The Sun. — London, England, 1831-12-02 00:00:00

the lininn. He (Mr. A.) knew no wrong in such correspondence, if true—for surely the 'distinguished Simation which he (Mr. A.) had the honour to hold did not shut him out from the courtesies which one gentleman owed to another. Much had been saidabout the excitement which the - Ministers were charged with producing in the nation. This was also false, It was their predecessors and present opponent; tvho created the excitement, and not We Ministers. When Earl Grey and his cc:lirAgnes entered office, they found soci e ty on the verge of dissolution; and if it had not been cor the interested opposition of their rivals, k was his (Mr. A.'s) opinion that the existing excitement would have been allay e d bef ore now. It was the giant guilt oi the chan g e o f th e currency which had produced the excitement,—it was the cruel and destructive attempt to 'compel this deluded nation to produce 16,000 togs of solid gold in the disehnrge of its public atld private taxation— it was this enormous anti destructive burden pres:i mg with its mortal weight upon every mantle, and every sinew, and every nerve, and .2t-ery throbbing artery of the Country, which had produced the ex citement which was now threatening the foundations of society. The Ministers had had nothing to do in making this excitement. It was the money laws breaking 'down the price of labour on the one hand, and the corn laws bolstering up the price of bread on the other, which had worn out the patience of the nation, and had at last produced that glorious excitement which he trusted would shortly terminate in the liberty and happiness of all.--(Cheers.) Mr. A. then proceeded to state that he had suspended the petition to the King agreed to at the last meet ing, in order to consult the Council again respecting the proprieting of presenting it. He had feared it might be deemed intrusive by their excellent Sow reign, or by his Ministers, and he was exceedingly unwilling to take any step having any tendency of that kind, fie would read the petition again, and leave it to the Council to determine. Mr. A. then read the petition, at the close of which— Mr. BENJAMIN HADLEY, Honorary Secretary to the Union, said be rose for the purpose of propos ing the adoption of the petition now read.. Again and again he would repeat, that the only safe and certain reliance for the people was on themselve• 'alone.—(Lord cheers.) Believing, as he did, that the sentiments contained in the petition would, if acted upon, greatly strengthen the hands of Mi nisters, and effectually rescue our beloved King from the insolent domination of those great enemies of the people, the factions Lords Spiritual and Tem poral ; and thinking it the solemn duty of this Council to make this last appeal to his Majesty, which would seive to convince the country that they had !eft nothing undone that could contribute to die advancement of the great cause they all had so much at heart, he strongly recommended the im mediate adoption of the petition. Mr. Hadley sat down amid loud cheers, and proposed the following resolution : " That the petition to the King, now read, be adopted and signed by the Members of this Council ; and that the Chairman be requested to forward it to Earl Grey with the greatest despatch." _ _ _ The Rev. Dr. WADE seconded the petition, which. after a short conversation, was carried unanimously. The Rev. T. M. 3PDONts . r.u. gave notice, that on Tuesday next he should bring forward a motion in support of the subject of the 101. franchise. BRIGHTON, DEC. 1. Their MAJEsms are in the enjoyment of excellent health and spirits at their Marine Palace. Yesterday, at twelve o'clock, their MAJESTIES left the Palace in a carriage and four, with two outriders (by the North gate), proceeded on the Lewes road through Stan more-pat k, and returned to the Palace about two o'clock. Her Royal Highness the Frincess Auc USTA, and Prinet GEORGE, did not leave the Palace during the day. The PI ince►s LOUISE enjoyed a carriage airing along the East and West Cliff for some time. Nam , s were left by the following nobility and gentry at the Palace :—The Earl and Countess of Beverley and the Ladies Percy, Lord John Townshend, Lord and Lady Maryhorough, Lady Clarendon, Lord and Lady de Roos, Lord and Lady Louth, Lady Mary and the Misses Pette, Viscount Newark, Hon. Mrs. Lushington, Colonel Brother ton, Sir Joseph Wheatley, Sir Charles, Lady, and Miss Burrell, Mr., Mrs., Miss Whitmore, and Captain Bagot. Last evening their MAJESTIES entertained a large party at dinner, in honour of St. Andrew's Day. Sixty-eight sat down to dinner, including their MAJESTIES, the Royal Suite, and the following :—The Duke of Argyll, Duke of Montrose, Marquis of A ilesbury, Marquis of Queensberry, Lord Belhaven, Lord Lake, Earl Bathurst, Earl of Kin noul, Hon. Colonel Henry Murray, Lieut.-Col. Wats,n, Lieut.-Clonel Grey, and the officers of the Scotch Greys, Lieut.-General Sir .1. Fraser, Admiral Douglas, Mr. Aberdeen, Mr. Cunningham, Mr. Marjoribanks, Mr. liaillie Himilton, Mr. Drummond, Lieut.-General Sir William Keir Grant, Lieut -General Sir Robert M•Far lane, Major-General Hepburn, the Right Hon. Charles Grant, Lieut.-General Pringle, and Mr. Robert Grant, and the officers of the Guards. The SUFFCX Militia assemble this day at Chichester for training. The Earl of Du NDONA rn, the Earl and Counte.s of BE- N rat.xa-, the Earl and Countess of BELHAVEN, and the Marquis and Marchioness of CA am)+, RTIIEN, remain at the Bedford. The Earl and Countess of SHREWSBURY are ex pected this day. An evening cotemporary has put forth a sort of skeleton of the alterations about to he made in the Re form Bill, which will be again introduced to the con sideration of the Legislature in the course of next week. We give the paragraph in another column, and consider the alterations, if correctly reported, to be judicious and satisfactory. The existence of the counties, without any division, will also form an additional improvement in the original form of the Bill ; and we have reason to believe also that Ireland will receive a considerably larger addition to her representation than that which is stated by our co temporary. The few days, however, that are to elapse before the Bill in its complete and final shape will be sub mitted to Parliament, render it a matter of comparatively trifling import whether our information and that of our contemporary be, or be not, correct. What the public is anxious to ascertain is, whether the great principles of the rtjected Bill are preserved in that which is now to be sub mitted to the consideration of the Legislature ; and on that point we can confidently state, that the pledges given previously to the prorogation of Parliament by Lords GREY and Bitoucieam, respecting the efficiency of the new Bill, will be amply and most honourably fulfilled.