverse the examiners rejection based on one and said this conlon describes a user interface for a spreadsheet application that allows a user to drag and drop fields to at the very next sentence after saying that khan teaches dragging and dropping to create a manually of the table they say the applicant has a medical and one to wasn't the thrust of their argument wasn't that the distinguishing between a manual system and where there's an empty shell and and and their system they said what what their argument was that conlin didn't describe a system for communication between a c r m application and especially application at all let alone automatically that is a separate argument that they made but the disclaimer or that we're talking about are the definitional piece  allows a user to drag and drop fields to manually create a pivot table on a spreadsheet they don't dispute that they were talking about clicking right place or here they said that that they were just summarizing common that wasn't their attempt to distinguish the  use use that to distinguish their automatically generated pivot table claims from manually generated pivot table places it's you know certainly to the argument section here but down below on fifteen spreadsheet application to manually select the fields for a pivot table conlan does not describe any mechanism by which this process can be automated that sentence is virtually identical to their second sentence where they're describing the drag and drop feature of comment now i don't master my art use at least on reply and they argued oh we were talking about something completely different there a completely different field selection but they did the exact same thing they didn't say on how to run here pivot table data displays something completely different that's an argument that they're making you know some ten years later what they said was they said also that c shows this dragging and dropping in order to create a pivot table and then as was sent out in our brief in fundamentally if you look at the description in common of a pivot table data display and th and that's exactly what mastermind says and they both say that they are there to allow the user to analyze summarize and view data that you know in different ways both of them say summarize and analyze large amounts of that performs those functions automatically based on the user selection within the c r m software then automatically sense that information over to the spreadsheet application to create the pivot table that's what the path is talking about that was the distinction drawn in the prosecution not attempting to redefine