stating that it is common sense however the information and how it is presented on a foreign document is not common knowledge thus without stating specific knowledge or points to somewhere on the record the finding of impossibility is not support after he left the ethiopian is understandably mistaken as to when the original birth certificate was issued because he had not seen the original birth certificate or identification card and so he had fled from ethiopia moreover that this is a mistake of trivial and that he then lost that passport when he was twenty one the agency cannot conclude the this affects his credibility well you interview it is important to note that the government failed to give mr levy a credible fear interview and then relies on that mistake to make a finding about herst credibility though i get a lot of what he asked states that the border interviews may be used for an adverse credibility's finding it does book border patrol officer he doesn't say anything about his brother's he didn't mention his brothers being taken by the military missing ever since he didn't mention the brothers arrest from the officer ask about the threats then it is the sound of my application no mention of his brothers when asked have you or your family or close friends or colleagues ever experienced armor mistreatments or our threats in the past now they're saying hey there's a difference here he was asked why he says i i did tell them they said i'd be able to do is this is the border patrol officer they told me i'd be able to say more much a part of what he's got to say here that's not that's not sufficient i mean the brother's arrest is more than a mere omission significant part of the persecution i guess i'm trying to figure out why gives state that is the location of his brothers were unknown and then later explains why he did not and page one hundred and forty of the record explains why he did not include information about his brothers as it was stated by someone of authority that as he described them occurred but you provides no clear affirmative evidence in the record noted by the i j a or the board resent this or of his persecution other than his own testimony and so therefore the board a him even though it was two thousand and seventeen according to the english version of the document there's no explanation given but what happens in that year and mr ali says it's impossible to have been issued in twenty seven because he was in ethiopia in jail then it would have had to get point actually tries to claim persecution based on race no city clearly harmed his family would have been relevant and he was actually asked plays in the border interviews the sceptically have there been any types of threats against you or your family and so in response to that specific widespread human rights violations in ethiopia and i guess i'm trying to figure out why that would be enough for the cat relief i ahead they don't honor and may please the court well we can see that the translation the english translation of mr lee's birth certificate was a consistent his actual original unfriendly to documents were consistent and cooperate mr lee's testimony that is  least six times in the record has demonstrated that he didn't go that he didn't will pass the th grade during his questioning or with his attorney during rebuttal during the questioning with mr seale the trial attorney and his asylum application and at the border here races traumatic experiences from his mind or does not require is not does not remember them right away especially when in a informal order interview as well after having ran away from an