— Morning Advertiser. We hear that the Reform Bills are ready, and that they will probably be read a second time previous to the adjournment for the Christmas holidays. We believe that the census of 1 831 will be taken as the standard of Population ; eight new Members will be given to Scot land, and five to Ireland ; the full number of the House as it stanch at present will be continued, and, of course, some additional English towns will have Members. Some boroughs from schedule B will be removed to schedule A, and the 101. qualification will be taken in a more simple manner than at first proposed. The pay ment of taxes as well as rent will probably be required, and a certain holding necessary to the exercise of the franchise. These are all the particulars we can collect, and, eel tainly, they all appear to us to be improvements on the late Bills. The only thing which now seems ne cessary is that the Reforming Members should be urged to attend in their places, notwithstanding th e incon venience to which it may subject some of them. The majority should, if possible, be greater, but certainly not less than on the second and third readings of the rejected Bill. All p ar ti es see m anxious that this great and mo mentous question should be settled with the least possible delay.—Mornin g Paper. SCOTTISII HOSPITAL.--Wednesday being St. Andrew's Day, the annual festival of the Scottish Cor poration took place. The funds of this charity are appli cable to the relief of all natives of Scotland, their wives and children, being residents of this metropolis or its vicinity. The Duke of Goanost was expected to pre side at the entertainment, but the Se cre t ary received from his Grace a letter , sa y in g , th at if his attendance were deemed of importance he should, rather than forfeit the good opinion of his countrymen, travel 600 miles for the purpose of being present ; but he hoped that after so long residence in London as his late Parliamentary duties imposed on him, the Corporation would accept his apo logy. In the absence of the Noble Duke, the Hon. Wm. FRASIER took the Chair. There were about 200 gentlemen present, and the subscriptions announced were of a very . gratifying amount, though few of the persons of rank or i nfluencet connected with Scotland were pre ent, Cases. Died. From the Commencement of the Disease, on - the `with October, 1831 (Signed) C. STEPHENSON, Secretary to the Sunderland Board of Health, We learn by the Austrian Observer that Sultan MAnstouD, who has oflate had Hercu lean difficulties to contend with, in the perpetual revolts of his Paellas, instigated, no doubt, in some degree, by Russian intrigues, has at length reduced the Pachalic of Bagdad to obedience, taken the city itself by storm, and made prisoners DAUD PACHA, and his son. His Majesty the - King of HOLLAND still withholds his assent to the treaty separating Bel• gium from Holland. His obstinacy bears much resemblance to that of the English Tories, with whom, if report speaks truly, he holds a more friendly communication than with the English Government, and like whom, (lest his courage should be doubted,) he will probably shOrtly an nounce a determination " to die in his last ditch." How stands the case, however, between his Dutch MAJESTY, the Belgic people, and the Powers of Europe ? On what pretensions does, or rather did he found his claim to the Belgic throne, and the allegiance and affections of the Belgic people ? Was it on legitimacy and Di vine right ? Was he not a foreigner in Bel gium till the year 1814, when the Allies, having agreed that Belgium should not remain annexed to France, bestowed on him a sort of feudal sovereignty, unable to concur in any other dis position of the spoil ; and did he not thenceforth rule by a sort of mongrel title, legitimate on the 'right bank of the Scheldt, and non-legitimat e on the left ? Were the Belgians consulted, and !in what way ? Did not his MAJESTY convoke an Assembly of the States, and propose for their acceptance certain Articles as the basis of a Con stitution ? Were they not rejected by a ma jority of the Members present ? Did not his MAJESTY then decree, that the absent Mem bers should be considered as having voted for the Articles, and that they were accepted ? Did he not tax the Belgic people to pay the in terest on the Dutch debt ? Did he not govern Belgium wholly by Dutch Ministers, and ex clude all Belgians from office ? The better to display Dutch supremacy, did he not ordain that the Dutch language should be used in the Belgic courts of justice, which language the Belgians did not understand ? Did he not quarrel with their churches ? Did he not en slave their press ? Were not these some of the blessings of Dutch rule in Belgium ? Could it then be matter of much surprise even to his MAJESTY, that the Belgians, when CHARLES X. was expelled the throne, feeling that a free and powerful State sympathised with their wrongs, seized the first moment to throw offthe yoke, and assert their independence? The despotic Sovereigns of Europe, who have calmly looked on, and now rejoice at the fate of Warsaw, would equally rejoice if the same fate still awaited Brussels,—but were his Dutch MAJESTY another Autocrat, and able to enact a like part, would the French people, and dare the French Government, permit it ? Dis appointed in his efforts to regain possession of the Belgic throne by treaty, counter-revolution, and force, has he not sought, and does he not still seek, to enthral all Europe in a war, as other worthies sometimes endeavour to promote a We have some advices from Mexico which are of interest to our commercial readers. A circular from the Department of Justice recites that great abuses having been committed in the sale of shipwrecked vessels and their cargoes at Vera Cruz, it is directed that all vessels and car goes shall remain in possession of the owners, or if preserved for them by others, that an inventory shall be first taken i❑ the presence of the Alcalde, or in his absence in that of respectable citizens. The contributions and list of subscribers of various societies are published, which have been organized for the purpose of promoting manu factures, in compliance with the recommendation of Government. A proposition to permit the Government to emit bills at a premium of five per cent. per month, to the amount of two millions of dollars, payable at designated places in money, or in duties laid, or to be laid, was discussed in the Senate on the 3d September, and adopted by a large majority. The Congress of Tamanlipas have declared Don FRANCISCO V. FERNANDEZ, and JUAN N. MOLANO, duly elected Governor and Lieu tenant-Governor of the State. The Treasury Report is a very voluminous document. It appears from it that the receipts of the year have amounted to 12,200,000 dollars. It is estimated that the expellees of the year beginning July 1, 1831, will amount to 20,499,680 dollars, and will fall short of last year by 8,000,000 dollars. The conclusion of the report presents a favourable picture in every respect of the improvement in the revenue and in the finances during the last economical year. The 16th September, being the anniversary of the declaration of independence in Dolores, the streets and houses were