The Sun. — London, England, 1814-11-18 00:00:00

NIP 1; PA itiAASI ENT . fIONE OF COMSfONS. tnursnAv, Nov. 17. pres.erted a . ietititm of twelve txtra Deg PilGts of Ship; of tear. I.irayitig, as A reward for their long. serviteS, to he pnt (S tai- Janie toot - hi: with respect to emo- Ininents as the regular Pilots. Ordered to lie on the table. The Nl3rilie Pension Rill was read a Third thut`, anal passed. The tin- (),irhafittee);•oa theYrich Tituber.frtaw ba.eV India Good`i; - \Vete reMveli ana ligreiti to. 'and Bills ordered to he beanglit in at eordingly. Seri eant iietceivia.z an tifilionritbie City Mem ber in h' .lace, retittesy!.cllo he intornleil ivilether it *as his intention to bring fort9tclnie mea.stirc of which he had given hake at the clue • of' last' ‘zesion, respeetibg a ilea . mode of teplatilk Br.6d ? Alderman .sits nOt av are. that he had ,giyen.trotic.e vordnrel,ntlar p 1 iis of the snbjectin questiun ; as he felt the necessity of snme ne.*regniations, heshotild Its diSpOsed to recommund the aaoption of some Measure of the na.tttre ..11.thled to. • rttopuidty 71" X -rt. Mi...:WIHTBREM) presented a Petition frorri tile Prop - rie, tots of the ilktadingg of the •Anction.- Mart, complaitt . ing. of friV,iog,been, forced to pay, ~ hy, the Commissioners of the ,Pro pel.t)"Va;: a'larger :mil "than their income justified. TheV had applied to the - I.ot:fs of the'creastir for redress, hnt itaa faiiiht of 0 . 14;0441..4, and therefore threw themselves on the justice of the House. , • The Petition, which stated the particulars of the case, bath* been read,. . ..• WitrrsaitAh Said, that he should only nfliVr that the petition he allowed tO lie on the table. l c should, sit the sonic time, make ano. thif 'cltort - to induce the Chancellor of the Ex theAner to express his decisive opinion on the time when the Property Tax, that sintree of so many hardships and abtse - s,'shonlil exi,iire. 'Whe ther it to or naturally . to cease, on the 25th of April Ai to birnscif, he eon ecired that iiiithing - emild be clearer than the ex pitatitin of 0421'1'0p1 - v 61 'nix at the time Which he - rn bad entionetli' And 'hi hoped itti it in - rh • tVotild he wholly of in an d he trus ted that without any suCh, the Crown ‘vould no t dare tO levy this Ti aftcr the '2sth of April next. • The .11..6t, was bOund to keep its. word, and not to disappoint the expectation of the Public. • 'The CtiAtic.F.t.t.iir. of the Excnr.'nutH: had no objection to allOw the petition CO lie on the to the arguments irsoil by the lion. Gentleman reSpecting the Property Tak, they would not pre vent him f-..oin the' excention of What lie thought right. lie shinild' no mitre shrink from his duty, it he should conceive it to be such, in proposing to continue the whole, or a portion, of the Pro perty Tax, than he was convinea the people of this couture xvoidd, from cheerfully bearing its weiOtt a little it its necessity Were rw.ltle apparent. As to natural termination, he would not hesitate to spy, that Eke :11l other war ta):es, it wait tl'f' pt c at on the 25th, h!it on the !ith of APritiiif;tt,u'utes'sit shoo ld be rene‘‘e:d()•r continued bs , .theanthor . ity r'artittnent. was nov,- icAed tipon 'to de chre at once the Whole try w i t ut o f la'iticome. It might - be tlerived . from tk'vt . nitv dif fe'ri6nt soni•ces, timid the charge would be made :old rettnved on each of 1.11c. , ,e ap rt, without reveal iikltfii'sccret tbe whole• When it kt . `: prO‘ (11 4"eire'netti was three tiriVe:s gtiatvi . treatWl'6- I'ol'6l tiim it h bee'n.siYo• t ee r l i rtfiNt , s ' - 't; (I . lAil , lelrsoriVe. 