The British Press; or, Morning Literary Advertiser. — London, England, 1810-05-03 00:00:00

I'SIPERIAL PARLL4MEAT. UOUSE OF LORDS, %%[DIESDAY, .IAV 2 "I ha Committee of Privileges, on the Illox'uttigh Peerage, or. flared fur Friday. The Innke.p•re' Bill was read the 3 ecoml time, and em itted to be committed to.looriuw cittir:l.Tv TO BlOrril ANIIIM.S. L or d titut Le stood,' more the se etol m01t.% of llte 11.11, for prevent's , ' a ueltv 10 : unto, 43, 11011,13 v m at, amt kw' .111 4' moved .• That their Lot tislispot liW 11331110AIMIS tor I Lot 11:1,:'-4 . 11derrd tot t ortiot,iy. LO I) 1% ELLING TON The LORD prereutril Lard Viscount %Vet. bagtoti's letter. exprrssirr of his gratitude fur ilie high ho. tour conferred upon hien, by • Vote of Thauks trom that Hoare. which, afirr benign:ad by lIIS Lordship, war ordered to lo; °tithe "rah!, LUKE OF BRUNSWICK. Thc Carl of Lt•r n root. presented a Mearize frolll Ilis Mitiosty, recontratendine u poets ttttt to Wiwi& for his High ness th• Duke of Brunswick. The Mcsaace was lead by the Lord elsauct Bor. and was similar to that p.osentod in the noose of COMMON. on MOlllitty. • The Earl of Li vt *POOL said, be should, to-morrow, to he a motion. for the concurrence of their Itsr.l.hips with of the hless..ee. and ho thou rout That thou . be summooe "a —ordered. M r L'irou, Mr. Pelham, Lord Francis Oshorny, Mr. If liar., and asetral M estate., from 11,. lit:us•C of CI.I iiiiiii too, brought up several Private woods were laid upon the table, and afterwaids read the brat huts. Ur. Owen. from the East India thrortols, nod Mr. 11.11, Aorta the Trea , ury, preeeutcd certain Papers at the Bar, which err. mitered to lienn the table. BILL. Eta Gao+vEsoa gave tioticr, he should more. that the . ite.ersion lull be read r *second woe, on Friday next ; for wind' day it was ordered that the Lords be sumwoied. _ Lord tlui LAND war deatrous to know, from His Majesty's Ministera, if they had received any di. rect lot, from H , a Majesty, whereby they could make any comtuuttication to the House, relative to His friajesty'a nt, that they should proceed in this Bull, inasmuch as it regarded His Majesty's wens. gluier ? The Earl of Ltvetront. said, he hail, at present, no cominuoicatinn to make on that subject. Viscount SIONtuUTSI observed, It. had, on a fibt! Mer eversion, intimated hn, totention, that if stay should a. kin come before them, affrctitig Hill Majeity's pr• togetive. to question he televised to a Couvutttee of Pri• viler+, that the! n,a. kt What had bees the pra.mettings of that House in respect to the stage when His Maje.ty',, cement stroilil he oh tai.iird. He stombl ass:i o*. 181 0 111.• mean time, that it grab generally liadetwood i• was tweet's ;:y to he obtained hi•fore.the 13.11 ps•sed. His Q 11,11,011 w.i., that His Ml t irety'i, e01e6e..1 oiteht to hen •I imed in the early stage of their proceedings ill bills of this description. . . . Earl Gitoticusos was of o inieti. himself, that ills Majesty's couse4t was not isece,stry ; but he should apprehend. from time conduct of the Noble Seerelary, it was the intention of Ills Mities'y's Mt rs to a.:vise that such totownt be given, os tar as it sfrictril fits Majesty's prenozatice. Still, he considered, if such were their intention, it would he more grieeful that 1.1 , s Majesty's consent be given In the present stlre of their isrOceedlogS. The Earl of Livsseoot, hoped that the Noble Earl w o liht oat d^ae. any inference from the con elm., of Mildater a , till he hs.l w►tnessed their acts. othiog wit.cl► had psvotA On the present oecasioo timid sanction soy oil triter it. to their condor , . Lord HOLLAND iris sore that the conduct of hin.4ters throughout was so unaccountable, that he would deft• any man to draw any inference inn these proceedings.—/4 Isaigh.)