The Sun. — London, England, 1809-03-10 00:00:00

01 . In the elucidat'on of. the whole business I felt , as much anxiety as if the charaaler of a brother had 'been concerned ; but in*tbis propo sition which I am about to tender to the House, I have been influenced.by those considerations alone, which would have influenced me in the rase of .an . . entire stranger. I havedone that which I thought puhlie justice,- and public- policy demanded of me. _./ It is for the House to determine on the question be fore them. For myself,,and for i the judgment which _ the country' may pron Ounce on my condual, I re . peat that I aril perleffly easy. As tar as lam con cerned, I assure the•Honuurable Gentleman oppO- ',~ 4~sf :,r, al ', site, that although my Constituents are as popular in their sentiments as those - of any. Member in the House; I bayonet theleast apprehension, that Wheh the course which Lime pursued is explained to them I shall not forfeit that confidence. which for- so many Years it hes been my. geed fortune to eojoy." The: Right tion' e Gentleman' ceucluded a must eloquent and impiessive speech, by moving an amendment to the motion of Mr. Wardle-. Mr. libtruutisT declared, that, in his ,opinion, the original' address sveS' so Objedionable, that 'he could not accede- to-it ; 'but at the aame time he 14 41 yd to suiltnit to the -.4 - lousee in its stead, some thing very different from the amendment proppsed by his Right Honourable Friend. He ccxild not allow the propriety of. any,Address to his Majesty, unless the Hattie bad something to communicate of a very different :more. It would be absurd to' lay at the foot of the throne an Address merely cone • tanning an account of their proceedings. The pre ferable step,.' in his opinion, would be, to take the , sense of the Hous e on a resolution, that his :Royal ' Iliehness tend by' his coodisee-exposed himself to • due influence in the discharge of his important duties. Should the House determine in theaflirmat ive on this resolution, it unghtbefteted upon by- his 103 , 411. High stess,and considering the relation that existed between bas Majesty and his 'Royal 'Highness, he did cenceive that this would glently; Preferable to any Addresg to the King, conveying the sentiments of the 11 9" e 401 i-the sr:bidet. He concurred entirely in the opi nion of his,Right Hon. Friend, that ITO corrupt mu, lives could be imputed t. his Royal Highness; but painful as the declaration was, it was a duty impera tive upon him to .state, that in the view 'which he had taken of she evidence, it appeared to him too clearly established, that..his Royal Highness had ex posedinmself to an undue intluenee. With tespett to the charader of the witnesses that had been brought forward, lie contended, that hoWever suspicious that character, hovh:Ver they might be justly accused of I being tit least accomplices -in the crime which they proiessed to espose e yet when 'their testimony was corroborated by indisputable documents, that. it ought Unquestionably to have its due 'weight. He began his examination with the ease of General Clavering.' When be considered the manner in which this sub. jest. was treated•in the letter from the Duke of York Clarke, he could not resist the conclusion, that the letter from Mrs. Clarke,' in which r this' ataiwet originated, must have contained something . more tieet eare inquiry Whether any new regi!- ments were or were nut raising. In his opinion, it mustlave cenyeyed to the Duke Mrs. Clarke's Termed ha , :loyal Highness would give Genet al Clavering one of tooge regiments which she pre sumed were abotit to be raised., The notoriety of thy existence of ihfluence on the part of Mrs. Clarke,. rt noturiety whicu Gen. Clavering and Dr. O'Mara bad beertitidecen to apply to - het - for - assistance, could s . eareety-have existe‘i without home ground. Hay , ing formed a connection with such a 'worthless. wo man,- it was not surprising that his Royal Highness should by degrees allow her to possess an infleence over him which was certainly unjustifiaOle• • And that she did possess this influence, there waS, his opinion, abundant testimony to prove.' The Right Hon. Gentleman then alluded to; the tett- tinioey of Miss Taylor, which he considered' aieaf• fording prout of Mrs. Clarke's influence over the Duke of York. Ott the catie of Samuel Carter; he waseiot desirous of ;preesing. inquiry. It was a go h erous trausattion on the part of his Royal Highness and Mrs. Clarke, and he would . only observe that' it was unlikely that Lieutenant Sutton's recomnienda- tion four years previous to his obtaining tirtvcotri 7 mission, was the cane of his appointment. I-Protn 4 • the circumstanres; he conceived' that it must be evident to