The Sun. — London, England, 1816-08-19 00:00:00

. , ...„. . . . , .. elrctunstanees , fount ) lortretteht",tne Culltv ; and, lOf June, 1 SII. n conscipc,:ce of the imigtnent, upon a subseq ueotapplication by the No ble Lord ad in obedience to th d e older ot the tourt, 'wit.- for a ne W'rrial, the -Court were satisfied frith the a n s conveyed the defenant to the Kings Betteli verdict, and refitsed to enter into a new inquiry. Prison, in execution of his seotence, 'end deliver - The necessary consegnence was, that Lord C. re- ed him jaw the eustmiy o f Litz, jail:A . l -; -Witness ceived sentence of conviction, and %vas adjudged to afterwards sail"„„t (In the 2 lit of , b e committed to the custody of the Marshal of the March 1 $l3„, about two in the afternoon, in the V.l n ool Bench Prison for the term of twelve klouse of Coin:nuns, NO, w:th the aliislanre of calei-idar ;Tomtits, ;snip 10 pay n fine of 100 Q/.. Ali% iones; the Marshitt,i Air. Brooshoeft, 0.,e De and to he further i m prisoned until that fine shinildr ' puty Marshal, LaVender; tire Bow-street . officer,.. b e p aid. Lard • Cochrane therefore - had two Poole, a tip-staff, and another officer , took him -. thivws to perform, and which it title obedience and into custody, and cooeyed bilithac , CO the 1 , 4.1'403 to l lonissiort to the laws of his country required of Bench, end replaced hint in eOtifittement. .1 . ~. L ar d „ WM, ,lI3MeIV, with: patieuce . to await the expira- crossrexarroneaoy e ,oct-te,Niee. . tjoo 'of his imprisonment.; and cheerfully to pay ' Tiy mot . ituthojity did ycia 'ci)nvey.liord . &eh • that fine vltieli the justice of his country had - -rane froet the Court of King's Bench to' the King'S ' imposed igloo him . . The period of It's imprison- -. Bench Prisoo on the 2lst of June, '1.31 I.?- , -A.. 1.. teent would, have expired, by efflex of time, on ' was present in Cotti.r, ;old heard your Lordship's 'fit! tiVetitV.filst day of Jiffies 1815, the sentence sentence pronotmeed by thc Judge ; anti 'in per. having been passed upon hint on the' same day - of ' formance of '•nry thity,tis direcfell'hy the Court, I June, in the preceeding y,ar, 18)4. One of the . took your .Lordship to,the King's Bench Prison, tharges against the defendant was, that he esearied . itt e x ecution of your sentence. I delivered you to from prison before the twelve tootitits expired. the Turnkey,' in obedience to my - onto s. Another was, that he took an opportunity of mak- Q. `leas the Marshal present when you deliver ing hi s etie ,p e ' b e f o re t h e 10001, ti ne 'it o ispaitt; , - Cti Lord Cochrane into the eustody;ol the Tian and lie (the Learned Cottitsel) . Was in 'ir''sittottion kev i , --A. The Mii nr•dial was not,present „ . . to prove Ihese ehat:ges most satisfactorily. lit the Q. DO you consider a zkdiVerance:. to the turn first place, ) . ecauce th e time of his imprisonment. key a deliVerauce to the custody of the ,Nlarshal of had, Iwo e lapsed cit ilie period ofliiii-Cietrptii which' the; King:s Beech, and do you know whether the took place Ur , the month of'Marell',"lBl"sl"between tomlicy had any ant hove yto act I—A. I know three and four months befttre the expiration of the nothing of the authority 44 the turnkey ; I acted year; and, senondly, because LordCoehrane hod in obedience 'to "lily orderS, and I delivered your actually. paid the title at a period stibserinent to • Lordship into .tht•cuitmly , -of t h .e. T urn key' 04 t i, Isis liberatimi---nantely, at the 3d of, July, 1813. • .crY.utit of the iklarShal- ~,-. , .• Tin , . orotecetiOn v.•is inritlttited by the Marshal Of 0. 