The Sun. — London, England, 1811-11-16 00:00:00

r I i 44 i?iii6.Rfs. COURT e c . . *RENT V. F9oTc4; ARLETT moved for a rule to ithew• cause • 1 ( t criminal inf orma ti on should not be filed aite'3.o,m Robert "F oote, E sq. , o f Char i ton-place, i n of Kent. He said he made the appli 17e' oh the affidavit and an the behalf oflimothy rit Esq. ' of Old Burlington-street, who was 6 to avoid a r e p et i t i on o f t h ose insults from lean which could onlyelovel3een intended lad one conclusion.—Mr. Brent had been' io tit lay before the Covet statement of the lc of his intercourse with the defendant, that Lordships [night see the reason for his present 'anion, and his past forbearance. dELLENSOaOUGH said, 'that Mr., Scarlett had com e to the substantial matter of the com a onc e. SCAnLzTT slid, he could nor reduce it to a it, but it was necessary for him to ,tats a rf of hat was supposed to have given rise InsaAion. , LLBNBuROUGH asked, whether the Rule he was for a libel or for a challenge ? tai.saer replied, for a challenge, and then to observe, thet Mr. Brent stated in his it he had l;nown the defendant from his ant's) infancy, and that he had lived in e greatest intimacy with the defendant's h intitnecy continued till his death So confidence which the late Mr. Foote rent, g hat he put his son," to school at in order that'thei.thight be under the :riot of that Gentleman. IBOROUGH, sold; that if the defendant • occasions violated all the chtrities of.. it was nothing to the purpose of the. 'on, and desired the Counsel to con, 'he substantial matter 'ot fart. r•said he would confine himself to ent as ,possible. Mr. Brent, in his , hai'lie had,, during the minority of whom noted in 'ibe ave. I),.adtanced.considerable sums of own pocket for the defendant's essrble that any money mold be tie from ihet ertate. A part of . teed by Mr. Brent had been laid of a Commission in 'the Army, of white , he now ,enjoyed the !), Mr. Foote promiSed, in the. er to repay when- he came event took pl ice, Mr. Brent mdship to Hee ',tinily, had Hinted texeiter of the, de rig his inieority, under the . ‘at the neceunts investigated hotioUra.ble nutter. - illation to the defendant for Brent) had advanced for r eleority. The suin tut 7001. and at the time the Vo•Ae ; was aatially en iintassion which had been advanced by Mr. Brent. city the t oney, and Mr. • an aClion for the pm-- , thia . attion Mr. Foote . letion was consequently epe Mv. Brent ceased to he defeedant, and en of discCiUrse with him; hie! in various ways, d, that tic believed all I with the intention di el. The affidavit also n meeting Air. Brent his 'stick at, him ; at 8., he put his hand encleetioured to s face'; that he bad in, such a way cOnelpde .that he aeli of the peace; altercation with a net like a parent, s keling , i,and 1101 1. At length, on was Walking up alliing down, in t thti defendant et"cire, to the test B. avoided hint ' his coutse----; . l e plaintiff was' the de dyinanopen fithout going biro; almost iassed him in o gentleme.n !.1 them and iaMe'side of his Com m back one er mistake our in the ed two of tatcd that provoca t added, Tck the 'nett lie endca d, with . defeit elence, proper ? Mr. inest ely dose, I the hole a Ra Mr; of for od 're • .t4iveits the parties, and desired ,that it might be , • I:struck nut. Mr. Scaßtit:r7 salnliat . Mr. Brent knew that isorpe pains would be 'rali'en to ruisrcpresent his eon duet; and was anxious that the whole of it should be before the Court. He 'added that he would alter the affidavit. The COURT deaired him to mention the cace as `soon as the affidavit was altered, and they would grant a rule to slim cause., In the'CoUrt of Common Pleas (Smithy. Se - 0U) Mr. Seajeant Susra BUD moved tor a rule to strew cause why the verdict in this cause for the plaintiff should not be set aside, and a nonsuit entered. The action was tried at the last sittings in London, and the facts were these :—A policy of insurance was Made upon the ship Helena, froth the