the mind of every man, that there had Steen reconstant • interference seting upon his Royal Ilighness, which in many instances had influenced his condua, and-was to a certain extent nrejudicial to the interests of the army. .There vas a part nut touched on, either in the Address of the Hon. Gen tleman (Mr. Wardle), or in the Resolutions . of his light "Hon. Freed (the Chancellor of the. Birdie- - (pet), Which inar•y puld think not the. least ine pt:nein itr this matter, and it wets this, Which did sat go to the extent of corruetien as to undue in fluence, that .he had thought it is cluty . to poiht out to the House. Unless some other Hon. Gentlemen' pursued this course, he would,'at time close of the de bate; suggest a Resolution, to mark with the animad version ut tee House the connection itself in which the Commander ii Chief had been engaged, mid else (e it hunt Yiewine it morally or religioasly) its • . political bad. conseqt.: uces and dangerous example. Previous to this, however, he would deem it neces tary to come, to a tote ou ailesolution, such 8S th 9, 'first proposed by tile Right lion. Gentleman—aye or la), whether the Commander in Chief was guilty of 'emloption or nut. Atterwards he would propose an Address, t‘ that • the House had. observed with' the d ecliest regret, that in Consequence , a a connection the most inimoral and unbecoming, undue intiuence had be e t continually exerte4,' which brought ‘dis-• .graceful charges against the Commander in Chief, and tended to give colour to transaaions the most .Pernicious and indiscreet." • Mr. W filiTIM AD said, that after the iippartial and •clear mariner in which the Honourable Gentleman who had just ~p „ ee e, b a d viewed the .case before :the and'af ter thejiidAcious and uneXception , , tible.teatio e r in 'whiCh uravin irretragable de .duitions train the various peiets laid down, his con .elusions could not: possiu4 u. re jetted except by the Honourable and Right Hon. Gentleman who, bad spok' 1 - 1 had 'wished much en on the oilie s t. t t r?, rise titter the Right Hon..GeDileinan opposite (the e-teiocellor nt the Exchequer) of %Own). hs.unght justly say, that in his exeroceis last night and 1 "& ht he Lao suipateicd l,rtusrtt, atia exceeded even whataitht have been expected tram burn..o powers itt that r. e.e.e. It ; tie Duke of Yolk faded, after so u g tat ui;,0.11 of taida its IJt ,Cause, f. 4.11 4 faiWre tt IP .' I could not possibly even be imputed to the want of an able and acute advocate to defend him. He gave the Right Hon. Gentleman credit for his assertion, that throughout this, hilliness he had been atluated by a conscientious sense of his duty, and in ani madverting on what had fallen from him, he would so chastise his feelings as not to say any thing pain ful to him, while he pointed out the errors of his reasoning, or the falseness of his . &durstions. . The Rightlieneurable Gentleman .had begun and end• ed his speech with an attack upon his Honour able Friend (Mr. Wardle). In the natter. part he had cert.iinly 'no right to suppose that his Hon. Friend in the expressions that fell from him had meant any thing unconstitutional, or any thing more than what was well grounded in fa& and in reason ; that it became theMenibers of that House to look tothe general sense of the people whom thesi, repre sented. The observations on. this bead came with a strange effete from the Right Hon. Gentleman, who had himself mounted into power by an appeal from Parliament to the People. As for what he said respe&ing garbled extre&S and libels,'he bs.d only to call on his Learned Friend on his right (the At torney'•General), not to suffer such illegal poceed ing to go on unpunished. . For his part as, far as he had been able to form an opinion, the cosi Ments that had appeared in several publications, were as gross and partial on the one side as on thentlier.s— There was another part of whatbad fallen froln the Right Hon. Gentleman.which he could not puss by in silence,it was, where he told them in terrorem, that if they rernoVed ! the Duke of York frail the Chief Command 'of the Army, they could not g A an other able to supply his place. That he had .done much for the army during sixteen years in which had theadMinistration of it—was gratited.' h • had - introdticed legislations beneficial to the servics., advantageous to the soldier, and agreeable to tht' interests of the coentry, was granted. But was it be caUse he was of the Royal Family that he was not to he removed? To him it appeared ceteris paribus, that this I was an objeel/bn to his Ina he Command ; for-Whatever : might: be said on the SubjeCt, certain it was, that the Duke of York was not treated like any other person not of the Royal Family. He i t as not inclined - o take up the cause On Morarconside rations, and to urge the condemnation of his actions in that sense, but wheti l4refleaed, that from these immoralitiel it was that . 