14ad Foe ; any a o hority to act On that OcCa- th e [cl og . .. B enc h 1 1 1 .1:oit, vi 110, nropedy ,Petiking, • ' . SI OII ?'" L A. • I lia i il no •• a uthority'ro'aet by exaelit the was the person who bad Lord toehtune in cos:- 'verbal orders of the Lord Chief Justicttiosvhieh I n dy, and ten() it is in soni c ' de g ree simenaltle:to were quite tic icitt for ute,- .1 was prestmt art the plibrie for the derention,of per , -; , ns . cominit led the proc,..cding, and he;oil :he . .fullge's orders pro to his charge. If the Marsh -11 pet-rented soul, uonoced ; with which I immediately crimplied, persOni to escape volunta r ily he was li,dde to tilt tool delivet•ed your Lordship into the custod y of indictment, and very severe punishment.' The , the Ittrukcy• ...u.nrshai. luta 6,0 objects io yiety by ins.4ituting ~. W. Will yon take noon yourself to swear, that th e .present prOseetition—the most pritminent of the. person into who..e enstody , y ou delivered Lort,l :which it-:1:, his own ritolie.ition from all snspicion ,Cete,hranc was a Tori.key :tidy, authorked t o Ac t of c o noivitoee at the defend;int's escape , and•the ,as snch 'i—A.l know ;lot hine tit the persoo's au dio., next .V , li, to hold out to the hundreds' of per- rity : he acted as Turnkey, tools 1 deliVered yonr arms cot rest ed to Ili'i custody, that there was Lordship Into his custody, ts at tiog officer on no po , sibilily Of escaping , without pttnish.- duty. .. ment for such au riffence, by siletvin4 that ' Q. Will you taktetipon yourself to say that the even a, lICI'SOII P f the highest. ,railit. hi , the persons, is to whose custody you delivered' Lord realm could not• violate. the laws ,tif his coentry .:Coehrnne, were renlly Terokeys.? with imirmity. , In whit winner ,the defendants .. ;qr. Justice Iluato.mou.—The only titiestion is, . esca pe' w a s effected the. prosecutor end. his entinSel .were they actiug ;is soils at the time; wt.+ e they 'vvere - titterly ignorant.. 'Whether it was,doue by then on duty ;Is turnkeys ?--A. They were the persons %rho .opened ,the gates, and were oil duty •-strat'agem, or by,.assistance from without the pri. ~ V ini walls, the prosecutor, as wholly tutinformed: :. g Ole ,!il' l e. , .• , `'. he knew it was tiot_done•;by.his:,own contriv.tece, Q. 03Y Lord Coc It it V 4.0 —"Will you take upon ...o r „b ya i l y contr io lto ce to ,, v a t icielte . was pi ivy.-- ~yoot.self to s wear that they hitd " the run of the Lord Cochrane' was 'suet) for thetas( time by the . Itey.?"---4,., I ii0!,, , ,E know_ of any such circum stance.; 'they ?peep the Mar:ll4l's servantS, awl ' atteliclaßlS of the prisoll 011, Sotord,ty (ht.! tit It of Illarcli ;' and he was tin t missed nntil a dly or two . acted.tind Ur his orders,, p , .„ afterwards.; and .4 iv, e! ,is; not recap( tired mull the 'Q. : The..Nlarshal was present 'f --7,1. No ;he ' . 21st of the:same 'Month. T herefuses reason to , wns.oot. ~., . , , , • Suppose; that snort after,liis escape.Lorti Cochrane Q. Do you conlider th,e delivet yof ,Loid Cods .. . o .,i s ,„,‘,„,,, : .„ o , t i oils to ' r eearn to sonfinemerit when , nine. at.the time to the turnkeys, ,nalelivery to the be was aware- of tite.: - ' consequenaes. With. the e .;),lareltril, the :11arsItal, not dreiog present !----A. I , • • oulti..'es di iris t onduci,%etystlie.nicans of his .4 .'-'sl'e , 'cert 3 ,, i 3 O : 7 c°,'"ide Fect i i _ t a: ll :e l , l `: er Y to .the, e'otnt l Y ., " t. • the 3 ~i* hail n othiog toxin! ; .it 1 / 4 1;t14 i s tric.kt3l.4 (bat, 1 : t'e ',.'qarSfiak of. the leing,s, &pelt,: to ottellieutee to be i'V•ayst""ik at birt.le bYtatgeeat, many pet sons be. , the orders of the Court—the principal iiiicers, fol.e the time of :hlt. itailt - iloot4ut bad exp:;red.