ornamented, and the city of Mexico was illuminated the same evening. On the same day the communication was com pleted between the mine Rayas or Guanahuate, and the work intended to connect it with the mine called the Canon of St. Simon. This communication would be of great advantage to the whole Republic. The Governor of Zaca tecas gives a good account of the working of the mine of Ascura. He complains, however, of the want of workmen. A spirit of industry is said to pervade the remotest parts of the Re public. The State of Queretaro was about renewing its ancient woollen manufactures with great advantages. The large cotton manufac tures which arc to be established near the capital were to be soon commenced. In Pornaro Marquili, on the Pacific Coast, in the Michoacar, an enterprise was on foot to esta blish a pearl fishery. A proposition in Congress to abolish the Bank des Ayes was undergoing much discussion in that body and in► the State Legislature. The report brought to Jalapa of the first effect of the representations of Colonels ARISTO and DURAN created much uneasiness, which was soon terminated by later advices. Congratula tory messages were sent to the Congress from Legislatures of other States on this occasion. The Governor of the State delivered an in teresting address, at St. Louis Potosi, at the in stallation of the Junta Protectora, for the en couragement of industry, particularly in the branches of mining, agriculture, and the useful arts. The want of funds only, he observed, had prevented the rich mineral treasures of Potosi from being advantageously employed. We understand that the cause of KEMBLE v. CHAPMAN, for infringement of the patent rights of Covent-garden theatre by the latter, when proprietor of the Queen's theatre, is set down for trial on Tuesilay next. Considering the time that has elapsed (two years) since the ground of action occurred, and that Mr. CHAP MAN has long ceased to be connected with the Queen's theatre, we regret that Mr. KEMBLE should have been advised to continue the proceedings. The Fire King, M. CHABERT, died on Sa• turday—the cause, an internal inflammation, by taking pboophorus..—Bettl* Chronicle, FRENCH PAPERS. (From the Morning Herald.) We have received the whole of the Paris Papers of Wed nesday, and the Messager des Chetbres and Gazette de France dated yesterday. The dntii-o?ncial journals announce the important facts that on Tuesday last the Prussian Ambassador at Paris, Paron de Werther, received from his Government full powers to conclude a Convention relative to a general dis armament, and that similar powers had been received by M. D'Appony, Austrian Ambassador, from his Court. Although no account of the actual entry of the Duke of Orleans and Marahal soult into Lyons had been received in Paris tip to four o'clock on Wednesday, no doubt was entertaibea of the speedy submission of the revolters. Several additional arrests of suspected persons took place in Paris on Tuesday. On the other hand, some of the individuals previottilv arrested were set at liberty. It now appears that the gunpowder se'zed lately at Belleville (an outlet of Paris), was destined for the Csrlists of La Vendee. PARIS STOCK EXCHANGE, Nov. 110.—Five per Cents. 951. 'Cc. 951. ; Three per Cents., (SSE 70c. 00c. 68f. 70c. ; Bank Actions, ; Rente de Naples, 81f. 50c. 4 1f. 25c. ; Rente d'Espagne, 1004 ; - Royal Spanish Loan, 7:3.,',•% 71; Rente Perpetuelle d'Es pagne, 57 , 4 58%; Haytian Loan, 2.551. Exchange on London, one month, paper, 23f. 20c. , money, 251. 20c. Three months, money '251 - PRICES OF THE STOCKS DAY AT ONt O'CLOCK. Bank Stock - 3 per Cent. Red B9N, 1 4 '2 I India Stock :1 pet Cent Cons. - Ditto Bonds " 4 dis. 3% per Cent...« ........... sp, South Sea Stock Ditto Red 89Mi!,', Old Annuities New:3%per Cent - New Ditto ............ ......... - 3 per Cent Ann. 1720 - 3 per Cent. Ann. 1751 .... - 4 per Cent. 1826 .........9S7i 9!c, Ex. Bills, £1,000......... 6 6 prr. Bank Long Ann. to expire Ditto 500 6 7 pm. Jan 5, 180' - Ditto Small ........ ...... 5 6 pm. Oct. 10, :569 — Ditto Commercial Jan. 5, 1860 16 13-16 Ditto Advertised Jan. 5, 1880 - 'Bank for Opening April 5, 1890 - India for Account Jan. 5. 1870 IConS. for'Jan. 19 6.3 exICIS OF FOREIGN /limns THIS DAT AT JNI o'cLock. Austrian Bonds Neapolitan — Brazilian Bonds 44 1 4 Peruvian Bonds Ruelos Ayres Bond!. — Portuguese Bonds — Chnian Bonds ...... .......... Prussian, Old Colombian Bonds — Ditto, New Ditto 1821 Oaniti ... — Spanish, Mal 111¢ Greek Bonds — —lBll 13 ,1 4;i, Ditto, 1f325 Guatimala. exican Bonds — 3 per —c. +lto. 1925 3(N I -- Exchange —f. . TO THE IRISH READERS OF THE SUN. THE undersigned begs to acquaint the Irish Public, that he has made arrangements to supply, on all occasion, the SECOND or LATER EDITIONS of this PAPER up to the departure of the Mail, parti culars of which will be published in the Dublin Papers— meantime Country Subscribers will please address their orders without delay to JOHNSTON AND CO. News Agents, Eden-quay, Dublin. Who will have some extra copies containing the King's Speech on the opening of Parliament on Tuesday next, 6th instant, for sale. JOHN KENT JOIINSTON. London, Dec. 2, 1831. ; tie _~ LONDON, FRIDAY EVENING, DECEMBER 2, 1831. CHOLERA MORBUS, OFFICIAL REPORT. COUNCIL OFFICE.-(THIS DAY.) DAILY REPORT of CHOLERA CASES, SUNDERLAND, Nov. 30, 1831. Remained at last report New cases . Total Died. Recovered Remaining at this date, 8 o'clock, A.NI, Cholera Morbus. . 32 . 13 . 45 4 3 . .1 33 row, that they may turn it to account ? The task however has hitherto proved as difficult, as its re sult would be uncertain—were he to succeed, could his Dutch MAJESTY calculate the consequences of the collision ? Has he altogether forgotten the past ?—and is it not possible, that in such an event even Holland once more might not re main to him ? Moreover, are not the sove reigns of Europe, restrained by very powerful motives, from yielding to such a course ? True it is, the brave and heroic Poles, in their strug g l e for freedom have been put down, but does not the spirit that animated their bosoms already pervade, or is it not rapidly spreading, amon g all the people of Europe ? Will arbitrary Sove reigns then willingly bring their troops and people into collision with the troops and people of nations contending for freedom ? Again, is not money the main sinew of war, and do the despots of Europe (at once the principals an d mercenaries of despotism) often move in earne st till assured of being paid ? Can his Dutch MA. JESTY, or will the English people, subsidize them for such a purpose ? We verily believe no Mini ster in England could retain his place one week, who ventured to propose to subsidize the despots of Europe, to wage a war against the liberties of mankind. The English Tories, i n the hope of furthering their own objects, there is little room to doubt, would gladly advocate or adopt such a course ; but the people of Eng. land will never again consent to waste their blood and treasure for such a purpose, whether the pretext be to restore Dutch