00vertunents were shaken and throneit'overturned, he could not but panic on what was before him, and-conclude that it any other person in his situation. true . been exposed. to have so much disclosed against . 'them as the Duke of York, thei'would have been no' longer com mander in Chief. It was not, however, his wish, • to catch at every thing as, a. ground for his removal, unless the matter in proof was stacient to induce the House to think . that step necessary.. The Her not and Learned Gentleman (Mr. •Borton) had told them, .that he entered upon this inquiry with his mind prejudiced against the Duke of York ; for his part he-did not enter upon it with such a feeling, but certainly with a high sense of the honour, and Courage displayed by his HoiL Friend (Mr. Wardle.) The Right Honourable Gentlethan bad said that he did nut believe the Address was prodUced by his Honourable Friend ; but that in framing it, he bad mixed with cooler heads thau his own. If the Right Hon. Gentleman meant no more than he said, he certainly had no reason to think his Hon. Friend so intemperate a$ to require the aid of cooler heads; but if on the other hand he meant to say, that he had lent himself 'to designing men,' who had objeas in view beyond his own, it was false to say 'so. His Hon. Frtepd was neither weak nor wicked enough for such a line of condutt. Such as his Address, wad, be would vote for it with out the fear of having any such mot ives aseribed to him. Before entering upon the merits of the case he had to refer the House to. the commencement of these charges,, when 'allegations of conspiracy, conspf rotors, and secret' advisers, were so freely made, at the moment when it' was generally brought that all proof bad failed, and the matter -must drop. instified..himself from this allegation, if meant for him, and. declared, that he had only been in company. with Mr. •Wardle twice during'the last two years, and had oply one conversation with him on the subjeet now before the House. In that he had pointed out to him•the heart-burn ings to which he Would' expose Ipmself, and the danger of failing in his proof; seeing' it .was die- - rived NMI such sources; but he had told him at the genie time, that' it he was determined to bring the matter forward he would,Vote for its being referred to a Committee, and was sure no Member of the House would oppose 'him. He had heard that in his absence last night his Hon. Friend had alluded to him in commendation for his aid, he .thanked him for this' complimeifit, but he had tic* no more for him than he would haVe done for any other man in the same situation, stood by to see him have fair play, and there had been occasions on which it was' necessary for, his Friends to stand forward in his behalf. The Right Hon. Gentleman bad accused his Hon. Friend of flinching, but this was not the fact. His Honourable Friend had stated distine.ily, that the Duke of York bad cognizance .of the corrupt practices carried on, and it was only a proof at liis Hon: Friend's temperance in approaching the throne, .that had • been construed into an abandonment of his charges. If be had tided otherwise,. the House would have heard enough ofl - the cruelty of wounding . the feelings of afather, by a strong representation of the misconduct of his son. ,Inahis, then, his opinion exactly coincided with' that expressed by his Ho nourable Friend ; and that if he could have said the Duke of York was innecent, he 'should have done it in short cud concise terms a but if be was in some degree guilty, he ought to express his, opinion mildly in calm ' language. - The Right' Hoourable. Chancellor of the Exchequer had, inone of his reso lutions, expressed it as the opinion of the House s that his Royal Higlmess't,vould in future be less lia ble to fall into such destru&ive connexions, History indeed afforded many 'examples of tuen, who had risen from disgrace to greater eminence and renown than they could otherwise have attained; and, in con , . r-bidetatiotr ofthis; as well as for the lakdolliii'Ma- Jesty, and for thesake of the . Duke of' York, ho %r Would most cordially agree with the, motion of his Honourable Friend. Undue influence had beeii picseo..ia eitist to a great extent,' and the Pena were called upon to mirky their sense of it. None but drivellers would shrink from' the'diny before them, and refuse to vote either that the tanduct of ' Iris Royal Highness was COMP; or that' he- hati $ knowledge of the corrupt practices carrying on, as their opinion stood ; and it was easy for