should do she did ok mine typical cases have a few service plans she has seventeen seventeen different service plans administered by six different caseworkers one of the cable guy who was removed from the case what was being done it couldn't be further from the true everybody says she was complying she was doing here she was working on it it would say i'm looking at the mistakes brief in maybe what you're saying is true and it says the mother had either been  and she has marginal income because it says here and here her built in two thousand and twelve that she had no money to pay her bills how's she going to provide a safe table environment for the of the domestic violence the mental health counseling the budgeting the parenting classes literally everything she made there was progress it was completed so we respectfully request she had fallen on hard times she was living at her mother's house and her mother had grown or out and she had no place to  go prior to august two thousand fourteen suzy had been homeless for approximately a year and these are her own words this is her own testimony that she was homeless for a year  and till close testified that in the july two thousand and thirteen service plan and the january two thousand and fourteen service plan was on satisfactory because she was homeless  so no she was not able to maintain a job and housing throughout throughout this this case most of this case she either didn't have a job or she didn't have housing and a lot of times the only reason why she had housing is because it was public housing so the second ground upon which she was  fourteen the mother had not been rated satisfactory on a single service plan so most most the time the case was open and she did not complete her service by hands i notice that  i heard counsel say that she had completed mental health justice chapman as she completed mental health counseling she did complete it after her petitions were filed so that you thousand and thirteen a serviceman said that she was not consistent with the goal of psychological counseling may two thousand and twelve reporter she was doing some of the services but not all so she  wasn't completing the services obviously the task of housing was not being completed and it was not being completed and as as far as the domestic violence i know is that  domestic violence disputes between the mother and father and i mean i think we can presume she was a victim and then in november two thousand and fourteen she absolutely was the victim and it was probably it sounds like the worst battering committed against her and and that that was pretty late in in the case and we're talking over two thousand and fourteen so for most of this case she did not really get out of that abuse she she was not able to break break away  terminated if you look at the exchange between the court and the state attorney it's just so obvious that he misspoke the the process is that the terminology is kind of confusing it's really easy to kind of mix up i saw big stuff you know terminated i don't fit you know it he quickly corrected himself he indicated that he was just making a decision the first stage he explicitly said i'm just making a judgment on the first stage those are his words and then he proceeds to sack immediately after that he proce to set a date for the second stage and that they just didn't terminate susie's rights didn't occur until after the second stage and i and again this is the allegations that none of the service plans were ever satisfactory they did say that but again that's the head if you look at the body what was actually completed she didn't leave the service finds the mental health counseling was completed after one of the