— ,Mr, Motris,eod :11r. I)eveaot ~ being elicit ale spilt}'. On the- 21. t 'of; ill heiog a , :. . Q., 'rhos , t." the brit of Yonc,tat l, ief, and It'pott • 111etobdr of PaellAthent, was step it, the 1.401,1 e of )01qioeith, yonnevvr szive the ant hor it y upon w hich Co:on:cuts S'Omehouryibefore,theSpeOct.r, took the 1 ,those l personA sett, i•.---A,. l'only know that they chair ; flnd the proiecittor having beard the place I were artitte officers of the prison.. of ili , retreat, west, , io, compatry wirit bis aiii , ;,t.. L t . (44,0.ip,k,qie NarSit .di wits not present ?--- 'out ii• and took bine pristmest oil ate satin! thry, in ,A. 1 hive ids ck,it!y . sald he seta .llOl. ,, '. dill w i ti v ' o f ,11,-111pic,:01,,Couviintil. :11iii %VR3 1 , i lkylopineti . .by 'Mr. Ano i t Rersons . the'isbort. out nue 44 , tlie:'etist. As 'to ,the faets to whop u, the..deteittlantvetrillelivered were.acting - which were necessary to Support this,loilte`t,ment, r o,actterttkeya, t o t tl,ofljecrsof..;the prisott ; ilefltpdane : ' they keoeld be proyett beyoed the pottsibility of was l eleljyered poireipcostody in the osisal way, in doubt. —Tile pi iticiple got' lAN 11ppliCiAbit?, 19 .119 t , whisixal l l m,her perspos,cmtnoitted by t heCoort, of in Wes'. eptite eltetr. . It was sitoplyjbis: the I.,liitoOtsßeochiwete detlystsd,kfi o h e di en.4 c.,tii, t h e • 'Eing's shbieeits. owiql t.hettionee to the ...I.l;4;istrt4 C 3 i ill of ! the Coust, ire,-exeetitiooof their seut‘Face., and' etorstititted authorities r ility were botitol• to ~,; 440140.4 by Me; Justice flu a tt ,,u641,.. its I , r , itilesc ,. t h e ; lieot . en ces w hiell, the Magistrates : ~ Wi,l3llos ,154$,in siteivii,bit of couveyiogprisimers Ilitliiiiilttev(l, .111tiatlit, .1“) ,will' CS1411)1i61101 is as . fo .t.hc.,N'itile+.llett4l.l Vivo', and generally oleli. 'this principle, thnt , - it' 4- , ..toate, Sekttenved En' :the. ,Vel eil thettr. tthe rttoqYlhe same l'gfe,. i • stocks made his- ;esnapei I'lloo7 1110. PeFsQ l l 3 ; 011- .' • hir.,ll)ho Einlinj.el Brooshooft, iNl.tirshal of the powered . - to see thmseuiterter etirried into e-tiectr- King's lie9Cli prom,e-..-The defendant was oM- tion,-Ite' Was liable•?by llie.olti,lnw, to-, be imlieted . s- ,ret claim) of ittett,,to,peimut o eoce, and n the `4lst ; of rem Jane ained last ther, iet: exeuntil - ' : ai'm felon', ITAdonbterliy the laW.iov i otlern,ehoe ,hiA,sent' ' lool'iteen ameliorate:l ,'situp Where t,kicyc..,yas , ,llo. !his eticopc,tcAk,place, which was some tinieiit the ;10 oat'breaeh of ' , prison, ..liot,:' the paPty..ekci9ed Inottlit,of:March. but ~tyittiess could not precisely by 811 a!agtin , or luttnagement, ,Ile. Wa3, i4*t - 'otiste 11 41 4,13 . Y ?, 1 ‘4llol.titst„leard of the,.defett ' ehie' - 'only for.an.io,eape, :or,.'for: ving rat large . :ilatit!S ,9,4stince,frskattlrisopi tiliont the nth (4, tit h 114! fiire'iltt'expiia:ion-tif the time ,of his ilolsrissict j.of-MttrWiti- wily!) 1:1, seArelletl opt' ,l' o mid the de eteuti:. enOlfetice witich-Aval' certainly not ? ; tr i oject fentlant Was missing. I.le %v i es itfterwartls preSent to the -seVerepenteltives. entailed opon ,(he,ite,rson.; : on ; the .21 svNi.rep ;T: w 'hp ii . d e f ou L tu i • ~,,,t . ~. t .,,,f,,,,, who broke .the prisowsvalls),Or toreqtt,thcAWts...s itowoostoikynitt,flAe I-Inuse of _Cpninv.:tis. . i .l'here . 1 1l t hi„,, se : it was l i ft * i i nt uited t0.1..,0r4t:',. : 11a0. trefe,ll9 .04FidgeOiS if) th(l,llotvie 4, the . t hue ~. he broke the prisorewalls, but only.thet.lje,bpike., ',lsnallite,.444o„lse,r,„wes not tben itht,lte„eliair,, l Alte. itS'boundariese—end n r 4fi ollt of prisoirlong telore House of 'Commons lusts, upc,ja il p,art, or the ; ,Nles' his::sentetiee had ,expiTetl. , i This ,olls[g.At.kOls A lViiSt , .or-litititis:,of.,.tyr. Kitig'S llen‘lt 1 ) ,r,14911. I)eltilthlOt ineontrOvertible ; becairse it would be proceil, that Was ,vecoo!cycil to confinement. iind, tindrvic.ent . , / ''' he'eeas're•eaptured isi the :Month of ;11,ar j elli at a.. theiremaift.slAr 9f. I?is. helitepee t „tg,.imprisorment.. ''tiine 'Whets his period.of ilutprisonment.lied,„three.