rule in Belgium— support the legitimate authority of the dearly beloved Don MIGUEL-or, that very convenient and venerable humbug, " the balance of power," that has descended through so many generations, its form and essence ever varying, and in no two xras the same. The King of HOLLAND very possibly en joys great popularity among his Dutch subjects, who, profoundly versed in profit and loss, ap preciate the advantages derived (inter alia) from taxing their Belgic neighbours to pay the interest on their debt, with as much accuracy and acuteness as English boroughmongers ap preciate the power of plundering their fellow subjects ; but the KING and the Tories, in the end, must both succumb. COURT OF CHANCERY, DEC. 1. WINCHESTER AND THORNTON V. YOUNG. Mr. PErvs moved that a person might be appointed to manage The Sun newspaper, and to receive all outstand ing effects belonging thereto, and that in the mean time Mr. Young, the defendant, might be restraine I by injunc tion from interfering therewith in any manner by which the property of the piaintilis might be affected. The bill was filed by the assignees elected under a commission of bankrupt against Mr. Peter Grant, and stated, that in the year 1826 that gentleman purchased The Sun news paper, of which he thereby became the sole proprietor; that in 1828 he sold one-fourth share of the whole con cern to Mr. Young, the defendant, and that the parties thereupon entered into a deed by which it Was stipulated that they should carry on their business in partnership to gether,—tbat Mr. Young should reside in the house where the newspaper was published, and that he superin tend, manage, and conduct the same. Under this deed the paper was curried on until 1830, when a commission of bankrupt having been taken out against Mr. Grant, the assignees proceeded to convert his interest into money, and for this purpose offered the paper for sale. Mr. Young proposed to give 7,500/. for Mr. Grant's shares, and Mr. Westley, a bookseller, offered to give 9,0001., whereupon Mr. Young raised his offer to 9,000/. which the assignees at a meeting of the creditors were authorized to accept. That a deed was prepared to carry into effect the sale at the last mentioned sum ; but that on that day on which it was to have been executed, a further offer was made by the other parties ; that Mr. Young thereupon again increased his offer, and that at length a sum of 13,0001. teas offered by a Mr. Lomax. Mr. Young, however, relying upon the agreement which bad been come to, insisted that be had a right to purchase the shares at 9,000/., and had filed a bill to have his right in that respect declared. The assignees then filed a cross bill, and they now came to the Court to have the property of the newspaper protected, by a receiver and manager being placed over it. The circumstances in which they were placed justified this request, because the property might be, and they alleged it was, in great peril. The LORD CHANCELLOR s id, in a former case con nected with newspaper property, it appeared that next to preventing the publication altogether, the appointment of a receiver was the worst thing that could be done for a newspaper. . . Mr. PEPY6 said the assignee* had considered that, but the duty of protecting the property had left them no alter native. Ile then proceeded to read parts of the answer in which the defendant relied upon his right ender the agree ment to sell to him, and contended that it was im possible for him sticceasfully to rely upon that agreement which had been left unfinished, or that the assignees were to be bound to accept the offer he then made, anotl.er and large offer having since been made. Indeed, the de fendant's own conduct in having at the meeting refused to increase his offers was sufficient proof that he had not in tended to abide by the agreement which was first made. In another part of the answer the defendant admitted the expense of carrying on the paper exceeded the profits. This was of itself ground sufficient to justify the appoint ment of a receiver, because, if the fact were so, the bank rupt's estate might he diminished. It was, besides, ad mitted that there was a debt of 3,000/. and upwards due from the concern ; and this, coupled with the admission that the paper was carried on at a lot*, entitled the as signees to the relief they sought. There were, besides, affidavits in the cause which had been filed, to show that the defendant was committing waste, or so mismanaging the property that his conduct was analogous to waste. In the first place lie would read the affidavit of Mr. Thorn ton, the assignee. Sir EDWARD SCGDEN objected to this affidavit being read. It was filed before the coining in of the answer, and every one of the allegations it contained had been met by the answer. Ile did not mean to dispute that affidavits might he made and read for the purpose of obtaining an injunction after the answer ; but in that case such affida vits must be confined solely to the point of waste, and must show that the waste was continuing. The affidavit which Pepys was now about to read, was by Mr. Thornton, who swore to no one fact positively; but stated a great many things upon his information and belief, which were contradicted in express terms by the answer. The LORD CHANCELLOR said he disapproved, and he had often expressed that disapprobation, of the practice of making affidavits as to the information arid belief of par- ties. As, however, it appeared to be the practice of the Court to admit such affidavit-, lie could not now reject them. The affidavit ought, however, not to be read upon any other points than those connected with waste. Some further discussion took place respecting the ad missibility of .this and other affi.lavita, and ultimately parts of them were read. The affidavits of Mr. Clarke ' and Mr. Hickman were to the effect, that the defendant had said, that sooner than he would permit the assig nees to deprive him of the paper, he would ruin the concern, and sell off every stick and stone belong iag to it : and the affidavits of Messrs. Golding and Ferriday, printers, stating that a newspaper of the circulation of 2,900, with a profit of 01. per diem on advertisements, would produce an annual profit of 3,0001. or thereabouts. Mr. Pepys, therefore, contended, that he had made out a vase for the interference of the Court, by moving that the property of the newspaper was in peril ; and that as, by good management, it might have been pro. fitable, if it had not proved so, it must have been by the mismanagement of the defendant. The Loßn CHANCELLOR asked if the affidavits went no further ; and being answered in the negative, said he had certainly expected, from the nature of the motion, some charge much more specific. Mr. KINDERSLEY and Mr. PALEY were heard on the same side. Sir EDWARD SUCDEN appeared for Mr. Young, the defendant. He said lie certainly nerer recollected a ease in which an order was made for the appointment of a manager of a newspaper ; and if one was appointed in this case he should witch the