'll6- • Iroule pre'cented the pentitin to the niPailit t eftilirastiry, Ise ti I. recollect el i s I'mit of tilt .1. 4 - atti4"Wf tl4•Tri'asurk sded Fait:ol;lPM th'e Chttm:ssionk:rs4 ?in. :Taxes eat truth t,:cm, not I,ing appointed by`ili*er4iii - li. Mr. BArtiG. Ctiii , ldered the ('Ol the jictt tioners as one of extreine hardOrp. • 'Mr. g't'F. RlsT bad honed, - that Before he sat down, the Itikht lion. Gentlenlan . (the Chancel lor of the Exchequer) would have 'expk . iined the grounds on whie•h- he intimated that it was pos sible the- Vroperty Tg . x ,should.enntinue. - The Petition was then mdcited to lie on the table. . . in answer to a question from Mr. TIERNr7, TheC7lANcht.r.o3 of the EACH . F.CIU.I:II stated,. tliat lie intended ti . )-i»orriliv to enter into soate details respecting otir ssibt:idi,try Tr-eaties: COURT-MARTIAL ON COLONEL cr'ENTIN. Colonel PALMLR, when he ti, t introduced the, stthivet of slit Court-Mall lid held on Col.Queutin, ilito the Ifunse, W. 1., not in possession of a copy of•its procet—iinLts. Ile had note procured one, and should 'beg leavc to read the particular passage to which he had then as the chief ground of lii prc, , cnt motion. Thu lionourable Mtmber then real the I:ajowing . exiract from the opinion expressed by the Court-Martial at the close of its 8-entence " court; however, cannot condi:de these proceedings tvithunt expressing their regret, that there appears to / Wyo. existed inch a want of eo-operatiu:, ainong the. o:iie , ;:es Athe Itvgiment, as to render ditties of the . Coamanding Citiicer much more arduous thou they oth , ..rwi3e would have tieel,,," , . 'lle hekized leave to state, that this,Opii;, vrloich • such an imputation on the Othci!rz. ot the retiiment, was not founded in fact. ',ls Cx . presiOonwas fairtlciiiarly'llard; it . hailbeen t he . groundon which a severe censure, and 'punish ment had been passed on those Officers. He had inteißted to put entering into any, details until the minntes- of the-trial should be he lore the House ; but, in order to substantiate the necessity in whicit he found biinself-to. bring :for- ' ward this motion, he should- go into the whole_ merit of the case. He sitotddl, on this occasion,. ! l ave felt happy had he not possessed a: . Seat in that House, because lie woidd, diet' haVe . ..put the sub- Wet into the' 'hands Ot another talents. gut kohltng, as he did, a seat in Paidianicitt, and Connected, as he was, with the trial 'itself, h e (1 1 /night, that hail the motion been hi'on - lit forward hy another, it Might have been cOnce:yed that it was ‘e . itliout either 1);Ition or Ids concurrence. Hp, therefore, took noon liiMself a task, 'to the pioper execution of s%:flich he feared hk abilities were u al; Ina the House would excuse him, and 'he I,cm o ur' lain with their It;►itetice: Ire should rea'd the tiefieral Order %which aeo on- pitied the Setitcnee of the Court-l'iliirtral, and cOnov cot on t le chArges . th u iii Uivir di i•: lit iiit'iCsterlibe: Hon.' Gentleman' ~„ Oiiposite - 01 r. Manners Sutton, the 'Jtidge Ad vocate). to favour him with his tit; elltioll, '2l ' S Cie S idered him, though how far lie was i i sht in so doing he knen, - out, as responsible to a certain stkittit fol• At intlttt - ot 'tlfe "Aill4nee 41iiell .11 , 1 I been pasted. The I.lon. Member then again ;Tn. logistsd t tol - 14+se c , .)r-. tlre : p6rk.i<nt of theif time be shot Id - otottplii,:itird,t)igli lii.lifvf(ld einietvoin• to roitfine ! „iisqf wilthiti the ita - trowe,A !Ann n uls pos.-, t sil)I. ~, i l i e {Alen Vead thejirst Charge against Goti;ne qietitin, with tilt. sentence of the Conrt ..lgaqi.ll, tqu'itk.ll.l.4l .