- OutittetUjoi,,,,Nly witopAsieceonymtied defendant's!. ' titonttirs' or notralo run—toltled fo, 1156, -‘l44 s ~ tfic seeretitrs trpnalie Cro,wao,lljee, where. slily, oft tA,, ,, iii - loi lint top.. paid ,the finc.of 1000/, .. 10001, wAstaitl. Defendant wits libt.nnt.4,,Q - 4, ..km - _, on Inc following third of July: vic only enquiry 6ll!ll.o.tial V ,. ~. . , . - ~ . ' Or to-oay ‘ v1.14, •..)„vbetaver. Lord Ccicliripe .itt . .,4, es- : : ' (....ioAs-f.rantiiteri by Lord COCURANE • . • ' c.ipea film his,,troitfirietnetit in the.Kitig's,l4otell ,14, Were 'you r prestott when Lord t 0 041 . 1\1k5 Was' rri,,flit .before-thetwelve months were; tii-pte ed.; l.cotis l'itte,d 1 %, N 'taus . .. ' c ' if ; ."--..: 04 i ll 9 l‘,l)ERVtrt'i - 4 " i I : ()I th At fact there' cooldhe no l bitubt„,,..Lord (; d eal- ; rocolliett4 r . , I ; . .r.e 'ill'lji,nkred, t(w.tlity tvithoftt C‘MoS4I; ; hot Wile.: 1 _' Q. Am tw i j ii, q. m t4 o,;,l prese . li t wir ' n — ''''''' r . 1 1 b - lo 1 a tiler - his- object .wasunt;rely to *witch. t).re local ' rane Was delivered into. 'custody at ii h,' f',,... i's -', - b , ' . Pl 4 t 4 (4 the mi"l.ettruninGur "Viinat : Milli, oil :to 1 Bench Prison.h.—A... litli.xc.r.tail I not "'' “' meet the charge by a streechitull evidertee,,.osors'at Q. Do you consider the deliv i e sY ry of Lard Coch. present uncertain , , .IVini.tever cuts: i i Alkg : 'N.Ale rant: into tin ca4tcioy of • the talrtikeYi; ' . (r ifelivtiry i LOrd might - think ~ prop& to ,tiii , ,e, : lie .(Nlr, into the ett , Aotly of the `Marshal'?--»A. ISi '?---A .' 1 certamlY id arryat4) 'should: ( confine-himself to rite. simple' consider a delii i nery effe boo tdeliv he cosiotiuly to of the th custo d e :ofliete: f ac es' of the , case, tibia) lay. in an pitreetely 01 Ilse prisout ct a ry y , - 'narrow compass,. and of'tlie result of the inquiry of the :.kitirshal. '' • there could not,be W.dblibt entertained,: ,With the Q. Do you Ittionfriby tOttit'iitittilirity Mr:.',lOnes, . sentence the Jury hail nothing to do; that ,wonlil the' Marshal, acted ori that:occasion ; and dri yiott b e . I „ ; , itter of co o s i f kretion of `the Coiat of 'Kit: WS Out litlOW that hissit point "Of . fact the Alartill'al '‘Vas 11e:itch-in the ensiting:term. .;.': ;;-_, ~,, .•' i 1 tr.. 11. m , i i ) litit Act ng n oi ILL o....arsaa.. , Mr. I?ichard,Gude examined I N Mr.:01,/,4llilY—• ' Ali'. JoStiee Butt Kano It.—:-The , 'question 'iv not . attired that lie wa s clerk in:the Crow-office i f . and. upon . Nv h Crown-office at authority 'the Alarsbal acted, •or Whe , he •I e' :ro : . y . ti ' ,-. ' • ' ''' 1 4 etullicethi copy Of ij°"l Cochruite-s commitment I i i. 1 i Lrl I scharktd die duties of his of . I(i . .t he King's Bench. pt ispn •In executtiOn of his fice..,, IVe hase tut ri.„!,lit to enquire into that , sntr.. sentence ; and alto a copy of the Rile of Court by ject . . ' ite issue is not wheelie'. my. j on „, use iv i t i e l l hi s Willi nirment W AS Matte, 011 i. .111k:Lt li') 7 INillYStial; in point of law' iii l ega ily. asi & pr „.. pot fit awl read by site Assneitt' te. petty, 'print. the 'question is ivitether the-aleftiodatit, ctlments were Thomas. Gibbons, • examined: by 111r,sApoLfo to. being legally - delivered' into custody, escaped front AVitness was Lord Elleithorough's tip-itaff; lie that custody before the period of lila int:prison , was present in the Court of King's Bench when meta bad expired. . . .. .t.opodant was brought up anti received the Sell- Lord Cacti RANI 3.