—Adjourned. ROUSE OF COMMONS. PORTSMOUTH WATERATORKs. Mr. lIICATWOTE blOtight up the Ite ! ant of t!ie Pnrfonnmith 1 ater.ll'nekt . bill, for the rr-comeniital of the After some frnin Mr. Heath, nte, Mr. Peter Moore, Minim, Welchem, Sir R. Peel, AAA Sir 1140111140 Turtnn, %Ir. Milne moved an antni•iinet.t, Ti at Cie futtl ee con•hlt ration or the Bill he pnetiwii.-41 tothi• ti et;x niontle.." A I a mina then intik place, when there ap• reared — For the Amendment ♦mass st liiM tbrawa at Ay • MlimilF of ....- DRURY. LASE VII FATIt R. On the moti.ni of Air. 14.1-va Nhetter, le.ne Irns Oren to hring iu a Rill for toe rt.-building of the piney-Nue Throw. ---__.-- MMDLEStX PETITIOV. Mr, Hy It; ; ;0 - 8; Ir:1ml the • Fret , holt4evo of the County of 111 i hlirttett; which MAI pos4 boy the Clerk. w follows : T. OF wolfOt;w♦RLl toe enwoops or 100 onnto itinonw 0/ 001 AT lIRITASI AIIIO 1 A O, IV /1/LIVIE•T £IIM Mr l`r.t:l ..1 I he Fry eh,ldesi „gored to is fwll C•tunty, this 2iith Jay of April, le i.t ; That vre bo.. nha•nrd, with ronreen. Mat in the ra m .. o f Mr Juba Gale j.hlM, an.l r Nanent Uoniett. Bar, your 14.•tewr amantr.l Vol ...cm...A a p...er naltrown to the Law, and unwarranted hy the Cm‘tiiatinn. lour Speak , •.'• .arr ant br•o executed! hy military fete.: as E•+=inhman. bovixr—hl. and thr DluoJ of ana:Tendlug educe.. !Ids iwt n shed in lb. oreets Against the mistake, ae welt as the Porten., of thin we nitrinofly protest t • protest the wore neerotaty , hemmer your votes, I:1 ii. StlenOrt, •re :.f..•• d foil yoor .1 •araalao—not at. ib. 1.• it.. of Sir Francis Iturdt•tf to )ol l f hor`lber, denting soon jes I n the earls part of Ib.. nips, in the tare of We. Wilke*, the rights gef tin.. county mud the Io••in. w e re erpwa t i .,th, and gruaaiyinolairtl try the Hans of ..... otons. At length the lan trio...eke& lifter I ',negate of nearly gl years, the Itonse abandoned toe peeleintosis the, had arrogated, nod rapencetr from their Jaurnols, "all their decimations. ...ler., and reardins.ine, ar bring inibans:nt °Ph* nghts .4 ibe • hole body of eketlos of this Itiordens " Tau hest, 14. 'II,. ;err OW drprisrd the or ff Ilene ef West Minster a then share itt the n presentation. and the palibe at laigor of the expellers • faithful servant. in whew.. ability hits. ne,. • and wire. ay, the. pre plaint...tit, eellfiflr. view,_ will. •11-loielooll and Jreloosy , the shutting lep Nr Franele Fis.. l . II to pet....., when the attention ttf th. let. 11011 is &retied a r h anxiety tu his I it. titled mauling. for • tic- Cwta in the N.; , • ...oblation of the prop e in ytter 11. , noarldtla in wititts the teriar of to ate has hews sense"' ifi Ihr vaneof Ms Pere.' al aud ',not Cast:eireagh, "fob.. as aotonows as the ran at noon thse," • pruner, at the eawnuu of to the euiphoto language of tune brrskrt. inn asirestatrs autild hate 'tartlet! with tuelti,te Ent rofoe. Twee von to f. o 1 .. Ihe ' , temple ..f,uor re..t. et Not I*. expuogt •Il soul Ar. hiralloww, tbrarro, atol Ve...10t11010 ell the atalTuri. It tame to the sulterreiou of o.ir Ithertioe," and to the .01r.Khortnott of tuolvtary dc•po and so recall the ont.,e botch:lt I. the *en we of tic tentstry is Parliament, that he may there enforce that plan of refu,ta, which last Sersiiin he 11111KMedUlly eCnfllatrllded and hieli, in owe °vino., is absolutely wecessary for the suitable and honour of the 'rill Ulle, and the safely atm well., Lein, of the peopfe.. Stgued in the name, nua in the behalf of this Meeuul, b 1 • • • After the petition was mid, Mr. BY NO inured, "That it ahonld lie on the Whir." Mr. Mums!' seconded the motion, but, in doing so, lie conceived he executed all the duty he owed to those of his Constituents, who're Petition it was ; and begged not to be understood as approviog of n. At the request of the CistsciiLLoa of the Ex chsousa, the Petition was reed natio. The Cu ANCLLI. jR of the EXCHEQUER then said, he 'as sure his conduct on it former occasion (the presentation