Definition: In this task, a passage will be given and the goal is to generate a question about temporal relations based on that passage. A temporal relation describes the relation between two things with respect to time e.g., something happens/starts/terminates/... immediately/shortly/usually/... before/after/during/... something else.
 Your question should include an event, or ask about an event, and should not be a yes/no question.

Positive Example 1 -
Input: Passage: I submitted the hit. The hit was approved, and then I was paid.
Output: What happened after I submitted the hit?

Positive Example 2 -
Input: Passage: Heavy snow is causing disruption to transport across the UK, with heavy rainfall bringing flooding to the south-west of England. Rescuers searching for a woman trapped in a landslide at her home in Looe, Cornwall, said they had found a body.
Output: What event has started?

Negative Example 1 -
Input: Passage: He will be happy after he attends the party.
Output: Is he happy now?

Negative Example 2 -
Input: Passage: I submitted the hit. The hit was not approved, and then I was not paid.
Output: What did I submit?

Now complete the following example -
Input: Passage: "The fact that Shell is proposing something -- whereas earlier they were keeping silent -- means they are willing to give something up," Gromadin said. "If this actually means a controlling stake, Gazprom should be quite satisfied."
Output: 



Output:
What event has already finished?
What event has begun but has not finished?
What will happen in the future?
What did Shell do after previously keeping silent?
What did Shell do before proposing something?
What is Shell willing to do after keeping silent earlier?