them it) agreeing to, this resolution to mark distintaly what their sentipents rbally were. Thus having made a few generaf remarks on what had'been paid on the, other side, he begged leave, with the permission of the House, to say a few words on the nature of the examination of the witnesses, who, for three weeks, had attended at their bar, and of the degree of credit due to their testimony. The Right Hon. Gentle man had said a good deal on this subject ; and the Hon. and Learned Gentleman had given them a lec-_ tore on evidence, and the caution' with which the testitnony of accomplices was to be received. The . Learned Gentleman. had, from his own experience, stated, that they ought not to be believed; bin he - contended that they ought, ,as well in this case as in cases of life and death, which they were every day called into criminal Courts to prove or disprove. How many murders would hays passed away un punished but for such witnesses ; and in this instance, where the life and death of the charaCter of the Duke of York; and the life and death of the country were involved, he could not see why it ought to be reje&ed. Where, in cases of corruption, was bvi dence to be got, but such as was brought forward `on this occasion, out of, and nnconneCted with, the Office of the Commander in Chief ? • The Hon. and Right Hon. Gentlemen had undertaken a task of no small difficulty to accomplish, when they attempted to disqualify all the witnesses on various grounds, some from parts of their testimony, some from their situation in life, and others in classes which they endeavoured to make out. Although 'women of the deacription of one of these witnesses, might starer .from this mode of arrangement; we would -wistsass.knose:hottiqhey were to manage with their Captains and. Generals ?• Cnuld they disClOilify'Mrs. Clarke beeause she had lived in open prostitution with several persons ?' Those unfortunate creatures Who sunk, degraded, and hist in the distinnionS of social life, 'could, if they were oilt d . on, con , via many, many of the other' aes, •of the blackest ,treachery and perjury. 'lf Mrs. Clarke's testimony kas thrown out, What were they to*think of receiV ikz, the testimony of the 'lowest and most degrad ed Af . womankind; living in the meat infatnous and ,miserable slate of beings, Who were daily heard in cases where the life of . an individual • depeiided upIN their es idence. There Was a matter OfV'hicli he .hid beard, but -which he would not now par tieularists, that a Lady of the same -description had twice given her testimony resOetizt a will in Co,irt, which was proven by , her 'evidence alone, unim peached by any of the considerattons Stated tiy the Learned Gentleman.--,Tne • (Hop. • Gentleman, we were inforrnetl, alluded to Mrs. Carey).—The Hoo, and flight lion. Gentleman heel also attempted to' ;nova that Mrs..clarke Was actuated by . wilfut 2:14 deliberate revenge. He would not mention the pr,)-, vocation the Dike of 'York had giveo her, tior t 14,0 manner in which he 'treated her in pecuniary mitt ters, which wa.i, to s.ey the least Of it, not very cre ditable-to nun. Rad there been any att!:euia to "hew site had atied in spreperP ? and yet the Mine GentleMati , had said, that if his nest had agreed to the .densatid contained its hem terS• (they were not chitAs; they were solieitatiens) he would lave been acknoWledeing that he was coin, pletelyin her power. The liea. Gentleanati here went into a defence - ofMrs. Clarke's condtl6l in this reaped, and contended, tort Atere was no proof at. a Vengeful diSiiiisitiou towards his Royal Highness, and tat the present discoveries might b e accounte d for on other -principles.' When she appeared at the Bar she certainly displayed all that ptttness, - wit, acuteness, effrontery, and iinpudence with which she had been charged; but on being exemiti stil for three boors by a late Attorney-General, the 'present Attorney-General, and others, with the So licitor-Geoeral at their back, by way of a corps de. reserve, and being culled in again and again,' and re.; examined, till she was like to fajut through bodily fatigue, they had not been able to make any thing out, The Learned Gentleman (the Attotney.Gene ral), might observe that she had baffled him, and when he thought !te had got her fast, off she went into a new beat, He then 'hada some Observations on the mode in which she %wet treated, and did not think it strange, that if allahe Members encouraged her by laughing at her answers, she should continue in a course that appeared so amusing, till she ex ceeded propriety and .deeorum, 'The Learned At torney-General had questioned her fur three hours, and made bet little of it. He got out some stories which led to the disclosures respeaing General Cla vering, DI% O'Mara, and the produCtion of the cor respondence, which Mrs. Clarke would never have produced but from these circumstances. How then did Gentlenteu exult in her having advanced false hoods ? Gen. Clavering apply to her ! Dr. O'Mara apply to her ! and give her letters from the Hierarch of the Irish Protestant Church, the Archbishop of Team !