The Sun. — London, England, 1819-03-03 00:00:00

who c rifit e l ;, itU" r ) „(11eY J ot 1115 efi tt prq' 0. Al P 6°T". L . 11 14 11 ICII , prer" I,deP ll g tUe emu- , t (e4t ; 14Y 11 qici IC° he ,1-,,,, . vt 7 ' 3l W td - ,- - ‘,- • . o• 11', It tiiel:.!nt 01 -. l A4l:‘ l *. 7 retintoy Ni. al n i . _ . tvi l i ct h"eil ii‘ysi e in ' (!f oor law ; it was one it w .: h4ll ,,gro m it p r ; ithin the last . cetittiry ; i ta i.,7 l'lihlited by a series of enactment's de , - llti; ing 46. "}n our ancient legal system. On hiolePart. Of the subject lie could . quote no wilt) atitlidrity titan that of Sir Willimit Grant, I to I ' ll bright be permitted to name, as he ~ va.; n eve 7r allertiGer o f this' I-loule—who cotthi a r e named by those who ktiowthittvithotit titlieP r ' s sion of that adtoiryion which his great Itti cities moat ak , AVScoIIiIIIIIIIII—A Mali who w A S lis -()110ti r not merely to thAtitt'otttaiion iiiiich Ic e 1 . 'ar.acter had ex:lited, but to ,the age in which , 14, 4 1 4 e(1 7 - a man . th ai , n ' l oi n 'll,i-re was no , greater At i bL . i 't Ita'soit, nor any whose Views on all Ai ,tcel tontlecied with I..t.gkikition. or the , atitai t )6 1 ,, t h i 1 09 4,4f„t1ic.,L aw ,. were directed by . the.pro-.. Irl, 6 a .( V ( li. r,rsitiont=:- whom iii, :IT had , e j % , e v r : ?y r li oi . c 'eu'Willio`tillgl'iTi'g it Atent"o . ti . ts . siiii i tt h e ' l lY, and the more so Irani'. Ilkil'Aflli4eitt?it , lf l ..A,„ vi Fes 3 -€4:33treirsr,rtotll.--xi5:1,41... - tion—this greit, iii`'"N t l,'l'DFh l e v y 1 wtr. o l VAIIISMS* to, t li t, 4,-,-,l74;rtant ; I nkject,had . ttie - n the reinat - lta1)1, t 1 4 , tl , l 41P,11/A (bran i t ft IlAt TOM t 77/ tiMi . P'iNili o.4: 4 ,: nl3, pvilfetlefaiiy Ifit I i owit tair4s , I , AV i tilt 0-i4,, tti 'l o 79l " 3l.ll4 li'bladAtir. l 9 ',PIN P 'h i 11 9 1 4'4414;11r , a '''':'ll) l. the criininal ; .—This la pas the rt;stilt,_ f 4 rr t of ' l o f?' . 2 1' : 6141,,Y , Vt""Ab ,rsygiVilo %IVA IL* a l'" e ",,: h i b . th e ir: ,01 11 " /( 'itiect -of tlsvta l a ailauptcaq ,$‘01.1c.,"! Olt . j' 44 1 1 :J(4:it, mu,st k„tiobs,(tr,ve4o;k4olovvolvii: ' ; ' '' '''ltar • .1. 1 4 01.g ..c v . cift.; )rccedi.o , ilte Sevy ti ei] ji vc-070)7'p ~3'f•W. ,„tod , .. ii ,,,.. -.. ~- ine e h ad ' been a nee' ea ~ ~ , t,p t ,''Y t ' 4. itifi ellahNthi4liki.eitilt l ll-111+Willeetv44e 0 1, -45e •i•:,i,41 12 i4 .sato;;,,ttstjp,O,er v 9l._., ycarl.ol.lpoo.l '' .' r 11 4 1 w.tr.llive had been an increase ;,..int , l, . N Yia' " Y " i'd . ' ... . . s " ' '' .l'''' ' ' lOili tii*4•Ti it , i 41,, o the Ath'eriCiitt war i there 1,1 , i , i 1 I,l l .. R .. ) lrakt'tilieliea'6''lliitrlforlSniet:'St2Ar's lft - , sii . ,7 , 1 1.lt-tifstitio,talinow.ls.llo3,l throe Atttil:!bieill l' iV' ' ' ., Vt . l • )(3l -1 6 9 ( I ,l o, ii i i;SlT'S r ejf i Ati4 alt?,lfi u! ' 1631,71 i ti n '",r} , there list been no verV great or alartnitil: ett :'' s tNi l cWitie. 1 -'lt it\i't'liciivAirdlas'l' tikritA, ii ) l l l4l iits.'ll:Of , )thei .prgteitt.:;4chnt.ory;!"‘"SPeciallY . I'f l , iGit s 4l,l ( lV )'‘.:Ar i s k Atht Abe .. glieN. infre,ise had 1 1 1 , 2 place. A; 6 the (Pevtations which hall I:p r ,"i4PSce - in • i'llellifir'ee"Wf , flie Ta'w''front ill , 10 Vgrtitur4 o f I he:: evectrinsts!lo. , :t ke - ettairierions, • (( i i r li t - q ll th e l," 11, ” 14 e:Qi i 0Y4 w \ e 'Pli r •Fg't i ji ab . I S'll' j l' q'. 01 ,. 1 .,'e, various, arfntiqiv I atioin . of , ,the , . Stim ‘ r . e ., ll , '!II„ to t of titetiw - il(tiOn' 'ti', ) die tfine"of I:m44J:hut, .0 ;p • I ' l lte proportion. !hail teen" fur : the most pifiT ,14 . ( 1 :',1 99 , 4 11 ' s rh w' as ' under 1 l 'c a 0 11 4i 1 6.tr,Akili" . 1i! ) ! ' li a i l l ti l :`,.uti S tY i I . ; 1) :: t tilt p r, , port ioo 0 , f 7. 