of the late West►ninster Petiti•. when a petition was presented, acknowledged on all hands to br couched in improper language, which he had yet, from certain considerations. ad vised the House to 'revive. would *hew, that there wee no indisposition, on his part, to treat such mat ters with every possible forbearance. That Peti two :admitted of some doubt; but no use could don lit hut this wee intended distinctly to insult the !loose. He wished to be understood. that no part of the Petition, which related to former proceedings of the House, was that which he eonctived to be offensive, and of a nature to cause the Petition to be rejected. His objection rested on this plant dry isms"; whether the language was such as was ne cessary to hring their proceedings again under re view, which was the professed object of the Peti tion, or such as was calculated to try how far their forbearance would go, in receiving direct insults? The Petitioners stated. that they, " observed with concern, in the cases of John Cale Jones mid Sir F. Burdett, that the House had assumed sod exp elled a power unknown to the law, nod utioarraut. cd by the Constitution." %Viol this the langurge of petition, or fit to be addressed to that House ? Hr would not comment on the repressions m that part of the Petition, complaining of excess in the execu tion of the worrint, as that might be directed against the Officer execnting it, whose conduct ruin ht. if conctived to he wrong. be most fairly brought under the consideration of the House. What he oi.jected to was a statement for rt dress, and vet no 'submission to their ; hut, on the cootrary, demanding it, and solemnly Protesting against their decieism. %Vas it the language of per son. approaching them as pentionets, to assert their own ontlionty in opposition to Ormond tweet that then had assumed and exercised nu illegal and nu e oists:iitioual authority, and to protest egaisist it ? These was nothing in the former petition (front tVestiniuster) at all like this.—. These tietitiontrs were lit opinion that Sir F. Burdett, and his letter to the. Speaker, had been dealt with in a way, of which they dis.q►proved ; and is the expression of that opiu'on, the !louse would not lw too fastzdious in seraiiiiinitg the language of promote thinking theni.elvra improperly deprived of their Represent ative. In all these things, however. there must Ire a point at which the line must be drawn. That line, lie thought, was passed on the prestoit °toot sion ; and he stibinitted to the !louse, whether they would air would slot receive this dictation. Mr. Alderman Comic said a few words in &- von t o f reseiting the Pei iti . It was unanimously agreed to in a very numerous county meeting; and, ;fit was rejected, be did not know what might be the consequences. Mr. C A I.CRA VT also supported the motion for receiving the Petition, though on different grounds front the Honourable Geutleinan who preceded hun. However unanimous a meeting of the county of MiAtllesex, or any other county. might 1,-, or es en were their opinions adopted by three or four other counties, yet that uvula never deter him from stooling back their - petitions. if court's(' in improper language. Ile considered the tVesto.iiister Petition to be 'written in such terms, that it could not be objected to.—The present was of the s ime kind. It contained l►a• ragraphs which might better I►e omitted titan la eeriest ; but when lie considered that the doors of the House ought to be thniwu wide open ti -the petitions cf the people, licit the present acknow. hedged ■isle of the representation of the country, he was Lot at all •ssto:iishrd tuna they were ap ;Toadied in t. rots which could slot be satisfactory t i their fee hugs, or pleasing to their ears. But an. lees t ha v rens, died the roil, by adopting an adequate and equitable Pariiantentary Reform, they must lay their account with