operations of the order ap pointing the receiver with some curiosity. The Loan Ctr.oicar.toa inquired if the case of " Har mer v. Westmacott" respecting the Aye newspaper, was not a case very similar to the present? Jir EDWARD SUDDEN was Counsel in that case. The application there was for a manager, but it had met with the same fate that the present application must share—the Court refused to interfere. If a manager were to be ap pointed I apprehend (said Sir Edward) it would subse quently have to be referred to the Master to settle the terms of the prragrapha that were to be in. serted in the paper; referred to the Master to ascertiin wheher a leading article was proper to be inserted or not. The Master having decided upon the propriety of inserting that leading article, it would then some before your Lordship, sitting here as Lord Chan cellor, solemnly to pass your judgment upon whether the article would be the safest for the country to appear in The Sun newspaper or •ot. That being so, it would depend probably very much on the political views of the Learned Judge sitting here whether The Sun should con tinue.to illuminate the people at night or not—l spy to illuminate the people at night, my Lord, because that's the great distinction between our Sun and the sox in the horizon--our Sun is always shining ; it shines and en lightens the people in the dark even when the other has withdrawn from our view.—(Laughter.) Suppose your Lordship had a particular line of politics—as a Judge, of onuree, you don't know any thing about politics; but suppose your Lordship were to be so imbued with politics as to find it impossible to divest yourself of all political feeling in your judicial capacity, then you would, of course, decide upon that strain of paragraph or leading article which fell in with your view, politically speaking. The Loan CHANCELLOR—I should be bound to do the best I could for the paper you know—the best I could for this Ward of Court—this Son.—(Laughter.) Sir EDWARD SUGDEN—Certainly you would, and I am quite sure there would not he a paragraph written that the parties would not be coming to your Lordship with to say, just do us the favour to settle this article•--be so good, my Lord, as to give it the proper terms. The LORD Cuar , rcoa--That I certainly should decline.--(Laughter.) Sir E. Suarmi—Probably your Lordship would, but I am perfectly certain that that would be the consequence o f your Lordship's appointing a manager of this news. paper, and I am perfectly positive that the parties would be squabbling from morning till night, and that it would he utterly impossible for the paper to go on one day. My Lord, we are told—l dare say it is not true—but we are told that the politics of newspaper editors have no thing to do with their personal gain. We are told that newspaper editors never think of whether what they write will he calculated to induce a sale of the paper or not; but that whatever they think is for the benefit of society they write it, whether it will be beneficial to the till or not. But suppose it should happen that there were two parties, as in the present case, disagreeing upon the l i ne o f politics, and that the question was to be put to the vote, what situation would we be in befor e the Master ? Why we should have one party saying to the Master, " I can assure you, Sir, that unless Th e S un immedi ately adopts Tory politics, if there are sue h po li t i cs, i w m e na esdhioauld h tely av have the other pa r ty sa yi ng , extinguished, and exti ngu i s h e d 46 It is utterly impossible for Th e S un to continue to shine, unless it adopts Whi g po li t i cs, if Whig politics there be." And in that way I am per f ectly forit sill ever;"be 'sure there would be a continual cotaraversy between the parties. My Lord, as regards myself, Ido confess that on this occasion I am in a dilemma--a pleasant dilemma I acknowledge it to be, because whether I succeed or whether I fail in opposing this motion, I shall, as far as I am myself concerned, succeed, If I can satisfy you that the I:lotion ought not to be granted, I shall theta suc ceed fot• my client, which is my most anxious wish. If I fail for my client, and a change takes place in the politics of The Sun newspaper, which at present advocates so forcibly and so admirably one line of politics, with which I confess I don't quite agree, then the result will be a benefit tome as far as my political views are concerned. —( A laugh. ) But, my Lord, to be serious on the subj , ct, I believe there never was a case in which there was less pretence this the present fur the interference of this Court. There is not a single allegation of misconduct brought against my client Mr. Young,—on the contrary, it is shewn that be has increased the sale of this newspaper by his zeal and by his activity, in a way that seems to me to be truly astonishing. The Loan CHANCELLOR—I think Mr. Pepys you said, the sale was increased from 100 to five and thirty hundred copies a day? Mr. PErvs--lies. Sir EDWAFID Silt:MEN—Yes, my Lord, that is about the statement. Now this was a newspaper which Mr. Grant gave 500 guineas for in the year 1826. Ile gave 500 guineas for the whole of it, machinery and all-500 guineas for it in one lot. And I must st y that knocking down The Stan at that pride was—l don't know how to ex press it—but certainly was taking a prodigious liberty with that luminary. Five hundred guineas for The Sun al together !—(lNlncls laughter.) I confess it appears to me to have been a great deal too little. Accordingly, when my client came into it, he very soon raised its value ; and your Lordship will hear from the answer, that from that moment its value increased daily, In two years after my client came to the concern he gave within a fraction of 2,0001. for a fourth of it, and by the deed of copartner ship he was to have the whole and uncontrouled management of it. He was to draw for his subsistence a certain sum—eight guineas a week, and if the profits exceeded a given sum, then he was to draw an additional sum. Now, my Lord, my client, Mr. Young, stands at this moment precisely in the situation which he has always filled, and which by the articles of copartnership he was made to fill. He is in no respect different to what ho was. The situation of his copartner is altered, but his own situation remains the same, and from the moment that he commenced his management of the paper it has gone on to flourish. I think Mr. Grant says that he bought the whole concern for 500 guinea-, and his own moderate estimate of the value of it now is. 20,000/. Mr. Young himself, which is not disputed, paid bona fide 2,000/. for a fourth of it in the year 1828. It is expressly stipulated by the deed of copartnership that he shall reside at the house from which The Sun issues its rays, and that he shall have the exclusive management of it. Sir Edward Sugden went over a part of the terms of the partnership deed, and said,—from this your Lord ship perceives it was expressly stipulated Mr. Young should reside in the house, and carry on the