Bay of Hon. duras to LOridon ; and while she was On her passage tin the high seas, she was' rue fool of by the MA-- garet, and theenestion was, whether the loss•was within the terns of the piliey, by " peril of the sea and • the foice of winds and waves." The Learned Serjeant contended, that, as it appeared that the Helena:w . run, foul of by the gross cul noble negligence of t liosewho had the management of the Margaret, one'of the seamen being found asleep b iard that vessel by sheet ew of thelielena, the loss • was not within the terms of the policy. He ~con - ceived it was the owners of the Margaret who were lwble to an action' for the damage done to the He lena, and hot the underwriter. In aid if his'ergu ment, he quoted the , case Malt bath v. Hodson, in which a ship wds fastened . by n rope to a Mporing post. A press-gang cur the rope, and tl e ship.be ing driven a-shore, WLI3 grqdy damaged. in that case it was held, that as the • loss was caused by the culpable ad of a third . person, , the- underwriter was not liable. Here he submitted that the loss was by positive gioss negligence also on the p:nt'of a third person, and therefore not by peril of the sea. Sir 'JAMES MANSFIELD did not know how this loss was not caused by the peril of the sea; because, Whatever may have been the bad management of those in the Marmaret, it Ar evicktviy, driven by the force oT winds anti waves against the,.Helena. If the negligence cuuid be.provcd to lie so gross tin the part of t!,e Margaret, he thought chat the owners of the Helena 'night tend their name to the underwriters, for the 4larpOse of bringing an apt ion Jgainst,the owners of the 1,11 irpret. If: he should suffer his brother Shell herd to take a'Rule in this case A there would be no _end .to qUestions of the most vexations and nature, amongst the ()tillers of such ships as ships as should hatip,, , n to sail :in, company. Rule reftised. [Far the I emAinder of the Law` Report, sce last PAge) -- _NEW ,SIIEitIFFS, NOMINATRO IN. THIS COURT OIP McctifiquEft ON I'USDAY LAST. Bedfordshire--Robert: Hopkins, of Sunden, Esq ; John Cooper, of Toddiington Esc; ; and Richardof Beiks—Adani "Luton, Esq. . • !'ark:, • - of Esq,;K Kingston Itagpuze, Esq., George El wrs, of March, and Atkii s Mount Atkink, of-Kingston, Esq I " Buelcs—S William ' r 1)0 e r t s - h i iil l i tr;l l. ; !s 9 q r . t a a i r t i d cY C lc hl t i l s i to il i a t t r i t e ' r ; S % a V ft i ut il Stoke Fogis, ESci, Cambridge Huotingdon—lohn Carstairs, of Woodhurst, list; ; George Parker, of Great Stoughton. Esq. ; anti sa. Magi l'epys Cockerefl, of Wooley, Esq. Cheshire —William Thomson Corbett, of Darnbill, Esti. ; Edmund ut Ince, Esq. ; uud efitonnas Wil s on, ut • Eandican Esq. Cuuaberlancl -Thomas Hartley, of Linthwaife, Esq.; Sir Wasted Brisco, of Crofton Place,' Bart. ; Thomas benson, of Wreoy Hall, Esq. Derbyshire —Richard Bateinan, of Bewston, Esq. ; Robert Holden, of • Darley Abbey, Esq. ; and Francis Hurst, of A lderwasley, Esq. , • • Devon James flay, of Col lypriest, .Esq. ; Sir William Poole, of Shute, hart.; and Sir John Rogers, of Blatctitord,' • Deirset--:Pliornas Hurlock Bastard, of Chsrlton Marshall, ; William .Schuyler, of Woodand,.•Esq. ; and 101111 Herbert Browne, of Weymouth, Esq. E sse k .4 0 ber; Wigton . ), of - Waltliiinstoyv, Bart. ; Rich. and Jothilrossey, of Great IlfOrd, Esq. ; and Robert Wil. son, of Woodhouse, Esq. • G loucesterShire —Sir William Hicks, of Whi tconib t'arl., Bart. ; William 'Hunt Prim), of Charlton Kovs, Esti, ; and Daniel tofu Niblett, ut Harestield, Esq. Hprefordshire • Sir Hungerford Hoskins, oil larewood; ; Bart Thomas lay, of ETeintlall, Esq. ; and Richard Adtwright, of Hampton Gouty, Esq. • Hertfordshire-. John Cottle, of Essenden, Esq. ;- lohn.Farin • l'imunns, of Aldenhavn, Esq.; and Nicholas Sedge!: Parry ) , of lladlioni End, Esq. Ketil I John Wells; of 13ieltley, Esq. ; the Hon. John Wing. • - field Stiatford, at Addington-ploce ; and lames Wildhant, of Chilhant Castk, Lsq.." • • „ Lcicestershire—'-. Roden I layites, •of Cleft Olsen, Esq. ; ('olio Clarke, of I;.igna, Esq. ; .and Richard I hestyn, •ot Eattgley, Ist+ . . • LincolrishiN— George Lister, of Glisdy, Erq.; Robert Vyner, of sq.; and Wuliatn Edward I online, of ltiby, Esq. Monmouthshire—Charles Lewis, of St, Pierre, Esq. ; balm . . Hammond Prichard, of. CiWriktUti, Esq ; and Ruben. Junes Kernys, of Nlaloos,,Esq. Trn Norfolk--John uer •Hales, of elardinghom, VA, Tlid. mas French Beraccy, of Hraeoit Aar!, Esq. s ; and sitosinuird ratford:Sonthwell, of 1V toxham, Esq. •• Northamptonshire-Peter Denys, ut Easton Neston, lisq.L George Rush, of karthingitcie,.. Esq:; Beriaft Midfield, of Norton, Esq. , • • Northumberland:— John Carr, of redgelcy, Esq. ; Bertram • Mitford, of Mitford c.astle, Esq.; and Ralph Bates, of Milbourric Hall, Esq. Nottinghamshire —Hugh Blaydes, of Randy Hall, Esq.; John Need, of Shircwood Had, Esq. ; anti lorau Kirk, ut hot foot. lisq, , Oifordshire—rrancis SICK VI te Lloyd tValeate, of Gly pton Varke, Esq. ; %Villiant Wilson, of Nether Wortan , E s q . ; and •Clicnnits a rdy.Coveofry, of.Heoley. • • Stafford Roil:aid —G era rd. Noel Nadi, of, Extol', Esq. ; O'Brien, •of Glaiatutt, Esq. ; ,attil George Flurber, clt A iston, Esq. Shropshire—William Owen, of ‘Voodhouse, Esq. ; Sir Corbet Corbet, of Adtlerley Halt, Bart. ; and Richard. .Lister, of Rowt•ollt t , r(1. • "' • Sontersetshire— form Hubert . Hunt; or e,ortipton r aincee. fort, Esq. ; of •lonkrutt Combe, Esq; and Francis Edwards W hafeley, of Winseorn, Esq. Stattbrdshire— WAN: . Sneyd, of Keel, Esq ; 10110 Fenton, Boughey, of Amialite, Esq ; and Thomas m o iler,Jll,w, o f Silkatore House, Esq. s oau thampfon, CountyGeor Thotrras of Thisletlawoi tEsq. ei o ; f S o uthwick, Esq.; ge Eyre, Branishaw, and Peicevol Lewis, et I.4Mtilgtult, Esq. • Sulii}lk--Kichatti Moore., of Alelford, Esq. ; George Wen yeve, et n m rettenha, ; and Sic Geary Cul• of ` Bury St. Edmund's; Bart. Surrey-Thomas Starit Be.oslii, of Champion Lodge, Est; ; Henry Bridg:s, or Ewell, Esq .; and pints Laing, of Streatham, Esq. . Sussex —George Francis Tyson, of Singleton, Vsq. ; - peckham Phipps, of Compton, Esq ; Ono Edward Nap. • .• per, oft ford, -Esq.. V.irorwiekshirts—Charles Gregory Wade, of Warwiek, Esq , William Moody, of Beaudeserr, Esq, ; and Samuel ?each of!lellicote, Esq. . • • Wilts—Sir Win Pierce Ashy A'Court, of Heyiesbury, haft. ; Wm. Fowls, of Chute, Esq. iIAKI Wm. WymPnonf cit Vinton, Esq. Worcestershire— John Bilker, of Wastley, Mg: Henry Guest, of liortl e sley Fork, Esti. ; and Richard Holism), of Wick:Esq. , • Yorkshire —.George Oshaldeston, of Hutton Bukhell, Esq- ; Sir Francis Ltrultey Wood, of Hemsworth. Hart. ; -and Sir Thomas at Scriven Palk, Batt, • • ENGAGE,IIENT OFF MADAIG4SCIR: {EXTRACT OF A LETTER.) His Majesty's Ship Astiea, Port Louisdone it, iSti. I have the pleasure to inform you of Our ar rival here, with two French frigates in our poSses sleet, after 'an action which was' foeght on the 20th of May, in which the iistrea lime a conside'r 'able share', thodgh *nit less hats than our other ships. We, were lying by ourselves, quietly moor-' edin Post Louis e About' the Oth of May, struen the 'signal was made from the, heights for three French frigates. All the rest of our ships were cruise. ing in different_ directions : knit we itnmediately warped out, both wind and tide against us, and gut. clear of the laid that evening; but 'it fetl‘ 'during the night, and continued ao for two days after which me fell in with out frigates, the Phzebe and (.14ilateai who ieforeted rag they had - seen the enemy the evening before, but had not ventured to attack them, their force ,being too' superior, each frigate having as many soldiers on board as' they could stow ; and Captain _Los/tee, of the Galatea, informed us he saw the enemy bear up that evening, about two biters before. _ We set every stitch in. search of them. After running fi,r three bouts, at the rate of ten knots, without seeing any thing of them, we • coruluded Captain I t osecte must have been deeeived; and, aceordiogly, we hauled our wirni e end beat up again to the isle ot France, where we oo4tinued cruizing till the isth, in Imes they would return,. : not thinking they had• intelligence of the Island being in our 'poelession. On the 15th, however, we deterrnined to explore the , coast of Madagascar, knowing the enemy were in .gr'eat want of water, &c.; and 'lonia-, t tve .