(,-;l),Argy 'i, the evidence produ ced in its stippoit s extracts: from. the Colonel'!: defence, and his own r'eplV, which have -already been nilihli'sliti in °tit Yap:2l-.1-11e wished- tO have laid the evidence httfore the lintiSt, which ; vould have spared it the trouble of now follow ! ng him throegli . its particulars, bet be had nest informed, by persons 'of greater experif ertee, 414 . 4 C it was necessary, and he appi'aled to the HOuse whether it was mit, that he shOuld reetipitttlate the evidence and the chargeS,. in order to make a sefficient :;round for his motion: Ile then read a letter written to Colonel Quentin, from Matoy; by the direction of . Lord Edward Siniterset, in which his Lordship referred Colonel Quentin to the General Orders respecting the pre cautions' to be taken for the - protqtion of foragers. lie coesidered melee letter as in itself passing. severe censure on the conduct of the person to whom it 6 as addressed'. But Colonel Quentin stated Ott the trial that he had no recollection of such a lettktr. 'ibis forgetielnessappeated to him to be tire result-of tot-al hotensibility ; or else Col. Quentin had been so long in the habit of receiving sushi letters, that this had puodueed no 6ptession upon him, and• had not seemed to him worth a seat in his nientorye The Hon. Member then read the 'Second Charge against Colonel Qeentie ; the sentence of-the Court t ha t he- wes scot geiltv, part of the Colones defence, and his own reply to it. Ile was really sorry to be under the ne cessity of urgings a syllable agehisi Col. - Quentin. In the part which he hadtaken in the Coutt Mar , tiah, he-had done his ditty, and no more, and it wt a ss only on account of the severe censure andpusishe. uncut passed on • the Officers who supported the charges, that he thottut it necessary to su.V irtnVe,;: 1 thingfurther on the subject. "I':.ev had only e ished, . - ' as tv, 11 as he. for ail mollify w hickseouin relieve, their own characters flout the bianse cast stem) them. ' That was all which they ori g inally want ed ; hut they had ',heels ~mutt compelled to bring forward charge's. The Hon. Gentleman then pro- . reeded to read p trtof his openieg speech to th e Churt Martial, iii which -he dee.lared that the pro secutors were not impelled by any unwor beemo tive, but solely by the wish of doieg justice to . th e ir e' lierecters, and called elite; Colemel Que;!- tin -to- do the sante it ' it was- in his power. He lead thus challeeged that Odieer to produce in stances of '• his good conduct, but he had not , availed himself of this opportunity. Hari he (Co lope! Palmer) ne , :‘ll more severely disposed against' hisrl,, he could h,ve brought !wally other instances in which he ,-ad displayed the same inattention and it-ca ren:ay as in the previouseharges. He did not wish to interfere with the sent e nce ef the Court. He had nothing to do with the acquittal' Of Col. Quentin. T,se Cturt had a right to form 'en iiitiiition,nf. their own ; lest ,he Wished to vindi cate the Officers from the charge of having with holdee tbeie e6-Operation irons their Commander. 'i e !lon..Nit:tuner then read Lii..