7e1: .. " ) .ti,;!q. 4,„ urt ' i iffliiinMjed, "Oa ' I h ii' he atist teipitte . t# NI se nrititiplesi-'which , ,-; 'however • linfisimiiiikble ~,t)Z : 111 iglAt i ttim4ityc beco,nc., t.y,iole j eilt,etta,itip,liy, iti;:': e whn had Imp the early c l o r poe . :.,i3its_o„qt , l. 1114-‘111:;i0fi I; I ' l, 3 :iv `l er• ' 1/0110 Min 'the propor: tt l i ( t i 'll „ Ht e ' x'e l :iiion ' & - hall 7 -beer? . ditituThit'tietf-t6 ')lle . 1 . 11 -- utiet i ki t o k , e —art,k_ z as ki, - ., : ven, as ope in i ii' " 'rlt : If c byes were divided . into variois ' s \v':,: l : a ,A . 7l !lle'll i t r i`i;er Oft-nres were t•epilrated, it t.N 4 ' tle fotiorPthat as to thelnWlier leinnii4 th e ri • Ooltio li , ,th (14 i ., 4 i lice ! ) one .114« , :ticenty—one a t s , ' l "l' *-7,9 (O.)RRIWNFIr,cYY ,, ,f , o , in sixty. It wt 14;. e "bserten ?bat in the lii4ier Iclon.es, exci2pt, , )I t , tll h tu tki t a.fi lu k iiiifiaii i-abiiist ; '‘v [lief% s t 004 1 4 1 ,,, l ' H ilictil ar circumstances, the law had tinitoriuls Jail! executed. It wolthi therefore be doing itti 4 'e ti to the arg Ittliellt to take the proportion iron ti I'a c(l9YiOj9!l4.t(eq , 1,0(1 . n, irs and got tq I ' 1 the •ase Av k ', this distinction, : T 1 !9" § t j'"; - .• t • AL'' ' i ll : l l , i . err the l.lt or higlie4l,F i !ls.?,, , o . yelonies •Irii i l ii ''"l; - i'l'ci ' li'jen esessued to every case—in a lite:C o evl thetn.tt.lio aetwention, Avers - int - lit - Yuen t —ill T o "' 1 ) . ‘1.1 class 11,, had 11 2 i 4 paeoipwilit k et . l.ai all i .-- itibllTTect this inecinAty j; se4 i , imprtst r a...( , tict inns. llt ' 4 ,:'t 4 lit the'. malirtabi?as M ertit,titat t li t ::, -- "Ce, "vat:, the grealtitalsittermAlieitivarue( l . -- . leti.i, 4 l l She all ailisatiirt;; it ~ the firp /14 ey,,w , a4 'At `,,g lr . I • t'et . fiel?tliti'slirtilrt r es'oi"Clcli r llfllql4. ll- Poi " 4 41 A i " tIt 'Patettli els"; 'shill idiki d a diffoo edt latc9l4l - ii; sis "'lst,..- 4.9 tile, Prst cjlitsikte , ,6 o o4( l ;i444ko ' i tt iti l l i t 'e l d l , s e ,'*?:ix - i ' d e urfri l ik ,it ' !; , ni o t)r( „ ft 1. • :: 11' , 3 ,, t,ta , ... g ri55,, ,, 5 , ,, ,Eh' ''fil :. ,„, '°() ,,, , iii .4l `o!liai;iii 4 6g widi 11 VICV7 fo Ole I ntart Vih u t i t--44 % , 41!)1, - )it CiPlitititai l / 2 I ik.. t •r. I-Nit ~,;tir a) 1 It); tll, shot4livivAl 11i5acxi,..401,C 4VA , W 01TA 0 0Xl 1 . : lcp qt ihimber of nine or ten, whic,h i Nic i r t e f.4-;Tr le t : filch the law was execitte(l;?hese he wuni u 0 e l orcre citiqMn - ; -- tnrwFir respect to then to e ' Lle talloti of'L tike lash s.ns t itecessary. ‘Vhati 111%1, attacked the liiiifillrlTF; or the person or ill . i V ii` e I , , i ?. :. ‘4,1 (11 S C A . ; .:( 9 ) (10 ( 1 . 11 ) 4 ka a tlitli?jtel %% .. i . t h death! tri ; .` )(lll igqii;in t'llete \iffliNTAV - kt . 4), - e - irebil of till th e l r il inalco t j e ts, those y : A ittl4f ri clt!Tc.,..toity, hi . L. e• ri) i'iit' , l'gbinit'llii lotudre4 Alta:111(y frier,. ‘4''s a nd 1 "* - j•-• ''''ff": ()l4 " t ra i ililril ) deatli wa ,1 _ . Atolls i te 0 el'c" , „I ...,- ti.A . Ih e u "" t i . alqiiit'ti`eieiriieltalf:' II tt6. sptct tc tu r 4e • be liitillici'lftliTrafi4l?(BrfalWit.,l atter Ultt to! etni sider4TiOn'iq't'lit4tibjeel, _e 1 I at they oiighl l a ' it eXptinged tram th i e Sra n t l lit s v I lk . ( 3 !lt eai ls atfor , l ufgt,"ostant t c zt u tt;:a .4 .U. i'ii i Zre'ctive ,ci agai r 4t the spill o .'ftr law, • ot i tletni l it7tiri h iti.ik a l l lS'at such at %tee „ cut 1 inii - ii)siiiiiigAridirti l %Hi . I,ne,tu in Plinio tree cur with deitif ? I fl7aq i altriliiiriltwli a y 000; p liti '!' 3 ge.ntletnan't ISPetAore ground should ht lii ed wikh deit. l l.l, That t,l i is,4l,:remsynder tfll "tk Ac ''' " Ir.'" t i; 1 ( 1 • colony,' 'with a iak'filt4&!, , i,t l .-t (Who ea Id) .:aie l . . D on wiacKeneo: :.tce,,atio .. ,fiar t iF c 7 e , ;vitt %% ea , I n SI shout - d be piiitsliett'vel'ilr'd i eat'ri'?' r destroy , ,„F the lte'cl-rit li il'sar:• ; tia Willi : lit b pnititillet ' thoisi) (leach This liiit'll'Fe:es of offences inclaidei se wiliew----;)Vrrtiltritrierlir or almost in tril i Z tit t : I ` 4 iY.