The Sun. — London, England, 1805-04-11 00:00:00

, 'in ' , P- 41 1 Itith , t specify. kg the service ; s;nce August, tifoj, die Mode' of con d u ai ng t h e business had been Yar'itel; aed'stiMs w er e wr i tten o ff at once by t h e ~ Rank f rom th e Tre a surer's account to that of the Sob -paymasters of the Navy, which accounts were i kep t also with that Cor"poration. Mr. T.HoRNTON ! kept Chat allusion s h a d been made to cert a i n i communiCations in which he was reported to be a Party; but herein he begged to set the House right, and, as far as re s p e oled lo in , h e could assure them they were founded in mistake. What might have passed with any - other Gentlemen they could them. I , °dices hest explain., As to the question moved 'this e . night. ,by the Honourable Gentleman, !; , euld not give it hi s support. On the preced. ‘ i fit etening. he h a d vote d w i th him f rom a sense t o ilL6 faitiublic ditty, had v iCi connivedi o n i a n t his and ownbeenmpi psi. d Mel v ill e 1 .7,t0 the misetindutl o f hi s D eputy. Mr. Tx-lotto. Tea could riot' fur a mo ment b e li eve t h at his Lord. shi p was guilty o f personal , corruption, and until j!"" wit proved, he thought the punishment already i. ..' n .qiaed was adequate to the, offence. He had long c " s iileted 'Lord Melville an inive, zealous, and etitorionestrvant of the Public, 2lnd the movers q mal t eXtusehi m if he could n u t at once go t h e l engt h . t o ll inking with t h em , t h at he was deserving of ttaen severe degradation and punishment as the Mu. two before the inose went to inflid. 4r ' ./1 fiR NAM entered his protest against the i 11ttudOttioreinto the Debate of the personal allusion i to the e ase o f two Nobl e CharaCters, relative to ! ifi t'ut.he had formerly. felt himself called upon to sio'i ellua aive Part. Nothing could be more inju. t -au s . than this reference. He contended no obli. on had been imposed on them, no benefit con. t , 4 4 Minister; joining in their defence. fie t d . e- Iluthat there was any hostility on 'his 'l4ng what he held his duty,part M its. though he was ,P k u ,t/t 1 10 Vold it so. When the case was decided Lofeitilt him by, so . great a majority, the chant(' of rioteoliferred a benefit on the objets of the Mo. 1,11 ca the With a worse grace . H e vote d f or t h e ba°lll)6. The tabled the House had in view should d h. ~.jr. ~-.".tartred to ►remain in a Stare of uncertainty, tr 4lll6 Old be decided upon beyond the power,of re. rai° , ti • How c ou ld i t b e c onten d e d wit h certainty d ill eh lit a te Noble Lord would not return to office ? He vt 7 i .',,,,c0 that there was any . personal hostility against - "` ji r. able Lord, for no marehad fewer enemies. i,,-"r'n;MICES, though he was certain he was (1 - " m ° way entitled to . offer his advice to the Hon. ~Lentleman from whom the' Motion came, with .1: Q111 '4 1 ' 1 Q neither personal uequaintance s nor any Vvlici.cal connexion, would yet take the liberty of trettAreentling to that Honourable %lentleman not ° Ptvere in this Motion. If it should lt© perstt.- i te,d in at • I nd , . , present, the same sense of duty Gentle. I:3uctd Nth to vot e with the Honourable Gentle. tittOll •the.l4.4t night wou ld oblige hint to vote n ttitiro on this. H. understoed the sense of 10.. f, adjournment en the former night to be, to al. 04 loal 1 2 1 VPltunity for Hi s M a j esty, front his lot -„,y motive, to r emove Lord Melville, or i. •Lotd IVlelville, feeling that he could be no s Z e ler on useful servan t to His Majesty under hiL,' f iliBMA that had been cast to tender t-V. , upon him, . t :110118natton. GentletneO seemed disposed to 11'14:'a ,With that resignation ; but lie maintained hA lle ll art ad preceding any step taken by th e - l ilii iesty in consequence of the Resolution, of Ilia Ll°use, could not be imputed to any other motive r , Mous e e Noble Lord's defeteoce to the sense of the o , 'and his determination to conform to it as qteeko r.. • ~ , , 1 th at 7 posstole. It was to he considered also, . "le R esohitirans that had been agreed to were but Aare o f L Ni n otd 'Melville's- case, and that they re. COUld to be„ followed up with other proceedings. ta g poT/. t here be ii,bctler reason than this for abstain. ie s ti ° : the present from the 'Resolution now pro. row ' It was impossible to teresee what may all s ir t 4 1 tbeAnquiry w hi c h was agreed to un e ittv ei• Could any one undertake to say these `Vas n it ° 1 Ise matter such as tocall.for inipeachinent ? INurid th " right . t o proceed further, when t h e is,t4,o' It o f the ul t i mate determination and proceed. m a d e M anse should art Opt wee so impeifeCtly N 1 . 