-1 sub mit to your Lordship, - --- - 0,....t. -., th., 2ht that it is of material importance to envire wile. eel tau) duties,. are as;signyd, u rfornit.l those ditties. ,Does not your Lot ',ship thfittc it is-4n iillllollallt iSStie in this ease, tvliethet holdittit such a sitoatioo, has iterforineil the iliitirs of his otlice,4tiol whether that officer can`-he con sidered as legalEy executing the ditties ot his otlire When itiippears, by the evidence., .that-he wai present. Mr. Justice" lutitioilon,--IVe Itaie..nothirv.; to do with the authority or the` datiViof the iVior shill. The tioe , t ion is, %vhether i;,s.) . factotlie de fendant. OS: been legally. conttnitt ed to. custody' It the Officer does not per,forin his thity,,or heliaveskiiinisclt, he way, he removed from his office, or punished for any mislichavitntr in i$ ; but that is a pt the oliVoce. ‘‘e no . kv trying._ Lord Cpc RANI3.-"Il 1$ clear tsposl to rross.:ei amiwition of the ‘VittteS3, that Mr. jOite'l, the ;Marshal, ryas not in the exercise of his oflice. nor perforining the ditties assigned to hint, and tit.st lie was not acting agreeably to the tenor ot his coin- mission. Mr.. ,Ingtice Buttßoucti.-11c ivas exercising the office of Marshal , and thetlefendant was deliv'er etl to thet custody of his,servonts lic;ing,oo his. be half. '.elte Marshal might not be personality act ing, but still he was exercising, his (Ate through the medium of his scrytitits. Lord CoQIIII,NNE.-1. trlist, I 'nay be petiniitt.4l to Call your Lordship's attention to the mints of the.comutision under which 'Mr. Jones is autlioris- ed tO act. Mr. MABRIATT.----I submit to your Lordship, it is not competent for the Court to enter into .any such inquiry a 3 thiS. Justiceliuuttouon:•;-1 -.take' the objection of my Lord CoChinne'to he rather to suggest what is'the natureof :be oiEce, and the nature of the commission tinder which the Marshal Nets. LordCoctul.A.l4F. t hen rea(l a p.ibiage from the Report of the C o ntatittee ,41 the House of CoM-, rums on-the subject of the King's Bench prison.. The definition of the duties Of the office of the of;th•tt prion were there, to . !ltktilted, principle of which Ntas, that he should he preaent and personally acting in the discharge of dons. Alr: Justice I.luuttottatt.---YsVluttever obicetiqn may ile'tnittle to the immner ill Ohich the (holes are - performed, that dovs, opt.unske thy Ofikr,' void: lie still acts th-the.otetisible oflicer in the govern -. :Ittent of ,the prison, 111 r. gAiittv A*IT * submitted that the Court on,ght 'not.to-ingttire into tire manner in which the, dopes, of the'nflice• - were ilisch rgetl. 11r.,.1,►isttcc"'1;URItOUt3 t 3 agreed that this crinrse tif• inquiry ought mot tti be puwied, tka the Cohlt ilasi untlkiov; tO do' u\itli be t»onner.in'whiCh:',the orlta,r_shal '`. Lord COCIIttANF! then obiected, that. the .evi tience olditeed nr)t tin lim.!tinige" of .fl i c indictment, Which hitn.with force and tarms., contoliptitoirily ei.6aped fro,n tritietriPlat es an pnreniitred `ctihrtifditient witin ilia wiills, as any description of escapewhatever. It is in reality an e seipe front pilSoti by the assist ance 01 the jailor. Tr,"); uciloritty tif stich enor mities (night to render it imperative an the liar- shal, to prove the manner 45f the eSapti hoW 'al leged, were it only to she* that he hittlself wo not an accessary. And even then; it could oulY be said, that the present proseciaititt is 'tit for a Violation of the sentence of the eit'urt; but fur tilirhaying tire - ConfCcleracy of the Marshal. It it itot for the edittliil4Sion of ii breitek of priSdii, but fur' 'not 'effectint it by bribet . y , The illarshal hititself, when e*atnitted before a COnithittee of the flottSe of Gutmann, did in effect acknotv 'letl!.!e the 4.