•being ' the nearest place, we made all' possible sail for it, with 'the followieg squadron (we being Commodore), Astrea, P/4wbe, Galatea' , Had Racehorse (brig). On the night of the h, being °lithe coast e we distinguished several lights, which raised our hopes, they before being very languid ; and at daylight, on the morning of the 20th, to our great satisTaaion; we saw the three frigates a long way to windward (FOul Point being in sightl. ?ou may well suppose With what eagerness we clearW our ship for anion i in ten . minutes, nothing was to be seen fore and aft,. but the guns, spurges, Sec.—el - tot of every description,--the men all stripped, and glowing with impatience for the attack ; and only regretting the time we must be in catching the enemy. We began along chase: how often did we wish the Racehorse away, as she gave us a superiority of forc6 ! Thotteh we sailed mucn.better than the French trig ites, the c hase continued for ten hours. My quarters are on the.foreeastfe, where I haVe the coramatttle and I have as fine a set of tellowS , ntidei me as I en'' wish. Another tnidshipman and the n ea t s ,,v,,in were therePlio.• Every time our ships crooted each other' in tacking,' we gave each other three cheers. In the afternoon we - ?hed very_ heavy rain; • which annoyed us. ex trernely;., and at length, a quarter before lour, there being very little wind, the "Ivrea being the headeiost shiteof our squadron, the ene my crossing is on the other, tack, the middle ship 'ot their line opened her broadside upon US, which was immediately 'seconded by: the • sternmost, for whomesre had reservedeeat fire, she beiege he largest, ' and also as we should fetetrrearer to her ; and this put us in eorne confusion, as we Made certain weshould' be the aggressor 4. We, however, soon returned it on the sternmost (the black ship, she being painted so); and the Ace& and iietatea coming up, be gan upon the ships that had .passed ots. The Met shot that struck' us: took; a marine. 4 thigh off at my (platters ; it was the only. part of the ship . where the men etuffeied, for two were killed • • there, and six or seven wounded; and we had only those two killed, and twelve or fourteen wounded, altogether. The wind '.continually decreasingettter we had 'eassed them, .we could not tack : rhis,was not for lorig. We got our head refund, and re-com— menced on the black strip : the Racehorse was entire ly out of it. Our .frieeds had each his opponent; • mid many men, who .have been :talon several times, say, they never saw a point better coitrested, or Oki fly Much thicker; an 'ueluelty shot came into the forecastle, completely 'diSabled one of the guns, killed two •mett, and wounded five. Atter battering an theni 'for some time, weeieain , fell oft', and - lay' useless ; at whientime the Phatte and Ga. latea were greatly damagbd, it being is dead 'calm and having the' whole . three upon them', end the. Galatea could not get re single gun io bear but across t he d)ows -of our old antagonist,' the black ship, :led raked her effeauelly. . She ',clould only'fire,a few guns now and then ; - till a breeze springing uti, the enetny hauled of and the Galatea havieg made the. signal that she was in want of immediate assistance, we were obliged to stayrby her. Finding 'she - ee l s not able to renew 'the .attack, we and the :Phoete made sail • as as our shattered condition wneld admit of; and, on coming near I hem, perceived' • one bed parted eon - litany we alum!, Attei wards. she bad - hailed .her Commodore to say, that she Was 'not able to stand above' twee or three ' snore broadsides, and was acct'rd'ng ordered to ,keep out , of the way. Her name r; La Aereide. At ten at. night, - we ranged np alongside:the French Commoe dote (La Renonifne); and gave her a broadside, which those who heard it will not easily forget ; we Were close is her as easily to heate'the cries of the wounded. nowt:tier, that was WWI drowned in a noise rather more powerful. She inintediMely edged down to board us ; but this we tntik good -cart to prevent, she "raving too many soldiers onboard.