4611 1? The precedents on the Journals were, ti lv i ss as ire precedents nuke out, against voting an Ad. of s i u c r i; Ise that proposed. He instanced the cases 11 4 0 e i r x ‘.' WalPote, Lord Rarielagh, and Lord to 4 , 11 .1 ' There was no 'instance of an Address and; i t ' d ve a person nut in oflice. Such an Address, veroadrhrtdi an Adress under such circumstances, thk„. )6 absurd CM the face of it. He slid not , lit oi th i c _ t e c( , old be any intention or any oos . asibi'. interro itistatitig. the Noble Lord in °ace in the sseell this tutee the present tirne and the period lois hubjett.w 1t be • unde r the cogni. WI ( agai n ... 114 9f th e H turnsto.c,. of it was possible toe, that eir. tile s i ‘iv ' °1 ellenuation may come out in the fur. ,0„.... estigation which would induce the Huth° 'l,, "ttent It self sae believ I altogether with whist it had dunes. w o ol,. se et such circumstances may exist, and he v uo _ ,,ti e them with more pleasure than the cit _ felt ces bt dtlinquefiCy and i. c'd him to v . malversation which has ni ght. ~,.., etc against the Noble Lord the he y,;U . ‘. a lere being no precedent, no neces. drl d rworob.b. i • • 4tvoutuliiityme Noinst tilt: , 1 nity of ills returning to power, Motion. !we t *, iND114:11, though not generally in the I ) , d 01 agreeing wi th the nor). Gentleman who Jost sat ~,,. "44 , viti , 1 - vwn ) more bust ! that Hon. Gentleman (ri /„„ sh l ),..s. ' l i' irc ili.)11. Friend who made the Motion t r 4rely „, ih )1 ' Ile lihil the Hon. G4ntleman were 3 tneh ( 4 / C "Ille SidC, though they sot on the same Pteseo,. eilnighol---agreed With 11411 in one point at k( r d tci 41 the quattlic.ition Proposed could be ac. its, to with the - feelings of the 411 Pold i n t ot e b:' , 4 ? 6 !)11 male by his flotiourable Friend ',Nand l i nrotight forward.. What Uentlenten the- omi4evcii.aßreed to o n th e last night was exactly nigh t. . , the y we t • e SI) d es irous t;.) put off this th li te 00 objec t' . e true eedin Y was' to ascertain whither w -4 i lll) {, , v i tah3c itiest:iNaliu:trie:3;l',llll:lll'ilectli was in itnnu''rueb: substance the :'nsuttd ' oluse w , dr ill rrwilcir form of the House. Ile 4. 611 tici , c,‘ tio had recourse to argument found. 'Aver lie i ' ,:,, c Y t and soft sentiment, which shinilil sti nt)! , . (it uctd or CotilittilltlCee in a grave as ii. ). L e ici , i . , . (411.1 priva te 4 • "S "Crested tor the Noble Lord 1,4, ttot ut lll(itlVeh th,m mato: 0111'r` th e l Th he mol e onte,,,, tvo. o , .., - - . 3 'II 4,11 t tt hell that , interest wa s C. WitlillUL.".4lllilLC"Ce , s cat het (14 .Ci5i.,)11 of a question, Nos tiic 1 . i LiQt e to do its duty, . • . he could not lister/ to i! . . .1( this •Itesoloo . on was a necessary corollary the other night, he saw no reason why' it should not be a neces. nary corollary now. The Motion went far be. y„ood what had been done, inasmuch as what had been done was net security for the perpetual exclu. stun of the Noble Lord, tilt,' it wois to be expeded he would not be reinstated. The only excuse that could be offered to the Public for not following up the Re. solution agreed to on the other night was, that in the progress of the future investigation matter of extenuation may come out. He did not think that could be. He thought the House justified in the vote of the last night, isecaese the whole of the case was before them. If he did not think so, God fOrbid that he should °Ned to any thing that could place, the case in a fuller or peter view. There was nothing to impeaelt the decision then made on the fairest motives : he should, therefore, require a promise or declaration, which would !ender it im. possible to restore Lord Melville. Otherwise, he had such a hold of those who were in power : they were so linked and connected together, thet an at. tempt may be made to counteract what the House had done. One instance was well known, in which, after a censure more strong than that now put up. on Lord Melville, the Noble Person recovered his situation, and the highest honours of the CoUntry were showered on him. What the House pro_ nounced in its best judgment should therefore not be given up.under less than an express pledge for what was implied in the Resolution of the fernier night. As to the idea that malice and passion entered into these proceedings, - and the Call for moderation and li. berality ; no passion or malice had entered into the proceedings ; moderation and