briefs we gave an opportunity to mr chronos attorney to appear by telephone and he has chosen neither to appear in person nor to have here by telephone there was a contact made with his that is there any evidence that he spoke greek there is no evidence they're working this book three and it's a fraudulent passport how's that going to prove that identity well that's true that's true your honor but i think that the judge noted that more so because  demeanor against him well i think if he does make mention briefly that he was left with the sense that given what given the substance of this testimony and the lack of corroboration i think he also he was in fact an electrician given the fact that he said he was constantly harassed in school he went to high school for years right after high school he went to the military and the i g didn't find possible that during this time he became an electrician was like he testified that he went to inconsistent with the testimony because he says the knowledge of the local headquarters was no i wasn't afraid now if you i would have thought that he wanted to make a really good story was that i was terrified from the very first day well he only becomes afraid after they tell him you know we're not going to pay you and he says you know i really would like to be paid i don't want to i don't want to deal with this and then that night he's warned he says by a friend that do better stay somewhere else in a story is that they then went after his dad  case the bat party and they're offered an opportunity to come and work for them in their office that it's possible for him to think that you wouldn't want to do that he did do it and perhaps one reason could be he was afraid that if he didn't do it he'd be hurt he does it look that that is undercut by the fact that when they spell him we're not going to pay you sign this document he stands up to them at that point and says that no i want my money and that's that's the way that i want it it's impossible to stay on one and she wasn't afraid to work there and then on the other end for him to stand up to them and say that there is a there's an underlying current of fear with what he has with the bath party and of course again i point to the record as a death actually that he wasn't afraid he thought he could work at the local headquarters and it's only after he works there that he finds out all this stuff is going on i mean it's possible for a person not to be afraid in certain circumstances and then things change all of a sudden they say well guess what we're not going to pay you and he says i mean and the next thing you know is he's being threatened this is not like such a crazy story of me  again your honor if i make it it's of course the could be alternate conclusions drawn and supported by by the record i guess i should say that is i don't see why that's a crazy story to anybody what i think phony greek passport which is by the way in a different container than his other documents supposedly now i can understand why somebody went on to present phony minutes it's up to the judge to confess retain what the judge would be to to have that claim established in this case given what what was presented to the immigration judge and the fact that the judge did give him a continuance to get further needed additional time to supplement the record the court granted respondents request to set the case over but what i'm after is the i j statement of what i need is evidence of your identity not just additional corroborating  produce it and then he didn't produce it i want to see where he asked please provide me with additional corroborating evidence of your identity because if you did that and there were several months elapsed and he doesn't come my problem is i don't remember having seen the request now i read an awful lot of pages and i read a one page every day and i read quickly and i could have missed it as well and this is not a trick question of i know you're wrong this is i'd like to see it because i might have missed it i'm this of course comes up after the fact the issue with the identity when reading this though had he taken the opportunity as the judge had suggested that he get further cooperation for his claim in general that would have supported his claim but to be clear with the court ye the degree that there was persecution at least by the saddam hussein regime and that's one what if who didn't i j n him and says well you know if it's true i take it as persecution but listen i change country conditions are on the government of course are probably moved to submit additional evidence of change country conditions but my with without it of course without giving you a clear concise answer which is what you want well and i minute to consult we'll take about a two minute recess maybe maybe even a one minute being communicated to the parties and we apologize that you came unnecessarily to court this morning the case was submitted on the briefs and after be franzl patiently we decided to remain submitted on the brakes we apologize for the mix up b