--lthClidtg e again - ColinCei ,Cloetitin, the sentence of the Court, and his rePle to the Colonel's (left:nee. lie 'afterwsirds Proceeded .to read Inch ptnts of, the. teiilence aS tended to exculpate the Officers from all •blatne-: Amongst ii . i, wcr'‘! the Cavalry'Orders:tif the '26th of FehrisaiT, I SI4, and the letter dame! the !Kith March, 113, sent by the Adjutant-Geiteral 'to Lord Ldward 60111erser, lie lipalogiti 4 fid for reading the whide of. Lord Conthertnere.'s evi denccee -but it was of it l portance, as. it stuted, that belote r the';iyiived of coltmel Quentin he had licvei• seen ii betiercorps 'of Offic;,rs, and attributed the alteration Which had afterwards taken [Aim!, not to 'in fault - of 'Ofl iheicers, - but of 'the Ctnnettander. . I lelhen w cut throoglea coticierablepert of Lord . E. E.'omersee's evidence, and that of Colonel Gerd ner, who badealso stated ee that he considered the discipline of the :oth fluSsars exemplary previous to e Golonei Quentin's arrival. and had remarked-a 'considerable difference consequently. .--Brigade Makirlones, who liachbeen attached to the brigade_ both before and after Colosiel'Quentin had joined, had given testimony to the same effect. On Isis t r i a l colonel - Quentifs had not produced a - tittle of evidence to relate all this. lie had heft: to -re mark, that the Serjeent Major of the regiment, and a l so th e Quarter Master, would have been some of his principal Witnesses, but when lie saw them after they had--hail ateinterView with Col. - Quentie, he found that' he could 10 - tenger depend. on their evideiiev. The Only defenee - Ivhieh . the Cohniel,had produced was a reference 'to varioem Regimental Oterers inserted On the Orderly Book of the ileginietsf. One of these e :dated Aug.,l 3, . 1814, related to the state of the arms.- With re sp e ct to these, it might be conceived impossible Oat theyshOuld Ineve iieetsiSSifted,Atbont, a - cause, This, liowever, was the fact,: anti fie''.Veaos sistre: ,that he had not explained that at ehe'time on the f rial : bat Colonel Qilentih's defence bad been so long, that it had not beenin his power to notice every point. These arms (carbine.' s) . bad long sincebeele fonhd:useless , toid, on eVn . ting horne. had . been reporteXat head-quarters as totally -miser v iceable. ,When the regiment had: gone 'abroad, be (Col. Pt.itu r . ) had applied to hiS Royal Highness the Duke of. York. and obtained new arms, and, mail their 'arrival, tile former could be of iio use. 'file' order Was • theefore , ridiculous and unfOunded, and iSsuedat a time - Mien the men were idlowed to appear drunk, even on parade, and mold- not be made to attend to any •thin;;. Another order directed the Qtriceis,to visit the squadrons twit:ea day, , aitd examine their arms, &c. There was no foansdation for such an order; : it . 60(11(1 not be exe elites!, in the Manner in which the regiment was scattered, when Ou service abroad. It was not the same Thing at home. All that ' ee ele- b e d one , would have been fo tell the Commanding thlicers to soiketbe Captains responsible for their troops, and the S'elialterns for the privates, and to report every offence. The same order also directed that they should be visited Whilst they mouuted guard; and all this, at. the very time 'a hen the want of discipline in the regiment was so great that the men svffe in the bahit of breaking into, and rid - thing' houses, without being punished.' Or ders of this kind he repeated, were ridiculous. It was impossible to go at 'ten o'clock at _night to t l / 2 'll;t3d talita'istA blight t' ...tite - e been, s; !left') to have wetedein their eivist wei'v. Ile then otle: red 4:apt-Ai\ 44,4t.15'etr!" , 411.4y, pear ~ t 1 hii Nto Bqtypoita 0e optirt in .'seiv.eV!il 11eel an'ees-, portishment oteieL, Prettr4- cut to have been' issued for the N ' vs:TU.C - re atalis-* or 'thee Men, appeared velien Iron /0 of , thent were in tiie hospital a't a thee. 11`t ell the reehnent had htietled at hishon, and their AV.._ Oval in a plate where tisey might procure wine cheap, was t ertainly at period in whieh :they were most like!y to 'commit e,xtt:,sses itt and ;nem- illness, thee