theory causally connecting the vaccination in the injury and that's not my paraphrase that's a direct quote out about them in this case we presented a theory that michael a there's an identified molecular mimic between the vaccine and the part of the brain that controls the sleep cycle than you say she is when you say that the wild virus well it actually and that's a good point but the fact is the thing that we know is the wild virus has in common with the vaccine mr mccollum received is the h one n one virus proteins the h one n one virus have to be in the vaccine in order to relate immunity that's the thing that has the h one n one protein in it and does not have imagined him it is the wild virus so he got that particular protein from that vaccine and there's no other way the least in the record for him to have received that but i cited probably half a dozen of those research articles and there are those two footnotes i think contain five of them but let's just i just just clarify that it's my understanding of the record and the special masters pandemics which was not given in this country is on the bottom and that's for comparison but the n p content for all the other these are all influenza vaccines that are given in this country and that's what they were studying there and so this paper directly looked at that question vaccines giving people in this country do that have a similar type and p content or how f factor is the critical factor right for narcolepsy right and that there's ample evidence that the u s spec scene has higher in p factor than than the study which did show a connection between a different form of the vaccine in england versus here and i almost agree with that it's some were high but not as high and there was one that was higher and some were kind of in the mid but it wasn't what they were trying to do they were trying to show that they found that they found what they said ok we found the mimic which is a big deal in their in their portion of science look we've  what looked at this we have at least several of them they do on the hand so that was their hypothesis with that particular article but look let's take a step back from that the special master found p content has several reliable components ok so that's up from my question to this panel of courses how is that not a theory that i what how do i not how have i not satisfied out in step one with presenting a theory when he talks about my theory and he does so that and says that there are several lawyer for whatever the world or i know but i'm looking at what you're reading from his report agrees that there are theories out there but then suggested that certain correlations can do it but that those are based upon the american vaccine  us he says that petitioner offered no direct evidence suggesting that the version of the vaccine that he received has been tested in connection with narcolepsy and to the degree of other vaccine pandemic task that is argument and he did not address it so i just leave that there but if it's special masters are free under out them to say i'm going to require you to go out here so then we have the two canadian studies that suggest looking at that english study that really what's causing it there is primarily the protein and you i suspect you dispute that characters and that's what let's assume that's what it says and then we go to the american if that vaccine and we know it has and maybe i'm wrong about this but i don't think they have that it has protein levels comparable to or higher than the english study why isn't those three s put together if the special master had made that pining for a sufficient theory of conservation primarily because there's other evidence in the record as well indicating for instance that the right right i get that but isn't that the special master job that's why i ask it to you in that way at the special masters balances all this evidence and says well yeah there may be this happened to me a logical sidey but we kind of discount it epidemiological studies there's nothing else that suggests that the activity is the key role it seem to go the other way so i'm going to buy this is a patient i get that he did it and you think that's not arbitrary capricious but i just don't understand why you'd say if it came out the other way that that would be arbitrary capricious and there would be a close call and there would be a reasonable argument though i believe from the respondent that it is arbitrary gracious because of the other evidence that outweighs the evidence that petitioner it what so the forced studies indicate that to a greater or lesser extent the basically it's a dual of factor between the high nuclear protein content and at so that it's the presence of the attributes that somehow contributes to vaccination the petitioner receives here but isn't the han study contradictory to that because it suggests that the wild virus can trigger narcolepsy where there is an attribute yes to an extent it does contradict however there are problems with the hans studies reliability which the special master addresses on page twelve thirteen of the appendix and of itself but additionally the high study involves just a wild version of the virus and on page twenty four of the appendix the special master indicated that here it's uncontested that petition received an inactivated version of the vaccine so we're not dealing with the wild version of the virus the wild bird from the virus can have a fax that the vaccine will not have primarily thank you thank you very much community at least at some level this quarter now can say you can't do that the irony of course is here we have the best researchers in the world on this subject publishing on  master make me wholly eliminate a potential alternate cause me it's scientifically impossible we don't have to speculate that's what he said he wanted all the eliminate something i can't do   he says that i have to show that the vaccines that my client guard has to be cast into the same level many of these vaccines never get tested specially the new ones we get them and we deal with these god over my time are harder when i don't care what the vaccinations you if i have the whole eliminate other possible causes i cannot win any cases doesn't matter thank you