---- A very awful scene now cotnineneed. Conceive a very dash, dismal night, which was.onlyintertipt ed by the and noise of the four blip(( batter:. Mg one another ; for the Mete, about ten minutes after we had begun, came up under her stele; (nal town% raked ~her; pasied between . the etteroy'e ships ; ;the fiac,:horse being tinder our lee; 'was trot of the smallest use. • Atter a very gallant resi4t anee, of :.(sour an hoer ; sire struck to us; and the Clarinet(: (the third ship) shortly attar did the same, We immediately t,ent rx boat- to take pcsseasion ot the: fit st, and having 'no what 'that could swim; the. Clorinde teak 'advantage, and made all sail away trout us : we immedtately pur sued her, and had air anxious chase of three hours; but finding we could not come up, our rigging, .13re. being too much disabled to make sufficient San, we were, with the' greatest regret, ,obliged to 'give up all hbp-es,,of punishing her for her perfidy. Having • knotted and spliced some of our lig " ging as wele , as we could, we returned to find the prize; and at t've the prize, t'vbe bore down to ; and the dalatea and Nereide to windward also; hut they did not. seeth inclined to .annoy each other. ,On cotninunicat; "ing:Wl l tli La iteholitmle, we found she had nearly an `,buffeted kitied and wounded; amongst them ttie Commodore ; he had been weiThded before, Ar i d would not quit his quarteis,Wheb a oeedthl bleat 'com pleted his business. Our Lielltetiinissaya, he never witnessed such a scene es on first going - on hoard her : the decki vere3 strewed with dead. La Ne.. reide suffered Mote she had an hundred and thirty hillfid and wounded; her Captaio also was killed, (if • La aorindit loss Icon it ay not hing,tint believe b wai 'not rleSr so great a; the other. They had all SW' rn to go to thel-Ottoin rather than strike : this i; French bolinii:g. They certainly behaved to :ration 5 and it is a consolation to think we t.ad enenty*wort by of uS. It is Most WonnerN 1 6 thinir„ that, train the first begritniog, to the end, Which was.SeVen boors, during which time we renewed t, ,o attack four times, we had only two nt-ti 'killed, and ' 14 or 15 wounded, entirely owing to their elettating their gong too much, , arid our taking great painti in 'rnit •artivring our sails. I counted, next morning, nearly 100 shot-holes through our fore*ail ; the. you k 'ow, most have 'passed pretty close over my head.: we had not a running 'rope left whole; and only ta . o' shrouds that were not 'shot away ; w e had fi%e'unionjacks Augpentkd in d4feri-ot [daces, which were' all kn'ocked down.' The Phoebe lost more tharo.ite ; she had about 24 killed arid wound. ed one. midshipman vitas killed ,on board of her The Gamated,''n4.l j said before, had nothing to de with the night-fight ; she lost her. top-masts be fbre dark, and slkieett killed and forty-five wounded. My quarters was on tire several times, but was poi ofit before it h:td time to do much d image. Their :shot were in. excellent direction, none passing either a-head or :fifth], only a few feet too high. 1• did not recover my hearing for a Veek alter. Same of our men Aerre completely deaf the next day. The Re:. :notamtle fired that day between 2 and 3000 large car tridges. .Throughout the whole atfits our men be havt.d with the greatest cookies's. The two folkw jug . days,we were employed in seenrin , , , the prisoners, and' pntting'our rigging in order, to gti in quest of the other snips. The prize and Galatea act off : , hit the Isle of Franco, Wo- having ao Many, priion-, ers 'on board, and-, having sent' some of 'our men ' in the prize, found it necessary o 'keep. taur men constantly armed'; the itettot, purser, Sec. ' . 