articles or products and is festus because we know it's a deep knowledge that those exposures can and do take place indoors the court can do neither it cannot write litigation or all the cool actions not specifically remember but but there is in let me just respond by saying that the definition of informal time to tort claims is long it goes on for almost a page and it's there's been a lot said here about whether or not clean rooms are environmental thing but if you look at the agreement and ask you to look at it very carefully injurious environmental conditions is defined as  that we could think of countless examples the notion that environmental in the context of this release necessarily means only outdoors just isn't isn't so let me take you to if in fact you accept the trough boards inclusion that he releases and big as we say it's not if it isn't big as we say probably the best evidence of all much of what we couldn't get but the best evidence is significant piece which we wouldn't get into which i think is rounds for rehearsal in of itself is what's in this binder of five hundred fifty pages we do know the file we do know that environmental lawyers put it together we do know that they absolutely so they chose different words and more well i have the roadmap of how to exclude even you know indoor sports but didn't do so the words have to clearly look at some other parts of the agreement there are some recitals that seem to indicate that the parties sit down at a table to negotiate a specific type of ok thank you but the core point is what is actually being religious and it says it quite plainly motorola released claims and ball environmental pollution environmental contamination and other new jersey environmental  chemicals it's a it's a way for a chip manufacturing facility out errors up and in the process of manufacturing chips they try to make a drug isolate the room where the chips are made factor because the process so  case motorola was not clear what was very clear it was not willing to agree to a release of that type so what happened next the parties went back and forth there was lots of correspondence act with between them and it's laid out in the m sits in our frequent pages seventeen eighteen it's in the records twenty two point zero zero zero three six this is associated sub presentation they do a detailed study presentation because the term environmental slash toxic to work which finds its way all the way through course watch two thousand and two into the actual selling ring in two thousand and three is the same term it's been used by the parties for months and months for more than it's all those extra little you know evidence in terms of what some are he might have described environmental or not has got nothing to do with this release i think the context comes from the negotiations which and there's a lot of record evidence of that in the trial and it motorola been zooms its negotiations and discussions with zork right before those negotiations start there was a sub meeting in two thousand and three right before that heard what happened motorola and he value the claims that certain level motorola valued them not surprisingly a higher level you know there are two primary policies that have a share of the best cost and then there are some of us that spike up through the primary level up into their access card they had ten million dollar