-!xistettce. of such practices ; for he ea •.'' fly c • • I ;„e .ifircssci. a resoltition not to be guilty of the hike• again. Indeed, the.. !natter was so notorious, that-the Committee did mu enquire vdietlier such thing- had been done, hut whether he continued to do them'? -Betio then, that such corrupt prat" tices, like others chew here, are ils notorious as the suo at 'loop-Atli', how conld it be expected that : I should consider: it any very serious offence to escape fruit tlie-King's Bench Prison ? ' 1 bad been coat:tuned with Seven others, 'and h a d ap pliedfor a Hew trial,.l)llt",was told that,l could o nt. ' be heard, because all the convicted persona were not then. present..; ',.1 had said 1 could not coollwt .--, them to come, 10111 the law did not require ,an i: 11- poSsihilily. But Ilie Mliwer 0.3 i, that the pri4c- .1 [ice of tlieCmat rt'qiiired it,'and that the practice of the Court of Bi'a's Bench was the law of ll H '' ''(;Dort Ourof lilitig's' . 4Kancl): Aftet•tslittds i %vas ..'e. nt " 'to the prison, wilt:i . e! found it was the prse" ce -to depart and go at loge. tVliythen, 'night iwt conclude from lyinit I bait been told, tn:il tile ~ 4 . i ractice 4)f, the . litugs Ilene!) Pri,ott Wk" the l'"; :of lite / - int.;'' !tench Prison.? why s hould praeli''' ennstittite the kw in one ease and not in ii)' - Other ?' y observil'g `4. lf, however,l 'have trespassed b the practice of the prison, rather than that of t:- 116 ..' 'Court, 1 have still 'to plead that my ria ,, gr es ' :( ' %vas the fruit of oppressiim. \Vas it notder . "' tiou to ktrow th:tt toy irnprkontneta teas till}ll'r 6 .to be conscious" of lily entire iont en ee 01 14 crime for which that iM nm prisoen w t a s intros` h" n punishm tits nt "? ' IV:is it ti exteunation that Cared( e!'' caped not t() e.vitic the pain of that•pnitishotel, but to -ihnowice the: ihjtistice ,of its iotlie L li : " , TO use lily: own pi e v huts latil,, , ,nage o n tlit: ouv.l 4c i , ...:` I staid,long enough in prison to evince 1111. ' t enoid einittreTesiraint as a End!), bitt nut a' g P liv halty,-1 had staid long enough to be certain 1.1111. t lily prost-,entors wete , COnsclotts of ,th,.:ir iyitist'L' '''arid'to feel that , my stibinission to ilivir twilit.. rited intlietions.vias,losing the (li e :nit y of l' cf:4 • 4 :, ' tlajii4i, atid ..iiiltiog - into the ignoi n i n i oit s e0 411 '; , , :Alice of 'an inSult.-- Was it immittiral then ,t think it high time to be gone ? and uty notwer 4 ' going tens ,of ;011, others least exceptionable : I" , aselleged in this indictment; "to the it od" . 1 16 pie of r All others i'' 'for my plan it' : ;ireely 11 10 / ( ° ,. ‘ },nett! , :9)11100e teoillit'd,tre to i t . oi l i t o ) k t s , t : e . 0 I o nei ; o ' l4 sp.t.,m) exattyle that _could he ni I- -- . - ii ,,s lowed the evil example that '‘''‘'s stet. ll ' ul I I l d , Atli escape by 'the old, 'To‘rordly, corrupt 1110.1 . l io , ‘`.•;tos ‘crtuld utter have livArti of tai •, pwsecilice.w " 1 " m m 1 36 t 4) y ot i v cs, tto cy were mo "" te 0.01 b. ' 0 * oc iiefiii 41We : thvy 'wel c hilltlable, . :lii'" l a 0 4.,,, :OA escape.att. to defraud a el eilitor, or 110 30 :I' l ii , lo . ;, ••i io (1 jitry, but. to 0 itml to obtssiti jFISOGC. 1 1 ' :: 0 ,01, . 4 it)deed, be mitaken ,ts to the mode try Ine '' T i l t v3 a • '1 btu it it was till error,' it a renial'o"c' /1 ,44 •ort irregular way to, be` bill'e;: but • it * 0 1 ii ,,,, of • one which presetae4 itself tO my itogi ii t ind i,. the time, .Wl).llj.y, ilipresied as 1 way tvil to ter linti.qii.at the itoolenceand iniquity' of 1 11 '" c , 0 1 ‘vhost,cortscioris injustice 1 was 'bni i.clin ,,, l i t re' eagitly.graspilg at the hope of ! )11)0S" 1 4 1, : to, L 4 pelito-14 that injusticelly,any ,practii: 3l ►" lc '', s ole 'therefore effected my ~ . 