liberality were good thing*, but they may be carried too far. Let it not be imputed to him, he was sure the imputation could not be made by his Hon. Friend (Mr. CAI. N I NG), that he was deficient in moderation or Jibe. rality, in thinking the consistency of the House of Commons doubtful in persevering in carrying into effed the judgment it had firmed. lie mould not have any falling off from the great dial produced,by the former Resolution. He would have the honour worn in its newest gloss, and be was unwilling the glory should be shorn off any of its beams. The House of Commons was on its trial., Some reTed was always due to public opinion, particularly on causes in which the Public felt its interests so much concerned. It was impossible the'l any de. ference for public clamour could have any ie. euence in didtating the decision of . the House.— Having formed a Resolution that :the Noble Lad was guilty of a, base breach of duty, such as was most shocking to public opinion, the further pro. ceedtng was neceseilty for the cherader of the House. The Noble Lord's guilt was attended with very aggraVating circumstances ; he did not mean to extend the charge to corruetion, and was it ma. iignity to endeavour to secure the Public against his future malversations. It was not neceseery in these circumstances for the Members of the House of Comitions, sitting as judges in the case, to go behind the bar, as the advocates of the ,accused , every enlarged principle of law-and public justice dictated a different conduct. It was 'the duty of Parliament to do justice between the individual and the Country,without being led away by feelings. He adverted again to the power of the Noble Lerti's Friends, and the possibility of his frustrating the Resolution of Parliament, if every precaution was' not taken. Though the Noble Lord my be iarus amicis, he was not id o e e us purist. He would, there. L fore; have the point put on the clearest understand. ing, so as to make this suppletnentel Rosolutien on. necessary. If that were dune, he had no motive of resentment against the Noble .Lord, and would be glad to snare him further mortilicetion. . The CHANCELLOR of the. EXCHEQUER rather hoped and expelled that the express under. standing, which hid been given, and which he had no difficulty to confirm, would haVe prevented fur. • ther argument, and put a stop to any ulterior Reso. lotions. He trusted that in consideration of this declaration, coupled with what wei expressed by the Honourable Gentleman opposite whets, he set down, and from a regard to feelings to which he wished to apply, the Motion would nut be pressed. The ' House, he was sure, would be disposed to spare those who were nearly eunnekied with the Noble Lord, as well as those who could not help, feeling, the ten. derma, friendship for him ; a feeling which he was surd the House wend,' not be disposed to censure. It was impossible while the vote of the fermer night was entered on the Journals, that the House could apprehend any danger of seeing the Noble Lurd again in office, unless .the vote itself were at an end. As to the extension of the Innulry, if any thing should come out in consequence of that Change, to the opinion of the House, he was sure Gentlemen would allutie that the Resolution should be changed with thp opinion. But in no other Cake than the House beiog convinced the Resolution, Wits founded in error, and rescinding it en that ground, in no other case could the Crown be advised by its Ministers to re.employ the Noble Lord. He had been misconceived by the Hon. Gentleman opposite (Mr. GREY) in the expression of surprise _he had uttered : it was surprise not that the Hon. Gentleman shOuld imagine there was nu danger of his return, but that he should not, in the cone. Bence that it could not take place with the Resole. lion on the Journals, think 'it unnecessary to press this Motion, which' went only to attain' the same, though' by a different mode. This understanding, while it was conformable to the liberality of the House, would not take from its firmness its means of -enforcing its Reselutioe. 