many such peut iiiii 4 , stud be con trod to pocket the afftout. The petition could not he rejected for cooties ii i ee g a tninien 'ankh bad before been asserted in that House, •s that the beteg scuts in the House was as open es the sun set norm-day." Was this a ht ell—No! for it eats true; mutt till she 'trainee was relormerl, they must be liable to expect disagreeable petitions. Mr. D. GIDDY agreed with the Hon. Gentleman, that the Ileum ought to open their doors wide to th e prtiti n . o s of the subject; but the whole of the urgwm• nt (wooled on this position. its the present isisisore, filled. its that which purported lobe a petition, wail ant• thin{ lint a petition, 'toddle form was 011 I) ■ covert manor► of °Grist, insult; for, however it might appear like a petition, in form and iu technical terms. it was not a petition, but a dnt•tetion to the House—{ Hear, hear/. lit what had hr.-it t.llll on this subject, it hail lb en coupled with the r- form, or rather, he would icy, with the alteration of Pio liament. Ott this topic he would it''t cuter now. as it was not neressarity connected with the qiiettisin now b-fore them ; but at any fu ture period lie would he warty to oiler Ilia senti ments upon it. aetd state lii• grounds for thinking that arch a reform as these per s ons, wished, would niter Pethauseist from hoilie the Iteiw. Imitative,. to lei tu f t the Delegates of the people. lie the mean time, he protested against Gentlemen's lakiug that fur agratitol, which yet reinitiated to Ise prosed, and on which he, for one, etiterosined II different opinion fsorti them. Inn she words of the petition he would 'sot cnnu.urut ; barely hearing it read was outfi t tent •o ,01.venre env one that they were diare.ta ct.. fut-...th a t tt cotrtaused no prayer which could be acceded to-eand that it exhibited a dictation to awns, which, if acetded to, would lead to other. atih more gross noel ie.sulting. This. then, was the hest time to make a shoot against such etieroecise , meow. The lino. Gentl.•es su near hint (Mr. Al derman Comb►) had tasked of the numbers and auautatily of the meeting. wham this paper ern. ginaleil. Every one must he ready to attend tome voice of the peop!e; but there was some di-ttnetiou to be nude between the people aid a mob. They all knew what kind of meetings there were in the neighi:ourhouil of guilt towns. As for their utia annoy, its vslue might be guessed at front the mode in which they received a &egolenses' (Mr.. :Mellish) of west respectability every where, but whose respectability ought to bine procured Into still greeter atteutiou in the midst of hit 4:006l1- tueots—(lker). Him they would not hear, be cause hss ultisiotu differed from those of the per sous who coavened the tueettue. But were they ever so unanimous. ever so respectable, ever so nu merous, that could not couoterbalance the itniqpiity offered to the House in this petition. Mr. H. Baowxt could not agree with the H , n. Gentleman, who spoke last but one. (Mr.Cis'craft.) We would neither look at the netting itself, nor at its causes, but at the words of the petition. It was evidently a studied insult to the House. Every pe thief' from the subject ought to be received with that respect to which it was entitled. Bat even if the object preyed for was the most correct, and, he was the Mort zealous friend to Reform, he would reject this gross insult, sod dogmatical dessial to the House, of those privileges which they must en joy, as the itate,.. , u I r. 14 of the lit.erties of the people. He drew a broad line of distinettuu between the late petition and the present. The former was dubious in expression, and it was but fair to interpret it to the mast favourable way. But whets the House sew that their liberality in this only led to insult, it was time to assert their authority, and the high C 00.