obviously had undertaken to care for mr christian and not only that you participated in discussions regarding the condition he went to the vehicle and crash into the vehicle to observe the condition of mr christian he participated in nothing other than a bypass or a doctor or a bystander and that simply isn't true because bystanders who they don't get in the car with the caregivers to assess the condition of the victim or the person who's incapacitated he went well beyond walking by some who question on the street this isn't just a matter of knowledge he didn't participate now that after vacation is it the the care that he needed them judged overly focused on the fact that in his view a decision had been made not to get medical care and measure why he pretty much removed mr cells from minimize it but what we need to do we feel is for me to be the tyrian standpoint somebody should somebody in distress there you know that attorney doesn't necessarily translate into a legal responsibility so knowing all that he knows  that he discouraged the others from seeking medical care that is an act of omission that might encourage him not to do one thing and he more importantly his involvement as an act distracted the others instead of monitoring kyle to call your mum do you want us to call an ambulance he says no no although we never opens his eyes again he's breathing as significantly improved from earlier in the evening and which the other fella did they went to see said who had seen the the deceased here previously overdosing said why she's breathing it should improve so the breathing has improved he school parent he's answering questions i've got s had experience with christians in previous search situations where he lives in the incapacitated state due to the influence of get a real life situation somebody comes to your house good people comes your house there's somebody who over the somebody in the car this is the stress they talk to you about it and discuss it you go up to the driver you look at the person you do nothing situation where the person is incapacitated who are c p r of the minister then to take those people that brought him to my house and shinji the school smoke cigarettes come on him we'll take you to all the coffee break let me get the car and check and see i was doing you know what think you can look good in this particular moment in time i think you have to look at it from the context of the situation  don't get treatment for him i'll take care of it and then my client doesn't do that and i think there has to be some sort of overt act or overt statement of again we have to put this also in the catholics of the real world i mean how far you go there are myriad holdman i mean you get a call from somebody who's a friend or relative and saying you know i'm with this person now there have been these problems breathing you know i'm thinking about just sort of waiting and see how they do would you think according to the argument here if  joe came on scene and said here's morning who get more her come on back will do their one and then we'll go inside a coffee shop and talk i think those actions were or could be viewed by regional trier of fact people to be again in my view and i think when you view the facts i mistakenly morsi and he cost voluntarily undertaken the duty to care for christian and i think they