4! -, , nr 4 ,Kaiyni k nstalting, my , seitt hi Parnato- ,1„.,,i; ~, .. I .„‘ of , Netninding, that Assetuhly, .dill( il'°. l ' l ,,„ple ' ' liberatton Avid', th e ~,,,I, oh 'x had beetrreversed by th e '' vel lig.e 2,1441,,(19,01.ent0r1ing frinit them -tiotr into the cause of lily suffering, 001 1 :,, ii ,101.4 ... conduct of my Judge, to which t was i" , " ..00 1r iiii - a‘, - iiiial IL:tii nett; then , mut.. w hici.i , f„ V,' 1 40# ii,a.t strict i.". i t, „ 0 ,,,, to say, 114S110t yet beet). a flotititi to me. 1% 3- ' 1 , 4 o peo of Ctnotoons is, described in ttitt'oh d rqitr, ,„‘,, all the Constititittin• '.tti' bc . the I.re'" ' iv"t' itti 1 ii: • obtain .redre tLi ss ;: ', l :l i se r w i lt h er t e " . l " P t i :( lll ` , . 4e:ll:eiol'lC'ttn.l:;l(.) : l :i .n r i:sl.st: • rwcongs are iliiit 'lloose . 1 - 11A a right to . e%neet 'OK I ' / ••icir ‘ • ... •• . . „ -,- -:. . , tif Wit. ,I, Willtli it ii 10111inill to afford to a11,,:4 0 9 ,-;', c t, 3 n,, lay to me as. a .Aleilibee., , Stich wag . WY .I t rit t ''''''j SuCh.,at the m6nient, lass my- hope ; " c bin . i!' too sap pint ,int tai 1190,,it._ 6 an rimy 14: oc r no ber 2 ft . nr Cm -my .'mitnt). by .thc alterati(%O. a iti • ari d 'llie octettiirittion - pi Itttftiiinient, ‘!3°.'",l-01,'‘ , gilts! end t .4i-411 'hisitr i iiifp li- Af.-':', c AU'L1t ` . 1 .4 ,11 : 6,f4;.:41.1 1 , er .01,,',, 'tterytowoutil latve , preitiett betel 'f,thrindiol-'' ,y4rIP r:;" - - , 1:. . ! ... '„ • • ~40flit' 1 , - '0 1 ?, 1 4r, wr!tttj) 4ti, ,:laxpitsittkes,i sori,' „..- ;.tint; i i , ' j .' tlititait WAS ilOStittittitt t. 0.. i ' t,Vt?, igfitCoo , f,i 1 : 1 ‘) ii - e ' tto. ' 111 , 1 A f Sbrti)e Kingy ther4iOtten..i-viirthzlr coo'":01,10 i Y. plc IQ, i y . 9 '.,_.( wrritYgs) . 'yttie l , e vi ' s ,:, ' . o l4lc - 6 : 4 1 1i a . ''''" S 1 l of th . ,- ' I 4 taMe • tucr•WlSt, 1:10 . 101 , 100 I'l.i.it •t on. , ~ .401. 14' ' ' - '''' .. ' ':'' iil 4 - loi lg,:itAid .in-:otlier.l.l(Ortitl.bY 1.)001.. s"' ,a lo gliP io Frttleit, Whictiln English is , " The', 1 !"' ` lO 0 0 0 (4 I 1 114P7 1 14P .i)()%r•ei :to ;11111;r: law s, jii(l. ,t)l. 110 7.; - 1 , •,,f I.attirtry the lifeiof.a iiiikii, and CO/ Tel''(' ,c0.1W1:11' Islitrilicn.4,.esprtialiv tvliere there iii.SCUll,,,,ielr. . 0 t r-' „,at - . ~ . , itr'Oic,it:. the c.,4'rilinary co of law .e8OP,„0-1i,u0',,f KrtiglAon, a veryiuld historian, s.yo , .4 ..cii - „it ~ 0 ,wif are tom, in 'nice . " Oils t 'poor as- Act ' .. vf ry. 4 , be refreshed w ;CB, p e - . ,,, , .' „ li d ~,,,f 3, ; 0 f t lou:r . ( ii: i f alo i } t a t ::ianti:ithv ay s 1.1tt,1 id:Wilde' ;Ind ;we l'i-"P . 1 .? p atl)_", it s i cola." An :I itushworth sacs to till 93 1 7 4: iv itt . t: tri , ! 11.101-P:arlitilliLiit ;:,. " the CtirF,,tti.V.!=...:.l.!:) ti t; and oppression, which (c4arectiv(),,'',.'o,,,,sitat,4: Mater( to alt, so that everyirtan '3'030 0 . , 1. . 0 t)l i v yt t}§fiC.A . 6tl prpte4ti , ./0 'Of itiSflee tt“lt its i . '; l i t st / is , ,:veti.OP Cellil NOW,liietle iiassage3.snew a veL.LI i t he ;AI Il l ittst ice toiglir be done to -a own " i .st ( P - 45 , ~, ~ I •= OA I.4iglt. tent's Out of Fart lattlent , Ottt i n i o r l i „, Courts he wt as .to look with .assitrance.,s.dr o t ..t ti , Miln e - t-IY 1 Suelt _being the case, 1, MI . ~ 11. 0 0 . t f r . Court, might welt imagine that 1 ,.- 11 -,,,,je 10 ,,,0 5 cross its thrfshnhi to lin:I not 0nty.;,,,, _ { , , f o r t ,„ ic dress. That I o.'ucs sotictliated is noto 161 ,`,,,d, j ot 1',.... house, in I once!" yetite',4,,tz, to twit tYOUSe, in possession, as very ' ‘ 1.0' .- --' • .4, o f that' . 0....