- Me ;11 j(k, iiiklC it et mill WWI t hat flier )Plittsh 4 fi'. l . o 3o9"i i i, t t ._4VA %M t n! , liYiltr e a l lt FP.?"-% ;i l Asi ' - s• t.tern wit tioncsta' utes imjiosing the p i vik 4 . l : I. tut (l eatlt'• l 'it' v ottlif"iii"tYPt iil - e lfOir=iiflit l 'pniitA n,:s w hicelswhe(btinot.-,bces-Jiittflk!til -kit slat ,Ss i ) ( lif I tifil,lnt h e iltiM , irltrAl, iAlttrllillev,' _".E4' Incii , _k,`1. 11 ,(1,, I f Ir etlles,, torttre they opt inupropei I t. 9istrartclikr Tiivie 6+oli t.i:at tidies Of r rlitiel It , er e .'t 11 - '4 e'',4l ikivl 4 2 ,! t i iet z ik'nfife '-' 'PVitki l3 Wiiii . Y 4 i : (1 it "reh i bilri49Pilil - e i n f tlq/filfitTile•.' • 'At ( i o tt!i 'fiii i t f il %, 414 ist be *it'k , 'WC" ila r in ete , y7tNistiialie , hruitt;itti y t 91,9 be ittaipteirrT i rtly- t t re . econd ihey pre 0 (ids a Mat ; MO W iiit' . • li ' l i I ll 4 v. 441;4 e I 1 I :kbt f 17P?1 SlOttilfi I id t,, , ~,., „Itit .130iffe(til. iliPfe'"Pb"OLitMtitiWii te," t4,zytitVri:tle elit''OftAeti'atettbleilPtlilittP:t*TPA ,),::4 :, ,vi:ri-i-:::,iiii:a.!...:,,i:ii,4,-,i.,,.,1t5ctit.te11,6,.Er,ai5iti..a,ir,:!;',1tie.,,,2,,,i-},t'tifiil;ml,4. 114iiiiil`kt;* Ei ' ' - ' ' ' iti : 3;!. 4 1 ,f: i i, ,,, ,(4 1 titifillc:hit slitri,tylt);.lliistcr‘eAti9os'A'&:,ll,;!lfeY;l(''4:lliiiii;:fl.: 1., .. ,_.,,,_........,...._..t . 1: 1 1 u i tt i, t it t i ttl 'A titliiifliVeY oith rari;i6l t ' ~.I.l.seottetices. ' iscretion should be allTsVeri?, yreatesr nic - r--,_....... .. .. _. . 5 . ,.. --- _:., ... , ,g, ~., , a ruTroT I7M;l"iriel se al- 1 A : , t; , ..Z','7ll , ,, : i''';;Tlt., 6 "3ol" l, )6:ltfit.(reivi . ..p i i . ), eiir I, ...'"ki A 4. , L A y t , _h. Y t t v ".. ' 0 "! : N T A S i t ' ll . 6 .° 11 r..- l'?1 3 :':tY1)41) tccbtd I,v .._ . ~ , .t;lte:,pintiattrrient textiressly.kli we'll** t ol' 4 ; tio 'off - " ' lf 4 ' • ' I " e cres qv ...ic.l, • Tit , .1 1)(1 , t1;4;it 3 / 4 4'7. 1 : . tAft bf 11-te I.l4l7 l StrTyliAlk;ll rti ra34) 0 4\t efl ssi,i i t ij9it a ti st; : q to the 6,11 tit : , Ihu,nx9si I filErireit'Efißt4iniiazfirb Ittiore.• 47 isf; S%, i) w 'l*(6l &hi ** * ** ' iket t et. tall by trn Ho nnu Crechtlin n. (S r..11 7 i lib et- lo rce who ; 1)14(1; - • itifb •• t elngtt'itue • • pfiti 1.1 t ) hinksplf, nrcnt.(?! . y. 41 7 ,11 it do- Parted SitY.TrioriPer of th . ore fcrattliklErii!,t !ilk tier, vii-bite• of than thß..:;kitiq , . o , loV l 4l . o/ . 1 .° 41 - ' all prai posals ,berf(),A;)(l , e , i. ~p,rie bow: ever, lie 6;11. iurtatliVoriog. the Lel.- ,f •is• la re ;tin en•-•;itt ge•siPa "lireve'rtt tng lit' .I "4"''.Y . t.iir , tii.l/41f4tacAt tii.silllicut.u.L4p.A.rii.... `""t 11 :IYXvel I.t7stilYg4isiteo.Ailnittgql4,,tit, the roe mory of Sir 5,0,10 4 1,1 . 1,0 . 0.ti,f1y01i1d he consecrate .rit i k• l 11 ert 01 . "'nt r . , ig•Alt i l-F.PA`Pdo.g „ f?' l `.s fd . l a (4f',4 o ` ) Sibba,ennsidererd was. ,11.e.aisltr -*Lei iio4cie.vronli take avv i a ‘ y { tire . diSCretionryriller ofi , spOralltii 7lPVY";9"litnii; 'firi l 4l4.. A I A:Yt;F4I I 4i) giii:.'"i' ' l l .4411tign ter itkEsLitVei,*ssl.kiir,tii•Jcltnitoy.er.sv,•othoef h Paley was right ill his position.ir illtitot , gehltin which he took wyrs—ryertritrtrteriter it was not some times a benefi?iiiliOc - ic'tiOi l eloore a iiiiichievon man, but Afftelb'eCtin'rlTel**llae't y lVi4t power node i+ f o i el o . .s.ne lt .', : f...w t a h - •!eio il 11l fb.:sir" e7xecolgt:ll. l lVll3 rtre 414 r figil •. • itt skii4l i i i i t ijli (It i O 4 1 o*.oWe ) '`iiseTeit'ily 1 Mis l -1. Phlritk it rgnitrattept.4 , o.6l .illiOVpliKny.,) I, hi I,r4e„ mat it was 1i0r..--34te,,C114-44;e, 1 hotle,ll elendeil, ot being condeintietlPtb.‘,l"he punishment of cleat!!, ha el the e fillPidgle 4 nfoli:l,ll4T o t t lle . • 1)1‘p re ss io ti oil the nunishnieniWei-W14144 . 