or whether it also prohibits an evaluation system where an officer's job performance is evaluated by counting in train tickets written by the officer there is not really an issue of whether talk tell you a little bit about what the activity points system actually is and what it isn't this is not a ticket quota system this isn't the system which requires an officer to write a specific number of citations over a given period of time what this is an activity point system that tracks all in officers and activities and gives them credit for doing things like making arrests like writing cases like writing say tasia ins and now we're talking about all types of citations traffic and otherwise for doing things like accepting an extra duty assignment is going to court calls that sort of talks about this concept of points of contact now it's not rigid enough in a mandatory sort of way it's written in a permissive it says you can issue these sorts of points of context system so for instance you if you look at that last sentence which talks about points of contact cannot include the issuance of citations i think that we leads back to the st sentence of the statute which talks about you cannot require officers to issue a specific number of citations over does a good period of time it also talks about a number of citations which i think relates back to that rd sentence of the statute you're supposed to read statutes in their entirety as a whole you're not supposed to render different parts of a paragraph and superfluous in this particular situation the unions analysis with essentially remove the language over a designated period of time so i think my colleague refers to it as were conflicting arguments we're presenting alternative arguments i think there is a plain meaning analysis which frankly you have to give some sort of mirror to the phrase does it mean that period of time that's what it would it is writing it's requiring an officer to go out and make us certain number of traffic stops over and right citations over a doesn't need a period of time so legislative history and here we actually have transcripts us for the transcript pages from both the house and the senate proceedings and those are clear that the legislative intent was to prohibit requiring officers to write a specific number of citations over a dozen period of time in fact i counted no fewer than ten different instances where either the house that sponsor a senate sponsor used the phrase does a good period of time give credit officers for frankly just doing busy and at the end of the day we're just talking about minimal standards here we're talking about a police department that was just wants to ensure that the troll officers are staying busy now if if an officer  in this particular system was actually negotiated with even prior to the implementation of the put so the idea was yeah you can just perform a traffic stop you get one point but if you go  orderly conduct or battery or the possession of marijuana those sorts of violations as well you're also getting credit score will patrol officer for that  well as any other activity is related like brady case record or making an arrest or something like that