'Mr. FOX Wished to set right the Hon. Gentle man on the Bench below him (Mr. BANK es), who had very much misconceived the , proceedings in this business. If the question hed been pressed that night, the lion. Gentleman would have supported it as a corollary, why snot now as well ? He was sore the Hun. Gentleman who had spoken under the Gallery would have supported it thercelso, and why did not he support it now ? His I ion. Ftieod postponed the Motion then, because it did not 21:- peer a pr o p er t i me to ta k e the !Neese Niche Hou se upon it, and also to give His Majesty's Ministers the opportunity of eding es they ought to do upon such a Resolution. This was the sense he for one entertained of the understanding that v. as conic (0. I; appeared to him and his liennue.Re '1'661". that'On a 4:ie:than oT sod; importance, inipartanee safrictent for another debate, it was not fit to ask the sense of the House at that late, heita.— He allowed also that other objeAs might be partly entertained. He did not unde;stand the hint to go to that, hut he did think with himself the delay may produce that further advantage also'. But his expeaations were very ill answered if it was con. ceived that Lord Melville, merely tendering his resignation, and that resignation being accepted, w , •tild satisfy the House. When he canctled Mi. nisters would do their duty in conformity to the Re. solution, could he suppose they would content them selves with a simple voluntary rereaval, without any sufficient mark consequent to tke censure of the House of Commons. He did expeat His Majesty would have been advised to dismiss the Noble Lord with some expression of his displeasure for what had passed. If, therefore, the Honourable Gentlemen were not still on his side, he lamented it ; but the (17nm:crawls:ad lor,r;r:iniidas of bring. ing on an important question at six o'clock in the morning had not altered the case. He came now to the speech of the Honourable Gentleman over the way (Mr. CANNING), which was so cot Ma. gent as hardly to admit a serious reply.—As if the indignation which was so generally excited in the Country was nothing, the Hanaurable Gen. tleman stigmatized as tyrannical and despotic she disapprobation of the employment of a man whom he himself ultimately dismissed as improper. 'Why did the Hon. Gentleman think it improper to suspend the employment of a man acCused on his own tes timony, because the affair was sub judice ? Why did he dismiss him since the Resolution, while the affairswas Bill sub . istelire P Was it not the fad, that she Hon. Gentleman made . this dismissal at length under the influence of alarm for the effat the further employment of a man, su accused, may have for himself and his Colleagues ? He could not sit quiet and hear all the claims that had been made fur tenderness and .liberality towards Lard Melville, without making some observation upon them, though he should even expose hitnself to the charge of bitterness or rancour, from which his con. dutft was in all, other instances free. Why was this tenderness so repeatedly and urgently claimed tor the convicted guilt of Lord Melville, Was it be. Cause he had aegleeted nu opportunity of multiplying emoluments Was it because, in the Grant to Lady Melville, of the office of Chamberlain of Fife, to the amount ut fifteen hundred pounds a year, the arrears due to the former holder were strangely added by the Treasury ? Was it because, • , hen he accepted the office of First Lord of the Admiralty last year, he required an addition of t soot. a-year, not to that office, in which the salary was inadequate to the ion. portance of the charge, and the extent of the duty, !out to that ot Keeper of the Privy Seal for Scut. land, which, from the nature of the Grant, he holds for life ? It had been said, in praise of Lord - Melville, that he had employed Officers whose political sentiments differed from his own. What Minister had not done so ? Had not Lord North employed Admiral Saunders, and Admiral Keppel ?--But, say his defenders, he was never bitter in his political animosities. He would relate to the House an incident, which, but for the assetlitni that Lord Melville was not a violent Partisan, he would, perhaps, never have mentioned, At a peiiod in the 'last War, when the Country was in as great alarm of an In. va.sion as it had been In the commencement of the present contest, the - inhabitants of the town of Tavistoek offereid to artn with the late Duke of Bedford at their head, which offer, on the suggestion of Lord Melville, was rejected, on account of political difference. The Dean of Faculty too, in Scotland, than whom there could not exist a more able Lawyer, or a more bril liant and worthy man, was displaced for simi. lar ;coons. It had been said by the Right Hon. Gentleman opposite of his Hona Friends near him, that, they had evinced more than Spartan vir. rue in attacking a man who had heretofore defend. ed thope with whom they were conne4led by the ties of blood. IfSpartan virtue. were teqUired, he knew not where it could be looked for with greater probability of success than in the breasts of - his Honourable Friends, but in the present instance there was no exercise for such virtue. Under what obligations were the two Noble Lords to Lord Melville ? He had eruPloyed them in the service of their Country ,they were successful ; some corn. plaints were' brought against them, and he had de. tended their conduct:, The contest had been repre sented as violent. 