business. Now, what your Lordship wants to start with, for the purpose of entertaining this motion, must be this fact, that Mr. Young has, since the bankruptcy, conducted this news paper in a manner different from what he conducted it before the bankruptcy, and that lie has been involving it in a course of expense which was not incurred before. Well, then, there is not a single syllable to show he has in any way altered the conduct of the paper. He began his management upon the precise course which he is now pursuing with so much success ; and all the fault that is found with him is, that his partner having become bankrupt, be has not got so large a sum of ready money to pay to him as he would wish to receive: nay, so far from the paper having been in any way deteriorated in value, Mr. Young himself has offered to give 9,0001. for the bankrupt's three fourth shares, including also certain liabilities, and therefore there is a positive increase in the value of the paper, since Mr. Young purchased his faurth, and since the bankruptcy occurred. If we look at the thing as it stands, the value of the paper having been fixed at something like 14,000/. or 15,0001., which Mr. Grant only a few years ago gave 500 guineas for, it is certainly one of the most flourishing concerns that any person could possibly hear of or desire to have. But, my Lord, some people are unreasonable ; and one of the unreasonable notions here is, that you, Mr. Young, notwithstanding you have thus increased the value of the paper to so enor mous an extent—that you have not got a great deal of eady money to let us participate in the enjoyment of. We never found fault with you before—we never had °e vasion to complain of your management of this paper, which began in beggary and misery, until the present moment—and now we are in avant of money and cannot hare it ! What shall we say of an old established paper like The Sun, selling for 500 guineas ? Why, it is clear the circulati.in of it must have dwindled down to an amount merely nominal; and no capital having been required to purchase it—no capital having been brought into the concern by the bankrupt, how was it pos sible to raise the paper to the condition it has now arrived at except by incurring certain liabilities, and by applying from time to time the profits as they accrued in the ex tinction of the liabilities, and carrying into effect the plans laid down for increasing its circulation ? Is i t to be con sidered that the paper is to be raised by magic to a valua tion something like 15,0001. or 16,000/. ? Is that to be done without liabilities? The truth is that Mr. Young adopted certain plans as regards the management of a newspaper which everybody has seen, and which hag been copied by other papers. I believe he is the person who first began, and has kept up, the sending off expresses. He is the person who first began giving the details in a sort of summary, which now you see in every Evening Paper, of all the news in the Morning Papers, very much to the convenience of the readers of newspapers; and now the affidavits which I did not want read—l did not want them read because I thought the admission of them was against the practice of the Court—those affidavits chew that the circulation of this newspaper in Mr. Young's management has been increased from about 400 to four anti thirty hundred copies a day—and indeed that appears from their own affidavits. Well, then they have been so good as to read affidavits, as I have said much against my wish, but affidavits which censiderably make for me, affidavits shelving that Si. a day for advertisements is received, and that the paper has a circulation which ought to pro luce a profit yearly of 3,500/. Why, ray Lord, the truth is that the answer admits a profit to be made nearly to the same amount. There is nothing so mistaken as tor my Learned Friends to suppose that we represent no profit ta be made. To he sure there is no till-box—there is no drawer into which the pounds, shil lings, and pence are thrown, and in which the profit is contained, but the profit goes to increase the capital ; and they have not been able to skew even by all their informa tion and belief, the misapplication of one single shilling of this property. There is no charge against Mr. Young of having misapplied one single farthing of the property, and when they talk of a debt of 3,000/. I could tell your Lordship on an affidavit, just as good as the affidavits they have produced, that one-half of that debt has been paid off, and that the other half is now in a regular course of payment. It was a large stationer's debt, but one-half of it Iran been paid off, and the other half is being regu larly liquidated. Wily, is it possible to suppose, that any man living could increase a newsp per like this, from the state in which it was, to a state in which it ought to produce 3,500/. profit a year, without money or credit ? I have always considered that credit is capital when rightly applied. If there has not been capital there must have been credit and talent. There has been the talent of this editor, there has also been his credit, and nobody even now is disposed to find fault with him, nobody has found fault with him, and noboby comes forward so to do ! Why, I had expected to hear of the stationer coming into the office for this large debt of 3,000/. and pressing for payment. I had expected to hear urgent demands being made for the payment of type. I had expected to hear of the clamour of creditors on all liantb, but nothing of the sort. There is not a single individual coming forward to ask for a single shilling—not a person asking for a farthing—no statement except that Mr. Young has raised the value of the three-fourths of this paper to 15,000/., the whole paper having cost 500 guineas, and they are now complaining that he has not got a great deal of ready ,money to put into their pockets ! But, my Lord, one of my Learned Friends who spoke very sensibly, and I am not disposed to find fault with his observations, stated what my other Learned Friend did not think it discreet to advert to. He said that they were willing that Mr. Young should be at liberty to propose himself to the Master as the ma nager of this newspaper. Why he is already the manager of the newspaper, and he has managed it in such a way as to benefit the concern a refer ( t m o, not.t o to the greatest extent. But they desire him to lie the manager of it under a Master of the Court of Chan cery, whether and h e t o have is properly'e your m Lnaugeidnsghip to Now anything so absurd I think could hardly be sug gested. I don't wish to take advantage of what my Learned Friend may have stated inadvertently, but I lay hold of it to this extent, namely, to infer from it that it a the paper must have been the subject of convert ttion out of Court. My Lord, I wish to impress on your Lordship's mind that Mr. Young is precisely in the same situation now that lie 'has ever been in by the articles of copartnership, and that he is only now exercising the power which be hat hitherto