• stitutional powers withwhich they were invested. Mr. Mestar telt reluctant to offer even the little he had to my ou the present question. The petitioners denied the legality of the exercise of • privilege contended for, and exerted by the House. They felt warmly on the occasion, and their ex press partook of this warmth ; but he should be sorry to see that these warn assertions ass their part, should cause the House ofCtsolinons to be as wars in the reception of the petition. Let Gentlemen look at the pert cited asset exceptionable, and they would end it only a denial, a coarse one, indeed, of the privileges and authority they assumed. then, they had gone one jot beyond tht it legal and constitutioual powers, the petition was trite, and ought not to be rejected. In the situation of the petitioners, they were ?withal to itodulgetter, and the more so, from their having -appealed to the House, for a remedy against their own set-. Coder these circumstances, howeier ranch he disapproved of the intemperance displayed in the petition, he would vote for its being received. Mr. Beensts thought the petition was entitled to furtli , r consideration than could lee Oven at 00 the spur of the moment, the same night it was pre prettied. It eves al-u important, in coining to a de cision on a quest of this kind, that there should be a fuller attendance of Members than was et o ess.eue in the Hou s e. He would, therefore, pro pose au adjourniaeut of the quest ion to a future day. If, however, hew** forced tout immediate docisiene he must say, that the impression on his mind was to reject the petition. Ate Hou. Gentleman (Mr. Combs) said, lie did not know what might be the consequences of a rejection. Neither did le ; hut that would never cause blue JIB it Member of that ,House, to receive what was unbecoming iu them to receive.--( Hear. /Another Hon. Gintleman. (Mr. noticed its being drawn up with warmth. It did not appear so to hien. On the contrary, it seemed to be carefully cud studiously worded, to try how far, under the name of petition, the House could be vilified and insulted.—(Neer, hear.) — If they received this, they would have a stronger and more improper petition at the back of it. and so on till reproach and indignity could go no fur ther in their clegrodatton.—/ Hear.) Bat they must make it stand some time. and they had better do it now, than at last, when they would not only have to make the stand. but vet ;ace many of their past steps. Ou all tome groin ids, he saw the more eativie for cool delibefaUt,ll and time maturely to weigh the metter iu all its bearings. After this it might perhaps be proper to come to a Resolution, stating the grounds on which they rejected the peti tion, In order to prevent the poseibilsty of mare. presentation. He concluded by moving, 14 That the debate be aeljourue4 till to-morrow." Mr. Geettreee wrangled this asneuthueut, and the question was put from the Chair. Mr. Sufi eea said, this we- a petition in nothing hut in moue. and against such an insult and at tempt at intittiolstion he would not lir Jeanine-el till to-morrow f giving his vote. An Honour able Gentleman Cdr. C be) had te;ked of fear for the consequences of rejection. He did not fear the cossaequencee ; roil no man worthy a seat in that Howse ought to fear him. If they did fear them, they would mint long rtijOy these seats. Mr. Coeur. in replanatioe said, he had never expressed tiny fear fur the consequences, and begged the floisourahle Gentleman nut so much to nits understand lain. Mr. LAMus remarked, that if any Gentleman an:world the ri.jeetins uf Ohio petition iatiold be stopping these matters. Si they were 'Dia take's. fielial not he:titl it rt;itl, but could dot conceive that it (villa contain any Kreater insult tl.an the petition which bail liven receiveil frogs West titer, complaining of " • glues tudignity beiug offered to the petitioners." lie recommend ed the postponement of the debate, for