did not average more that) six or seven .sick. Under Cohsmel Quentin, forty, fifty', sixty, eighty were in the hospital, and that chiefly tht.ough dieeascs brooght on by in toxicatione The lime - Melt - titer then read someS other parts of the evidence, in which further cases of olrenee were stated to have been suffered to go ou unpunished, even whet' men mede away With their toekings and apparel. When they were permitted to sell ei'eu neeessaries„ then every one mast allow that all discipline WAS at an end. An other order, issued by Colonel Qtlentin, directed the Officers to see that the mi n 's dinners were re gular,..aod their persotts clean. _This was impos sible in their state of intliseiplioe, and the order perfectly useless. Colonel Quentio's defence attempted to.prove 14 +lint:roils instances of want of. sco-operation on the part of the Officers, and. iii a particular :case, that he (Colonel Palmer) ltad suffered him to rentaio ignorant of a medical report xvitieh haul been trausmitted to Lord G. Somerset. On the contrary, Colonel Quintin was Very glad to hush this matter tip. — He told the Captains that Mr. Morrison, the Sur geon, had produced a report against them, but he found, they were right, •and he was glad, lie repeated, to hush it tip. But for a conversation which he (Colonel Palttier) had had with a person in a certain cenirter, whom it was not netts:7;ary to- name, be had not included Colonel Queut-in's eonduer to Mr..notrison in the charges, oritei.- wise lie was convinced that he must have been broken'lrefore any Coins-A:kr - 6d. As to any blaine attaclOng to hint (Colonel Painter) in this IniSittess, the. fact visas; that in consetplettee, he - snpposed, of the iublic Artinkenness and wk,tot of disselphire and nea th of rite Melee au order cattle to fir. Morrison t. 7) reptnt the medical state of the regiment. Col: Quentin was then alts - ittit, as it frreptently happened to hint, for it day or- t wo.— Mr. Al orri-son came to hint (Colonel Painter) to itit hire seeliat --he should - do. Ile replica, that be could not take upon himself todeeide, but referred hint to Lord I:di - Yard SomerSet. beytind this; he' had nothing to do with the suiject. He regret- Jed lie slionldt have neett coral ellett to tees'lntSs al ready so iong on the tittle of _the House. He.had C u,ied upon Colonel Quin in no prove any want of nttention nod co-opryarion on his part. fte -- had done every thing in his ptevver to support him , on 'evdrysoetaticn wnich Cee screire reltsired, for' he was too well aegiednted with his chity to his rteLfirrneitt4i4t. to neglect it. On his pert, Cbienel Quentin, though he isf,new better than, to ofer him a 'personal insult, hail. tiendered his situation sa uepleasant in the regiment, that he hut tried to tic plaved on the Staff, g.'et' - ota. 'of bus way. 'rho then ie>ut another _regiment 41 order about- -the- ----inumber of shirts (four) which the men Were to have. This.wits-ns tiseless and unfomtded as..:tivermegt, and he reaily believed that whenever Col. („)mentio reeeiyed it reprintand himself ; Jib! issned Snell dos.: - ettntents., and inserted them in the'ordcrlybot4e, merely to blind and Colonel, itl WhiK, he feared, he'had succeeded. The flone•Colottel continued for some time to. refer .to the ditrerent iegitntiffti4l:' orders. tt+ltivo to the 100. while the regiment was on the French frontier; and the general infereoces he drew from the con duct of ColonA Quentin towards dies:446l e were, t h at lee abstained front severity, tvhi're - , it - had been merited, and only held ont threats,. such as that ofssendii!g theca to hivoietc, ,on the casion of the order of the 26th of February. By such means' die sought for populerity from the men at the expeece of the Meets, and.uirtitiug was more likely to obtain it, than censitring pu nishment, and on some occasions even preventing the - infliction of what had been deereed e The• titan whom he ordered to be taken down when he had received-)4)1y. halt' his nmnber cif lashes, said, ``• Thank Vot,t; Colonel, you are a Gentlentan-± the regin;elit is a . gOiid regitnent ; but I ant in a bad troop."