1 • He had examined the Journals of the Hoese, and 'he found tl}at althotigh"there were three diVisioti4, the number (of the Minority on •those divisions was on one thirteen, on another fourteen, and on the third seventeen I What was the amount of the Noble Lord's merit in this case ? He had employed two gallant Officers, who, by their bravery and good conduCt, rescued the Ministry from the imputation under which they. had- laboured from the re cotnence. tnent of the 'War, of inadivity and iinbecility.— They ate accused in Parliament unjustly, and the party feeling of Lord Melville it not quite strong enough to induce him to oppose them: An Hon. Bank Direetur, in repeating the. Resolutions of the' klouse on Monday night had said, that they: charged the Noble Lord with inattention to'hivtiuty; Not so ; the Charge was for gross vi , lation of his duty. That .was something more than inattention.' •He sincerely and earnestly hoped the House would main. ain the-character they ha& act/aired by their ac spiescence in those Resolution., ; and that they would never . be justly accused of swerving from the path of duty through nay apprehensions of the con. Sequences. After putting' together 'What 'had fallen from the other side of the House, and win t had fallen Isom an HONOentiernan on the same side as him. self, , he confated he • felt no great solicitude for pushing the Motiun to a Division. The latter had totiti-;thit it 'may be proceeded with 'hereafter..... Mays'! exclaimed Mr. Fox, " I say it must !" Bitter and violent as he had been imagined to 'be, he was •willing that this should be the last measure, that it should finish the Criminal Proceeding -4, H 4 had no inclinaiton to pursue the delinquent further. lie should certainty support the itcpositi.‘n w make hail refund r.iat weaiih which was the Pto. , perry ; 1 .41 this wouid be a Ci vil PruCCa.r, nor a eri/C4C.firig. it Might iikeWiSt b. 43;p4:11'„ei14 • to inquire into she pounds on which t h e N o bl e Lord had obtained several Grants from the Crown, several of which were known to be erroneous ; bUt this was not a Criminal Proceeding. In his opinion, the Address at present moved for would he the most proper tnede of finishing the Crimioal Pro.. ceediagsof the House against Lord Melville; bat if it were thought more proper to postpone it, he had no very strong ~bi,aion to the delay; after the declaration of the Right H Gentle Man, which completely did away all possibility of Lord Melvill's return to Odice„ at least during his Adininistration. With the permission of the House, he would say a few words on the subjed of his own expulsion fro tho Privy Council. He had carefully examined the List,. and he found, that in the whole course of fini Majesty's Reign, this punishment had been it ida. persons, the l at e D u k e of Devoo;. ed shire, an o l (w ms o elf; and he assured the Right Hon. Gentleman, that he did riot wish for such a com a pa ai on as Lord Melville. If Ireland were inclUded in the calculation, one man mote would he found who had shared the same fate; but it would be veiy incongruous, if Mr. Grattan, the constant tvrtt . mitting pursuer and dereetar of abuses, should be associated with a man who had been guilty of th e most enormous abuses. Tice Right Honourable Gentleman seemed to be of Opinion, that the very jet of the Resolutions of Mooday was, that Lori Melville was by them virtually rendered incapable of again . folding Offices of Trust and Honour. With this impreasion, lie had no great onjettion ter sec the Motion of his Hon. Friend withdrawn. Die worst of it' would pie, that no statement ut all this would exist on the journals of the Hotoe, The Public would *aye " .The transaftions of the Muse on Monday were highly praiseworthy ; but they h ave ' not followed them up ; they have admitted the premise., hut they refuse the conclusion s ; they have passed the Resolutions, but they do cot "Atte to the corollary which justly fiowe trim them."