the purpose of allowing trine to consider how fair the lieeirse of petit g. air liberdly given. hail sou been eon rerted tutu 4 gross whose, and turned to the delu sion of the people, by wit lied and Jesig X men. There was a di.position through the country, nut to retpure Returns, but to b.Kw by asserting that the House was not the legal representation of •he peo ple. Now, hoarier friendly to Reform he was, Ire would rather yeah-see with those who drought tine Honor Wu. goy., RIM pure, at tar at hUlti•bn in. stituitor... could be perfect, than with these who held that it was utterly eon apt. and ought to lit destroyed. the petitani before them, however gross the assertions might be, they were not worse than others that had already bees received. WAKOLV had heard frost one Ilan. Gentle mass, that the petition seas an twilit; Croat another. flirt it was a dictation to the Hansa; and, front a third, that it contained no pr. .ver. Now. he bid gt•lneed Ishl eye over It. and could not discorcr these things. It said, tt ae earnestly request:' and. sorely, this was tit latlinie to br weed . As fur tat alatrtio . a t that the noose " luta to mem , 46 *Nese which slid wit elong to it. t giro opinion. and b considered it h as as justitioul! As fins the intention to insult, it was rird eolt 'hem cuuldilsarintie such. It would be unwi.e ; end, slats. if that had been the, wilh id the so nd i„ x. they conga brae accomplished it brttee„ underthe form of resolanions. thou that of pett,iou, liable i s b e rejected by the Douse its, If. Unii-r tbe. r no. pressious, he would vote for the petition by t rt . reived. Mr. Aszacuonata was happy to hear f rom the Gentiles's:lth ti at there could be ou wish to use cepressintia cslcutated to bring the into content pt.—f Henn/a—He would vote for recepticu of the petition. as he aid not think iiw expressions useJ in it stronger than might be ex pected, cousidernig the feelings of the perm, from whom it crone, and their op:inutis tie subject of tie privilege elsinted by House. For liiinstlf. lie believed that the floss, had not exceeded the powers to which hs were, by the laws and Constitution. entitled. ;;- tzar asp inclined to receive the petition, nu pining it with that from WCllttailadet ; which • i„ taopinion. sic the more objectionable of the h. d . This expressed a peremptory opinion ; but IL, other nut only ;lid that. but uecused Oita of is. suit. lie wished that a postponement tni at 1.- agreed to; as well fur the learions stated by ilw lion. Mover of the ailjnitroment. as to afford au oii. portuoity oneinitiint precedents, 111141 seting j„,„ tar A latitude of tosignage had been peritintedto Initialers sit • a when a . est constitutional rporsnous were agitated, that they might not now deal more hardly by the comity of Middlesex, them they Meal done with their ancestors. Suppose any pert of the people should itetitiosi against an act of that House. an oppeem.iveat:d unjust, ati4l pray then, to rPrhie it ; this would be received. and lie did not think there were any wur.!a wore bomb in this petition, to cito,e jag rejection. Mr. STEVEN agreed as to the practical e ssaien i. rote of an adjournment ; but if the delay of a single they could be construed into a want of see. sibility in the House, or of indignation at the studied insult offered to theist, he would b e ii,„ last mini there to agree to it. If this Houst, the It gal represeuratioo (to :slake use of a term w trh had been much qiisap:ilsed) of tiir Majesty of ate People. the Corot 11111 l s of FAxtaud, and so ism. ;turista a brands of the Legislature of the noun. try. aria not only to be libelled ants impnitity, but to hr indite the servile instruments oh iheir Oa ordo gratintiou, it would indeed he very rianiordioart. An llon. (entlenian (Mr. Wardle) had said, it in sult intended, it might have been better ef feeted i v resolutions thin petition. But