-:'He wished not to lay any Particular stress on this observatilin ; the malt might have been itemik, - or a fool ; Or'at any vete his escape from ptiniSbneent - ivas alone sufficient to make hint thankful. But 'theeircumstauce went tri show the means the• Colonel 'took to acquire pOyttlarity,.. As to his - retnissiOn of the punishments of the inert, it was, intle&l, his invariable . pritet ice. This, he would-tot - item% was of itself sufficient to ripe - rate against.the inaititenanee of good order and dis cipline: If the men were convicted of Miscon duct, and siMtencedstopunishment, they ought to receive it, and if was -the duty of tire Officers. to de it .intlieted: The misfortune of such conduct istieictol of keeping up the discipline of,the. regiment, it Only tended to increase the irregularities, so that when the regiment was., marched -up thee-eontat y„ the punishinent,.of ne , e setssity;beetune mare general. The Hon. Colonel' mentioned. another iustance in point, Which was. the ease of 'Abbott - , Who, when convieted,: and hrought before the Commander for 'punisher:Pore: was pardoneti.by hiet, alt 'toughie had been proved„ that this. matt behaved in such a'i Outrageous and die . g - r - ae - erill planner, that it was ahs'oltitelv neces sary to ; bring hint to a Court Martial. Alluding 7 to the letter of the Prince Regent, he noticed the remark, that certain Officers had affixed their. tointes.t6 the: letter that had led to the Court-, Martial,,Whos had not been with tlie regiment at the time the complaints arose, and edding, that it appeared he Othet..A hail till co-opeeated in a com pact against their superior Officer. On this topic the Honourable Colonel said, ,that he only . !visited to ask, if the privates of a regiment, bare any just einnplaints to make against their °dicers, they are allowed to preter them, why should not. the Officers hive ' the same right to Indust.; comPhtiots etgainst COMmitnder ; ?— Thustir's, however, accused of coming forward in a holy. How else were they to come forward? or what manner could have been more proper than If, .' • r iTtit Vt - lia they ackopied Vl,ltit r e ° ic.s ....'i o il l i l t ,iiitt, 411 self, he qssared the Ilotlae, tha t '''''' 0 4 4 w'oild shottld haVe induced hint t" c `! .. l , e c ati" l h t k!ltgAilit Colonel Quentin., lint a diel', ,:, 'lli. - 1 the hotrour and character Of the reg li ,,' C)',• t i, l did 'licit Speak of the conduct of C" 1 "' I ; r e!'-' t :;, '!() ally Officel - in tht totinti-v ckeePr ,'(-„,(10-4 to the affairs ' ! the ' . '' t fie 1 4 " ) 1' ( 4.- 1.- styli obliged to (il t;ott: . T.: g o li t i • i d ti C lt o s in u b ieltrlttere! ie l:'‘l hip reasons. But after tvhat iiAB baPrii.eoiCelii 'O e ' d cckittbe VRI - i•kttcd to ensue ? , 11 ,.. 1 : 1 t t" t ,, °t the regintent are to be sent rigilt-?"-.):,611?,iit '"S", Whitt' chance will tht • 'tett? oneA 11 ,`': e I? ' 0 ? to streceeti thote who have been di0"5",„05 11 ) fact- tea's, that Col. Quentin'' c ondu ct 1 (00 e'',,, • rionsly the same, Itt)t only abroad but it' ` 10 (1 1''',.,0 was very much tallied Of ' tvliercvet be foo' c' t l; with' the, reginteltt, e ven at ipswicli• ga ll .i arty superior Officer pit down will' t , 1 : 1 , 9 tj.r,:liti, ings at the intss tank', anti hear f 0 : - .,: o intit", ( 0, and charges thrown out against' the C''s rota t b t without wishing to have t h e con'tPl3.