error and that he was prejudiced as a result of that error specifically yes which show that the outcome in its case would have been different on this record he has not and cannot make a showing it's interesting you know that the translation issue fact in front of the immigration court because there was no contemporaneous objection to any form of improper translation we'll see clearly in the record that the immigration judge took explicit pains to make sure that the translation and the translator provided was a competent translator and who was interpreting in a language that the alien said understand that that the shooting would be some tension there in the transcript as to the actual occasions of the substantive hearings the immigration judge inquired of the alien himself what was his best language and whether he understood and could communicate with the interpreter in all three occasion s he said he did speak armenian the best now this is a multi lingual petitioner he speaks apparently russian armenian some georgian and perhaps a little bit of english but it's important for the judge to make sure and he did so in this case and all the occasions that the interpreter provided is in the language that the alien understands best and confessed communicated and there were two occasions where  word that the alien used and the english translation came out to be the word hooligan which is perhaps not most commonly used and i submit them probably some english speaking people i would not understand what is meant by term in his explanation the interpreter noted that he used a russian term and that the then the judge again repeated his questioning do you understand how many languages do you speak of the alien respond and then the judge said he reminded him that the armenian interpreter was divided nature that he understood armenian and i reminded him to speak in armenian it's not uncommon for multilingual people to go back and forth different attorneys representing him and these two very widely separated the sort of the from direct and then across in the second time around i think i recollect in the transcript there was some notation toward the end  second part of the hearing the attorney would have been picking them up that's correct and then there were no objections at all made to the quality of the interpretation of the objections in the brief to the board and continuing to this court are that well the law requires that if you prove a valid asylum claim under the standard for bided in order to succeed even deeper minutes are made in the united states whether the department of homeland security would decide as a matter of it here in los angeles but not playing on the record and it doesn't seem like a long time again no contemporaneous objection ever to that length of time or even on appeal there was no objection to the length of time it really only enters in the to the benefit of the alien who is allowed to remain in the united states longer and here at the gravesite is an issue so again he has a citizen daughter who lives here and i think in glendale correct and the record is clear that she has not that's where they come from but their attorney seems to understand enough to be able to ask a question prior to the full interpretation and in english at some point certainly an armenian speaking attorney would have objected but again i believe that i don't see an asylum claim here i don't see an incompetent translation claim and i've seen thousands of cases if i in any way believe that there wasn't a problem with due process here it would be i think my duty to send this case back and ask this court to do that but i frankly don't see the point in this case the alien and elderly his entire families in the united states because only want to remain and i don't begrudge him that make a lot of confusion when you read this i agree my mind yeah i agree that there's some confusion but i don't believe that was related to incompetent translation and i don't think the record shows that it was in any way language and they carry from there but i don't think in any way that his non response and this can be attributed to incompetence translation