—Oh 1 it was impossible! But when titSse things were proved, oud the letters from Nicholls Produced; they recorded in chatadets as dark as ,Erebus, General Claverine's miseondua and Mrs. Claricectretb, From this lie' did not mean' to coif= tend that she was altogether a pure witness, bat that some points in which she was so itropgly suspeCted, having turned - out •to be correct, it - wa,i but fair to allow her some credit in others, would exa. mine her evidence a little more closely, The Learn ed, Gentleman (Mr. Bnrton) had • stated a great charge and , had proved very little. He had as serted altat Mrs. Clarke contradided • herself. in et! Instances—of these he had adduced one,: ttaniely„ her having represented herself as a widow, Whieh shu .denied having done, and left the remaining 27 as he found them. The tionourable Gentleman now entered into a review of the evidence, which went,to thew that Mrs. Clarke had rt!presidutO her self ax a widow. Nicholls' he cousidero(l as a bss.. and impeachable witness, .whe had'got possession of Papers and would not give them up, though they might „have affected the cliaradvi or life of 'the per. son whose:pnaperty th 4, Were, • He had often Ob.: served that nature would bring a 'Witness through - a cross , exaoaination, while ctemtng and dexterity al , ways failed, arid. this • waC• ex,..tiplifted by IVlrs' Clarke in many points; particularly in die joy she expressed when General Claverin‘s assertiOti disprosed,—Fle. called' upon Gentlemen to look at their 'Tot - had days.- OA .they, not all.occasiosally -made owes for particcl. - a-parposes and reasons ;- mid if Mts. Clarke even hal represented. herselt ail the ,time she w..ts at i*S. 1 7 oW1T/ it d: '4' 4 troy , ' lietea. • • I .imony. That Nicholls never brought an aition against Mr. Doveler for the money site Owed t o hin a e was is convincing proof that he did net believe Mrs- Clarke was his wife; and as for the ,esti mone o f 'Reid, his waiter, porter, and the person who carried the wine, if it was a case of life and death, he deSs dared to God it would wei g h no thi ng with hiirt:Le He was of the same opinion with respect to the eel', dence of Mr. Few; and the deditaion endeavoured to be drawn front the Court-Merrial. The Hon. Gdntleman went through the other alleged con tradiolions, and contended, that StoWers'a-evidence did not prove that Mrs. Clarke's husband, whom she represented as an independent . Gentleman, was a stone-mason. He afterwards allowed, that this was a gross contradiction. With regard to the two pointi in which she was eceitradieted hy Mr. Knight, he considered the first As . threat , nitig to expose the Duke of York as no contradiction, as she bad not then in view to do it in the manner iq which it' was now done ; and as for the second, though be must believe the testimony of Mr. Knight, that she had desired the matter to he kept secret trom the Drake of York, yet he could not agree in the deduftion, . that because she desired one case to be kept secret, she would wish them all to be so, If lint mill was going every day, it was natural for his Royal High. ness to say, " keep me out of sight of , Greenwood or Gordon, whose knowledge of these things would ruin me; keep out of improper hands." This was not a contradiction, in substance, that woold make hiin disbelieve all that Mrs. Clarke had said. The next contradiction was, that .qf her haying denied seeing Dowler more than twice, although she had slept with him at Reid's. Was it not very natural for her to deny this > and would any other witness be disbelieVed for such a denial I As for the hinehing of the:midnight plots on .this occasion, it might be a very fair inference, but could not be made e rea sonable deduction from the circumstance. From all these coincidetices, he was not disposed to vie* this witness with suspicion ; but lie had said so touch only to show, that he. did not tliinic her testi mony;altoget her extieguishedahereliy, :14(1 he Would 'believe her where her staterneets were eortoborat, eta, The Right Honourable Gentleman had ,men. tioned Saeeral presumptions ; in favour of the coin mender iu Chief; there were also some on the 'other side. The corruption began inainediately after corn. mencieg the expensive establi.htnent ; Nlrs, Clarke bad great influence over hie Royal Highness, from the