exercised, and which is very material for y, to hear in your recollection. Sir Edward S adverted to the manner in which the affidavi' brought forward by the other side—affidavits lion and belief filed before the coming in fendant's answer, and used to contradict the an! he designated as a manoAivre and trick, thi! • Court bring that the pl iintilt could onljr tee junction on the disclosures in the defendant The Learned Counsel also adverted to the agt tered into by Mr. Young and the assignees chase by Mr. Young of the bankrupt's thi shares in the paper, at nine thousand poi stated that that agreement had actually been and ready for execution; and that a bill had beet the purpose of compelling a specific perforrnar agreement. That when Mr. Young waited m to hsve the agreement executed at the counti Mr. Thornton, one of the assignees, a sort of tion of the bankrupt's shares in the paper took is fortunate (continued Sir Edwird) that m: Friend the Solicitor-Genet-31, is not now in Coui had been here and heard this, it is probable he mentioned it to the Attorney-General, and then what would have been the result ; we migh have seen some lab,' posted tip at the places wi. ceedings take place, something similar to the la, see in certain parts of town, warning us to ' bad plaves"—labels bearing the inscription auctions." Mr. Young, my Lord, found 1 , with other persons—fearful odds against him. h nerve, the solicitor of the assignees, and foi persons who came forward for the purpose of this farce. When Mr. Young called to get the signed, the assignee told him, why Mister will give so much more than you, t' c,tnnot let you have it for the sum named. Mr. Young said, why, I cannst let tu come into the concern, and rather than suffer else to come in, I will give the amount in, meaning to give up his right of pre-emption ; get Mr. Young entrapped to offer considerably he had originally offered, this sham auction was seems singular, and it only shows how the when they are acting in their own affairs, may at tunes or allured away from the path that on sions they would in other circumstances have prudent course to pursue : it is singular, bl Mr. Young states that one feeling whirl him to go on bidding, was a curiosity how far the other parties would farce, and as fast as the assignees told by him th it he would give such and amount, they went into another room, ant ret ing that so much more was bid—and really singularities here is that the parties were not same room—they were not brought face to face, Young w.,s kept in one room, and that they trig! him the other parties remained in another room ing been told that Mr. Young would give 9, withdraw into the other room, then into Mr. room, and say that 10,0001. is bid—without At knowing whether it had been really hid or Young immediately said, why, if that be the give 10,0001. ; and rea'ly it was the most tion that ever took place. I should not it had Wen followed it had led in the result suit, but most people know that a Chancery I the very best mode of terminating proceedings. they proceeded until they got the bidding up deralile extent. Another point of importance, is, that in this ease there has been no exclusion. weeks after the bankruptcy the assignees sent office an accountant, who examined all the papers, and who reported that he was - accounts. They knew, therefore, the e, the receipts, having had all the accounts aH !mints before them, and never having found any of them. The LORD CIIANCELLOR-Doer Mr. Young explanation of that particular conversation whicl. to have taken place between him and the person the affidavit in which he is represented to have to ruin the paper. Sir EDWARD SUDDEN-0 yes, my Lord ; tha' sation is represented to have taken place by a the name of John Perry Clarke, who was . from the office by Mr. Young, months before, for duct; Mr Young positively denies that such a tion ever took place. The LORD CITA NCFLLOIL—Was he discharged count of making that representation ? Sir EDWARD SUDDEN—NO, my Lord, he discharged months before for previous was long after his discharge that he trumps ul versation, and your Lordship knows that it is to find a person who has been discharged fur to swear to a previous conversation. The LORD CHANCELLOR--Certainly. Sir E. SUDDEN—Mr. Yuting positively and nits it. The Learned Counsel now commented I lerable length on the evidence, arguing that there being any thing like waste in this case,. been nothing but the best of husbandry, and an ingenious, energetic, and lively address, by if ever a case of good conduct on the part of of had come before the Court of Chancery it was sent ca.e, in which nothing had appeared but tl was creditable to the character of Mr There had not been a single attack his integrity or his efficiency. The consequen ferring this case to the Master to appoint ger would be to have the parties contint the Master--it would be utterly to destroy the of all parties ; and he (Sir Edward) entertained that the Court would instantly dismiss the a r . Mr. JEatMETT followed on the same side, an , anxious to occupy as little of the time of the Co' sible ; but considering the importance of the client, he having embarked all his property in paper i❑ question, he felt it to be a duty on hint to draw his Lordship's attention to se. culars. The bill was filed by the plaintiffs on the May last. On the same day the affidavit of Mr. ton, as well as the affidavit of the person who had missed for misconduct from The Sun Clarke, had been filed, and from this it was to that the object was, if po , sible, to have rate injunction ; hnt on re-considering the vale materials, it would appear that the plaintiffs consider them sufficiently strong to au' to apply to the Court. Mr. Young's . in, and then of course they were informed could only recover upon the facts disclosed in Notwithstanding this on the present occasion, read the affidavits, which had actually been Vie coining in of the answer, with a view to the answer. It was material for the Court to bear what the charges against Mr. Young were. The charges were these—that Mr. Young wanted to the shares of his bankrupt partner at an under value wanted to prevent others purchasing them at a that he bad not any ready money to supply the with, and that, in conversation with a person of t} Clarke, he had threatened to ruin the concern. plaintiffs producing affidavits it was to have been that such affidavits would have gone to sup! charges ; so far from that, however, being the was not a single charge attempted to be by the affidavits, except the conversation wh; had alleged he had had with the de which had been refuted in the most matinee.. Not only was that statement of Clarke dieted, but upon the coming in of the answer evi tion in the bill, and every thing in the shape was positively contradicted or satisfasworily affidavit had been filed on the part of the the coining in of the answer to support any of gations ; and it was l a id down in 1 ° Milbenk v. 2tl Merivale, that the Court would not appoint a managing partner in any trade, except