°ll-,,[0 ~,Ii into ? There was no- alternative att er :,11 , P ( ? I A happened ; sold he, was compelled t° b oll ;4 only line which remained open: g e s ,,itirci 1eat , .... to say only a fetv words 11O r t e i e ( '1 1 P 1 ,,,, Which could net be passed'over• l' - : ii :to` j oi the letter which- the Offico'shad s,ig"'i,';',,„itil4 dresetl to :tlie Prince Regent, ill ''''",aF l l , their conduct, trhicek.lettei . :, he 11 , fier e ''',14 1 01;' tlboThret-I• from- them by Col. Qu•e"",":e°10, Pretences ; this let - tel. - he w oniii beg ''''' - ,,, v ol'iol' He next read that Fart of t;ae. c ooin .- ,i ' il l. o , Prince Regent which /elates -tO ti- x ii'''' t io !t distribittion of the., (llii.-ers ; uti l '''' ' 11° : '1 ' 1 .. , • i i i r i e e a c c ( t i o ' account he e l :l i t e e i g i g i :htlai,diLatifo:Tht:O ,Old t lit'apitill'al I:::::ftenljtlctilles4l/11;1 state it. Ile had not in any tvaY ''', o l o t h r l'ilHself as 1 . 0 be obliged ti' being t."11.01154/4 charges ; he even regrette,l the I)''i r c i pilor r4 ifr l i found it necessary to take, which he, ::e'l )c t - t wholly and solely out of regard to" ' dc ciirloi'; his brother Ofitc,rs., li e fat the °„0(1i0 bringing the subject before the 1 -11) "' e 'ti. - r te Y 'big so done, he should leave it to the 0 0 ,i,, i their discretion. The tion. G ent b .e •l/ I°e i r , Moved; " That' an hill'. Ile Addre's, ‘o•Ofir to the Prince ltegent, praying o ' l ' ( 4 :t'liPl',;:il ° g P l i ' Cr e c i e f) e n d s i l i Sr ig i s )k ;t s. et t i the General (.(iiit..rtcl:::altht-''l"°'4l.j i' r t i l : :?l;.4 t) Colonel Quentin, of the 1 Ozh ° ll3-54 1 0 : ( l e 1 i ( 1- i I n a :I I i!: - ‘ ' :1 ' :I'l - .r, been read . f . r i. " .1. ` 1 ... f ,i ' :;, , ° o ' t lit ,. t 1 ' Mr. - INI A NN . F.r..'s Su '1•1'41 ta i o ;e.--- -- l ie r ' ' '.l oe 1 ;1 , "p r o t ti ) ina r h e ii. jale l tic ie ttdoo p r rt t le i e cc i t l i t e o t t l io t i o l o a t taltdileus:i .- i t ,, l l t s e c b i l ' e ;; ;1 1 c r e ,,a - ie ld tl ; fit it necessary to declare, that he .1- ,:i4r l Y, ; a ni ii .,: i k d e e, f l or t - 0 11 a b v v i tt,c t r h i c t ec u it o son. (I.ecci,llll::iiitii:iiiil;:itii,,,,e;il", .. 1 cattse _tie had ' already deelai eel' 31 ;`,. , , -ti) •',O r, I , repeat, that IYe WOUt?i St•iiiili nil f tl .'; '''''' ; di` , kl. tar 'ati Itisd:fiwn individual "P''''', )l tl ,e 'li`,.., r ' the tvlialo that had been done ("- . t lte„ ~ ' ,l : , ..." 7- 13 ' •61°1112elit, and been 'tvls Su r '', e. i ) ( 1 . 1 1 ';i wfmld think, that the,eondttet " 1: -1' ." ;5 0 11. .4 nor j •„ 1 ,- ith:e ePlyrte I • VVA'S . very CN tr A OP" . I t ( ',ir b P , hear, hear I) - - --1 in• , the reason' '''tliel'••lo J 0 Its ti! ...: -the neees•Sity o f j i :e ld t• : Pl as i t i o r ti li e e ci T •t t l a e b t i :;; . tit l e A n i t i e e r t i l t ' s elfit:ir ;r lr',. f.' ,'ltlPCl,:; 1 ,, e eoritti ► not Ore hit ‘, ( c te 1 ,, 1 . die, o iol o : JiVir di f Ite::ntotion. w o llot a Il i c,L. c-,ark)ll:„' wz o ,cl‘-I,t I.)ciat'.e..t.i.°litt.etilvtee l''l: ., i l i i i•i e j tie l l e . n ,li til:r_tt)iutt.itel c .• .t ..1 - ::: ' Isc !t 1 ),01 `1 1 ,1.1 1 4:: r t i :Tte , 'c'tY 01*-theit;telligence. of. the_iii,Tort".,llo;toe ogether. Ile should' think it . 'e''`; ; ',. o,l e beeros 1. ,,, a if the House' .liiilittl agtei,‘.l, t •t t , o tt - tei - the partial reasons dice. ) o. ' l , ''':4l (l . .),,f le : r t a il, he 'Honourable -Gentleirrait •1"'"- r .i.it' ,- 11' 11. ) ll Only ;on e half of ththir ur"ece.