one and the as the plight of here in shoals two is that the blue folder the so called blue folder was a proper st amendment petition for redress of violations of the constitution and as the full record before the court shows i have been denied the complete fall and fair opportunity to pursue and litigate my petition cause claim justice demands my petition clause klein be fully and fairly litigated and decided before there can be any notion or determination of a penalty pursuant to section six thousand seven hundred we're here today nineteen million ninety two thousand and two i and upwards of ninety one thousand members and supporters of the we the people foundation for constitutional education with the assistance of constitutional scholars and attorneys repeatedly served the appropriate federal officials and congressional committees with proper st amendment petitions for redress of for violations of the constitution st the iraq resolution zz violation of the war powers clauses how we wish of course the government had responded to that petition which was filed five months before we went into iraq we could have avoided the whole isis mess and so forth but the nd petition was the us was submitted to a file because of violations by the usa patriot act violation of the privacy cos when i st read that and saw that the government could commit to my home and copy my harddrive without ever telling me they were there i knew so there was something seriously wrong they took that  off the shelf right after nine hundred and eleven dollars and the rest is history but it was a violation of the price it had numerous violations of privacy cause and then of course the rd petition back then was that the federal reserve systems a violation of the a numerated powers and the money clauses of the constitution is simply no authority in the constitution for a central bank there were two dollars prior before this one and they both failed and then  the petition which focused on the direct on a portion tax on labor's violation of the tax causes in each of these petitions we laid out the facts and we ask questions looking for answers to questions there was no remedy other than that that we were requesting they were proper petitions in that they exceeded any rational standard requiring a formal specific response from the government they were serious and documented not frivolous they contain no false or they were not absent probable cause they had the necessary quality of a dispute they came from citizens outside the formal political culture and involved a legal principle not political talk they were pantelion us and dignified containing both a direction and a prayer for relief they are dressed a public collective grievance with widespread protests of patients and consequences they were instruments of the liberation not educated and they provided legal notice seeking substantial substantial a substantive redress to cure the infringement of a right guaranteed by the constitution above all for a meaningful him sorry we're asking for an order dismissing the penalty that's been imposed and directing other defendant to restore the organization's tax exempt status and removing the penalty that was imposed retroactive aftershocks one retroactive to two thousand and three which is now in the hundreds of thousands of dollars nd declaring that our blue folder that was a proper petition for redress of grievances and directing defendants to meaningful meaningfully provide a penalty of which not and for a petition the penalty was imposed for organizing them promoting their views of tax avoidance schemes based on false statements about internal revenue laws and that was the same activity that was enjoined in the prior case and in which this court in a published opinion affirmed the injunction on page six hundred and seven dollars of this court's opinion and the injunction  acknowledge the petition clause argument and then found that all of mr shelter's arguments were without merit without merit is a direct quote from that published opinion so the petition cause argument is irrelevant