'Werd obliged' to keep watch in like Manner: As we - were expeatition Of lolling -in *Hi t her titlieihips, our quarters'we're kkpt 'constant ly clear, and we were et. ry moment expetting anotlfer fight. On Abe Saturday following, llaCehOnt beingja4ore, onade,sjgoid that the ./Ve. reide was lyinq in l'atn itave, with her :opmilst4 xp. As it is one' of the airs( dan,,,,eriins to she, orld, " was - init!er pit.) it,',.1 . 10t1 01 3 . battely, and moored, rig'it a:toss the' valance, 'and had no pilot, on hoUd, in a rs lioat with a Itig Of truce, to summi4,them to swl:n(l,r : this they agreed to do", on condition they f;bould nut be tie‘ited as prisoners of stn:Lild be sent to ranee; with this we %teal obliged to cL u iiply, • t. 8$ they i• have ra ked us at ple,isare coming iu ;, and we well kneW theconsequ,:nces, had We tiolucki ly got on shuse on the dangerott,re ; we a:So knew that they were determinal, after all, to blow the ship ,up;:as theyhadtrains'laid f put or that pt,se. 'day moranig, 'the day week a!ter the action, having procured a oilot, we anebered, arid took possession of the Nereide. Ne'Ver was a snip much more cut Op her'sideS ar e completely born , ', aid her masts and rigi;ing cut 'to pieces, 50 that we were Obliged to'. jury-rig her. The Ff ench [pen belonging td 'her we ficpt to the Isle of trance in' t a ,i o u 6 6 1 4 ' we pressed, for that purpose. We immediately sent half our tnePtio put her in order to procael to, the Tide Of Frelke. This took us a week ; after, t w h l i f s ic p h ilee. itic r .d 9 s f a fre l a t the; phu_es I have sera its clay tea• Tanfatave . is the worst I never had dot thread on my bads.' POLICE. , Gummi' ALL.—;.Yesterday, Pilei. 117'Clinh and Michael Ill'eavart, two If ish porters; in the-etit:. ploytnent of Messrs. Allan and Pell, wholesale 'drug. zista 'and drysalters, in Aldersgate-streei, were broughi up-on a charge of, stealing a rinaistity of nut. meg*and essential oil of peppermint, in. the dwel ling-house of their employers. • The Prisoners had been for same tithe suspe6.l...ti or ilistionot praeliOeli and in conseritiethie of a pri vate intimation by letter received by MessiS., and Pell, me: siires were tat;en to dete&thern: morning a drawer, into which a certain rpiantity 1)1 nutmegs had been put (yet . 'night, being 14,4 .accu !lst i"ly weighed, about thre , ..-quartrs of at pound • w e re missed, shortly alter LIKI, prtionera cone to work, and before any 'customer kid on into. the warehouse: . Cirtwright ,and teadbeater, two of the d e pu t y Marshaline:n, having been sent for.--ott searching the prisoners, found nutotegs concealed about b-t o; .but patticularly one had his pockets, filled with th e m ; and nif9n switching the lodgings Of the other,' ahn t it two Rounds were found cut ealed ; And, in a bottle, ,about, a pound of essential oil of peppet,nitti worth , In their defence; one Of the prisoners !edged that he had taken the few ntitmogit (r.-4r pounJ) found about him, for his own use • and the other said; that. he had. taken the few (tWo potind9 found at his lodghigs, lot 'the use of his wile, who was preparing to l►e in and, of course, both pros tested this was the first think of the kind that either , of them had ever co►emitted. Mr. Pell declared he had ritts6n to suspect that both the prisoners had been robbing him to an in. calculable amount, for the last three months at least. The prisonera were both fully cocinnitted for trial, BOW-STREUTo—rA journeyrnsin Blacksilmith has; ‘Vithin these few days, undergone an examination, charged with an attempt to commit a tape on at, in. Pant, only eleven years of age. The charge being sufficiently substantiated, he ',vas order to' ti' d buil to answer the chart* at the ensuing Scssious. k