- r , , . very , refuge, aoti in smut , - . _ o , c ent , o pe ''' that'} 1V43 found by iny.preseiit vi .. a Me es i, ill li a l ti l (147nPleynrilg'il:tiaritsi°811$(:Ifit:r)Y, t 1 ° ) r r lcviiii) : l; l g e( : ';' ,: la r g' o g s e s a l il g i l iger''' : '; to the seat of oppresion ; and . 11 :710300.. i tioct of that oppression, histantl 3 P I .. prison, Jrtstice•BußroV,Wi tliat Otis formal L0041411ge,. s at •s(ii t were furled.licr.t be esco . pe . tva r s effected with violence or nt,t, %Va ot . ! no concegnetice. Mr.; M.kit'aVATT , that the langortga was visa n eases of !Ohl .on perjary, j I. rll CotitlttAtitt. ;lieu sOspit'.cii, tivat it wai tltaterirli to state the iadietinent it prvcise (lay on : which the escape hal tali.ew Mr. Justice By tutovoti..--- , The day is not at all. ntaterial. There arevevy rev cases io,vvliich it is necesSary ,to the precise they on' which the .Offetiee Ctrttuitiltoi, • Lord CoentiAt:ct then resesnseil.his.cross-exatni tultion o( the' 'iv Itne'ss , . v el l 6.:!;l:,rtt4 160 b e ne v er knew of any ease ‘Oiete. prilot)er was ;at liberty to go at large. Ile Ol?ver knew that .Sir AIII 1'1..0 'the beiletit Of . .the roles, though certainly J w init person as lis . 4 confined whin Ilt . fotte vettl,ls of.the priii o. Mr. J ost ice: 13u P. tiOLIGI.I.--SIV wrfi ntie rs never esettvitl "fr(ifo'iiiisOtt," therefore that case is 4pplicatile to tile-present. .tint evensupposing he w„s „Opi.Operly.iiltifil.tzril with his i.iblrtv.,•tiia! is only matter of qokupl;,ilit, !be oii4er, purl ha') ti)(rtywith rliei resC.tlt t t7e. your i s to shenv. that . yoh were really , in prison at t h e t i m e .you are.aligged havet i io,4ped. Their: case 'is, that yon %vete at, 1 ar.g e beftnt Vo4ll' Lord ship'a imi)r*toittneut It yOti can ;shew 'hitt that:is.l•ot.ste, tin. answered, Lord Cac 'MANE tieclioetrittrther cruss.exami- Dation. - • • , „ , , • Mr. 111 A ttuy ATfit'ere el ed ititisiqisecutor's case.' Lunt CocuttAtin 110W::Eose' add , suldretiteit Court a nd . :lo.iy ; be ohseri,e,d, that with a' view to treivas sin-, !il,•ort , o pf;r4o , i iss.,piy..sthiel upon' ijeir attentio , t or tl-o,l'ittiitiet; ) he- hatl contenittei to paper !orli 't . 1,1410.• it teat' fieees sary should be iincitelsto .;(1 iU .t Ire Aikvestigaition the Siihject hefrir,l l . , .( , ,h, and , whielt . I.leNcltlught , tOtetii , ..ei) 4- , ooitfeiinili.,4 l ..lVlrei.`,.Tarr. before they curie ,1 Con-, ceivititpt'u-; he in' ; ‘l , lthto .done to him. oil a l'ol'atei . tile conduCt hi3n t UMW: VI; ttcc 1144,1;• resolved , irc tiAIS iowttie .- • • try apilt. ~ )- - i•rt"tiuiettee ;; relV -I..atr— dthin _then 113'1 ~cotttlei I 1 vi-teuti, -ibis Spcecit,' which tva" ns . " Gentleritpktt,:±,iite !trim" That the Mat thaV himself has: repeatetlibe-eit 'te.cesiv. - y to .more' vf laring,,yinhoionl,ot the than tlyat forWhicTi-lfe. noW`prOv,ectittis haven `,'escape; to' he , odr - frivol, is • , eutrtetrifilaterf in law us ; Het dime isittithectile. intent Wit/45"P 4.4l4°Tut . from . and'ayatlekjustice, Nylitteas, mine Was a,Yeify contrary intentton, as ti evii en Isom • le use, which 1 iiiinte'oUin#libeitOP- Tiuti - the"escape, if a n: offence, ;was , ,hintsell at- tsmpteil to comproniitse ; ,ass, on recap.:: tine, he had to pattish---a power which ht. hot fail ib;titereise.' lt is notorious that t 1 sentence , of tile Court has ire quenity beet' 't-iolyea imv the'-'igailltirl himself, who has t o,elil . tou Ficrapied to allourettel prisoners its Could pay for titeilittlidge.nce-to quit the prison nt their pleihnre,• autt--wJlk daily to any distance within Ow space denominated „the Inks . ; or e v e n wholly to reside in thein..: And I.hare heard that neither the rules of the King's lienchi nor the shores of the okingdom, have always limited their excurliions. F e vety such practice is as much aan era.sion of the sentence ok the Court s which