when i look at the country report it sounds as though they are not persecuting the roma at the moment they're discriminating against the roma and a number of respects but it hasn't risen  and it sounds like the only violence was by some skinheads but there was no evidence that they were working for the government or beyond their control the government had trouble following peace because of those things the immigration judge found that his arrest were limited to his criminal activity the immigration treasurer i do not believe paid attention to the testimony of mr donohue mr dunne first said he was arrested and he was arrested and for if the court is referring to the there was testimony at the individual hearing in which mr guy trip testified that while he was working at kinko's trading he was approached and interrogated by the police officers regarding the well the government maintains that the passport issue of something tied it was not here other than the course of the individual during the trial attorney for the through all those arrests to his the skinheads mocking him could all be reasonably explained either by legitimate police inquiries into the asked or else appear to be independent of his friendship with the roman like you are not having anything to do with the government absent mister don't share this testimony i would say yes you could argue that if we were looking straightly  stuff individuals who sat in the front of a bus were charged with sitting in front of a fast and you could say well they violate the law but it was racially motivated the same would apply to mr i don't see the the analogy actually the law there they have laws and in a lot of southern municipalities that required the segregation these disaggregate the trains going from new york to d c and in delaware and it was pursu this court has dealt with cases that are actually very similar if you had the nickel to the facts of this case and made the same essential finding that with the state department report that states that conditions have improved in a country where there's essentially widespread widespread economic revision and discrimination of minority groups that does not amount to extend itself to persecution that we have here a case of a young man who does not actually belong to a group obviously of that group and anything that happened to them one could reasonably imply that's because of their skin color you have someone who simply associates with people who you think would include me goodman shorter and cheney were murdered but without a place things happen to that effect that's just his opinion it could be because the police don't like kids his age if you think that there are bunch of hooligans out there to cause trouble it was a police are just going for a quarter of a felt this has to be something besides i think more than that even an e mail that we see that there was that the incidents are similar but only one of them was found to be persecution the other two were not and the facts of this case are so show that refusing a meal of test these don't read ri and sure they did say that and that's one incident and this record i believe that might have some connection and that case i would i would say one wild guess that the policeman did that expressed racist sentiment and that point that there was no particular and there force wasn't used regularly in other countries but it is unfortunately and that alone is not persecution  and later he's going to get a police station and he was beaten and sexually assaulted had to escape from prison and escape the country and this court found that that didn't necessarily show that it was not a conference and he was a roman in this case with with those you however we don't know if that was because of his connection to the romas maybe he thinks that they knew he was friends with roma and she thinks that they did it because they knew that those are both just wild speculations he's making and even because of who he was or any race that they that he was beaten it was because of the fact that he didn't share the racist views of his superior officer and furthermore if even if that work is there and event that's not something that has a well  if you look at these two statements in here is these people are having trouble getting into the european union because they've got a lot of work yet to do in their relationship with the gypsies correct your honor but i guess i would respond if they're doing the their opinion there is no longer any systematic or widespread government persecution of the problem i guess i should point out the submission made by the trial attorney back in two thousand and three that the government cites to the page two eighty three actually starts a two eighty two this is a