money judgment we've got a stipulated my judgment was all about getting the money you were owed on the stipulated judgment what other basis did you have for extracting anything of value from them your honor we extracted the shares lawsuit designed to be a good collection of a judgment or all wrong as a matter of the undisputed back now i'm really puzzled by that because you say it's and you appear before us now to for the basis of the stipulated judgment we had not ok so everything that follows in this dispute between the two of you the current flows from your assertion that you're entitled to who previously owned the shares interfered with our ability to find out what the value  what does that have to do with anything except for the fact it was only relevant because you say we're over two hundred seventy five and change and now he's got your money your honor at the time we commenced the action asset that you were given with the share certificate but your entire case seems to come down to the word unconditional you used the word unconditional repeatedly in your briefing we had an unconditional ownership interest that's that's your language and i guess my question to you is since that share certificate was put in your care and keeping for the sole reason of allowing you to collect on a judgment for money damages the fact that at some point the district quirk when you sue in aid of execution says ok you've got your money does it i mean isn't there an inherent condition in this transfer of ownership inherent in the notion that you're using it to four hundred thousand dollars you execute against a home for five hundred thousand dollars your position is i own the house i own the house i own the whole house i'm entitled to five hundred thousand dollars worth of value on my one hundred thousand dollar judgment that's your legal position that injured in any way i don't understand it you know you can say we don't know what's happening with the land we don't know what was happening here will how does any of that matter to you if you have to acknowledge as you must we are entitled to that's the company sold for yourself yeah that's what you're saying and i guess their research should toss and i don't see anything in the record that really disputes it is as they would tend to get information from your clients your clients we're not giving them information associated with source or bressay except for saying you've got the wrong company it's not worth anything i mean that's a you've got a real logical kind of group here mr stockton you're not answering it any better than mr logan to answer the question about when fall and help the very end when you know yeah they want to windfall and that is if this thing was really worth nothing your client was well served to say ok you've got it and walk away instead there was this f repeatedly going on for a year until you came up with money can you give us any credible explanation for that except you were saying the execution if they could come up with cash so they couldn't have the advantage of owning the property value they didn't have a hundred thousand dollars cash they had an asset we were given the asset in need and judgment if it had amounted to more than one hundred less than a hundred thousand dollars were less than well we have some maybe additional remedies but if we were entitled to own that thing and if it were and if it was a valuable asset that was worth less or just one hundred thousand dollars would be entitle to keep it and we would be entitled to whatever increase in value over time with occur because of it you know that's what we're title to the retired two hundred thousand dollars when we got it it was perhaps worth less it would have to say but we were entitled to it and any value that would be increased because of that we were prevented from enjoying the value of that which we owned because of the bad behavior of these misconduct what's wrong with the argument that we should be entitled to have possession of that property and it we should have the value or the worth of whatever increase about you there might have been for the year that was held and we didn't get the execution of the judgment period or no you are the if the judgment was obligated to be satisfied if we had received seven hundred seventy five thousand dollars plus interest scripting then you would have about some program when we let you go ok thank you thank you very much