a matter of appreciation for the planet and we're holding our for deportation based on fear of persecution if returned to china and the facts were raised in the appeal to the the i a e a and therefore left the watchful eyes of his fellow performers at disneyland when they were not watching him so he escaped to a restaurant due to a restroom and he called his friend who come to pick him up and it's just that  examples when judging credibility and the swamp that we go through when we work credibility arcade we have a lot of cases on credibility determinations and who can do that are you saying that we should ignore whatever was said about the hospital because it wasn't materials or whether he was accurate or not it didn't make any difference when you make the credibility germination your honor if it if the lie it was a lie if the law and hence of his claim of past persecution  for at least withholding of deportation it's not asylum for which i think that one is already given the country condition that is in the records i would just cite a very sharp paragraph that country condition published by the united states departments they said and unapproved religious groups including christian groups experienced persecution and religious services were broken up and church leaders or hearings were harassed at times fined detain any material issue it would go to withholding even if he was not credible as to as to an issue that was that would so to speak go to the heart of the claim he was not credible in filing for asylum and the immigration judge relied upon that as well as other inconsistency and testimony and and other things that were not believable and not credible in in this regard case in order to conclude that he was not credible and it seems to me that you can't oh no lack of credibility edged in the way  right greg it does have to be as to material items but if there is a little lie or inconsistency as to one part of the testimony the immigration judge can draw upon that conclude that the individual appearing before the court it's not credible that it's not generally telling the truth that of the spanish not generally tell and in addition to that he also found that it was unlikely given all the testimony that was given about how this recount constantly followed and being in being monitored by these minders from china that it was impossible that they would just you know a moment of celebration watching t v in the politicians argue about what's material to perjury it seems to me that we're either going to get into our cases on what our function is on credibility and try to stick to the law or when trying to make it up as we along and say we're going to throw this out because it's not material i'm going to throw that out i thought that was the a g was trying to do is take the factors were presented by the petitioner relative to the relief he wanted and and then try to say well is this credible is a credible about his day in the hospital well he said i didn't file for all these years because i was sick for seven months as a credible to i i i don't know if we're going to start starting a stout are you are you saying that some things can be thrown out and that some things that are not material should no no no go on i mean i think that the entirety of the testimony and everything that  into the game any training and he came over under watch he couldn't approach people to get give them a basic a what he called and autograph and they all these things like i'm going to figure out which one of these things are material what i do with perjury analysis here are we know we're not we're not we're looking at what would the material to his claim and to his fear and one of the things that the immigration judge looks at is whether or not the story as a whole is persuasive and credible and make sense and in order to determine whether or not the person appearing before the judge is telling a true story the judge looks at at everything that the person has justified to including things like whether or not you know he was minded in one situation and left to his