that invested five hundred thousand dollars in the company that company loaned the money  i think we have the land developer who has a great plot of land and he has contracted with various other people to sell them and they say i want this dollar amount how much you get above that is your business and then this person does the when the canvas fossil is not worth the millions dollars to pay for what you value the fact that this person the middleman has you know we don't know what the transit what it was they were originally wasn't under duress had a family emerge and a million two hundred thousand dollars which is more not a current or appraisal a backdated appraisal look at the property at that date it was worth one point two million dollars which is more than was paid for this property so but you can't just say oh that will create u s jobs for u s workers and nowhere and the argument that we just heard was there any focus on crude job creation and u s workers was the entire point behind the program why the program was created twice a path to citizenship  also that they did not show that there be sufficient job creation i think the reason it wasn't focused on in the previous argument is because james you questioned just  create at least ten u s jobs none of that materialized it was that concern that sort of led the agency to giving the project more time when they actually put in our fee they focused on that concern  how look this transaction given that nothing has occurred in three years on this development site are practically nothing we are very concerned about the flipping nature of the land deal transaction and by the way if nothing is occurring out of the united states and it's not always clear that money coming from the united states is legit so that the agency requires restraint tracing of where those monies are coming from and how those monies are actually getting to u s building it's difficult for the agency to credit the methodologies however complex mr doe wants to make them that those workers will actually get those shops and i think and there's usually a lot of paperwork involved that a lot of planning that's presented but we're none of those plans materialize that is it something material change a circumstance that i think that the changing circumstances here was that ok you got a job site and you got and they'll take a look at that and if if those conditions and the symptoms that were built into the plan never actually check out then these people start getting concerned and ask for a new methodology and that independent i suspect that's what  following the other investors in this this is been sort of a rather sordid investment projects but i've been focusing really on just mr doe's i case willing to pay a million dollars to get the green card and most of those people my understanding is don't care if they lose that in a song as the money is goes where it's going to go can involve things are being done things are being built one three million dollars was invested in this case the government did not take that they created this whole number of seven hundred thirty five thousand dollars as far as money expenditures and that's where they came up with their nine jobs created as opposed to ten jobs created again there's no requirement that the actual building be completed or the project be completed exactly working towards that goal and it can jobs will eventually be created and we've met our burden on the thank you thank you