1 ai i On , ti•f;lcli,when the . rtrin a 3e.44. teed oirtftt by /gig r(cat pr.t t ' 'of .tirttftbst a ~ v- 11 furititt;S - Stlitieisi ; /14tti4lifidatriftilSf . aittleitnite with -6441:1C-4175:1tuire:i. 71itle:=71'Tetrtii-llAgiF4i4li-Xii':lterrbileTllC'ealti;(l3l::t the greaketrda . ttglie?..ettipe)l. tire, minor suffering, and the cl'i+l4 7 ioal-40434(re44-44p04+445-tratospurtalott, as Cicettv , ltttillelPelii4 baii4.ltorieWt-tint a- punish . - nient but aFrorr i.;Z.. .WiTcl i clie, - aient of this ef fect he could arot'r‘eterltis laity btter authority thato.fAlfat Al ' a . a ._ liftlif. eit:p.erieticialand... eminent Botgistratei-- who-- bad-said that tltre•evil of :nne n r pardon, priminced, a. worse. effect than . fit' y ~: ; !.•,:, .- • • ..., , . executions courd tin away wit h. There were • " liitiWy " I VA :7 ,4. it i ireet q'li it4l 3 lit ' o VIA T O At ' ' the. efficacy A tfitlre j minrirt,pupishos,enti,wit i ksi,ityloollyAestroyed when tlre : greater was tmettly devounced from the s.r, ;•-:"1 . • L'e • Ift i . `Y.. 'Yc , ►l. f';' ' • joiftstient scat, wit 'ti a pet .ct. no . tye that it 4W0;114 , -liot-I*4l)4licti4l; ::1-14 'again referred to the ,Apittionof Sir,g.,Grao,t,ultat crintinal , laws never nrod,yeed a, go ct ti,rtfe,ct,, but when they were its noto,„, 2. .-_,J.,.A..t 6. . • accordance with pu ite opti t ion. F,' ant the time H off'FirrlßV.4ll4ksltiVe, aft the i;re-itest men had concuifed itt. thisAtoitionent.. Air:: l:4'.ox,.Air..l'it t, I '`?P l ' th • sllo v tiiii e e' ilikAl°ll.-e?`russo, it, E ii t Ae„ Slate of the Crtintlial f..44 w . now was, in.'a Freat. degree, ''et zvaiiiiirce 4 Wiill i publie Opittioti. -L -Isii""at V'a ' irillseettriiilso , it occasionallr.ww.si ., incident to all. 10!f;;!%gfei6 VllbllFllP4?!4ltAkYinireP,P9Pttt between it add thelopintons of the wisest. inert,, was a very IN'tl l 'iqiuptotze 'cif' the' lt a te - Of 't 11 1 ia te. lu ail ',countries.. ! diets( Attila:4l4 e tCriminftlil;,iw was AIe ,IIC.WIFP4 sot IltNiqo-130911.-illikliig!eltsro4...iess degree. Bu % itt,..4ltis . cotintry,,,oeie a, great part f at ihe 'crintintaliisei l ee''Va4 - .'t i ,'O t tniiritfetl' to the - bands of th.tli peopte;LtiVektelVoi politic opinion tiron that law ~wi t A At iq pq4a,kkie. ,• . ,Fior 2 4jta t, tept 7 son k.was, that he wat t led to Jo i resetic lii . insell to !, ile' 1 loose tr'irilfis zl i t iC'eastWi. 11 116' iiiil'VoMiilf iirocpUtGellatro , lfilitinor ill lltienlify , oki!:tioil , '64 1 .Y PAP fliLeAtvi! 1 GPl44,(ti r ilitltt-..014-111.4.4-nlktitlii kilAfjlt' tirkik , ,, , , , ; i 10, ; i Nt nme l, !+! l o l:r ipApsd,iorigni s , o t,_s l rl s i ,li 1 - ;of.)Teet". - !lad of `+ great benefit to. be' deriv6l (fillittli3otoili?PitWiiillltio3 .4 VFCs ! ks j a 9 OM if 41i'tikk.rt4 Liticrtliet3l)ttnt'Ate,iaTiAkeopy:igoinir.o?liAlstpiixittlitt _ _ - • 4. 5 tll%; e ll I Ii !& ti f ete i) P Nll.l occasions—in those very parts w [tete ()be it ot• ins,tireerShaf.lyttaht,(tright fiylo.4 piihne opinion,,wit wilt derogating trotfl its i WlliclPl)(Plattifft s i;ifVitiT I' • itjont , Wot!itl; luo ptese C.Etut -trio alquesatiOtt •I hrda'..'ati!ll t atlYiJ 114 e iU; 1 111 • 19 gent, til t it was not i liecessaryloc tie noose to. %mit Wi l t§ PRlNit' iii'Whs!""l l -Ihi . 4 Oda tole thdtifftitatt main .ou "sr,issicaliihad il► r 1 ti 'ls4f It!Wil/d ,I 3IAFIY i ." ilut t4e P etition f lion) %he y faondoti 'el %Via rPA ? i g itt ell . it o 4 l t t i s iid,4l, o i 1;ft,4100421t9 lap.) wti frOseo) thia:Uartiark , 419: it Litaikii VilstrthSt.l 4.Pig-.4 0 ..! tAi PLche , V(rs9. l . .rnefrppolis,--tite. Jurors aect . is;ohted ,to .. ()Mcitite its t t`liat the Eg rit% Ns! .04 fikvilti titto4P okintii thit iteltin ti4itvin ittcttrn3lll*lgififihbOdfAcifrolllMlePrirein.o44 . .taFa l l# i, .stiosi exp t ised to th E (I . e . prelt l ;itilts to .. 