... The Houle should recollect, that the Public Aiten. tion is most c, mpletely awakened on this subjett, and that the Public 0 1 . inion ought to thfloence tine ti so tar as to prevent their shewing tenderness ogtoir, The House should likewise recollect, the unplea. sant situation in which they placed His Majesty:— The House had read the Report, they had consi. dered its contents, and they had: prooounced judgment on the culprits. His M.jaaty had not an opportunity of she wing them one mark of hia displeasure. For it would be futile to say, that that was CKpttsitil ley the acceptooec of Lord Melville-a resignation. He himself, when at ai former period he resigned his seat in the Cabinet, availed himself of the 4rst opportunity to pay his respetts to His Majesty, t!eat it might not oe sup. posed any political Feelings could weaken his at. rachment to him as his Sovereiglo May not Lord Melville do the same ?—May he not be seen at Court unless some step be taken by the Executive as well ashy the Legislative Power to prevent it Dearly -as he loved and respeCted the House of CoMmons, as the corner -stone, as the foundation of the edifice of the State, he should be extremely sorry to see the confidence of the People placed solely on that House, and lost to Ills M , jetty'. He should be very sorry to hear it said, " The House of Commons have done their duty—the ! louse of Lords . , may do their duty, but the King has, not done his duty." Is that a titution into which Ministers would chose to th i row their Sove. reign ?-a-The matter has been extensively agitated, and the People demand, and ought to have aunotana tial justice. He waned Ministers to weigh well the importance of the juncture. In this ferment they ought to prevent those who did not wish well to a Monarchical form of G ivernment from being able to draw a line between the King and the Par. liament, and to assert with any chance of being believed, that the sensibility of the Monarch was dead to the crimes which filled the minds of his Sub. jetty with indignation. - Mr. WiLIiERFORCE repeated the opinions which he expressed on Monday evening, as to the importance of the subjeift, and the necessity of search. ing into abuses, the existence of which was preg. mint with danger to the Constitution and the Court. try. It was by no means his wish to shelter Pub lic Offenders from that punishment which the House were imperiously called upon by their duty to in diet on them; but he certainly thought that the circumstanees of the present case were considerably changed by the resignation of the Noble Lord, and he therefore confessed, that he wi s h e d t h e H on . Gentleman would withdraw his Motion ; at the, saute time, if the H )n.. Gentleman pressed it to a division, lie by no means meant to say, that he should vote againit its adoption.' In the execution of their Public Duties, Public Men ought not to be governed by any motives but those or Public Uti. ,lity. He did not like the system of adhering to a Party, fur tlae sake of that Party a l one . What had been said by au Hon. Gentleman that evening sheet. ed the danger of aettog on such a system, although he could not but admit, that Lord Me LV I t, t. s, had at least acted lib:rally in employing the two No. We Lords alluded to. Mr. WlLticeeoe.ce con. clti o d; s t e l , t with o rt f t ( r i o un s clog, t trie ,i la t t ,u t the e dc i ne t h e e r m p i , t ic i is p o : l l l ) t ,, h r a t t Ei ne o t ri st o s u , ra w bi o c ul G d e n i.l o o t c b r : a ,r, t w ra u n ti s id ien n t on uti e uz ; jr a t t i ld le t s h: e t ni t n h g e t h e e ffg . t o f the vute of the House on Monday, by per,isling in leis present Motion, when it was evi. dent that many. ~vlembers were unfavourable to the Litter, who were Wilitn in their approbation of the former proceeding. 1;‘,7 1,1,E A: hoped the Honourable Gentleman w0u,1.1 silt the mattei to the bottols, aild not ullow the depredators on the Ptvilic,to go.undrietted tnid unpunished. If there was a gr'ain of ipecacoanha or of emetic tartar.in the world, he trusted it would be administered to the delitoluents, to oblige them to re.gorge their ill,gotten gains. (a loud laugb.) Toe pwccedings of Monday would be rtuga,oty tf they were thtt tAlo.sed up. by 'ton: Msiti , ,tl) itke the. present ; at the same time he ths,oglt: that the House should not be ton precipitate in their steps; and he Wa't not sore that it was .tdviscabie .t,a press it I:rwatil as was tY Milt/lea by the Gn.ltlein in. Mr. S. 1)1'ot - row explaity-tis Mr. I),,ittl a) CO •I' (ft 3* the ,tallry.) at. servekl, that =ttowevgc the Potthe apj) 0:e of the prJcc....; , ..1t0g; Itithettu iskiviltta by the G„,ule