there was a wide liliferenrC between the insertion of libels, by resoluttens, gross in terms, and dangerous in eon. sequences, in the public press, *here they might be puetslied, either (us he believed they could) by the !loner. ea coutempts, or (asGentlemen of the oilier opinion would allow) by the laws of the country, and the reception of a libellous peiiiion. which was sanctioned by being laid on their table, sod incorpotated with their 'woo-riling*. It being conceded Ly every one who had ipoken toi this subjett. that there might exist a pacer which Nat a Wert out the Hou-r, the question came to be. nas this Petition 0 paper of that description ? rounder this ponds he relfrrive 4 the delay to he nercesery, as their decision roast be so isnimirt.ttit in a question insulting the rights ut the subject to petition, and the extent to which t hey could go,_ without directly inst.ltieg the [bow. Much, too, might &prod on the contest; and they could not deride on merely herring the Prrinuis read s , and one or two objec t We m aws cited. And. besides the opportunity at. forded for fuller deliberation. woollier import. sot point would be gained by the adjourn nient, they would have is more numerous House. Thu. wise the more desirable on a delicate _question of this kind ; as the sense of the House bring once embodied, might be a lesseo to Members bow far they ought to go iu the presentation of petitioos. No Court of Law per mitted insulting petitions or dictations to their judgments to be offered to them, and Ito Barrister would undertake to offer such. dreading the dit pleasure of nee Court. Why were they. the House of Cognitions, to be treated with less respect than a Cow t of Law? a Representative did trot owe more to his Constituent. thlus a Lawyer to hi. Christ. He hail sio ides of men being Members of that House. or of any Body they despised or held to be illegal. I' any were '4;l enough to hold this opinion, their honour ought to point out to them their secession; at any rate, the House ought to enforce on its Members. proper respe:t for its dig nity. He did not doubt. but the arose of the Home, on the present occaeou. ails the same as that on Sir Francis Bus dett's Inter; the conaideutioli of *hull they had agreed to poop° se. on similar grounds now states' for saloptiog a "NW'S! course. As for the Westminster Minion being cited as a prece• dent. there was no analogy betiveris ttse cases. The one, was the remonstrance of pe oohs 011. c e " ln tt thelo•eitiet. arongfwlly drprived of their re presentative; the other, a wows, intentinelt, and rf &leder libel. for the purptoe of vslif,in,; 4:441 s'e grading the House. The CII/INCELLOR of the Esc') in: tat !weir"; those who agreed with him in prowi l ae •twitg' ,l 4 &lay necessary, though hr himself on( a rert to that opinion, ctvuhi !Hare nn t chug to it. Nog, hr * hur le o'ls 1101 s tO •d ex..lain the difference b t.teea the PIA pi:E•l).`:: . 2 end chew that the Hon. Genthtuan upwrite (:.Ir. La'"lw) wet not mnrect in toe deductiva he had made. The groulAt on which the hunter petit: ct was received was repeatedly static; in the date., am: was precisely tror—that as the sent.-nce tinning the accusation of w gross insult being "i.e feted, might aiiiply to the officer recent:tog the S i leakei's watram, it was but fair to put the in o 4 favounibk construction upon a petition from the subject. He agreed that they mast r.ce.te 10 -11- hops avant their arts, but, or the woe time, th, r would take care in what language they were 1 . 011, !.. I.ll.—They would take care that they w , re petit.::-. 1194 not papers to doctirte to the I toti.e a La , t ought to do. They might ask a rralsiuss of t. e jtaltr,ditat of the Leeislatnre ; they' we re 'l'', wells the prevent Las-. to .‘ t up • fe-titioure. wnd illy against the anthorty of the Iloatr, and tutpertutuly for • uut Lor u re-coo-uter.t. wl be