11 yji v.) t , . pert!, was haute. s tte zaorporai ion 11105 composeu; speaking front the most extriViiititenifte'Aiettee.: 4*ArttP;ieviaiistibtotittilienistiVrfldai'tf itt! :;Ski4iinarY, e to tte sh rtes _,1711 1 41(il 9#l 1 ; , ?a wit`o, oestroyi sv hoever t ojimet unit 11;iy(41Aii . Ao4o;l4@ria'if iii tt 4tiol lltooiltl)tcr444; qoi o b i at i 9seil \vit,lhout notice:; l/e '0 tei`,:t ?Tr 14.!:, 1 0(i'll'ele8req j fiehlli "thit r i X PiiiifitYy of Qualoiresipt-liiiielnitl'lrs(otionapotityot el rail jai tlieu€ rimiciiJl tsr,gt) Ilt4 ettt 3,iitintilr :cull's oft re jostiatiae.b.:, Jl4l,,llec t a t isteif a ltel Jtiti kipyrer 5( Mt(tul $l-411.i . okitst? ny(ilttoThet#4ll4.,elt p tail mi to as , Oplithel aostkinteiiatti race; Itatitiati thostg netiiittsti icioeddiyiultsfir DAS .1 had been en tei tained.-Lty(saatuatly g ood men in sil l gts 911 Iskrtkigui tditAt !Ail* t iPhi49o) fir; A s 3 l4,ig t' fttli6i%ibi§l444 - #lo44.tiovciackitikYjtArytn • that those who alone of ail the people iti,ahh t e kin i; donvatntANopastpiTs. , ftsatity , ipattaiil , )id no sciaooo . 3(;(4fraL--tfilc, h a t midi 4411 :tolcoadv a. Ischia) I apttatiliest ;s 1, 'ttniverselliits OcAl r t.Otalltittlaki pet• :feetittolTO/Vlintoan):tiakst(ll, wiilt trot/licit; ' , And isilvethimscnitsitlereit..4kg i tit 111it^ltrdtieltir NA ile o r.n. sestf4ltitivii lteAlfiVist-(Alr i%V i 11Yer itsvesec)4 )1,0(1%31A( ifteliilYtll6l(i intt ) it lOW *i)le et 4e4ii ved , nip4ll , tliei Ito tiiev it) Olt? n toirii,hlrire confidence iii the goodness of his caliseosbutioriat hopes of its spceet)7""irre,Ciinelinied by moving iitt6. 34 ' dr; sait4i tosifinivel 4g4 Nuiii4.lPlCtirto it. shier so much of the C r imirtAaAsivaroimpiteilitittis.)tx 1Y,41 poiri tg4r,rtAt 11j 94.441cp tkg4pqi .vikihjp,v,clic. titfmico. report ireir IdbervAtifau s4iiert npe n tat 1, , I+6,ive, ..... 4.i4.1.;41, , "-ir=on; CASTLtlitkXt4Vilit4.tafl t)t!'ettir.o*lerfin his -senie of :tile Vett? Pti)e anid cBtictitl maroiee,ii) Learnid, (-lentitril'an bail treated this initiortant 'snhjecti. thitad dlscttsseji 'the itv thht foolosei,qvhiciPm4s.la-be eX-, li pecte 4 eintil Isis getiri'al atitttleghl habits;' lanitAt4t4tal-Wattlvandled it whir ;.i'temilet . itice anti moderation deiervit.g of the highest pritise.—;— ( e';"11 t:lietir )---The vi FAr4B h ell •Ifind Eekii•wett'6lntietwirr had fatal) of 'the inbjeti, iiii4itun •in that tiegtei: 'ttight be , eicvectecl'frotii"t he tff , hts /11e 'l4tOtiiki clne ‘ . 6f.t he chief giVahtis tliat • twit War, that; co'rt.sictereil. ai w Ye:ill - tract" nn Law cts t fitf4i.&tiri'at . ;:,t'ttnent egaitisit the 'erel-ity'itt 'that law 'ill it stacsil ati the St at ate 134k, 1 - 13at • t'he tie:Frrii:. tl tvtatett tliat • lie . - ctid'ilot iiitet!'il to i;triirios'e . lie ' , hail no intt , titiein''ni . :Caking away . enlittly tkc 'pnnisktnent of ite'4llr. dii6lAitniog any inleiftiori of Wrilitlrtm;i:nk horn Hit Jndites and the Crown the prerotakivir: of p . !irdbik , 'Or'of mitig - ation =':111c . Hgenetfal'hiiitiOn involved in this disetisli'dtsgtilei,s l r•ft"tW'elli:.i'i•e`roftnation and regnlyttion of 11tii4e110,vs. 'frophsing the punishnient of •death, anel the' pat - ttieCillar'qdijittion . now for decision 'mils, what'llie r . ' eieti" 0 prOcreetling the anion 'should •ritlopi . (6-arl- . !Hive 'at 'that wise and'Saltilary" , conclusinti2 , ' he Moat 'admit th it the +ion. and Learned Gentle?- `Juan in suppoi t. Of his ' proodsal 'had • quot ed two :preeetleOts of titiquesticitiallre atitlintity. Yet he world vent tire'tni.ian liegitinent ttom these very precedents, to !Wove that". the course proposed hy'this innti(in vvas . not• now ;advisable. He would assert that the experience of t hose very f ifrecedents :tvaaagaitist 'the filo! inn; As In •thlitii , st:piece . . dent quoted, that of 1750 the authority of "this 'precetlitit. 'wi'is unquestionable. But - What' did it proie as to that pv;rt "of the Hon: arid Learned Genilettait's argionent•which - went io SuPport: His motion'agairist the course 'which 'he (LM-11 Castle reagh) had pursued ? :Against the latter 'conrsl 'the Hon. and Learned Gentleman' had • cOntiiidet that it would occupy tOo Much , lime, and , coitlii titot be conchae& in . one' Seision: But the . old' Ireee dent showed that the inquiry Then intittit‘Alkil occupied two Sessions.