upon case being made for so extraordinary an int this were the principle which governed the Co" ordinary trade, how infinitely much more was ciple to be adhered to with respect to a newspaper was no charge of extravagance brought forwat Mr. Young there was no statement that b e industry, or that he was deficient in talent. trary of all this was shown. Mr. Young gave time, and attention, and ability to the of the paper ; he did not live in an e. nyinner, or in a situation which his station ciety did ❑ot fully authorise ; and by his his tention, and ability, he had, as had alreadY stated, raised the circulation of The Sun news; degree that it could not but strike every person Adverting to what took place bet' Young and the assignees, when the defendant 9,0001. for the bankrupt's shares, he also offered all the liabilities of the concern upon his own and which was a circumstance of no t r ifling ance. He stated subsequently to Mr. Thorr he thought he had made a bad bargain, Thornton, instead of being dissatisfied with Al conduct of the paper observed, " I have no doubt your exertions and management of the paper make a good thing of it." Mr. Thornton was to be distinguished from the other assignee, Al' man Winchester in this affair, and the manner I for y. ur ward Stagriet,l°lY not bt affidavits h l a l ltl i tw e. e . % r b ti la ti : i e i c h l i t se cn d t t h f h e a l idavits on is 4 : n g but fa'r ing in ofth r „Y, h "oottrabl t the ansaver., ^r opt's sir .k, the rule r t,T i t P een bid 1 Illy ni6ve fdr h a of the E on , lefendant's :li n t at th e rm the agr. eniffitt Probably ignees for thil e a lready b, Tea three '0„ ~r e could Ili ratted jraainiydbpoeenontitniie,elv.vt,lo,ll;bpoinneions,i, II had been f il y q „. g',. The erformanee o 1 t - ' r ing . earl counting-Ott e , all nov e sort of r onehk, ti l `; and per took plie t ae nt rt could h, that my el Ai a PPlieatic p $ v in Court, W o lit t , l l% IlAcost table he n , ou 1r d, and tl ad then I cao "ono 4 ,-,a 1 e might, ,:lti ttL at the ,ees where aill , ii ii "d states! o the lab!l mill a e d .; RiNnE us to ‘‘ bereta, not m. riptien of ',l, „1° 14, t teti e mar mind birrsell)st. 4 l o f the k st him—the rh - tr a fine „ and four It „ that Ali rpose of OP t e v - 4 4 , 0 4 or t ) get the age t pt - Lot liberi Mister SA, 4 ° o to 1 u, therefore,r,itltPer-_, sum you , r,, i e Loßn c ant let anyhn fii; 4 41 t° rtling t suffer any /li t i r t t'Per p e Haunt myself , iit hey creased c ption ; and t h t i tte r when alerably me i It„!,• ICI/in } ion wa s g ot'' , ka '''' the pot tw the wise 0 k i Ov -heo tie rs, may be I t ' t h e s Pecu/at. that on other, pl c % t unpr s have though; 3 7 had a , ;ular, but or r; til oto an which in t te e ' Mr, j curiosity to Ti t :: it to ti 'ould care/ ia t i Loon ',nets had th 'ealey's o Leh and su e ," t h , e i t the at really y r e onetn e' of tl il tre4 l 4 e atly tt , er t , ae 're not all l $ d r u g ? g e h e ir e v t y r o eo n f o, a a m i c , g s :4 o t ao b n f l u r; : r t. t i dy ti; , e b } : x t 1 : , Court a t E i nto Mr. l 1 . 1 1 , 41 .,g like shout Mr. I r. ti lt - Loan I hid or not. 0 4 '04 en eoting be the cafe Maki' °ek bi id il l PC. k most singti- jd 1 o t her 1 . 1 - boa ingted i n u g p s . 1,1 not wouo''Clr, y and, if he result 0 ,1 14 th .„ . ea ng's c to g o ° " o l 4 l4 lo eri t i ° l4l.4 i ii t t h ae , r,in 4.' fagnew to ll' ree ' n o l ' , 2l l: r o }: r, e honesty suit ll o t. Al t ,, t- 1,. rr tance, lily ' i y 4 th e ' to ti elusion. Is asst s, • *ay n o _.es sent iun t i t° 4 e° (tool to h tti i • all the boo, 6 r e h h. , )e'n g i satisfied oil', The 4 his I expenditureta, v, his and aH the th 4e w i d , found fault lia e i . ° he et Oat 41 drivi , r E tva • Young Pl7l work' rig an which is -t,, • . s um ..a,,, , he person Ilk ea • 13 ' . a to have thre a ritcl, g d et hent orb ; that C O :vei l , : 'Sec 'et f sl br c ye h ' af a orP cus ehre?;724ai4ll;:rh:tv'n: o was disrl' it _lry : a fess( tli " 'thereti lt , I discharged °° l td t . "' t he Dr( v N I , eict,.he in( ard, he haa t: The )supi r miscondia - t kre • l orm umps up ik sak, ent t ' d t fiotr is i:L rini°'i.°l'll:t4ju:l'egn: no %at: a Pproaei l 'ai,,, 'lion c , 'el). and flst l i t ,,, t ; Itt„, n meo r e d at ,c9lie-C'e,en( el l t4 ust °. b e c that jus t )5(4 - arnot ini 3 case, thel e g ifre, l l ic.uld i,„ y, and con Ai, 11) on, , ,tt. a sk _ Ye , :ss, by sallno,,i't , ''''en sal of par,to aY art one ~ to rt Part it was the ;,'`o r %Plain, t ed but that 00 1 ° J)it l e i t !'t to, 1 of Mr. 1 1 mi lar 4 i n at tttack Mau e r Ztiiir t; ! l ands msequenee 0 ,, t., tri l ,i, n that appoint 0 s 0 ' ti lt t s al continually r i eitti cap- art stroy the is li i t by 4 , by ter tained 0 " ~, a 4 ti, t h e 1 be applicatl'''/::l inter tout' side, and b e 7 ', 4 te r .2nsiti • the Court l l ', l i' WI ) ' ;''Y in' of the case v,, 'a the th e d in the ' 1 i lie "tit, ' erty a duty ine°;l4 then n to severold ~ta . 'w o ills on the i',A, i' l ls the I ,, h t 'it of Mr. '') i lit I,,_"eptil who had bee t :, ' l l • ari l , I ' far el tun office, f d it'), 44 aug was to be ind , , b ete •• ti Ma obtained s 0 11 :lk:: h° ei the value n j 0 ,att,,, to tb, plaintiffs d i 0 4 ~%t t itt "i er Ivry r authoris e d iigitl i i: lt reat hg's answer oi 0 , 7) II 1 d a a, sal formed tbet/ ,lati t - be pc led in hie 1 10 V eat rit a Otipefi li :casion, tb e ,, t ' r fi 144 4 4 1::" of been filed 't . tliatoi iew to roS tr / • ' rt to bear indite THE. re. The ei anted topn r ,,,"th l h, ider value; fr l i l l4e,,lt . : t e was ti m at a fair'', ti k jt t ,',,arict , I i rk 1 r s etc', pply the ) . 4 „ kiln ed son of the °% oncern. oncern. I-le t ) ii: b lish ave been C$ ilf '''"ei;' '''''' to support r o i t.7: ing the eas e l • at as 'll,. to be tur,., l e.rat I t ri on which t'i3OaLki4uel,a,r's r„ deft n driti/ii i t i A b t e „tk b il t r hi most esti° Ist;h, ''ri. t, f Clarke's : 0 4"4Dei, 4 4 t ewer ever,' V p it I NTI f, shape of ol e i ti YI N , z eta i . , ily explait 3 ',N t iorn the plaintis",l,,,'':lciii4e)i)at any o f those "s p it 114)14 1a,,,, , i 1l Ink V. Riee t YareZte tl ; l ick..._ ta s 0 oin t a reeei ve l,,SlatstlostiT s upon theate ° 0 gtiki t 7uoljg Isti a v vi interferen oe , 0 the Court ; 'it , tea s • lit re was .t sP r f t i e. , ewspaper• 01' . 1 4 , forward 4,,,te' G, at be land ' - c oot t i ttt, alent. 0 , ,, 41; . ;,... ........ mg gave his 0 / 0 '' ..... the manage asap I h a i station h t l ab t r i : f ivt : f t, ; I ' 1 11 ii il t r t hi . ;, 1 n ; ; i • . . ..... 1. ... : ad already 01 16 0, \PeIY 4,01 ! a newspap e r or el . and person Wi t ' ill t ' ~,, ace betwee li fat ''OL • of fs PI va h iefendant i r I, t ad psi SO offered t° jeMt h °ltl ) ., s own sP ui r ot 4l 4, ° ' &c. 3 trifling i n ' s to / Silj: lla ro n i , Thornto n jal,'ltt l i n gs. ), rgain, bni„ 0 0L, t 4, 145 shop with Mr. %"0 1 ; 1 , read p( no doubt ti - 01, k A d paper y°L'o,l;,_%t,h ~•!ret; to was verilvoir;°isl, ir k: y sase Alt. ) 1 . loakm r n I ' if r on. aanner irt ........ ?nod, ark