royal based on his age skills training and working a story and then that and that's what the commission found based upon the opinion expressed in the vocal mode of locational report that because of her skills age and training which the commission misstated the evidence said it has absolutely no shops within its restrictions first language or it scales and that's not true we listed six of the food prep jobs  dilemma of them having an indian your argument has some you know intuitive appeal but we have a situation where in essence you are asking us to really weigh the evidence you are to be very blunt asking us to find that core bellows broke before it was than that some of the positions require quote unquote good english skills in more than just the spoken word i mean somebody may be able to speak english and maybe not adept at doing a jam that we choir's all of the skills that stem from that if you combine them or with a core of l o core valve and call for potential employers and finds at least six positions where that we need to be mulisch would not be a factor which was of course i am assuming argued before reading arbitration but i don't remember i know the commission specifically said and i can read from the ruling where they said for a rally to be given thirty away because there's absolutely no jobs that they list within this interpretation of the evidence incorrect the vocational case manager opining petition to work in the areas of food preparation telemarketing and inspection she was evidently on where the sisters lack of secondary education total and that that that shifted the burden to the employer to show them that the employee was an employee for a stable labor market system and we believe that the commission was correct in finding that they did not  years old that's in the record is it occasionally you only had six years of education in texas this trade when i have any training neither in mexico or here didn't hold any certificates of any guy his work history included twenty five years in the united states of unskilled labor at different levels might lead you to me and for his language the employee did say he does speak and understand some english but it's not his first language and nor does evidence that was the central theme in his distinguishing between the two vocal we have reports so i don't respond directly to his argument you heard there for fifteen minutes at the commission misinterpreted dns if you don't agree with that why is that  there seems to be a debate here is exactly what the commission found i don't seem to be making my so quite understood here so try it again simply didn't commission fin that this media did not possess either the english language skills transferable skills or physical abilities per dr john to perform in the work that they are they are you that they may be they weren't under standing the level of english language that the petitioner possessed but that was not the testimony the testimony was that yes he does i've been here twenty five years he does he can understand some english but however not his first language he doesn't really need us right it doesn't rise to that level where he would need to have as we have a conversation with someone in the second edition so i for it because they suggested it was not what the commission found the commission understood it understood what they were saying but turned around and said they had the close of the man's lack of good english we would agree with you and that there was there was that report for about four along with the employees report were taken into account and those jobs were available i believe even the employees report indicated cashier and service the labor market surveys a lot of the argument has been made that if the employee actually did hold the job he was offered a job i'm a lawyer and didn't work for five months i believe this should he's in the employees favor he didn't try the job because i'm obsessive these benefits were cut off and he didn't do the work for five months he did have a lot of problems he did have problems taking the boss he did have pain he felt for a while he was walking