- And after having ()ten pied t wo Sessions, what - wns tite'resUrtil - A"*Bill li4l . been intrilduced,•• wllich ''passed thrinigli the". House. • The • Honotqable ..ainl.., , Leartied :Gem leman had . not stated . that - I he : end ;; was, ,this Bill: was thrown ; out, in . the... House ,of Lords. His principal objeettonto the project now propSsed by the 1-lon. and Lea.rnetiGentleman, was, that it took an abst'ract instead of a , vac', "licalVieW of tlie qitestlon. 'Frnn the precedent of 1770, i,lie • Hon; arid Learned GentleinaP had not contended that iiity.practical benefit had re r ' stilted; In Ilion, if he had sought •for precedents to be avoided, and not to be imitated,'.tione tobld have been found more - appropriate for that pur tise than thOSe of 450 and ft7o,; .!.FlieyAvere precedents w i ttich did .11ot lead to any. practicA conchisiott.,; l 4le could "not „,go Aog .with th'e Hor.otirablerand Learned , ,Member' in thinking that . the'infit i llrce !p(4,11,1 be fairly dravvii,''that the ;! .„' iisetit;.stiti:ei of the ' iii\V tended ' to, en:- courage offences. The late Sir Samuel itottlilly, whose tiforts to mitigate the rigour of the law, had been' so ciohsOicnons, - biid'rtieceeded in a lt4j.lit;li'l,s'Bill k. I pa__etinto aii• Act to alter tlie intent •of ' l' f • punts iitiation,' iiitit earl 01 death. What had het , t hi erect - 6fi'llii - t - al,territiott . ?-;-Aectir'.'iing .to.'die- rod sit ion of the, lionOtirable aptl L , :aelked l , efkiti t e.,4 the etfect.ohnnld: have benl9,:dittlittisli the I * 41111)t ber of such offences. lititAlle.fact was, that. the hail ittheased. •• It appea'i l ig,fini . the recut ii s ,'t tail the number of persona -, lika for that . Offeti . e t , sitieturiptuitcetthe Act ~ I rail.been —in 1810p136 in 1811, 194; hi - 1t4 . -11 . ,:: i .,'24 ; in . ,18131 1 2 ; 7;24;)4 1814,311 ; in 1815, 2..7, ";, iii 1816,; 402 ;:11;18.17; 509; in 1818,531—50 that they had gradually increased t0,1nur.... - 9r , Ave , Oates the ',mount at the time when_ tbe,,-.Act_was passed for inif I t t iga I irm i the;.,-,puPioll99,Fat,i,.4fif .19 1 1 ) Pr.ii."A..51 )1 Ellt.ltic:!4lnAi ill; 1t!4 8 .'7 . -- TFILSJI 51?flwg(t. the lttßill in crease. crease. They were as follows : 2 '6-1, 84, ,§pul33l 148, On ,:4.4 ; ,, , , `? f . 7, p.p, , 1 Tl, e argtipielit therefor 4 t.tbM,Plict 'f-Pe9 1 .099 obtaw,4l%.lt,iFilllt,t9thhhfell th lirclvirigP9Pi3lii»vill,±7inli),.i9ct:43F tine, crinrlF,,the otln ce i v ,ippidvi : ts) pr tc yetm, wps no . t s fpunded on tact: iit 3 lll): l 3‘en!:thte A 19 1 1: allt1;40PItI.P!"-IPIC'fla":•Oked -why i tlie,cmnsit,le„rit,iptymf ithe ,lans mentioqed in :hifli tiefliitilhOlKlllSlAlcilliitCA to an itt'llirYl,o49 the isOleitlfaTil,9Yist? :ili‘O li 1 0.4.n ) Mg!"1 )1 1 a l ll t :9?Yri ali ve i p,pw . sy, i r a ef son foreOnjoinitig,. the lotion i,,e! b , 5 4 1 ,q., s if th ia,ooo persons corAneel in, .the ,jail ,thiiißghp4l t tlte,kingdoni, 1.44,9q0,were couttroic,(l f o rigeiNer, under the , very,la i ws towhieli, 1,1,4 yirr e jtip,:yclated,—(Hear., hear, hear,!) : 7- 7 1:1: 1-App; a,ml,,L t epr oesi,.Pent Inman had said,thatt h...-.xgrwejiti lesi,dthatLgQo capita), li felonies..imposecl , h e r; I f ityst ytflick....ctr4l,ilort now,,,t,te ,entorced, ~,It'or l l )s, own Piirt,4tP:tt*fliVA,e.99fligriPP .l'e,tc,'YFl:t! .r) many... : ;t. moht„t7e,Ropsitlereti'thoAe statute!rwhich had been ,A l i cAcribril - .as- (let - 19(1410)g deat,h4fq,:laiitast,ic of hilttcesJiwr. t:riAlt))eter,;,Yltet"Vt„t. ll U„ `.nqrS iS'i ' lie-alai! 4.1411 e; 041cri ot' .4.Al i t,l),e ; l , tterl : cF4Aislib l , ,w,,of„tiy,vc;r,Astitiy!Fe,4:s, , Feitig i they I, J ail.,heetftlel - 3 de`titl letfer..,-„kt o was cant eAd,q,cl,„ ;bat, the Cpn?.. it)lilAloc.l4'l l 4.iri94iillquiqg AMC! 1101,49bieels,\ka• the s!t!ttet;494 l cin;ss , l;ho- , M a - 4 .11 r PF 4, : ,13”-V,thSY: could - 1 -"(11 1 tr4 j.939iAloth F ,, II)I.CFIt, 1 1 P_IPYc. 4e)? Pr4tie oil' thcji(Yell l 9t.lonit,..