`be'e.tedi.eo4'l, Ite'ar:l).--It might, hOvvevcr, be ei;'! / D ,t l e f o !iiiiiscy stioliici reiii the other i0110it'016,,g„,;0:4 :issiire - the IlMise he had ii- suc,' .illi'',,';l(ol,,l tionouranie Gentietnati 1 1 .01 stattl":101(1 .i,e: ° f ell contents of the l'ap,n-'s, that Ot;/),elt., ~t ,C.,,,4' read 'by ina.ly Members., tfor 11 ' P r ot tl —at l ‘;1 ( • knew that they teCre „,,,iiia the . , , : 1.01.1)•,: t , b0 .. .1y• unless ; • thecefore, the 11 '. ) ::,.ei l we l d) ~ i , tie ,i,"' !ti,..i , tit t?) attach the decisiou, ' -- “ t t tig-.Ali , :,i l: ' grity•of the Court,' bet,votild re1', e3 „ . . 3 • 9 ' /, 0 14 1 ,/, ' g ei l . ) et r e s .' 4 i f si l l i l t i 1 1 (:) t i g l i l si t ;:ir .1 1 1 1 :' , O ; :t: l i t!l l l' i t I:1 (,)C:i.t.—: ini(elic4lL;ests::l:T; ic ; 1 : 1 : 1, : 41 1 ; ii i ir t il l ti s it c%: ,. ( i i #: o , lo ;i l ll : 4 ' !li ii i ,lieee.,c eat. (c)iiiii:i.:(Yti:.:ghlt:l.ilesd,:ll. heard s l t i i i:t e l t t 7)::: make r'els, i i (' 1 1 ':: : ::: , i c ' ei c e ‘( ,vein{' ) 1111 , ;, f , I i e' 41° I ' " 1 ; 1 14i t teply ; but the and House tb l o i f t)le":::":' 1• 1 :1 411 ; , l it t; 11; ; :c t c : nothing read to them but tile co ati ri.ct. it''' the same time he shOold abstai° ,itle i : ili,d 4; e , e j , 41 1 4 1 any detail at all,- either Of' tk e ' „ I vit 0: 0, 1 4 4 ' f01111C(1 the half which hod heci' oe ilr ef f r o l lioitsf; or any other part ~tit° f,l, '' ic°,l,./ because, as he had already go °if r• ~ ,,111 ~ , e tt I hail xllO felt interested at , ' • lb jeer% tP;deP 1 4 . -Of_ satisfying himself on the '‘ieitettilo '.61070,,‘ d o ”otiling but justify, 11 " t l e , P. i' t. . c it l ' il , result tvhich had taken pi}4,,,,,,,,,,irP0lo t tilt indeed, was, in his opiiii° 9 ' 11 t 3O 1 4411 0'4 °4? therefore only explain the gr°',l,l-I,e r(4 O, , io:',,„ G t .e l ete,ciiti.it(ti4(e),:iiiiirtliitt:t:ll:eaibille(riee,tc:bailc):l iti,tl:lei(titte :(1 1:: t e : t 0 c o ., I,, e , ,c , 6 ii ite ' o l( t io: fi l l ,re l - r: 11 1 1 ! ) : g i '- j i l negatived,. and on the third - collect` sc" .e „01 4 1 1 11 lie if 1 1`..:0w, when the House recollect.;e , ell 11`; 0 "'ho had; been called ou t° iii‘" : llleC l t4°lerill ' t ' l , ~, tr fts so re ~ 1 14er ,ill Vo upon these efiargeS, ii , --,. , be ie • -r r , •jj tv • little inclined to impeaeo ; I ,:sr tc' e :.' 1 i ,4 ,1 i er, to suspect their honour• ' - i : er vier r e i e e ' t fo l 0: ! eminent for (heir 1.101 all ~ li' 4( , I rle t) ,o' ; ,:i i i'al • (}slicers, Many of `"°-ilj,eir , i i it c ,,, qf t hal' ii.s .. of the House f0r ,0 ,, ; ri l . t il 0 ,41 9 0i 1 vices and unquestioned tidt.ii.l•loo./°;; ii1;14,1 necessary to read ave r r '` . . - i . l iert e . o oA l/ Ti e it l ,,, every Gentleman th: ‘ , , t er t e be t i fo tt r e g s , l ll ti t l i e , i l l ,) s / 5 e 't i f i l ' and higli bottom . the° - t lki t le po si t Hight doll. GCntleinall - ► at-- 4 1 or or . 1 ;) Aieto bers whit formed thereC°11.101001; f;i' was certainly nothing- tut i. 6e0 1 ,1 •o t I l ia fl i e d ordinary than that the 1-I ‘ )i , f ill e ,j,;!' T O ee T , ' , ,1 , cllo , 0 . it' irr if the prosecutor shoulo 0- ~ ti ere heat t ii tot 15 i it wits natiiriil in , prosec" os t c"; 5 ( l O ct 1 .01 0 , 1 0 . in • their object, ai theY n'iloot"r.lo, 0 0',1( c lieve that they had i tist I.;,•ecut('cil' it ii;L it il ' ceediags... Still, if a 1)1111,,bloc,i,Fol'oe I substantiating what lic 11 .0 ( 5 a ,r` ea be thought that he s' _ o eau wake the moat ivapartial i'l 1 I n ~~ I, i