now from the government however he found that all of his testimony was completely consistent with his revised application and he never provided false testimony before the agency on the application  are not required to be an attorney anyone does this or that but there is a really big difference between persecution by guerrillas which will happen to make you eligible for asylum one time you apply  and persecution by government military which you happen to make you eligible for a silent six or seven years later because country conditions have changed you know  and here you go and then when that when they have to have the matter translated to them they often find that it's a bogus application you know if you were actually to make a bogus claim  i've never seen one where where there's been a find you know an adverse probability finding and the person did not at least you know allege that he himself was tortured or beaten i mean here he could have had a stronger claim i think it's cool to fish you claim because you don't have to he personally was never beaten by the military or taken into custody he doesn't have to show that to an asylum he just has to show that he has a person in his circumstances would have a reasonable and well founded fear of persecution and i think he has that you know considering that one of his brothers was beaten and suffered terrible permanent damage and the other one was this just assume for the purpose of the question was there anything else about the original application in terms of its description of events that was changed by the supplemental statement streamlining provisions for those forms of relief however the cardiologist an exception first silent and under that regulation whether novel issues with facts such as a credibility finding we don't know what the board made its decision on the board basically gave a rubber stamp was regarding the guerrillas based on his political support of the political party and then only after the piece of course as he changed his claiming to say oh well now my fear is of of the government because i was a little less i was hoping  really the question is is that suspicious set of circumstances i think the immigration judge characterized as suspicious of a sixty five is that suspicious of circumstances so compelling that we're we're we're forced to believe what he's later tackle ration he recognized that it was in his power to attempt to cure that problem and we witnessed the fact that his parents supplied him with a medical report about his brother scuse me and when asked why his parents could provide him with a letter  my kid made a mistake it really was the government that would certainly been an easy thing to do or his brother who testified page one hundred now lives in mexico he could have supplied a letter from him he could have asked about that he never explained why he didn't provide any he didn't supply any independent corroborating evidence to support his present claim really the question is is this is suspicious of circumstances did the immigration judge have a reason to expect there to be did he have a reason to question this applicant's credibility there is a difference there is in this record a difference that that is that is a valid grounds on which the immigration judge could question his credibility so you have the obvious credibility problem you have the suspicious set of circumstances and you have pereira's failure to corroborate his claim despite the fact he's been here since one thousand nine hundred knew that there was a problem and his failure to even attempt to corroborate his claim makes it all the more or less likely that his claim is correct  that's what i mean there are any number of reasons i don't know what how is his relationship is with his brother or if that they came real close contact he did request from his family members he didn't receive anything other than the medical report regarding the problems that his brother had after the beating and there is also information in the state department report as far as mentioning that the police are still have to kill people in detention and that was