‘Y lo ti tirAisablThtllit 5 1 10 9.1.0„i1ei 41 ; %pc.; dy i ., i t ,,s,.posityle,, , ,,pa‘di Iv% that purpose. „y 3-1 ;NtlifutPilktlushgtliP°rP lii,dfii/A4Je "tiat!!!that'_btillb - 6 •YilikiF-cts , AltiAll.ift PS ,:!.e4freploto the, titYne !-‘,ip wit tee . Nothing could be more injtniio,u,:with.,,a view to the ...pretit --object -fts•-+o-wkicli they were -0 1 - 4 aXr , ttrloa OWL dint,._-aft sttehjecLa t sitoul(l.;" be etittlitcorkLtiiroAeiii . ka Variety ibtliantls, vtikit 111 1 1A1,0t - ' --ce,”.kttity,-Valtota tijviciOi: idllii. it) 1 1: 1 :4W .- ,Vie , Y14 10 f.Ahrt — i ,it WPAIR0140401411.1)f Ilipll3,batllie jbloiMlA *ktit• .IJ . l4l.efi ! .aity fWV t: l l.*la n-, : itin .4;r:stilt initt.t4o9:ifl e, , Ci o notice. la:MIMI ttiot,ilitAw:kl4:ll; waeil t.P3Atltt . OA!! Wilt t,er t inlitain.-..ilieldt(iltot ;hold .omit .00: +0414 itnydnlttniKatlly,for.ref9rtning ,this .I) : artAf .therdhw,,,illot thitusl6 , ltiisl(l4w,w, , (ol: l ose I)oWAttit tlic , t.wo courses - rliTriferl - .. He, had sta.etthel ':Vtiiii'f'Vi.'iliit'i',6ropeiielrby , lilitlielf : Ire litst,' l i iittPrti're',!' liig,e't . ` : t tie rlmiliuyi'ar the 1101%,,tir'iiiIN ' 'gift ! lie`iit tied Gent Iv rata by iii3d,. , It g the pi ,;‘ . lo i 3s' •10171 5 0 4'.' NiCif the 1 4Oii ( iitli'd'Icartit:(1' Ger0:10- ~ ; man sli'dkilitiet - ted' th 'tiiiiiiidi'6g the honse • to .eittittate ilia iultrtilits., he could only say, that in hissvpittion it , Avotilti be more convenient that they Ithbithl be combined. iie_ concluded by - moving are previnoß question. BurroN said, that. On a foimer occasion taken an Opportunity of stating' the reason which, in his view, niight to preOent the Hon's* from entrust i ng the' inquiry propmed by the pre sent inolioo to a Committee, 'Niviticlt 'was already ta . sitet! to an intiniry into six•stibjeets, namely--- 1.. The suite (it 'a i i ' the Prisons.itvEnglantl, Scot.. ktia:—;-2. The "Management of ' Vritoners in 'these PliSons.-3. The l'ulice of Transportation.---5. •The aria '6. - The' state of-ar'Colony at the An , „ .9poties•.- ''Tie' Nbbie - Lord thought tve ought to - erinSider.the.tpiestien'froin cause 'to consequence, !from beginning te-eatl!.''''fbit; however, ‘vould be _ impossibk. If it should he said that the canse of 'the Ifictease of 'Ctitne• ''was the want -of tell •giOtis ' etrudatiOn, time plificiple - of the Noble Lord 'would 'be to refer that -'subject to his 'Vottifilittee„ and say that be 'thought the sub ji;ct "id religimOms edueation 'a' very fit one for 'the ciinmiiiteeiat ion -Committee. - -The Ho. 'neural/1e ber fhen'ts'ent on to 'e rove, I st, hat . tlie 'severity 'ef 'the'Criminal Law as it now stood %vas hti iiiit'ovitiiiiiVorillt. l oldiiystrnt,•in which he follOetri-fi prieripally.the argtritteut• and instances ot . lanieS 'That' the seve rity was - agninit ice.---3(11y, That it titiiithiid=raised , no n-pewer in the State which- abrogated the laW—namely, public 'opinion ;' , .rrit'itil!el l a t sss' of thoie eniplo)ed in the administration of justice' eon) hioeti . to firevent the execution:cif:the law: he illustrated these posim. 'ions by 'a variety of cases, ...selected with Mitch ingenitity,'and stated' with , gredt effect. The lion. INlernber then-stated.theeperAttion which the con finement thgether tiiiiiiberS hail - oti•the moral feelings of 'criminals. It vvould he' curious to learn 'the caictilations which'those adventurer's torrned on the progress of eriMe. They 'endouraged each, other by the follimiitig • doctrine of ebances-:---. 'Tis 5 td,l• . (after the commission of a crime) yon are not charged---'l is 50 to 1 you are not impri soned--'tis.loo-.10 yon• are ' not convicted—'t is 500 ni) 1 you'aili not capitally convicted--'tic 1000 'to 1-you are trot executed ! Here they appeared 'not only its it'Oang of thieves - coldekpockets, but as a gang - of ganiblers—Sporting no'. only the . preperty Of - others,' but own existence. Thus the'operat ions '.of our criminal law become a sort of itivertiAliifferio;'lf he might be allowed the .teXpresiltiti. 