elleeioti he bOre her. These might. be balanced teLainst the presumption drawn from- the tratlie es caping-the notice of Col. Gordon—the.commitiiions all geinfereaularly through the . ' official Course, and every thingbeing Consietent. With ell Gtteawoai. and Gordon's caution, all this mieht still go forward, It Was 311 po3sibl . : enough (he (hi not say it was so), and that from the Duke of York's atieftion. for Mrs., Clarke, he might adre.v. her to get money from of. : riceei for having performed what was done in tlie regular way, and flatter her with the idea that it wits [ all througli. her'interest and for her sake, If the ~mill could net go at . ail - times, it ~ v as from the stream's being dry, owing t , tie gieitel., i eipo's..d by :. olonel Gordon, which prevented Dimling to the extent • it wa's said might have been (Woe, bad the, Commander in Chjet bec,ll a party ia t hi, tratik,7— Frlie Right Hun, Chancellor of 'the Ee.chet*luer had said, that it w:.:; miraculous only four histate'es could lie adduce,: ,teeinat his Royal Highness :during so, Jung a ;v. :ioti_ kb, '..7osliidetucl• it.tt.or,. tthrocniotti, that his Honourahle Friend 4ltould have t)roui;:,t'hili .?charge against the Sot) of a :rt.ig, p:sesie.,ll of ~ nt,tl influence, and. Surrnunded by so malky litervi:is, to the point at which it now was. •:.I'o,i site ht lion, Gentleman also exclaimed, " Is it poi.iiLlO tai ;up» pose the Duke of York could, have so committed himself for 250011" Here (said. the Hon..Getitle- Mae, laying his hand on the. Minutes of Ovidencw) is the damning proof, if not of corruption, .at - least that he .WaS privy to these corrupt KA:tit:ea, - It wit,* not for the sake of putting . wn.tel. into his own pocket, 'but for the paltry wageS of iniquity, and such must be the concluaion to which the iliefi e must come. They wow also asked, w o uld t h e D u k e of York, for the F ake of 5001. have. allowed these charges to have been made public i- 4ut•this proved too much ; for if his Royal Highness set these let-, teln at defiance for the sake of 4001. a year,.be might meet any.other danger or disgrace. , He would now very briefly notice what ,had been asserted, that it did not necessarily follow that . the Duke of York knew that the expendifure of Gloucester-place ex deeded the sums of.money he paid for its support, and that Prinies were not so well acquainted with the value of money as men in a lower station, Ile ' acknowledged this,, bot the Mike; of York, at the heid of such in, office as he was, ought to know something of the value of money. Morn the nature of the entertaihruents at Gloucesterrplace, the nuns* ! ber of carriages, horses, &c.. he must have suspected that means were' found somewhere to meet the ex pentlittire necessary. There were great distresses not always relieved by him, and jewels and trinkets,. which are so desirable to women of that 4aatgiption, wore pawned by Mrs. Clarke to supply the pressipg demaechi. It appeared to .'him morally impoesible r that the Duke of York was not acquainted with the fad that money Wei, procured 'eliewhere. There , - was another strong point which must Iti.ve awaken etl'his suspicions on Ms=s head, and that was, Mrs,. Clarke's asking favours for persons unknown to her. If she had said, do something for my brother, it might have been sO far excusable. to . comply,. with , her request; but what could be said when her HO Clergyman stepped in ? What could she know pc' hint, or the Archbishop of Team ? Flo 1 4 . " 41 ,41,1V6 • been knOxim to he -a stronger, And that was st'Acie t it to inform the Duke Of, York of the nat:, ,, a, o f'h er ' interference. Sandell; who is now eA)lating his oll'enceif in Newgate, and French ate i a Clavering, a family man, were all in the same pe et ei cam ,„ t ; e qr what interest could NIrS. Clarke le, , e,inatieir sttecess, • As for the case of Samuel Carter, Avwc34ld only teen titan it, to say he w=ished it had ',lever been ititrodtteed, ie e , had been over-stated byllp Itt, 1104..,0•.'iu. OPPrI. ' Site : - yet, aa'he had tefoc4leaut a tneriterieet orlieer, he trtisted what had ne;elad on elii. • iiieuirywould not .., prejudice hia'brothet • Otrteets. against hint in 3 coma try - where eaa did not lOok to our , tuct!*try • . lite vi e e e h - ,armieS stewed UR wh4t,kipa of , mt_n were' made Generals,' and he was gla:liq find tact the Doke of Yot't hid discerned - met - it evetieltinci his ' cites=, and prompted it, to an ,t..iin,74,1 wllt.e. 11,is , cirCtlaiStake;liowever, w3 s a S!.* P,'4 l l:' P '• ::C 'r" O Jf OS W illtbl;32Co exereioe4 by ;ili'i. CLa :o;; l t . nd at, ti n t same i itA:orpt iiet hlinsanity. I,et no man,:on, s.vw4 .ats 0a1k.... 1 . . ~ ~' ' . .. • . . , ~ _ • - . . . . ... ,