'As - toit he , effect 'of'an•execmition, -it imadetiiiitnpres . ! - -i0..1 on those 'hardened criminals.. It *as next to nothing towards the amendment of 'their morals.- They termed • it their ' liar veist•---for -while the-eyes of - the spectator were fixed lipol%'llle victim 'above, their hands were pilfe'rini'his - pockets- below '. Front his relation :(111.r5.L.144v) . '-; Lady'teWhorn beftpast always•id ii hide '!Wiffi "the 'Mem' profound respect, the }lon. ..Meniber eotrtniitriicated cartons extraordinary factsl. 7, -"lliicone , ihmitalice;•sonie ides' May be-fi4ined •oflWiiitekt'i'ertie'clepraVity.• Lady once told •hiin, ?hat itiActelf\-iiiy'oltheie acii4aiotaitee or gang suffered turd` ptitifshmetat of death, time surviving sided !)each -ot exclai m Alrell'lliVel4;gblielfti l heaven ! In time case of a boy. liml,l - -tieen charged with a crime, one ati vised andtlhe . r to •go to the gang, and see - what cnblrt 'be stated .in the boy's favour. They "Cakifed the boy, - by assuring him, 'that 'even in . eo.9t ) entietice . s, he wras'crrtain of heaven; thei did' `not . henevel heittat in danger. A •fr%o:itay - 0 'the b(i.y l W,Eis 'executed; and 'nian'Y' Or' tice TaVie tinting ti'r'e lekrectitimmo were .e x Aribefir4ii"tis'iPal-liefatietii practices. "[he 116 . 61, 'llirtlier in the 'Winne stfriik,' mlifill'eriiteludetilitiY"liaying, that as iidtqfiming ti rn4r t hei . atild'ldi=tveiy - delay 'was tia't it'lli4l l ol . AtnWY, be- - -'shod id vote' for .the'- trio - inAind'lL'is46;fll Ptiend.' ':("Mr.-Ci-itirtiigik)l4oiJastlifiieftdmilvi'ni that the only lirffeiaen del tiVivi;iii'd!WV his Ho. AViiii i iiiefely ao to the `mtidebi tei'iVhat %vas best 'id Irer.dlifik'.'.':llC•besroiveiPsiitne'llig-ti eneourionis on' the'Hlrn:tint! 'Learned Gtiitfleitrarr ' James A2acl2lhtti~li'}',' `hilt Conitl'fidt agree: tir his :motion. flo,Witt`t , t'ipoke Lout. ;- but the • l'iutYticatii3lCV"QtqitiOn ;" and " iof incessant fit of 'C'Ortiriii4,lftti'vkit'eir'llitiilift4th being heard in the - • r : • Y. MOUortv:N'conSidered the subject as itirportaiicerarfil l Ought to be, in 'V6.1141,4(1 by live it self.'.Tire Hon. INletn. tiY) stlelega'm ing thir power to what "be " mt 4 their Family Committees !" MrTil regretted the - rapid . and early "lpfegl'Fis i Vf"brinie. He instanced the ease of a Vq . 6iisji'tir's 'ot age; - who Was' not only igno the, eXtreine - , bo't:absolutely unacquainted natUreAi . f' crime. ' . •Tlie mode proposed 7ffidviiet to'eJ•l"' . #4l . ll his 'appftilaticin'. If even fheYe r ivei'e' half la dozen of Co'diniittees they might it'' l iitrPtirifittche Whole Session - wirbout coining to 'gtif's'aiikfitl4o' - I' ) ltfrZlATTEe'rciirli r esttioa• - cd - .tniny compliments '111)1Y!' ll anti Learned Mover, anti observed, 'that'its:46t'lle , m'se ' etionely cot- sidered the (pies. theYiki3Ohldiagree — With the Hon. and Learned 'Nl'ot: e ie','"tlikth ti'm'e'Vart• Of the Criminal Code all deserved an immediate " -"Pg.P. ['d o t - If we ‘,tfe' to discharge our 74,1,.v- a's iltepres'ent6fivt srf the give time Hon. CtAigratillated the House but' liiinseff'illibiithe very - excellent speech' whie4 delivered by the Hon. and 1 14ittilecr(Vehl.leANki.,;' and sai . d, that unless the 'N'oble f - ;'4(t • d l itilmielitell . to` the appoint men t of a differe . lt 't'h'at 'carried last th m•fliiir;'Ale . tiibii'wonld,'vbtelor the- pr,e -seo • , Aillell'ttliiirAketi', 'after' Wlifit' the !louse bad l'At' . l . 4lll,Wrinifil at woutil be 'e. tied M th eniligtf'Oilleised, that Heird"ti more able speech, his Ilciti. and Learned was iirofound in argument; splendid l iqp,4lliiinence . , a w.l ittlinVAWy corinbormed by facts eieperierice'.' "Nlitlifog of a substantial or lilt niiiidne &kite litid been 'advanced against ,t (4t 6(0 of the Y ‘verl eq ' of 01 ' , ca ring odoced , e s teOC, 6 o ir 3 i 6 the with 119(c!" 11, He l t.